Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics
Lensed quasar time delays and the Hubble constant

Recompute the Hubble constant from seven TDCOSMO lenses

Sandbox Physics ·

This guide turns the published time-delay distances of the seven TDCOSMO lenses into a Hubble constant, one lens at a time. With the line-of-sight correction and no internal mass sheet the seven lenses give H0=74.2±1.6H_0=74.2\pm1.6. Multiplying by the internal sheet λint=0.91±0.04\lambda_{\rm int}=0.91\pm0.04 that TDCOSMO IV found with extra stellar-speed data gives 67.5±3.367.5\pm3.3, close to the paper's 67.4−3.2+4.167.4^{+4.1}_{-3.2}. A slope shift of 0.05 moves the answer by 5.3 percent; the matter density hardly moves it.

Read the mass-sheet chapter first. This is a check of the scaling relations on real inputs. It is not the paper's hierarchical inference, which uses stellar kinematics, orbit anisotropy and full posteriors.

Get the files

Put these five files in one empty folder:

Then run:

python3 reproduce.py --check

The script needs only the Python standard library. We ran it with Python 3.9.6. It prints the tables below, writes outputs.json in the current folder and exits with status 1 if the rounded outputs differ from expected-outputs.json.

The input: Table 2 of TDCOSMO IV

TDCOSMO IV, Birrer et al. 2020, arXiv version 3, published in A&A 643, A165. Table 2 lists for each lens the redshifts, Einstein radius, power-law slope γpl\gamma_{\rm pl}, external convergence κext\kappa_{\rm ext} and the time-delay distance DΔtplD_{\Delta t}^{\rm pl} of the power-law model. The caption says DΔtplD_{\Delta t}^{\rm pl} comes from imaging and time delays and does not include external convergence or internal mass-sheet terms. That is exactly the quantity the mass sheet acts on. TDCOSMO IV, Sec. 5.1 and Table 2

Each value is stored as a list of three numbers: the median, the lower error and the upper error. We transcribed the table by hand from the ar5iv HTML rendering; check a digit against the PDF before relying on it.

Step 1: one lens, one Hubble constant

For flat Λ\LambdaCDM the time-delay distance is proportional to 1/H01/H_0 at fixed redshifts and Ωm\Omega_{\rm m}. So compute DΔtD_{\Delta t} at H0=70H_0=70 km s−1^{-1} Mpc−1^{-1} and Ωm=0.3\Omega_{\rm m}=0.3, by integrating 1/E(z)1/E(z) numerically, and scale:

H0pl=70×DΔt(H0=70)DΔtpl.H_0^{\rm pl}=70\times\frac{D_{\Delta t}(H_0=70)}{D_{\Delta t}^{\rm pl}} .

The error is the mean half-width of the DΔtplD_{\Delta t}^{\rm pl} interval, carried as a fraction.

Step 2: the line of sight

The measured distance is the lens-specific one, DΔtlens=(1−κext)DΔtbkgD_{\Delta t}^{\rm lens}=(1-\kappa_{\rm ext})D_{\Delta t}^{\rm bkg} (Eq. 32). Cosmology predicts the smooth-universe distance, so H0→(1−κext)H0plH_0\to(1-\kappa_{\rm ext})H_0^{\rm pl}, with the κext\kappa_{\rm ext} error added in quadrature.

Table 5.1 Lens-by-lens Hubble constant from Table 2 of TDCOSMO IV, in km s−1^{-1} Mpc−1^{-1}.
LensDΔtD_{\Delta t} at H0=70H_0=70 (Mpc)Power lawTimes 1−κext1-\kappa_{\rm ext}
B1608+656513675.3 ± 2.167.5 ± 5.2
RXJ1131−-1231233483.9 ± 1.578.1 ± 3.2
HE0435−-1223275771.6 ± 4.271.3 ± 4.6
SDSS1206+4332575468.9 ± 7.369.2 ± 7.6
WFI2033−-4723487775.2 ± 2.470.8 ± 5.1
PG1115+080166880.1 ± 6.480.6 ± 6.8
DES0408−-5354358471.9 ± 1.574.7 ± 2.7

The inverse-variance mean of the last column is 74.2±1.674.2\pm1.6.

Step 3: an internal mass sheet

The total transform is λ=(1−κs)λint\lambda=(1-\kappa_{\rm s})\lambda_{\rm int} and H0,λ=λH0H_{0,\lambda}=\lambda H_0 (Eqs. 29 and 34). Multiply by the population means of Table 6:

Table 5.2 The seven-lens result times three choices of internal mass sheet, against the published values.
λint\lambda_{\rm int}This scriptPublished
1 (power law)74.2 ± 1.6H0LiCOW, six lenses: 73.3−1.8+1.773.3^{+1.7}_{-1.8}
1.02−0.09+0.081.02^{+0.08}_{-0.09} (TDCOSMO only)75.7 ± 6.574.5−6.1+5.674.5^{+5.6}_{-6.1}
0.91±0.040.91\pm0.04 (TDCOSMO + SLACS)67.5 ± 3.367.4−3.2+4.167.4^{+4.1}_{-3.2}

TDCOSMO IV, Table 6 H0LiCOW XIII, abstract

The middle row is 1.2 above the paper. Our shortcut multiplies a fixed λint\lambda_{\rm int} into a fixed combined H0H_0; the paper infers λint\lambda_{\rm int}, the anisotropy and H0H_0 together from the kinematics and lets λint\lambda_{\rm int} vary with the ratio of each lens's half-light radius to its Einstein radius. We did not reproduce that inference, so do not read the agreement in the last row as more than a check of the scaling. What the table does show is the size of the effect: a 9 percent sheet moves H0H_0 by about 7 units.

Step 4: slope and matter density

Slope. At fixed image positions the predicted delay scales close to γ′−1\gamma'-1 (Kochanek 2002, Eq. 8), so the inferred H0H_0 does too. Shifting every slope by +0.05+0.05 raises the combined value by 5.3 percent; −0.05-0.05 lowers it by 5.3 percent. This is a rough guide, not a refit. In a real model a slope change also moves the other parameters. Kochanek 2002, Sec. 2.1

Matter density. Changing Ωm\Omega_{\rm m} from 0.3 to 0.25 raises the result by 0.2 percent; changing it to 0.35 lowers it by 0.3 percent. The time-delay distance is a ratio of distances times 1+zd1+z_{\rm d}, and most of the dependence on the expansion history cancels.

Failure cases

  • Ignore the line of sight. Setting κext=0\kappa_{\rm ext}=0 gives 76.8. The sample mean κext\kappa_{\rm ext} is positive, 0.035 (TDCOSMO IV, Sec. 5.1), so leaving it out biases H0H_0 upward.
  • Trust one lens. RXJ1131−-1231 alone gives 78.1±3.278.1\pm3.2. Its small distance error hides the model and environment errors that only show up across a sample.
  • Drop the lens H0LiCOW did not use. Without DES0408−-5354 the remaining six give 73.9, close to the H0LiCOW XIII value from the same six lenses.
  • Treat asymmetric errors as Gaussian. We do this throughout. For B1608+656 the κext\kappa_{\rm ext} interval is −0.045/+0.084-0.045/+0.084, and averaging it understates the chance of a large correction.
  • Edit an input. Change a distance or a κext\kappa_{\rm ext} in the JSON and the --check run fails. Any edit breaks the checksums in provenance.json.

What this does not show

Image positions alone cannot fix H0H_0: every number here starts from distances that already include measured delays. Stellar kinematics fix λint\lambda_{\rm int} in the paper; here we copied λint\lambda_{\rm int} in. Line-of-sight corrections come from the paper's per-lens κext\kappa_{\rm ext} posteriors, which we reduced to two numbers each.

A checklist for the next lensing paper

  1. Find which time-delay distance a table lists: with or without external convergence, with or without an internal sheet.
  2. Find which mass profile it assumes, and how the slope uncertainty enters.
  3. Find where λ\lambda comes from: an assumed profile, kinematics, or an external sample with its own selection.
  4. Check how much the result moves when κext\kappa_{\rm ext} is set to zero, as a sense of scale.
  5. Separate what is measured (delays, image positions, velocity dispersions) from what is assumed (profile shape, anisotropy, the parent population).

The next page reads TDCOSMO IV section by section: how to read TDCOSMO IV.

Sources

  1. TDCOSMO IV, Sec. 5.1 and Table 2
  2. H0LiCOW XIII, abstract
  3. Kochanek 2002, Sec. 2.1

Keep reading

What this page links to directly

See this series on the content map →

Lensed quasar time delays and the Hubble constant · Reading path

From a delayed flare to the Hubble constant

  1. ArticleHow a delayed quasar flare measures the size of the universe
  2. ArticleArrival time, the Fermat potential and the delay of an isothermal lens
  3. ArticleMass slope, shear and the time-delay distance
  4. ArticleThe mass-sheet degeneracy and what stellar speeds add
  5. You are hereRecompute the Hubble constant from seven TDCOSMO lenses
  6. ArticleHow to read TDCOSMO IV on the mass sheet and the Hubble constant
1 more group

Other articles that use the same experiments

Each experiment from this article that another series also uses, followed by the articles there.

  1. LabGravitational Lens Telescope
  2. ArticleHow a dark planet makes a distant star brighten
  3. ArticleFrom a bent light ray to two stellar images
  4. ArticleWhat happens when a stellar disk crosses a caustic?
  5. ArticleWhat can a microlensing light curve tell us about its lens?
  6. ArticleRead a dark planet’s mass from Earth and space
  7. ArticleFit the published OGLE-2005-BLG-390 photometry
  8. ArticleA background star helped weigh an isolated black hole
Something broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy