Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics
Lensed quasar time delays and the Hubble constant

How a delayed quasar flare measures the size of the universe

Sandbox Physics ·

The images of a quasar behind a galaxy flicker in turn. A flare shows up in one image first and in the others days or months later. The delay is set by the shape of the light paths and by one cosmic distance. Measure the delay, work out the galaxy's mass, and you can read off that distance and the expansion rate of the universe.

One quasar, several images

A quasar is the bright centre of a distant galaxy, where gas falls into a giant black hole and glows. It is so far away that it looks like a single point of light. Sometimes another galaxy sits almost exactly in front of it. That galaxy's gravity bends the quasar's light the way a glass lens bends sunlight, and the light can reach us along two or four different paths. A telescope then sees two or four copies of the same quasar, about an arcsecond apart. An arcsecond is the size of a coin seen from four kilometres away.

The paths are not equal. Some are longer because they swing wider around the galaxy. Some pass deeper through the galaxy's gravity, and clocks there run slightly slow. Both effects add up to an arrival time for each path. Gravity also changes how bright each copy looks.

A flare that arrives on different days

Quasars are not steady. Their brightness drifts and sometimes jumps over days. When the quasar flares, the flare travels down every path at once, so each image brightens in turn. Astronomers watch the images night after night for years and line up the light curves, the records of brightness against time. The shift that makes the curves match is the time delay. Among the lenses Christopher Kochanek collected in 2002, measured delays ran from about 12 days in PG1115+080 to 417 days in Q0957+561. Kochanek 2002, Table 1

You can see this in the Lab. With the default lens, the four images light up over about two weeks: the second image follows the first within a day, and the last one trails by 15.5 days.

From a delay to a distance

The delay grows with the size of the whole set-up. Put the same galaxy and quasar twice as far away, with the same angles on the sky, and every path gets twice as long, so the delay doubles. That is why a delay can work as a ruler. In symbols,

Δt=DΔtc Δϕ.\Delta t=\frac{D_{\Delta t}}{c}\,\Delta\phi .

Here Δt\Delta t is the delay, cc is the speed of light and Δϕ\Delta\phi is a number fixed by the image positions and the galaxy's mass, measured in square arcseconds. DΔtD_{\Delta t} is a combination of distances to the galaxy and the quasar, called the time-delay distance.

That distance tells us about the expansion of the universe. The Hubble constant, H0H_0, is how fast distant galaxies recede for each megaparsec of distance (a megaparsec is about 3.3 million light-years). For given redshifts, a faster expansion means smaller distances, so the time-delay distance is proportional to 1/H01/H_0. Sjur Refsdal proposed the method in 1964. TDCOSMO IV, Sec. 1 and 2.1

The catch: a mass you cannot see

The images fix where the light goes, but they do not quite fix how much mass the galaxy has. Imagine spreading a thin, even sheet of extra mass over the galaxy and shrinking the galaxy's own mass to compensate. The images stay exactly where they were. The delays, however, shrink or stretch in proportion. Astronomers call this the mass-sheet degeneracy. With image positions alone, the same lens can give quite different values of H0H_0. Peter Schneider and Dominique Sluse gave an example in 2013 where two lens models fit the same images but disagree on H0H_0 by about 20 percent. Schneider and Sluse 2013, abstract

The Lab has a preset for this. "Same images, hidden sheet" keeps all four images in place but moves the flares closer together by 12 percent. Someone who assumed there was no sheet would read H0H_0 as 79.5 instead of the true 70 used in the Lab.

Two kinds of evidence help. Galaxies near the line of sight add a real sheet of mass, and counting them estimates it. The speed of the stars inside the lensing galaxy weighs the galaxy independently of the light paths, because the sheet changes the star speeds in a different way from the delays.

What astronomers have found

In 2019 the H0LiCOW team combined six lensed quasars and found H0=73.3H_0=73.3 km/s per megaparsec, with an uncertainty of 2.4 percent, assuming the galaxies' mass follows standard shapes. H0LiCOW XIII, abstract

In 2020 the TDCOSMO team dropped that assumption and let the hidden sheet float, held in place only by the stellar speeds. With seven lenses the answer became 74.574.5, now uncertain by about 8 percent. Adding 33 more lens galaxies that have measured star speeds but no quasar behind them moved it to 67.467.4, with an uncertainty of about 5 percent. That last step assumes the two groups of galaxies are alike. TDCOSMO IV, abstract

The spread between those numbers is the mass sheet at work. It matters beyond lensing. Supernova distances and the cosmic microwave background, the afterglow of the early universe, give different values of H0H_0, and time delays are independent of both. H0LiCOW XIII, abstract

The course continues with the arrival-time surface and the delay of the simplest lens: arrival time, the Fermat potential and the isothermal lens.

Sources

  1. Kochanek 2002, Table 1
  2. TDCOSMO IV, Sec. 1 and 2.1
  3. Schneider and Sluse 2013, abstract
  4. H0LiCOW XIII, abstract

Keep reading

What this page links to directly

See this series on the content map →

Lensed quasar time delays and the Hubble constant · Reading path

From a delayed flare to the Hubble constant

  1. You are hereHow a delayed quasar flare measures the size of the universe
  2. ArticleArrival time, the Fermat potential and the delay of an isothermal lens
  3. ArticleMass slope, shear and the time-delay distance
  4. ArticleThe mass-sheet degeneracy and what stellar speeds add
  5. ArticleRecompute the Hubble constant from seven TDCOSMO lenses
  6. ArticleHow to read TDCOSMO IV on the mass sheet and the Hubble constant
1 more group

Other articles that use the same experiments

Each experiment from this article that another series also uses, followed by the articles there.

  1. LabGravitational Lens Telescope
  2. ArticleHow a dark planet makes a distant star brighten
  3. ArticleFrom a bent light ray to two stellar images
  4. ArticleWhat happens when a stellar disk crosses a caustic?
  5. ArticleWhat can a microlensing light curve tell us about its lens?
  6. ArticleRead a dark planet’s mass from Earth and space
  7. ArticleFit the published OGLE-2005-BLG-390 photometry
  8. ArticleA background star helped weigh an isolated black hole
Something broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy