Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics

Alloy Dendrite Growth: Why Phase-Field Models Need Anti-Trapping

How does a dendrite grow into a supersaturated alloy melt, and why does a diffuse interface trap too much solute? The solid takes in less solute than the liquid, so the rejected solute piles up ahead of the crystal and any bump that reaches fresher liquid grows faster into an arm. A simulated interface is far wider than a real one, which lets the solid keep too much solute; an extra current that pushes solute back into the liquid restores the right amount.

Grow a four-armed dendrite with Karma’s 2001 phase-field model. Switch the anti-trapping current off and watch the solid keep far too much solute.

Interactive modelAlloy Dendrite Growth: Why Phase-Field Models Need Anti-Trapping
Tip speedVd0/D=0.0253V d_0/D=0.0253
Tip radiusρ/d0=45.4\rho/d_0=45.4
Solute left in the solidcs/cl0=0.146c_{\mathrm{s}}/c_l^0=0.146
Time since the seed was placedtD/d02=1334t D/d_0^2=1334
Simulated tip speed over time
Solute along the arm axis
More numbers and how they are computed
Local-equilibrium solid concentration at the tip
00
Excess solute in the solid
00
Solute far from the crystal
00
Tip position
00
Interface model
00
Change in total solute
00

The tip is where the interface crosses the growth axis, found by linear interpolation; its radius comes from a parabola through the interface on the rows nearest the axis. The solid concentration is averaged along the arm axis from 30 capillary lengths out from the crystal centre to 20 behind the tip. The dashed reference is local equilibrium at the measured tip curvature, not a fit. The exported file lists the settings and every sample.

A growing crystal must push its solute away

BackgroundWhen an alloy solidifies, the solid usually accepts less solute than the liquid it grows from. The rejected solute piles up ahead of the interface and has to diffuse away before the crystal can advance, so any bump that sticks out into fresher liquid grows faster. That instability turns a round seed into a dendrite.

Why it mattersDendrite spacing and the solute left between the arms set the microstructure of castings and welds. Phase-field models are the standard way to compute it, but only if their diffuse interface reproduces the sharp-interface physics.

One-sentence intuition
At slow growth the solid should hold cs=k clc_{\mathrm s}=k\,c_{\mathrm l} with k=0.15k=0.15. A phase-field interface of width WW far wider than a real one lets solute diffuse through it at the wrong rate and leaves extra solute in the solid. Karma's anti-trapping current pushes that solute back into the liquid and restores local equilibrium.

Core mathematical model

Solute flux with the anti-trapping current

j⃗=−D q(ϕ) c ∇u−at W cl0(1−k) eu ∂tϕ  ∇ϕ∣∇ϕ∣,at=122\vec j=-D\,q(\phi)\,c\,\nabla u-a_t\,W\,c_l^0(1-k)\,e^{u}\,\partial_t\phi\;\frac{\nabla\phi}{|\nabla\phi|},\qquad a_t=\frac{1}{2\sqrt2}

The first term is ordinary diffusion in the liquid, switched off in the solid. The second points from solid to liquid and acts only where the interface is moving, with the strength ata_t fixed so that the spurious solute jump vanishes.

Choosing the coupling

d0=a1 Wλ,β=a1(τλW−a2 WD)=0d_0=a_1\,\frac{W}{\lambda},\qquad \beta=a_1\Bigl(\frac{\tau}{\lambda W}-a_2\,\frac{W}{D}\Bigr)=0

With a1=0.8839a_1=0.8839 and a2=0.6267a_2=0.6267, choosing D=a2λW2/τD=a_2\lambda W^2/\tau removes interface kinetics, so the model describes growth controlled by diffusion and capillarity alone.

Common difficulties

A thinner interface is not the fix

Typical misconceptionSolute trapping is just a resolution problem; make W small enough and it goes away.

Better mental modelShrinking W to a real interface width would need a grid far too fine for any dendrite calculation. The anti-trapping current removes the error at the interface width the computation can afford.

Run the experiment

  1. 01

    Grow a dendrite

    Start with A four-armed dendrite and read the tip speed and the solute left in the solid.

    What to observe: Four arms grow along the crystal axes, the tip speed settles, and the solid behind the tip holds close to k cl0=0.15 cl0k\,c_l^0=0.15\,c_l^0.
  2. 02

    Switch the current off

    Choose Solute gets trapped, which keeps every parameter but drops the anti-trapping current.

    What to observe: On the Lab grid the solid now holds about 0.31 cl00.31\,c_l^0 near the seed and 0.21 cl00.21\,c_l^0 further along the arm, against 0.145 cl00.145\,c_l^0 with the current. That excess is the spurious trapping Karma removed.
  3. 03

    Take away the anisotropy

    Choose No anisotropy, no clean tip and compare the tip shape with the four-armed dendrite.

    What to observe: Without a preferred direction the tips flatten and split instead of growing as steady needles.

Related experiments and articles

What this page links to directly

See every article series on the content map →

Continue exploring

How solids slide, deform and crack

What happens atom by atom and grain by grain when a solid slides, deforms, grows or cracks?

  1. LabAtomic Stick-Slip: How an AFM Tip Feels FrictionCompare Atomic stick-slip with Smooth sliding and watch the sawtooth in the force chart.
  2. LabThermal Friction: Why Faster Scans Rub HarderCompare Slow scan rubs less with Fast scan rubs harder on the friction-speed chart.
  3. LabSuperlubric Flakes: How a Twist Cuts Atomic FrictionLeave Twist sweep running and watch stick-slip vanish a few degrees away from alignment.
  4. LabEdge Dislocation Glide: When Does Shear Tear a Dipole Apart?Compare A dipole torn apart with A narrow dipole holds under the same shear.
  5. LabGrain Growth by Curvature: Why Small Grains VanishChoose A round grain shrinks at a steady rate and follow its area on the picked-grain chart.
  6. You are hereAlloy Dendrite Growth: Why Phase-Field Models Need Anti-TrappingChoose Solute gets trapped and compare the solute left in the solid with A four-armed dendrite.
  7. LabGriffith Criterion for Crack GrowthChoose Short crack needs more stress, or drag the crack tip, and find the stress that grows it.
  8. LabPhase-Field Fracture Model of a Growing CrackChoose Shear turns the crack, then Hole pulls the crack, and watch the crack pick its path.

Crystal defects and microstructure · Reading path

From the Burgers vector to alloy dendrites

Articles on this path that use this experiment, followed by the other experiments they suggest.

  1. ArticleSolute trapping in alloy phase-field models and the anti-trapping current
  2. ArticleReading Karma 2001 on alloy phase fields and reproducing its dendrite figures
Something broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy