Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics
Lensed quasar time delays and the Hubble constant

Mass slope, shear and the time-delay distance

Sandbox Physics ·

When the images are fixed by observation, the delay between them depends on how much mass lies in the ring between them. For a power-law galaxy that mean density is set by the slope, so the predicted delay, and the Hubble constant read from a measured delay, both scale close to γ′−1\gamma'-1. A nearby galaxy adds a stretch called shear, which turns two images into four. Once the model predicts the delay, the measured delay gives the time-delay distance and then H0H_0.

Before this chapter, read arrival time, the Fermat potential and the isothermal lens. You need integrals in polar coordinates and a second-order Taylor expansion in two variables.

A galaxy with any mass slope

Real galaxies are not exactly isothermal. A flexible model lets the convergence fall as a power of radius,

κ(θ)=3−γ′2(θEθ)γ′−1,\kappa(\theta)=\frac{3-\gamma'}{2}\left(\frac{\theta_{\rm E}}{\theta}\right)^{\gamma'-1},

where θ=∣θ∣\theta=|\boldsymbol\theta| and γ′\gamma' is the slope of the three-dimensional density, ρ∝r−γ′\rho\propto r^{-\gamma'}. The isothermal sphere is γ′=2\gamma'=2. A steeper galaxy, γ′>2\gamma'>2, concentrates its mass towards the centre.

For a round lens, the deflection at radius θ\theta is the mean convergence inside that radius times θ\theta: α(θ)=(2/θ)∫0θκ(u) u du\alpha(\theta)=(2/\theta)\int_0^\theta\kappa(u)\,u\,{\rm d}u. This is the two-dimensional version of Gauss's law. Doing the integral,

α(θ)=θE(θθE)2−γ′,ψ(θ)=θE23−γ′(θθE)3−γ′.\alpha(\theta)=\theta_{\rm E}\left(\frac{\theta}{\theta_{\rm E}}\right)^{2-\gamma'},\qquad \psi(\theta)=\frac{\theta_{\rm E}^2}{3-\gamma'}\left(\frac{\theta}{\theta_{\rm E}}\right)^{3-\gamma'} .

At θ=θE\theta=\theta_{\rm E} the deflection equals the radius, so the mean convergence inside the Einstein radius is exactly 1 for every slope.

Two ways to change the slope

Keep the source fixed. Put the source at β=0.1′′\beta=0.1'' behind a lens with θE=1′′\theta_{\rm E}=1'', zd=0.5z_{\rm d}=0.5 and zs=2z_{\rm s}=2. The model in the Lab gives a delay of 16.6 days for γ′=1.8\gamma'=1.8, 2.02.0 and 2.22.2 alike. The images move: the outer one sits at 1.124′′1.124'' for γ′=1.8\gamma'=1.8 and at 1.084′′1.084'' for γ′=2.2\gamma'=2.2. So at fixed source the delay hardly cares about the slope.

Keep the images fixed. This is the situation an astronomer faces. The image positions are measured to a few thousandths of an arcsecond; the source position is not observed at all. Changing the slope now forces a different θE\theta_{\rm E} and β\beta to keep the images in place, and the delay changes a lot.

The delay at fixed image positions

Take two images on opposite sides of a round lens, the outer one at radius R1R_1 and the inner one at R2R_2. Kochanek (2002) showed that their delay depends only on the image radii and the convergence in the ring between them. Define the mean convergence in that ring,

⟨κ⟩=2∫R2R1κ(u) u duR12−R22.\langle\kappa\rangle=\frac{2\int_{R_2}^{R_1}\kappa(u)\,u\,{\rm d}u}{R_1^2-R_2^2} .

Expanding in the ring's thickness ΔR=R1−R2\Delta R=R_1-R_2 over its mean radius ⟨R⟩\langle R\rangle, with a power-law density of slope η\eta in the ring, he found

ϕ2−ϕ1=(R12−R22)[(1−⟨κ⟩)−1−η⟨κ⟩12(ΔR⟨R⟩)2+… ].\phi_2-\phi_1=\left(R_1^2-R_2^2\right)\left[\left(1-\langle\kappa\rangle\right)-\frac{1-\eta\langle\kappa\rangle}{12}\left(\frac{\Delta R}{\langle R\rangle}\right)^2+\dots\right].

Kochanek writes this as τ1−τ2\tau_1-\tau_2 with an overall minus sign; we quote it for the later image minus the earlier one. His η\eta is our γ′\gamma'. Kochanek 2002, Eqs. (3) to (8)

The leading term is exact for the isothermal sphere. There ⟨κ⟩=1/2\langle\kappa\rangle=1/2 and the bracket's second term vanishes because 1−2×12=01-2\times\tfrac12=0. With R1=θE+βR_1=\theta_{\rm E}+\beta and R2=θE−βR_2=\theta_{\rm E}-\beta, 12(R12−R22)=2θEβ\tfrac12(R_1^2-R_2^2)=2\theta_{\rm E}\beta, the result of the previous chapter.

Near the Einstein ring a power law has 1−⟨κ⟩≈(γ′−1)/21-\langle\kappa\rangle\approx(\gamma'-1)/2. So at fixed images the predicted delay is about (γ′−1)(\gamma'-1) times the isothermal one. For a measured delay, DΔt∝1/(γ′−1)D_{\Delta t}\propto1/(\gamma'-1) and

H0∝γ′−1.H_0\propto\gamma'-1 .

Wucknitz (2002) writes the potential as ψ∝rβ\psi\propto r^{\beta}, so his β\beta is our 3−γ′3-\gamma'. For round lens models with images near the Einstein ring and a fitted external shear he finds H0∝2−βH_0\propto2-\beta, the same scaling. For quadruple lenses with the shear held fixed he finds H0∝(2−β)/βH_0\propto(2-\beta)/\beta instead; either way a shallower profile gives a smaller H0H_0. Wucknitz 2002, abstract and Sec. 11

Worked example. Put images at R1=1.3′′R_1=1.3'' and R2=0.75′′R_2=0.75''. For each slope, the lens equation at the two images fixes θEγ′−1=(R1+R2)/(R12−γ′+R22−γ′)\theta_{\rm E}^{\gamma'-1}=(R_1+R_2)/(R_1^{2-\gamma'}+R_2^{2-\gamma'}). The exact Fermat-potential differences are:

Table 3.1 Delay at fixed image positions for five slopes, in square arcseconds of Fermat potential.
γ′\gamma'ϕ2−ϕ1\phi_2-\phi_1Ratio to γ′=2\gamma'=2γ′−1\gamma'-1
1.60.33690.5980.6
1.80.45050.7990.8
2.00.563811
2.20.67581.1991.2
2.40.78611.3941.4

Kochanek's two-term series matches every row to better than 0.02 percent. A slope uncertainty of ±0.05\pm0.05 therefore means about ±5\pm5 percent in H0H_0, which is why lens modellers work so hard on the slope.

A nearby galaxy: convergence and shear

Lens galaxies have neighbours. Model one as another isothermal galaxy with Einstein radius bpb_{\rm p} at distance dd from the lens, in direction φp\varphi_{\rm p}. Its potential is ψp=bp∣θ−θp∣\psi_{\rm p}=b_{\rm p}|\boldsymbol\theta-\boldsymbol\theta_{\rm p}|. Near the main lens, ∣θ∣≪d|\boldsymbol\theta|\ll d, so expand to second order. The constant does nothing. The first-order term is a uniform deflection, which just shifts where we think the source is. The second-order term is

ψext=κp2θ2−γp2θ2cos⁡2(φ−φp),κp=γp=bp2d.\psi_{\rm ext}=\frac{\kappa_{\rm p}}{2}\theta^2-\frac{\gamma_{\rm p}}{2}\theta^2\cos2(\varphi-\varphi_{\rm p}),\qquad \kappa_{\rm p}=\gamma_{\rm p}=\frac{b_{\rm p}}{2d} .

To check it, put the neighbour on the xx axis. Its second derivatives at the origin are ∂x2ψp=0\partial_x^2\psi_{\rm p}=0 and ∂y2ψp=bp/d\partial_y^2\psi_{\rm p}=b_{\rm p}/d, so ψext=(bp/2d) y2\psi_{\rm ext}=(b_{\rm p}/2d)\,y^2. Writing y2=12θ2(1−cos⁡2φ)y^2=\tfrac12\theta^2(1-\cos2\varphi) gives the form above.

The first term is a uniform convergence, a thin sheet of mass. The second is shear: it stretches images along one axis and squeezes them along the other. With shear, the source-plane line where magnification diverges, the caustic, opens into a small diamond. A source inside the diamond has four bright images; outside it has two. The Lab's default neighbour has bp=0.75′′b_{\rm p}=0.75'' at d=3.4′′d=3.4'', so κp=γp=0.11\kappa_{\rm p}=\gamma_{\rm p}=0.11.

From a delay to the Hubble constant

The model predicts the Fermat-potential difference Δϕ\Delta\phi. The measured delay then gives the time-delay distance, DΔt=c Δt/ΔϕD_{\Delta t}=c\,\Delta t/\Delta\phi, which is TDCOSMO IV's Eq. (8). Since DΔt∝1/H0D_{\Delta t}\propto1/H_0 at fixed redshifts and matter density,

H0=H0,ref DΔt(H0,ref)DΔt.H_0=H_{0,\rm ref}\,\frac{D_{\Delta t}(H_{0,\rm ref})}{D_{\Delta t}} .

TDCOSMO IV, Eqs. (8) and (9)

Worked example. For the Lab's default quad, the model predicts 15.5 days between the first and last images when H0=70H_0=70, using DΔt=2972D_{\Delta t}=2972 Mpc. Suppose the measured delay were 17.0 days. Then DΔt=2972×17.0/15.5=3260D_{\Delta t}=2972\times17.0/15.5=3260 Mpc and H0=70×2972/3260=63.8H_0=70\times2972/3260=63.8 km s−1^{-1} Mpc−1^{-1}.

Worked example with a real lens. TDCOSMO IV lists DΔt=1947D_{\Delta t}=1947 Mpc for RXJ1131−-1231, from a power-law model, with zd=0.295z_{\rm d}=0.295 and zs=0.654z_{\rm s}=0.654. A flat universe with H0=70H_0=70 and Ωm=0.3\Omega_{\rm m}=0.3 gives 2334 Mpc for those redshifts, so this lens alone says H0=70×2334/1947=83.9H_0=70\times2334/1947=83.9 before any correction for the line of sight. The method tutorial repeats this for all seven lenses.

The matter density barely matters here. Changing Ωm\Omega_{\rm m} from 0.3 to 0.25 or 0.35 moves the seven-lens result by less than 0.3 percent, as the tutorial shows. A time-delay distance measures mainly H0H_0.

Lab tasks

  1. In the quasar time-delay Lab, switch off the nearby galaxy and set the source about 0.1′′0.1'' from the centre. Move the steepness from 1.8 to 2.2 and note what moves and what stays.
  2. Turn the nearby galaxy back on and drag it around the lens. Watch the diamond-shaped caustic in the source-plane panel turn with it.
  3. Load "Wide double, long delay" and then "Einstein cross". Explain from the caustic panel why one has two images and the other four.

Exercises

  1. Derive α(θ)\alpha(\theta) for the power law from α=(2/θ)∫0θκ u du\alpha=(2/\theta)\int_0^\theta\kappa\,u\,{\rm d}u, and check that it reduces to θE\theta_{\rm E} for γ′=2\gamma'=2.
  2. Show that ⟨κ⟩=(R1α1−R2α2)/(R12−R22)\langle\kappa\rangle=(R_1\alpha_1-R_2\alpha_2)/(R_1^2-R_2^2), where αi=α(Ri)\alpha_i=\alpha(R_i).
  3. A modeller changes the slope of a lens from 2.00 to 2.10 and keeps the images fixed. By how much does the inferred H0H_0 change?
  4. A neighbour with bp=0.5′′b_{\rm p}=0.5'' sits 2.5′′2.5'' from the lens. Find κp\kappa_{\rm p} and γp\gamma_{\rm p}.
  5. A lens at zd=0.5z_{\rm d}=0.5, zs=2z_{\rm s}=2 has a model Fermat difference of 0.300.30 square arcseconds and a measured delay of 22.0 days. Find DΔtD_{\Delta t} and H0H_0, using 83.2 days per square arcsecond at H0=70H_0=70.
Answers
  1. ∫0θ3−γ′2θEγ′−1u2−γ′du=12θEγ′−1θ3−γ′\int_0^\theta\tfrac{3-\gamma'}{2}\theta_{\rm E}^{\gamma'-1}u^{2-\gamma'}{\rm d}u=\tfrac12\theta_{\rm E}^{\gamma'-1}\theta^{3-\gamma'}. Multiplying by 2/θ2/\theta gives θEγ′−1θ2−γ′\theta_{\rm E}^{\gamma'-1}\theta^{2-\gamma'}. For γ′=2\gamma'=2 the power of θ\theta is zero and α=θE\alpha=\theta_{\rm E}.
  2. From Exercise 1's method, θ α(θ)=2∫0θκ u du\theta\,\alpha(\theta)=2\int_0^\theta\kappa\,u\,{\rm d}u for any round lens. Subtracting at R1R_1 and R2R_2 gives 2∫R2R1κ u du=R1α1−R2α22\int_{R_2}^{R_1}\kappa\,u\,{\rm d}u=R_1\alpha_1-R_2\alpha_2; divide by R12−R22R_1^2-R_2^2.
  3. H0∝γ′−1H_0\propto\gamma'-1, so it rises by the factor 1.10/1.001.10/1.00, about 10 percent.
  4. κp=γp=0.5/(2×2.5)=0.1\kappa_{\rm p}=\gamma_{\rm p}=0.5/(2\times2.5)=0.1.
  5. The predicted delay at H0=70H_0=70 is 0.30×83.2=24.960.30\times83.2=24.96 days. The measured 22.0 days is shorter, so DΔt=2972×22.0/24.96=2620D_{\Delta t}=2972\times22.0/24.96=2620 Mpc and H0=70×24.96/22.0=79.4H_0=70\times24.96/22.0=79.4 km s−1^{-1} Mpc−1^{-1}.

Next: the mass-sheet degeneracy and what stellar speeds add.

Sources

  1. Kochanek 2002, Eqs. (3) to (8)
  2. Wucknitz 2002, abstract and Sec. 11
  3. TDCOSMO IV, Eqs. (8) and (9)

Keep reading

What this page links to directly

See this series on the content map →

Lensed quasar time delays and the Hubble constant · Reading path

From a delayed flare to the Hubble constant

  1. ArticleHow a delayed quasar flare measures the size of the universe
  2. ArticleArrival time, the Fermat potential and the delay of an isothermal lens
  3. You are hereMass slope, shear and the time-delay distance
  4. ArticleThe mass-sheet degeneracy and what stellar speeds add
  5. ArticleRecompute the Hubble constant from seven TDCOSMO lenses
  6. ArticleHow to read TDCOSMO IV on the mass sheet and the Hubble constant
1 more group

Other articles that use the same experiments

Each experiment from this article that another series also uses, followed by the articles there.

  1. LabGravitational Lens Telescope
  2. ArticleHow a dark planet makes a distant star brighten
  3. ArticleFrom a bent light ray to two stellar images
  4. ArticleWhat happens when a stellar disk crosses a caustic?
  5. ArticleWhat can a microlensing light curve tell us about its lens?
  6. ArticleRead a dark planet’s mass from Earth and space
  7. ArticleFit the published OGLE-2005-BLG-390 photometry
  8. ArticleA background star helped weigh an isolated black hole
Something broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy