Model assumptions
The mean relation is equation 2 of Macquart and colleagues (2020) for a flat universe with the Planck 2015 parameters they list, fully ionised hydrogen and helium with a helium mass fraction of one quarter, and a constant diffuse fraction; the paper lets that fraction change slowly with redshift. The clumpy universe is a teaching model, not a cosmological simulation. Halos come in four fixed classes, from dwarf galaxies to clusters, with constant comoving abundance. Each keeps three quarters of its share of baryons inside the radius where its density is two hundred times the critical density, spread with the modified NFW profile of Prochaska and Zheng (2019). Halos below the feedback mass hand their gas to the intergalactic medium over one decade of mass. The intergalactic gas varies from one 8 megaparsec cell to the next by a log-normal factor of width 0.6. Halo masses, abundances, cell size and that width are schematic choices; they give a spread parameter of 0.09 to 0.2, inside the range of the semi-analytic values Macquart and colleagues quote but lower than their 0.32 for the smallest feedback mass. Each simulated burst adds a host term drawn log-normally with width 0.5 and divided by one plus redshift. The Milky Way terms are fixed at 30 and 50 parsecs per cubic centimetre as in the paper. The real points are the six localized ASKAP bursts of the paper’s table 1, with the Milky Way terms removed; the open diamond is FRB 190611, left out of the paper’s gold sample. The stage stretches the up–down direction so halos are visible, shows one fixed random realisation and slows the pulse to seconds.