Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics
Lensed quasar time delays and the Hubble constant

Arrival time, the Fermat potential and the delay of an isothermal lens

Sandbox Physics ·

Every point on the sky near a lens has an arrival time: how long light from the quasar would take if it were forced through that point. The images sit where this arrival-time surface is flat. For the simplest galaxy model, the singular isothermal sphere, the two images are one Einstein radius either side of the source and their delay is the time-delay distance over cc times 2θEβ2\theta_{\rm E}\beta.

Before this chapter, read how a delayed quasar flare measures the size of the universe. You need vectors in a plane, the small-angle approximation and the idea of a partial derivative. The gradient is introduced below.

Coordinates, angles and distances

Put the centre of the lens galaxy at the origin of the sky plane. A point on the sky is a two-dimensional vector θ\boldsymbol\theta, measured in arcseconds from the lens centre. The quasar's true direction, where we would see it without the galaxy, is β\boldsymbol\beta. One arcsecond is 4.848×10−64.848\times10^{-6} radians, so every angle here is tiny and sin⁡θ≈tan⁡θ≈θ\sin\theta\approx\tan\theta\approx\theta.

Three distances appear: to the lens, DdD_{\rm d}; to the source, DsD_{\rm s}; and from lens to source, DdsD_{\rm ds}. They are angular-diameter distances, defined so that an object of size ℓ\ell at distance DD spans an angle ℓ/D\ell/D. In an expanding universe Ds≠Dd+DdsD_{\rm s}\neq D_{\rm d}+D_{\rm ds}, which is why all three are needed. The lens redshift is zdz_{\rm d}.

The arrival-time surface

Light forced through the point θ\boldsymbol\theta is late for two reasons. The bent path is longer than the straight one, and the light spends time in the galaxy's gravity, where clocks run slow. Both effects are collected in the Fermat potential,

ϕ(θ,β)=(θ−β)22−ψ(θ),\phi(\boldsymbol\theta,\boldsymbol\beta)=\frac{(\boldsymbol\theta-\boldsymbol\beta)^2}{2}-\psi(\boldsymbol\theta),

measured in square arcseconds. The first term is the extra geometric length. The second is the gravitational delay, written with the lensing potential ψ\psi: a projected, rescaled version of the galaxy's gravitational potential. Two facts about ψ\psi are all we need. Its gradient is the deflection angle, and half its Laplacian is the convergence,

α=∇ψ,κ=12∇2ψ.\boldsymbol\alpha=\nabla\psi,\qquad \kappa=\tfrac12\nabla^2\psi .

The convergence κ\kappa is the galaxy's surface density in units of a critical density; where κ\kappa is near 1, the galaxy is dense enough to make multiple images.

The time between two points A and B on the surface is

ΔtAB=DΔtc[ϕ(θA,β)−ϕ(θB,β)],DΔt=(1+zd)DdDsDds.\Delta t_{\rm AB}=\frac{D_{\Delta t}}{c}\bigl[\phi(\boldsymbol\theta_{\rm A},\boldsymbol\beta)-\phi(\boldsymbol\theta_{\rm B},\boldsymbol\beta)\bigr],\qquad D_{\Delta t}=(1+z_{\rm d})\frac{D_{\rm d}D_{\rm s}}{D_{\rm ds}} .

The factor 1+zd1+z_{\rm d} appears because the delay builds up at the lens, and the expansion stretches it by that factor on its way to us. These are Eqs. (4) to (7) of TDCOSMO IV; Kochanek writes the same surface in his Eqs. (1) and (2). TDCOSMO IV, Sec. 2.1 Kochanek 2002, Sec. 2

Images sit where the surface is flat

The gradient of a function f(x,y)f(x,y) is the vector of its partial derivatives, ∇f=(∂f/∂x, ∂f/∂y)\nabla f=(\partial f/\partial x,\ \partial f/\partial y). It points uphill, and its length is the steepness. At the bottom of a bowl, at the top of a hill and at the centre of a saddle, the gradient is zero.

Fermat's principle says light travels along paths whose time does not change to first order when the path is nudged. So images form where ∇ϕ=0\nabla\phi=\mathbf 0. Differentiating the Fermat potential term by term gives θ−β−∇ψ=0\boldsymbol\theta-\boldsymbol\beta-\nabla\psi=\mathbf 0, which is the lens equation

β=θ−α(θ).\boldsymbol\beta=\boldsymbol\theta-\boldsymbol\alpha(\boldsymbol\theta).

Each solution is one image. A minimum of ϕ\phi arrives first and looks like the source, only brighter. A saddle point arrives later and is mirror-flipped. A maximum sits near the dense centre of the galaxy and is usually too faint to see; the Lab does not track it.

How bright an image is follows from how the lens stretches a small patch of sky. The magnification is μ=1/det⁡(∂β/∂θ)\mu=1/\det(\partial\boldsymbol\beta/\partial\boldsymbol\theta). A negative μ\mu marks a flipped image.

The singular isothermal sphere

Many lens galaxies are close to a singular isothermal sphere: a round galaxy whose stars move at the same speed at every radius. Its convergence falls as 1/∣θ∣1/|\boldsymbol\theta|,

κ=θE2∣θ∣,ψ=θE∣θ∣,α=θE θ∣θ∣.\kappa=\frac{\theta_{\rm E}}{2|\boldsymbol\theta|},\qquad \psi=\theta_{\rm E}|\boldsymbol\theta|,\qquad \boldsymbol\alpha=\theta_{\rm E}\,\frac{\boldsymbol\theta}{|\boldsymbol\theta|} .

You can check the first relation: in polar coordinates 12∇2(θEr)=θE/(2r)\tfrac12\nabla^2(\theta_{\rm E}r)=\theta_{\rm E}/(2r). Every ray is bent by the same angle θE\theta_{\rm E}, the Einstein radius, towards the centre.

Put the source on the positive xx axis at distance β<θE\beta<\theta_{\rm E}. On that axis the lens equation reads β=θ−θE sign(θ)\beta=\theta-\theta_{\rm E}\,{\rm sign}(\theta). It has two solutions:

θA=β+θE,θB=β−θE.\theta_{\rm A}=\beta+\theta_{\rm E},\qquad \theta_{\rm B}=\beta-\theta_{\rm E} .

Image A is outside the Einstein ring on the source's side. Image B is inside the ring on the far side. Their separation is always 2θE2\theta_{\rm E}, whatever β\beta is.

For this lens det⁡(∂β/∂θ)=1−θE/∣θ∣\det(\partial\boldsymbol\beta/\partial\boldsymbol\theta)=1-\theta_{\rm E}/|\boldsymbol\theta|, so μ=∣θ∣/(∣θ∣−θE)\mu=|\boldsymbol\theta|/(|\boldsymbol\theta|-\theta_{\rm E}) and

μA=θE+ββ,μB=−θE−ββ.\mu_{\rm A}=\frac{\theta_{\rm E}+\beta}{\beta},\qquad \mu_{\rm B}=-\frac{\theta_{\rm E}-\beta}{\beta} .

Image B is flipped and fainter, and both images get brighter as the source approaches the centre.

The delay of the isothermal lens

Evaluate the Fermat potential at each image. At A, ϕA=12θE2−θE(θE+β)\phi_{\rm A}=\tfrac12\theta_{\rm E}^2-\theta_{\rm E}(\theta_{\rm E}+\beta). At B, where ∣θB∣=θE−β|\theta_{\rm B}|=\theta_{\rm E}-\beta, ϕB=12θE2−θE(θE−β)\phi_{\rm B}=\tfrac12\theta_{\rm E}^2-\theta_{\rm E}(\theta_{\rm E}-\beta). The geometric terms are equal and cancel, leaving

ϕB−ϕA=2θEβ,Δt=DΔtc 2θEβ.\phi_{\rm B}-\phi_{\rm A}=2\theta_{\rm E}\beta,\qquad \Delta t=\frac{D_{\Delta t}}{c}\,2\theta_{\rm E}\beta .

Image A, the minimum, arrives first. The delay grows linearly with how far the source sits from the centre.

Worked example: the distance factor. Take zd=0.5z_{\rm d}=0.5, zs=2z_{\rm s}=2 in a flat universe with H0=70H_0=70 km s−1^{-1} Mpc−1^{-1} and matter density Ωm=0.3\Omega_{\rm m}=0.3. Integrating the expansion history gives Dd=1259D_{\rm d}=1259 Mpc, Ds=1727D_{\rm s}=1727 Mpc and Dds=1097D_{\rm ds}=1097 Mpc. Then DΔt=1.5×1259×1727/1097=2972D_{\Delta t}=1.5\times1259\times1727/1097=2972 Mpc. Divide by cc and convert one square arcsecond, (4.848×10−6)2(4.848\times10^{-6})^2 radians squared: one square arcsecond of Fermat potential is worth 83.283.2 days.

Worked example: the delay. For θE=1′′\theta_{\rm E}=1'' and β=0.1′′\beta=0.1'', ϕB−ϕA=0.2\phi_{\rm B}-\phi_{\rm A}=0.2 square arcseconds and Δt=0.2×83.2=16.6\Delta t=0.2\times83.2=16.6 days. The images are at 1.1′′1.1'' and −0.9′′-0.9'', with μA=11\mu_{\rm A}=11 and μB=−9\mu_{\rm B}=-9. The leading image is brighter by a factor 11/911/9.

How the distances are computed. In a flat universe the comoving distance to redshift zz is DC=(c/H0)∫0zdz′/E(z′)D_{\rm C}=(c/H_0)\int_0^z{\rm d}z'/E(z') with E(z)=Ωm(1+z)3+1−ΩmE(z)=\sqrt{\Omega_{\rm m}(1+z)^3+1-\Omega_{\rm m}}. Then Dd=DC(zd)/(1+zd)D_{\rm d}=D_{\rm C}(z_{\rm d})/(1+z_{\rm d}), Ds=DC(zs)/(1+zs)D_{\rm s}=D_{\rm C}(z_{\rm s})/(1+z_{\rm s}) and Dds=[DC(zs)−DC(zd)]/(1+zs)D_{\rm ds}=[D_{\rm C}(z_{\rm s})-D_{\rm C}(z_{\rm d})]/(1+z_{\rm s}). Every distance carries the factor c/H0c/H_0, so DΔt∝1/H0D_{\Delta t}\propto1/H_0.

Lab tasks

  1. Open the quasar time-delay Lab, set the mass of the nearby galaxy to 0 and keep the steepness at 2. Drag the quasar's true direction about a tenth of an arcsecond from the centre. Predict the delay and the image separation, then read them.
  2. Double the source offset and check that the delay doubles while the separation stays about 2′′2''.
  3. Open the redshift settings and move the lens from zd=0.5z_{\rm d}=0.5 to 0.30.3. Predict how the delay changes using DΔt=1552D_{\Delta t}=1552 Mpc at zd=0.3z_{\rm d}=0.3. The Lab keeps the Einstein radius fixed when you change a redshift.

Exercises

  1. Show that ∇ϕ=0\nabla\phi=\mathbf 0 gives the lens equation, starting from the definition of ϕ\phi.
  2. A lens has θE=1.5′′\theta_{\rm E}=1.5'' and the source is at β=0.2′′\beta=0.2'', with DΔt=2972D_{\Delta t}=2972 Mpc. Find the delay.
  3. For θE=1′′\theta_{\rm E}=1'' and β=0.3′′\beta=0.3'', find the flux ratio of the two images.
  4. An observer measures 16.6 days for the lens of the worked example but assumes H0=75H_0=75. What delay would that observer have predicted, and what does the mismatch say?
  5. A second source behind the same lens lies at β=0.5′′\beta=0.5'' but at zs=3z_{\rm s}=3. Which parts of the delay formula change, and which stay the same?
Answers
  1. ∇12(θ−β)2=θ−β\nabla\tfrac12(\boldsymbol\theta-\boldsymbol\beta)^2=\boldsymbol\theta-\boldsymbol\beta and ∇ψ=α\nabla\psi=\boldsymbol\alpha, so ∇ϕ=θ−β−α=0\nabla\phi=\boldsymbol\theta-\boldsymbol\beta-\boldsymbol\alpha=\mathbf 0, which rearranges to β=θ−α\boldsymbol\beta=\boldsymbol\theta-\boldsymbol\alpha.
  2. ϕB−ϕA=2×1.5×0.2=0.6\phi_{\rm B}-\phi_{\rm A}=2\times1.5\times0.2=0.6 square arcseconds, so Δt=0.6×83.2=49.9\Delta t=0.6\times83.2=49.9 days.
  3. μA=1.3/0.3=4.33\mu_{\rm A}=1.3/0.3=4.33 and ∣μB∣=0.7/0.3=2.33|\mu_{\rm B}|=0.7/0.3=2.33, a ratio of 1.861.86. The ratio (θE+β)/(θE−β)(\theta_{\rm E}+\beta)/(\theta_{\rm E}-\beta) depends only on β/θE\beta/\theta_{\rm E}.
  4. DΔt∝1/H0D_{\Delta t}\propto1/H_0, so the prediction is 16.6×70/75=15.516.6\times70/75=15.5 days. The measured delay is longer, so with this mass model the data prefer H0=70H_0=70. The conclusion is only as good as the mass model, which the next two chapters question.
  5. DΔtD_{\Delta t} changes because DsD_{\rm s} and DdsD_{\rm ds} change. The Einstein radius also changes, because it depends on Dds/DsD_{\rm ds}/D_{\rm s}. The formula Δt=(DΔt/c) 2θEβ\Delta t=(D_{\Delta t}/c)\,2\theta_{\rm E}\beta keeps its form.

Next: mass slope, shear and the time-delay distance.

Sources

  1. TDCOSMO IV, Sec. 2.1
  2. Kochanek 2002, Sec. 2

Keep reading

What this page links to directly

See this series on the content map →

Lensed quasar time delays and the Hubble constant · Reading path

From a delayed flare to the Hubble constant

  1. ArticleHow a delayed quasar flare measures the size of the universe
  2. You are hereArrival time, the Fermat potential and the delay of an isothermal lens
  3. ArticleMass slope, shear and the time-delay distance
  4. ArticleThe mass-sheet degeneracy and what stellar speeds add
  5. ArticleRecompute the Hubble constant from seven TDCOSMO lenses
  6. ArticleHow to read TDCOSMO IV on the mass sheet and the Hubble constant
1 more group

Other articles that use the same experiments

Each experiment from this article that another series also uses, followed by the articles there.

  1. LabGravitational Lens Telescope
  2. ArticleHow a dark planet makes a distant star brighten
  3. ArticleFrom a bent light ray to two stellar images
  4. ArticleWhat happens when a stellar disk crosses a caustic?
  5. ArticleWhat can a microlensing light curve tell us about its lens?
  6. ArticleRead a dark planet’s mass from Earth and space
  7. ArticleFit the published OGLE-2005-BLG-390 photometry
  8. ArticleA background star helped weigh an isolated black hole
Something broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy