A long tube balances bending against tension. A very thin tube bends sharply; a broad tube consumes more membrane area. Their balance fixes a radius. Each extra length then costs the same energy, giving a force plateau. Instrument elasticity determines how much of an imposed displacement actually lengthens the tube.
Take a cylinder of radius r and length L, leaving out its end connections. Choose the pulling direction and force f positive along the axis. Principal curvatures are 1/r and zero. Set spontaneous curvature and pressure difference to zero. A sufficiently large reservoir supplies membrane at specified tension σ.
The tube area is 2πrL. Multiply the bending energy density by this area and add the tension cost of taking area from the reservoir. This fixed-tension condition differs from the fixed-total-area condition in the shape experiment.
G(r,L)=(rπκ+2πσr)L
Bending favors a broad tube and tension a narrow one. End regions, finite reservoir area, pressure, spontaneous curvature and tube nucleation need additional modeling.
At fixed length, differentiate with respect to radius. The bending slope is negative and the tension slope positive. Setting their sum to zero gives the equilibrium radius. A positive second derivative confirms a minimum against radial changes.
Insert this radius into the energy per length. Total energy grows linearly with length, so f0=∂G/∂L is constant. The plateau describes an already formed, sufficiently long tube. Initial protrusion from a membrane has a different shape and end-region force.
−r02πκ+2πσ=0,r0=2σκ
Rigidity has energy units and tension has energy per area; the square root of their ratio is a length.
f0=2π2κσ=r02πκ
Energy per length is force. The two expressions also give an independently checkable product relation.
Connect the pulling probe to a linear spring of stiffness k. Let X be the axial reservoir-to-support distance and L the effective tube length. The spring extension is x=X−L. Static balance equates its force with the tube force.
On a long-tube plateau, spring extension stays fixed, so further support motion becomes tube length. A softer instrument needs a larger displacement to supply the same force. Stop using the cylindrical limit when the remaining tube approaches the scale of the end regions. The experiment begins with an existing long tube; pull stroke adds to the initial support coordinate. During motion, drag allows instantaneous spring force to differ from the plateau until the tube settles.
Gtotal=f0L+2k(X−L)2,x=kf0,L=X−kf0
This one-dimensional quasistatic series model assumes a spring-like probe and a preexisting tube that remains sufficiently long.
Worked example of force and displacement
Choose teaching parameters κ=80pNnm and σ=0.010pNnm−1. Then r0=80/0.020nm≃63.2nm and f0≃7.95pN. This radius is much smaller than a micrometer-scale vesicle, so apparatus drawings often magnify the tube diameter.
For k=0.050pNnm−1 and X=2.00μm, spring displacement is approximately 159nm and tube length 1.84μm. Treating the support distance as tube length would overcount by the spring displacement.
Doubling tension narrows the tube and raises force. Doubling rigidity broadens it and also raises force. Observing both quantities helps distinguish the causes.
Recover two parameters from two measurements
Plateau force alone determines the product κσ. Add an independent radius measurement: multiplying force by radius gives rigidity and dividing force by radius gives tension. Use a radius measured independently of the assumed rigidity for this second observable.
κ=2πf0r0,σ=4πr0f0
These expressions retain the long-cylinder, zero-pressure and zero-spontaneous-curvature assumptions. Probe stiffness and radius calibration errors propagate into the estimates.
Predict how increased tension changes diameter, force and probe displacement.
Hold rigidity fixed and vary tension. Then change instrument stiffness and compare displacement at the same force.
Drag the pulling end and compare support position, spring displacement and tube length. Explain why the plateau force does not grow with long-tube length.
Inspect probe thermal motion and response in the specified calibration model.
Explain why membrane tube equations cannot determine instrument stiffness and list the quantities needed before converting displacement to force.
Exercises and explanations
Quadruple tension at fixed rigidity. How do radius and plateau force change?
Read the explanation
Radius halves and force doubles. Taking area becomes more expensive, favoring a narrower tube that requires a larger pulling force.
Measured force increases. Does this alone establish increased rigidity?
Read the explanation
No. Increased tension also raises plateau force. Measure radius or tension independently to distinguish the two.
Why cannot extrapolating the long-tube formula to zero length explain a nucleation peak?
Read the explanation
The derivation removes end regions, which dominate the short-tube problem. Their shape needs a fuller calculation. Constant plateau force describes the long-tube limit.
Original curvature-elasticity paper, pages 693–703. We use its local quadratic curvature energy with an explicitly stated sphere-positive curvature convention. The sphere, tube and small-slope examples are derived here; no original figure or measured material parameter is copied.
Version 1, 29 May 2002, equations (1)–(2): the Helfrich energy and the long cylindrical tube radius and force. We recalculate this analytic limit and add a specified linear instrument spring. The nucleation peak, short-tube profiles, tube interactions and published figure points are outside the reproduced scope.
Keep reading
What this page links to directly
You are hereThe force needed to pull a membrane tube