Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics
Fast radio bursts and the cosmic baryon census

Reading the FRB baryon census papers

Sandbox Physics ·

Macquart and colleagues showed in a published 2020 paper that five localised bursts carry the electron column expected if the early-universe baryon density is all there, mostly as diffuse ionised gas. A 2024 preprint by Connor and colleagues, revised in 2025, uses 69 bursts to go further: it splits the gas between the space outside halos and the halos themselves, and measures the baryon density to about 10 percent. The first result is peer-reviewed; the second is not yet. This guide names the version, section and figure behind each claim, and sorts the claims into published results, preprint results, model predictions and open questions.

Read Recompute the localized-burst baryon census first if you want to see the 2020 likelihood rebuilt step by step.

Which versions this guide reads

Table 6.1 Sources, versions and status as read for this guide.
PaperVersion readStatus
Macquart et al., A census of baryons in the Universe from localized fast radio burstsarXiv:2005.13161v1published, Nature 581, 391 (2020)
Prochaska and Zheng, Probing Galactic Halos with Fast Radio BurstsarXiv:1901.11051v1published, MNRAS 485, 648 (2019)
Petroff, Hessels and Lorimer, Fast radio bursts at the dawn of the 2020sarXiv:2107.10113v2, 19 January 2022review written for The Astronomy and Astrophysics Review
Connor et al., A gas-rich cosmic web revealed by the partitioning of the missing baryonsarXiv:2409.16952v2, 24 June 2025preprint; no journal reference on its arXiv page

All four were read in full text. The journal references for the first two come from the reference list of the Connor preprint.

Macquart et al. 2020: what Figs. 2 and 3 do and do not show

Fig. 2 plots an estimated cosmic dispersion against redshift for every localised burst, over the mean relation for Planck 2015 and a shaded band that holds 90 percent of sightlines in a feedback model with F=0.2F=0.2. Each point already has a host term of 50/(1+z) pc cm−350/(1+z)\,\mathrm{pc\,cm^{-3}} subtracted. The agreement in Fig. 2 therefore depends on that assumed host value and is a visual check, not the measurement. Macquart et al., 2020, Fig. 2

The measurement is Fig. 3. It fits four parameters, Ωbh70\Omega_{\mathrm b}h_{70}, FF, μ\mu and σhost\sigma_{\mathrm{host}}, to the five gold-standard bursts and marginalises over the last three. The main text gives a fractional precision of 0.31 at 68 percent confidence, a ratio to the early-universe value of 1.1−0.6+0.51.1^{+0.5}_{-0.6}, and rules out Ωbh70<0.02\Omega_{\mathrm b}h_{70}<0.02 at 98.6 percent confidence. Adding two more bursts moves the best value from 0.051−0.015+0.0140.051^{+0.014}_{-0.015} to 0.042−0.012+0.0110.042^{+0.011}_{-0.012}, shown in Extended Data Fig. 4. The Markov-chain version is Extended Data Fig. 5 and Extended Data Table 2.

The paper says the bursts are consistent with all the missing baryons sitting in the ionised intergalactic medium. Read that as a statement about the total diffuse electron column along the sightlines. A dispersion measure does not say where along the path the electrons are. Separating gas between halos from gas inside them needs the shape of the distribution, which is what the newer preprint uses.

Where the gas sits: halos and the space between

Prochaska and Zheng, 2019, Sections 3 and 7 supply the model behind most of this discussion. Halos above a minimum mass keep 75 percent of their cosmic share of baryons inside r200r_{200}, in a modified NFW profile. Section 7.1 adds such halos along random sightlines and shows how the spread of the cosmic term depends on the minimum mass. These are model predictions: they say what the scatter would be if halos kept that much gas.

The Connor preprint turns this around and fits it. Its new step is to give the intergalactic medium and the halos separate parameters, fIGMf_{\mathrm{IGM}} and fXf_{\mathrm X}, referenced to redshift 0.1, with a likelihood built from a mock survey in the IllustrisTNG simulation. The fit gives fIGM=0.76−0.11+0.10f_{\mathrm{IGM}}=0.76^{+0.10}_{-0.11} and fX=0.15−0.10+0.11f_{\mathrm X}=0.15^{+0.11}_{-0.10}, with a median rest-frame host of 130−23+25 pc cm−3130^{+25}_{-23}\,\mathrm{pc\,cm^{-3}}. Connor et al., 2025, Fig. 2

The feature that drives the large intergalactic share is a floor: no burst beyond redshift 0.1 has an extragalactic dispersion per unit redshift below 800 pc cm−3800\,\mathrm{pc\,cm^{-3}}. Fig. 3 of the preprint shows why that matters. Two universes with the same mean cosmic dispersion, one with fIGM=0.80f_{\mathrm{IGM}}=0.80 and fX=0.12f_{\mathrm X}=0.12 and one with 0.600.60 and 0.320.32, differ mainly below the median. Gas-rich halos would let more sightlines come in low.

Three things to keep apart when reading this section:

  1. The shares of baryons in clusters, 3.75±0.53.75\pm0.5 percent, and in groups of 1012.710^{12.7} to 1014 M⊙10^{14}\,M_\odot, 5.4±1.05.4\pm1.0 percent, come from X-ray and Sunyaev–Zeldovich measurements that the authors combine with the bursts. They are not measured by the bursts.
  2. The statement that the gas around individual galaxies holds only 0.35−0.25+0.300.35^{+0.30}_{-0.25} of its cosmic share, for halos of 10910^{9} to 5×1012 M⊙5\times10^{12}\,M_\odot, is an inference from the budget once the other pieces are fixed.
  3. The fit uses one simulation, TNG300. The authors widen their Markov-chain errors by 30 percent to allow for model mismatch.

Joint cosmology

If the total baryon content is left free, the preprint finds Ωbh70=0.051±0.006\Omega_{\mathrm b}h_{70}=0.051\pm0.006 (Fig. 4), consistent with the early-universe value at the 10 percent level. An independent fit to the mean cosmic dispersion alone gives fd=0.94±0.05f_{\mathrm d}=0.94\pm0.05 (Extended Data Fig. 4). The paper also quotes H0=71±7 km s−1 Mpc−1H_0=71\pm7\,\mathrm{km\,s^{-1}\,Mpc^{-1}}, with the caveat that this requires fixing the baryon density at its early-universe value, so it is not an independent Hubble constant. Connor et al., 2025, Fig. 4 and main text

The same paper writes that its result may ease the lower clustering amplitude seen by weak-lensing surveys, if feedback pushes gas out of halos. That sentence is a suggestion, not a measurement. In the same way, the upper limit on the stellar baryon fraction, at most 9 percent, follows from fdf_{\mathrm d} and an independent count of cold gas.

Sort the claims

Table 6.2 Claims sorted by status.
ClaimStatusWhere
Five localised bursts give a baryon density consistent with the early universe, to about 30 percentpublished resultMacquart Fig. 3
The cosmic scatter follows σDM=Fz−1/2\sigma_{\mathrm{DM}}=Fz^{-1/2} with FF set by feedbackpublished model, calibrated on semi-analytic modelsMacquart Methods, Ext. Data Fig. 3
Halos with fb,halo=0.75f_{\mathrm{b,halo}}=0.75 would add a predictable spreadmodel predictionProchaska and Zheng, Sections 3 and 7.1
About 76 percent of baryons lie outside halospreprint resultConnor Fig. 2
Ωbh70=0.051±0.006\Omega_{\mathrm b}h_{70}=0.051\pm0.006 from 69 burstspreprint resultConnor Fig. 4
The gas around galaxies holds less than its cosmic sharepreprint inference, depends on X-ray and simulation inputsConnor main text
Feedback that empties halos eases the weak-lensing tensionopen questionConnor main text
One dispersion measure gives one burst's distancenot supported; FRB 20190520B has a large host excessPetroff Section 4.1, Fig. 13

Open questions

How the gas fraction of a halo depends on its mass between 101110^{11} and 1013 M⊙10^{13}\,M_\odot is still model-dependent. The host contribution is fitted as a log-normal because that shape is flexible, not because it is derived; bursts like FRB 20190520B show that a long tail exists. The Milky Way halo term is assumed at 50, within an expected range of 50 to 100. Surveys that miss high-dispersion bursts bias the inferred baryon density low, as the injection test in the method guide shows. And a census built on one simulation needs to be repeated with other feedback models before the split between halos and intergalactic gas is settled. Petroff et al., 2022, Section 4.1

Lab task

In the Lab, choose Feedback empties the halos and compare the band and the histogram with the default. The mean relation stays put, while the low side of the distribution tightens. That is the signal the 2025 preprint reads from its 69 bursts.

Sources

  1. Macquart et al., 2020, Fig. 2
  2. Prochaska and Zheng, 2019, Sections 3 and 7
  3. Connor et al., 2025, Fig. 2
  4. Petroff et al., 2022, Section 4.1

Keep reading

What this page links to directly

See this series on the content map →

Fast radio bursts and the cosmic baryon census · Reading path

From one delayed pulse to the missing baryons

  1. ArticleHow do fast radio bursts count the ordinary matter between galaxies?
  2. ArticleHow free electrons delay a radio burst
  3. ArticleAdding up electrons across an expanding universe
  4. ArticleWhy every sightline gives a different dispersion
  5. ArticleRecompute the localized-burst baryon census
  6. You are hereReading the FRB baryon census papers
Something broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy