Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics
How physics instruments measure

Air helps hold up the object on a balance

Air pushes upward on the object on a balance. It also pushes upward on the reference weights, but the two objects often displace different volumes. A precise mass comparison has to account for the part of the weight that the air supports.

Sandbox Physics ·

The larger object gets more help from the air

Picture two objects with the same mass of 100 grams: a compact steel weight and a much larger sample. Air presses on every surface of both objects. The pressure is slightly greater underneath than above, so the pressures leave a small upward force. This is buoyancy, the same effect that helps a block float in water.

The upward force equals the weight of the air displaced by the object. A larger volume displaces more air. The effect is easy to overlook in everyday weighing, but a laboratory balance can resolve changes much smaller than a grain of rice. Air buoyancy can then shift several digits.

A balance compares the downward forces delivered to its pans. Of two equal masses, the larger-volume object presses down less in air. When that object is compared with compact steel weights, its indicated mass comes out a little low. Here, indicated mass means the result of comparing the object with known true-mass standards in the air present during the weighing.

Sources: [1]

A 100 gram sample can read about 105 milligrams low

Choose round numbers for a teaching example. Give the sample a mass of 100 grams and a density of 1,000 kilograms per cubic metre. It occupies 100 cubic centimetres. Set the density of the steel standard to 8,000 kilograms per cubic metre; the same mass occupies only 12.5 cubic centimetres. Take the air density as 1.2 kilograms per cubic metre.

The sample displaces 120 milligrams of air. A 100 gram steel standard displaces just 15 milligrams. The difference is about 105 milligrams. The amount of steel that balances the sample has a mass of about 99.895 grams. Correcting for buoyancy restores the original 100 gram sample mass. This worked example uses calculated values for the stated teaching densities.

The correction uses the densities of the sample, the reference weights and the air. The relation below converts the indication into sample mass.

mx=mind1−ρa/ρr1−ρa/ρxm_x=m_{\mathrm{ind}}\frac{1-\rho_a/\rho_r}{1-\rho_a/\rho_x}
The left side is sample mass. The right side uses indicated mass, air density, reference density and sample density, respectively. Equal sample and reference densities give the same fractional buoyancy, so the correction factor becomes one.

Sources: [1]

Put the sample and standard on the same pan

There is another small difference to consider: the two arms of a balance may have slightly different lengths. A downward force turns the beam according to its distance from the pivot. A slightly longer left arm gives the same load more turning effect on that side. A direct comparison can therefore include a mass error from the geometry.

Substitution weighing changes the comparison. Leave the same counterpoise on the right pan. First put the sample on the left pan and read the detector. Then replace it with a standard and read again. Both weighings use the same suspension point and arm. Subtracting the signals removes the fixed right-pan contribution. A small known calibration weight establishes the sensitivity needed to convert that signal difference into a mass difference.

The detector zero can also drift with time. One useful sequence weighs the sample, then the standard, then the sample again, with equal time intervals. If the zero changes at a constant rate during the sequence, the mean of the two sample readings has the zero appropriate to the middle reading. This cancels linear drift. The buoyancy difference between sample and standard still needs its own correction.

Sources: [1]

An electronic balance holds the load with a current

An electronic balance can replace the opposite weight with a coil in a magnetic field. Current through the coil produces a force. When a sample pushes the pan down, a sensor detects the displacement and a control circuit adjusts the current to bring the beam back. The current needed to hold that position tells the instrument the balancing force. This is electromagnetic force compensation.

Air continues to support part of the sample even when the readout is electronic. Calibration weights establish the relation between current and indicated mass; the sample may displace a different amount of air from those weights. A more precise weighing needs better knowledge of the densities and the surrounding air. That is the practical limit of the correction: uncertainty in sample density also leaves uncertainty in the corrected mass.

Sources: [2][1]

Sources and further reading

  1. NIST SOP 2, Applying Air Buoyancy Corrections (2019)

    Equation 3 gives true mass from a reference and a buoyancy-corrected difference; section 5.1 defines same-pan substitution. Equation 5 distinguishes conventional mass.

  2. Arthur Reichmuth, METTLER TOLEDO, Adverse Influences and Their Prevention in Weighing (2001)

    Printed pages 1–2 explain electrodynamic force compensation; page 6 defines sensitivity as the slope between two load/readout points.

Keep reading

What this page links to directly

See this series on the content map →

How physics instruments measure · Reading path

How physics instruments measure

  1. ArticleHow a vernier reads between millimetres
  2. You are hereAir helps hold up the object on a balance
  3. ArticleHow Cavendish Measured the Attraction Between Spheres
  4. ArticleWhich pressure does a liquid column measure?
  5. ArticleThe cup absorbs heat too
  6. ArticleRotational rheometers need both torque and speed
  7. ArticleWhy the air beyond a pipe changes its resonance
  8. ArticleHow a seismometer reads the ground through motion inside its case
  9. ArticleWhy does a meter change the circuit?
  10. ArticleHow a null detector reveals a resistance
  11. ArticleWhy a capacitor can behave like an inductor
  12. ArticleWhere does the slow wave on an oscilloscope come from?
  13. ArticleHow a lock-in amplifier finds a signal buried in noise
  14. ArticleWhere a small peak in a spectrum can come from
  15. ArticleHow a network analyzer separates the cable from the device
  16. ArticleWhen a slower quartz crystal can measure added mass
  17. ArticleHow an echelle spectrograph gives overlapping colors a second direction
  18. ArticleHow total brightness reveals many infrared colors
  19. ArticleMeasuring a Solution’s Concentration with Light
  20. ArticleHow an ellipsometer reads thin-film thickness from reflected light
  21. ArticleHow a polarimeter reveals mixed polarization
  22. ArticleHow individual photons reveal a fluorescence lifetime
  23. ArticleBrillouin Microscopy Listens to Sound with Light
  24. ArticleHow a white sphere compares a lamp’s total output
  25. ArticleHow powder rings reveal atomic spacing
  26. ArticleHow Small-Angle X-ray Scattering Reads a Particle Halo
  27. ArticleWhy X-ray fluorescence depends on sample thickness
  28. ArticleWhy an AFM makes a bump look wider
  29. ArticleHow a small indentation separates hardness from elasticity
  30. ArticleHow Differential Scanning Calorimetry Reads a Melting Peak
  31. ArticleHow thermogravimetry separates mass loss from the gas around it
  32. ArticleHow a diamond anvil cell reads pressure in ruby light
  33. ArticleHow diamond fluorescence reveals a magnetic-field direction
  34. ArticleReading a magnetic field in the rhythm of atoms
  35. ArticleKeeping a laser in time with atoms
  36. ArticleWhy a Kibble balance needs two experiments
  37. ArticleHow a dilution refrigerator keeps carrying heat away
  38. ArticleWhy a bigger vacuum pump may barely help the sample
  39. ArticleHow microwaves read a superconducting qubit
  40. ArticleHow current leaves a voltage across a thin sheet
  41. ArticleHow an ion flight becomes a mass spectrum
  42. ArticleHow four straight rods select ion mass
  43. ArticleHow a rapidly reversing field can hold ions
  44. ArticleHow a cyclotron keeps a proton on the accelerating beat
  45. ArticleWhy the drift tubes in an RF linac get longer
  46. ArticleThe directions hidden inside a small beam spot
  47. ArticleHow defocusing magnets help a beam stay in a ring
  48. ArticleWhy a collider cannot keep every collision
  49. ArticleGetting synchrotron light onto a sample
  50. ArticleHow a free-electron laser gathers electrons into a brighter beam
  51. ArticleFollowing energy exchange with neutron flight times
  52. ArticleHow a tokamak holds heat and measures where it goes
  53. ArticleWhy stellarator coils bend in three dimensions
  54. ArticleHow NIF turns a laser pulse into an implosion
Something broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy