Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics
Fast radio bursts and the cosmic baryon census

Why every sightline gives a different dispersion

Sandbox Physics ·

Two bursts at the same redshift almost never have the same cosmic dispersion, because each sightline crosses a different, small number of gas-filled halos. The number of halos crossed grows in proportion to the path, so the relative spread falls roughly as z−1/2z^{-1/2}. How big the spread is at a given redshift depends on how much gas the halos keep, which is set by feedback from stars and black holes. This chapter derives that scaling from a counting argument, builds a schematic halo model to put numbers on it, and compares the result with the distribution Macquart and colleagues fitted to their bursts.

Read Adding up electrons across an expanding universe first. You also need the Poisson distribution, whose variance equals its mean.

Counting halos along a line

Suppose halos of one kind have comoving number density nn and a gas radius rr. A line of comoving length DD passes within rr of the centre of, on average,

λ=n πr2D\lambda=n\,\pi r^2 D

of them, and the actual number is Poisson-distributed with mean λ\lambda. Each crossing adds a column δ\delta that depends on how close the line passes to the centre. For a sum of a Poisson number of independent contributions,

⟨DMhalo⟩=λ⟨δ⟩,Var(DMhalo)=λ⟨δ2⟩.\langle\mathrm{DM}_{\mathrm{halo}}\rangle=\lambda\langle\delta\rangle,\qquad \mathrm{Var}(\mathrm{DM}_{\mathrm{halo}})=\lambda\langle\delta^2\rangle .

Both grow in proportion to DD, and at low redshift so does the mean of the whole cosmic term. The relative spread is therefore

σ⟨DMcosmic⟩∝DD∝z−1/2.\frac{\sigma}{\langle\mathrm{DM}_{\mathrm{cosmic}}\rangle}\propto\frac{\sqrt D}{D}\propto z^{-1/2}.

This is the Euclidean argument Macquart et al., 2020, Methods, after eq. 4 give for writing the spread as σDM=Fz−1/2\sigma_{\mathrm{DM}}=Fz^{-1/2}, with one parameter FF that measures how lumpy the gas is.

Worked example: how many Milky-Way-sized halos does a sightline meet?

Give halos of 1012 M⊙10^{12}\,M_\odot a gas radius equal to r200=0.211 Mpcr_{200}=0.211\,\mathrm{Mpc}, the radius inside which the mean density is 200 times the critical density. If they hold 11 percent of all matter, Ωmρc,0=3.94×1010 M⊙ Mpc−3\Omega_{\mathrm m}\rho_{\mathrm c,0}=3.94\times10^{10}\,M_\odot\,\mathrm{Mpc^{-3}} gives n=4.3×10−3 Mpc−3n=4.3\times10^{-3}\,\mathrm{Mpc^{-3}}. Out to z=1z=1, D=3396 MpcD=3396\,\mathrm{Mpc}, so λ=4.3×10−3×π×0.2112×3396=2.05\lambda=4.3\times10^{-3}\times\pi\times0.211^2\times3396=2.05. A sightline to z=1z=1 meets about two such halos, and one in eight meets none.

A schematic halo model

The Lab and the saved materials use four halo classes, each with a gas profile from Prochaska and Zheng, 2019, Section 3: a modified NFW profile ρ∝yα−1/(y0+y)2+α\rho\propto y^{\alpha-1}/(y_0+y)^{2+\alpha} with y=c r/r200y=c\,r/r_{200}, α=2\alpha=2, y0=2y_0=2 and concentration c=4.67 (M/1014h−1M⊙)−0.11c=4.67\,(M/10^{14}h^{-1}M_\odot)^{-0.11}. A halo that keeps its gas holds a fraction 0.750.75 of its cosmic share of baryons inside r200r_{200}.

Table 4.1 The four halo classes of the teaching model, with crossings out to z=1z=1.
Halo mass (M⊙)(M_\odot)Share of all matterr200r_{200} (Mpc)Gas mass (M⊙)(M_\odot)Mean crossings to z=1z=1
101110^{11}0.100.0981.18×10101.18\times10^{10}4.02
101210^{12}0.110.2111.18×10111.18\times10^{11}2.05
101310^{13}0.100.4541.18×10121.18\times10^{12}0.87
2×10142\times10^{14}0.0441.2332.36×10132.36\times10^{13}0.14

Feedback is modelled with one number, Mmin⁡M_{\min}: halos lighter than it lose their gas to the intergalactic medium, heavier ones keep it. The baryons removed from halos are added back to the smooth gas, so the mean dispersion does not change, only its spread. The intergalactic gas itself is drawn as a log-normal factor with width 0.60.6 in each 8 Mpc cell. These are teaching choices. The model ignores the clustering of halos around filaments and uses only four masses.

Worked example: the average column through a Milky-Way-sized halo

The halo holds 1.18×1011 M⊙1.18\times10^{11}\,M_\odot of gas, and each solar mass of ionised gas with Y=0.25Y=0.25 holds 1.04×10571.04\times10^{57} electrons. Spread over the disc πr2002=0.140 Mpc2=1.33×1048 cm2\pi r_{200}^2=0.140\,\mathrm{Mpc^2}=1.33\times10^{48}\,\mathrm{cm^2}, that is 9.2×1019 cm−29.2\times10^{19}\,\mathrm{cm^{-2}}, or 30 pc cm−330\,\mathrm{pc\,cm^{-3}}. A line through the inner tenth of the radius picks up several times more.

What the simulation gives

Running 3000 random sightlines per case gives the numbers below. The mean agrees with the uniform-universe value of Table 3.1 within 1 percent in all twelve cases, as it must. The standard deviation agrees with the compound-Poisson formula within 5 percent, except when only clusters keep gas: there only about 150 to 400 of the 3000 lines meet a cluster, and the sample standard deviation is up to 13 percent off.

Table 4.2 Spread parameter F=σDMz/⟨DM⟩F=\sigma_{\mathrm{DM}}\sqrt z/\langle\mathrm{DM}\rangle at z=0.5z=0.5, teaching model against the semi-analytic models of Macquart and colleagues.
Halos keep gas aboveFF, this modelFF, Macquart Ext. Data Fig. 3
1011 M⊙10^{11}\,M_\odot0.180.32
1012 M⊙10^{12}\,M_\odot0.16not given
1013 M⊙10^{13}\,M_\odot0.130.15
1014 M⊙10^{14}\,M_\odot0.090.09

The two agree when only groups and clusters hold gas. With gas kept down to 1011 M⊙10^{11}\,M_\odot this model is about half as lumpy. It has only four halo masses, no clustering of halos, and no gas beyond r200r_{200}, so its value for light halos is a property of this schematic model, not a prediction. Macquart et al., 2020, Methods and Extended Data Fig. 3

The distribution is skewed. At z=0.5z=0.5 with Mmin⁡=1012 M⊙M_{\min}=10^{12}\,M_\odot, the mean is 444444, the median 410410, and 90 percent of sightlines lie between 356356 and 658 pc cm−3658\,\mathrm{pc\,cm^{-3}}. Most lines miss the big halos and sit a little below the mean. A few that cross a group or cluster form the long upper tail. The sharp lower edge comes from the smooth intergalactic gas, which every line crosses. Macquart and colleagues built that shape into their fitting function,

pcosmic(Δ)=A Δ−βexp⁡ ⁣[−(Δ−α−C0)22α2σDM2],Δ=DMcosmic⟨DMcosmic⟩,p_{\mathrm{cosmic}}(\Delta)=A\,\Delta^{-\beta}\exp\!\left[-\frac{(\Delta^{-\alpha}-C_0)^2}{2\alpha^2\sigma_{\mathrm{DM}}^2}\right],\qquad \Delta=\frac{\mathrm{DM}_{\mathrm{cosmic}}}{\langle\mathrm{DM}_{\mathrm{cosmic}}\rangle},

with α=β=3\alpha=\beta=3 and C0C_0 fixed by requiring ⟨Δ⟩=1\langle\Delta\rangle=1.

Why this makes distance ambiguous

The spread means one dispersion measure maps to a range of redshifts. At z=0.5z=0.5 the 90 percent band spans about 300 pc cm−3300\,\mathrm{pc\,cm^{-3}}, which in the mean relation covers redshifts from 0.400.40 to 0.720.72. Adding a host contribution widens it further. A dispersion measure is a statistical distance indicator for a population, not a distance for one burst. Connor et al., 2025, Fig. 3 shows the other side of the same coin: two universes with the same mean cosmic dispersion but very different shares of gas in halos produce different distributions below the median, which is what a large sample can tell apart.

Lab task

Drag the host galaxy up and down in the Lab and follow the gold line across the histogram of sightlines. Then choose Feedback empties the halos and compare the width of the histogram and of the band with the default.

Exercises

  1. If F=0.2F=0.2, what is σDM\sigma_{\mathrm{DM}} at z=0.25z=0.25 and at z=1z=1?
  2. In the teaching model, what fraction of sightlines to z=1z=1 meet no halo of 2×1014 M⊙2\times10^{14}\,M_\odot?
  3. Explain why moving gas from halos to the intergalactic medium leaves the mean unchanged but narrows the distribution.
  4. Why is the median of the cosmic dispersion below its mean?
Answers
  1. σDM=0.2/0.25=0.4\sigma_{\mathrm{DM}}=0.2/\sqrt{0.25}=0.4 and 0.2/1=0.20.2/\sqrt1=0.2. Relative to the mean, nearby bursts scatter twice as much as bursts at z=1z=1.
  2. The crossings are Poisson with mean 0.140.14, so the fraction with none is e−0.14=0.87e^{-0.14}=0.87.
  3. The mean counts every electron once wherever it sits. The variance depends on how many separate lumps carry the electrons: the same total split over many cells of smooth gas, each crossed by every line, varies far less than when it sits in a few halos that most lines miss.
  4. Most of the halo contribution comes from rare crossings with large columns. A typical line misses them and falls below the mean, while the few lines that hit them pull the mean up.

Sources

  1. Macquart et al., 2020, Methods, after eq. 4
  2. Prochaska and Zheng, 2019, Section 3
  3. Connor et al., 2025, Fig. 3

Keep reading

What this page links to directly

See this series on the content map →

Fast radio bursts and the cosmic baryon census · Reading path

From one delayed pulse to the missing baryons

  1. ArticleHow do fast radio bursts count the ordinary matter between galaxies?
  2. ArticleHow free electrons delay a radio burst
  3. ArticleAdding up electrons across an expanding universe
  4. You are hereWhy every sightline gives a different dispersion
  5. ArticleRecompute the localized-burst baryon census
  6. ArticleReading the FRB baryon census papers
Something broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy