Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics
How physics instruments measure

Why the air beyond a pipe changes its resonance

A resonance tube responds to air beyond its visible rim. Play a fixed tone near the open mouth and slowly move a piston inside. The sound grows louder, fades and grows louder again. You can measure each resonant air-column length, yet using that geometric length alone gives a slightly displaced estimate of sound speed.

Sandbox Physics ·

Returning waves reinforce a particular rhythm

A speaker pushes nearby air together, then lets it spread apart. These compressions travel down the tube. Small parcels of air move back and forth near their original positions; the changing compression travels much farther.

The rigid piston reflects the wave. When the round-trip timing matches the drive, successive returning waves reinforce one another. Some places develop large pressure oscillations and others stay relatively quiet. This persistent spatial pattern is a standing wave. Sound pressure means the small variation around the ordinary air pressure.

A microphone detects pressure, so its loudest position need not be where air moves farthest. Air cannot pass through the piston. Its displacement there is small, but pressure can vary strongly. Elsewhere the microphone can become quiet even though the air moves through a large excursion. Such a quiet location is a pressure node.

Sources: [1]

The glass rim is not a sharp end to the moving air

At an open mouth, air can move between the tube and the room. The moving air inside must accelerate some air outside as well. That exterior air adds inertia to the motion. The glass has a sharply defined edge, but the air motion does not stop at that edge.

This changes the timing of the reflected wave relative to the next push from the speaker. For a narrow pipe at sufficiently low frequency, its effect can be represented by a small extra length. The wave behaves as though the pipe extended slightly beyond the measured rim. This extra effective length is called the end correction.

In 1948, Levine and Schwinger obtained a low-frequency correction of 0.6133 times the radius for a thin unflanged circular pipe. A radius of 10 mm10\,\mathrm{mm} gives about 6.13 mm6.13\,\mathrm{mm} per open end. Thick walls, flanges and higher frequencies change the exterior motion and need a suitable correction.

A pipe closed at one end has a simplest resonance of roughly a quarter wavelength. A pipe open at both ends has a simplest resonance of roughly half a wavelength, with exterior air contributing at both ends. Changing the end plate changes the conditions that the entire standing wave must satisfy.

Sources: [1][2]

Two neighbouring resonances remove the shared extra length

Keep the drive tone fixed and continue withdrawing the piston. The next resonance accommodates one additional half wavelength. Both resonant lengths contain the same end correction. Subtracting one length from the other removes it.

For an ideal example, take a drive frequency of 1000 Hz1000\,\mathrm{Hz} and neighbouring resonant lengths of approximately 0.25160 m0.25160\,\mathrm{m} and 0.42342 m0.42342\,\mathrm{m}. Their separation is 0.17182 m0.17182\,\mathrm{m}, which is half a wavelength. Twice that distance, multiplied by the frequency, gives a sound speed near 343.64 m/s343.64\,\mathrm{m/s}.

Once sound speed is known, identify the resonance order by the number of repeated sections in the standing wave. This tells you the effective length required by that resonance. Its excess over the geometric tube length gives the end correction. More measured positions check whether the same correction describes the sequence.

c=2f(Ln+1−Ln)c=2f(L_{n+1}-L_n)
Adjacent resonant lengths differ by half a wavelength. Twice their separation times the drive frequency gives sound speed. Lengths are in metres and frequency in hertz. Boundary type, radius and temperature are held fixed.

Sources: [1]

Sharp peaks still need independent geometric information

Hold the piston fixed and vary the drive frequency instead. A series of sharp peaks still appears, but all of them measure the same transit-time scale through one effective length. A somewhat larger sound speed and a correspondingly larger effective length can produce the same entire frequency sequence.

Changing the real tube length provides a new piece of information. The main length changes from one setup to another, and the small end extension is added at each opening. Comparing several lengths separates the two contributions.

Temperature belongs with those measurements. Warm air carries sound faster and shifts a previously resonant tone. The ruler zero and frequency counter need checks too. A small microphone should disturb the open mouth as little as possible. The useful result is a comparable set of lengths, frequencies and temperatures.

Sources: [1]

Sources and further reading

  1. PASCO WA-9612 Resonance Tube, 012-03541F (3/95)

    Printed pp.1–6: piston, weak pressure microphone and an unobstructed source end; pp.20–21: pressure patterns, adjacent resonant positions and approximate temperature-dependent sound speed.

  2. Levine & Schwinger, On the Radiation of Sound from an Unflanged Circular Pipe, Physical Review 73, 383–406 (1948)

    Publisher abstract and low-frequency result: a thin unflanged circular opening contributes an extension of 0.6133 radii. It is a geometry-specific limit, not the empirical coefficient of every teaching tube.

Keep reading

What this page links to directly

See this series on the content map →

How physics instruments measure · Reading path

How physics instruments measure

  1. ArticleHow a vernier reads between millimetres
  2. ArticleAir helps hold up the object on a balance
  3. ArticleHow Cavendish Measured the Attraction Between Spheres
  4. ArticleWhich pressure does a liquid column measure?
  5. ArticleThe cup absorbs heat too
  6. ArticleRotational rheometers need both torque and speed
  7. You are hereWhy the air beyond a pipe changes its resonance
  8. ArticleHow a seismometer reads the ground through motion inside its case
  9. ArticleWhy does a meter change the circuit?
  10. ArticleHow a null detector reveals a resistance
  11. ArticleWhy a capacitor can behave like an inductor
  12. ArticleWhere does the slow wave on an oscilloscope come from?
  13. ArticleHow a lock-in amplifier finds a signal buried in noise
  14. ArticleWhere a small peak in a spectrum can come from
  15. ArticleHow a network analyzer separates the cable from the device
  16. ArticleWhen a slower quartz crystal can measure added mass
  17. ArticleHow an echelle spectrograph gives overlapping colors a second direction
  18. ArticleHow total brightness reveals many infrared colors
  19. ArticleMeasuring a Solution’s Concentration with Light
  20. ArticleHow an ellipsometer reads thin-film thickness from reflected light
  21. ArticleHow a polarimeter reveals mixed polarization
  22. ArticleHow individual photons reveal a fluorescence lifetime
  23. ArticleBrillouin Microscopy Listens to Sound with Light
  24. ArticleHow a white sphere compares a lamp’s total output
  25. ArticleHow powder rings reveal atomic spacing
  26. ArticleHow Small-Angle X-ray Scattering Reads a Particle Halo
  27. ArticleWhy X-ray fluorescence depends on sample thickness
  28. ArticleWhy an AFM makes a bump look wider
  29. ArticleHow a small indentation separates hardness from elasticity
  30. ArticleHow Differential Scanning Calorimetry Reads a Melting Peak
  31. ArticleHow thermogravimetry separates mass loss from the gas around it
  32. ArticleHow a diamond anvil cell reads pressure in ruby light
  33. ArticleHow diamond fluorescence reveals a magnetic-field direction
  34. ArticleReading a magnetic field in the rhythm of atoms
  35. ArticleKeeping a laser in time with atoms
  36. ArticleWhy a Kibble balance needs two experiments
  37. ArticleHow a dilution refrigerator keeps carrying heat away
  38. ArticleWhy a bigger vacuum pump may barely help the sample
  39. ArticleHow microwaves read a superconducting qubit
  40. ArticleHow current leaves a voltage across a thin sheet
  41. ArticleHow an ion flight becomes a mass spectrum
  42. ArticleHow four straight rods select ion mass
  43. ArticleHow a rapidly reversing field can hold ions
  44. ArticleHow a cyclotron keeps a proton on the accelerating beat
  45. ArticleWhy the drift tubes in an RF linac get longer
  46. ArticleThe directions hidden inside a small beam spot
  47. ArticleHow defocusing magnets help a beam stay in a ring
  48. ArticleWhy a collider cannot keep every collision
  49. ArticleGetting synchrotron light onto a sample
  50. ArticleHow a free-electron laser gathers electrons into a brighter beam
  51. ArticleFollowing energy exchange with neutron flight times
  52. ArticleHow a tokamak holds heat and measures where it goes
  53. ArticleWhy stellarator coils bend in three dimensions
  54. ArticleHow NIF turns a laser pulse into an implosion
Something broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy