Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics
How dark matter was left over

Freeze-in, hot relics and faster expansion

Sandbox Physics ·

Turn the cross-section down far enough and the same Boltzmann equation stops describing freeze-out. If the particles start in equilibrium they keep the hot plateau, Y≃5.3×10−3Y\simeq5.3\times10^{-3}. If they start with none, they are made from the bath with a yield that rises in proportion to the cross-section, YFI=(3π2/32)a2λY_{\mathrm{FI}}=(3\pi^2/32)a^2\lambda for the Lab's contact interaction. A faster early expansion changes the freeze-out branch: with a kination phase that ends at 20 MeV, annihilation keeps thinning the particles for a factor of a few hundred in temperature after they leave equilibrium.

This chapter follows The Boltzmann equation and freeze-out. It uses λ\lambda, F(x)F(x) and Yeq=a x2K2(x)Y_{\mathrm{eq}}=a\,x^2K_2(x) with a=45g/(4π4g∗s)=2.68×10−3a=45g/(4\pi^4g_{*s})=2.68\times10^{-3}. You need integrals of Bessel functions, or a table of them. The aims are to compute the hot-relic and freeze-in yields, map all three regimes on one curve and derive the relentless law.

The hot-relic plateau

If Γ/H\Gamma/H never exceeds one but the particles start in equilibrium, nothing changes YY and it stays at its value while relativistic:

Yhot=2a=90 g4π4g∗s=5.36×10−3.Y_{\mathrm{hot}}=2a=\frac{90\,g}{4\pi^4g_{*s}}=5.36\times10^{-3}.

The Lab's hot-relic preset uses ⟨σv⟩0=10−38 cm3 s−1\langle\sigma v\rangle_0=10^{-38}\,\mathrm{cm^3\,s^{-1}}, whose peak Γ/H\Gamma/H is 1.5×10−31.5\times10^{-3}; that much annihilation removes 0.5 per cent, so it reports 5.33×10−35.33\times10^{-3}. For m=100 GeVm=100\,\mathrm{GeV} this is Ωh2=1.46×108\Omega h^2=1.46\times10^{8}, a billion times too much. Only a particle lighter than about 82 eV in this model ends with Ωh2=0.120\Omega h^2=0.120, and a relic that light is hot dark matter, which is excluded. Hall, Jedamzik, March-Russell and West, 2010, section 5.1 The same reasoning for Standard Model neutrinos, which decouple near 1 MeV, gives the familiar result Ωh2=m/93 eV\Omega h^2=m/93\,\mathrm{eV}. Particle Data Group, 2025, eq. 27.4

Freeze-in from an empty start

Start with Y=0Y=0 and a tiny λ\lambda. As long as Y≪YeqY\ll Y_{\mathrm{eq}}, drop Y2Y^2:

dYdx=λF(x)x2 Yeq2,YFI=λa2∫0∞x2K2(x)2F(x) dx.\frac{\mathrm dY}{\mathrm dx}=\frac{\lambda F(x)}{x^2}\,Y_{\mathrm{eq}}^2,\qquad Y_{\mathrm{FI}}=\lambda a^2\int_0^\infty x^2K_2(x)^2F(x)\,\mathrm dx.

The integral can be done exactly for the contact interaction. Its thermal average obeys

F(x) K2(x)2=14m2T∫4m2∞βs K1 ⁣(sT)ds,β=1−4m2s,F(x)\,K_2(x)^2=\frac{1}{4m^2T}\int_{4m^2}^{\infty}\beta\sqrt{s}\,K_1\!\left(\frac{\sqrt s}{T}\right)\mathrm ds,\qquad \beta=\sqrt{1-\frac{4m^2}{s}},

where ss is the pair energy squared. Put T=m/xT=m/x and swap the order of integration. The xx integral is ∫0∞x3K1(bx) dx=3π/(2b4)\int_0^\infty x^3K_1(bx)\,\mathrm dx=3\pi/(2b^4) with b=s/mb=\sqrt s/m. What remains is

YFI=3πa2λm8∫4m2∞β s−3/2 ds=3πa2λm8⋅π4m=3π232 a2λ,Y_{\mathrm{FI}}=\frac{3\pi a^2\lambda m}{8}\int_{4m^2}^\infty\beta\,s^{-3/2}\,\mathrm ds=\frac{3\pi a^2\lambda m}{8}\cdot\frac{\pi}{4m}=\frac{3\pi^2}{32}\,a^2\lambda,

where the last integral becomes the beta function B(12,32)=π/2B(\tfrac12,\tfrac32)=\pi/2 after substituting s=4m2/ws=4m^2/w.

Worked example: freezing in the observed amount

The observed density needs Y=0.120/(2.74×108×100)=4.37×10−12Y=0.120/(2.74\times10^{8}\times100)=4.37\times10^{-12}. With 3π2a2/32=6.64×10−63\pi^2a^2/32=6.64\times10^{-6}, that requires λ=6.59×10−7\lambda=6.59\times10^{-7}, or

⟨σv⟩0=λ(2π10/15)g∗ mMPl=2.57×10−45 cm3 s−1.\langle\sigma v\rangle_0=\frac{\lambda}{(2\pi\sqrt{10}/15)\sqrt{g_*}\,mM_{\mathrm{Pl}}}=2.57\times10^{-45}\,\mathrm{cm^3\,s^{-1}}.

That is eight billion billion times below the freeze-out value. The full solution gives Y∞=4.373×10−12Y_\infty=4.373\times10^{-12}, 0.1 per cent below the closed form, the small difference coming from the start at x=10−3x=10^{-3} and the dropped Y2Y^2. Dropping Y2Y^2 is safe: by x=3x=3, when 99 per cent of the yield is made, YY is still below 3×10−93\times10^{-9} of YeqY_{\mathrm{eq}}, and later the produced particles are far too dilute to find each other.

Production is concentrated near x≃1x\simeq1. In the saved run YY reaches 47 per cent of its final value by x=0.5x=0.5, 75 per cent by x=1x=1 and 99 per cent by x=3x=3. Hall and colleagues call this IR domination: the yield is set by temperatures near the mass and does not care what happened earlier. Hall, Jedamzik, March-Russell and West, 2010, section 1 It works here because F∝x2F\propto x^2 at small xx. If the cross-section were constant, dY/dx∝x−2\mathrm dY/\mathrm dx\propto x^{-2} at small xx and the yield would grow as 1/xstart1/x_{\mathrm{start}}: the saved scripts find a factor of 10.1 between starts at x=10−3x=10^{-3} and 10−210^{-2}.

One curve, three regimes

Table 4.1 Density today for m=100 GeVm=100\,\mathrm{GeV} and standard expansion, from the saved scan.
⟨σv⟩0\langle\sigma v\rangle_0 in cm3 s−1\mathrm{cm^3\,s^{-1}}Start in equilibriumStart empty
10−4510^{-45}1.47×1081.47\times10^{8}0.04670.0467
10−4010^{-40}1.47×1081.47\times10^{8}4.67×1034.67\times10^{3}
10−3710^{-37}1.40×1081.40\times10^{8}4.66×1064.66\times10^{6}
10−3610^{-36}1.01×1081.01\times10^{8}3.99×1073.99\times10^{7}
10−3510^{-35}3.05×1073.05\times10^{7}3.05×1073.05\times10^{7}
10−3010^{-30}1.48×1031.48\times10^{3}1.48×1031.48\times10^{3}
10−2610^{-26}0.2480.2480.2480.248

Reading down, the empty start rises tenfold per decade (freeze-in), meets the plateau near 10−3510^{-35}, and from there both starts fall together (freeze-out). The meeting point is where the peak of Γ/H\Gamma/H reaches about one. Above it, particles made from nothing reach equilibrium before freeze-out and the starting state is forgotten. This is the slice through the phase diagram drawn in Figure 4b of Hall and colleagues. Hall, Jedamzik, March-Russell and West, 2010, section 5.1

A faster early expansion

D'Eramo, Fernandez and Profumo add a fluid whose energy density falls as a−(4+n)a^{-(4+n)} and equals radiation at TrT_r. D'Eramo, Fernandez and Profumo, 2017, section II With g∗g_* fixed,

H=Hrad1+(TTr)n,dYdln⁡x=−λFx E(x)(Y2−Yeq2),E=1+(xrx)n,H=H_{\mathrm{rad}}\sqrt{1+\left(\frac{T}{T_r}\right)^{n}},\qquad \frac{\mathrm dY}{\mathrm d\ln x}=-\frac{\lambda F}{x\,E(x)}\left(Y^2-Y_{\mathrm{eq}}^2\right),\quad E=\sqrt{1+\left(\frac{x_r}{x}\right)^{n}},

with xr=m/Trx_r=m/T_r. Kination, a scalar field dominated by its kinetic energy, has n=2n=2. Light-element abundances require Tr≳(15.4)1/n MeVT_r\gtrsim(15.4)^{1/n}\,\mathrm{MeV}, their eq. (14), so the Lab keeps Tr≥20 MeVT_r\ge20\,\mathrm{MeV}, which satisfies the bound for every nn it offers.

The larger HH makes freeze-out earlier: with the standard cross-section and Tr=20 MeVT_r=20\,\mathrm{MeV} the crossing moves from x=25.2x=25.2 to 22.4, 19.5 and 12.9 for n=1n=1, 2 and 4.

The relentless law

For xf≪x≪xrx_f\ll x\ll x_r, E≃(xr/x)n/2E\simeq(x_r/x)^{n/2} and YeqY_{\mathrm{eq}} is negligible, so

ddln⁡x1Y=λFxrn/2 xn/2−1.\frac{\mathrm d}{\mathrm d\ln x}\frac1Y=\frac{\lambda F}{x_r^{n/2}}\,x^{n/2-1}.

For n<2n<2 the right side shrinks with xx and 1/Y1/Y converges soon after freeze-out, as in the standard case. For n=2n=2 it is constant, so 1/Y1/Y grows by (λ/xr)ln⁡(x/xf)(\lambda/x_r)\ln(x/x_f) all the way to x≃xrx\simeq x_r. For n>2n>2 it grows as a power. This is the relentless annihilation of eqs. (C16) and (C18). D'Eramo, Fernandez and Profumo, 2017, appendix C

Check it on the kination run, xr=5000x_r=5000. The time-domain solution gives 1/Y=2.57×1091/Y=2.57\times10^{9} at x=200x=200 and 3.56×1093.56\times10^{9} at x=500x=500. The law predicts an increase of (λ/xr)∫F dln⁡x=1.10×109×0.90=9.9×108(\lambda/x_r)\int F\,\mathrm d\ln x=1.10\times10^{9}\times0.90=9.9\times10^{8}, matching to 0.1 per cent. The final densities with the standard cross-section are Ωh2=0.871\Omega h^2=0.871, 4.02 and 13.7 for n=1n=1, 2 and 4, against 0.120 with standard expansion. The settling point moves from x=208x=208 to 1140, 8080 and 26,900. These densities are 2 to 3 times below the paper's Figure 1, because the paper keeps the full g∗(T)g_*(T) and the fall from 86.25 to 10.75 by TrT_r raises the extra fluid's share of H2H^2. The guide to the paper works through the difference.

Lab tasks

Open the dark matter relic Lab.

  1. Choose Freeze-in from nothing. On the abundance chart, find the xx where the violet curve reaches its plateau and compare with the 99 per cent point above.
  2. On the scan chart, follow the dashed empty-start curve up to where it joins the solid curve. Read off the cross-section and compare with Table 4.1.
  3. Choose Faster expansion. Watch the dashed curve for the particles present on the rate chart: it stays near one for a long time instead of dropping away. Explain this with the relentless law.

Exercises

  1. Check the closed form numerically: with a=2.678×10−3a=2.678\times10^{-3} and λ=6.597×10−7\lambda=6.597\times10^{-7}, compute YFIY_{\mathrm{FI}}.
  2. In freeze-in, YFI∝λ∝m⟨σv⟩0Y_{\mathrm{FI}}\propto\lambda\propto m\langle\sigma v\rangle_0, while the observed yield is proportional to 1/m1/m. What cross-section does a 1 TeV particle need?
  3. For a constant cross-section, show that ∫xstartYeq2x−2 dx≃4a2/xstart\int_{x_{\mathrm{start}}}Y_{\mathrm{eq}}^2x^{-2}\,\mathrm dx\simeq4a^2/x_{\mathrm{start}} when xstart≪1x_{\mathrm{start}}\ll1.
  4. For n=1n=1, integrate the relentless equation from xfx_f to infinity, ignoring the eventual return to E≃1E\simeq1, and show that 1/Y1/Y stays finite.
Answers
  1. 3π2/32=0.92533\pi^2/32=0.9253 and a2=7.172×10−6a^2=7.172\times10^{-6}, so YFI=0.9253×7.172×10−6×6.597×10−7=4.378×10−12Y_{\mathrm{FI}}=0.9253\times7.172\times10^{-6}\times6.597\times10^{-7}=4.378\times10^{-12}.
  2. Fixing Ωh2\Omega h^2 means Y∝1/mY\propto1/m, so m⟨σv⟩0∝1/mm\langle\sigma v\rangle_0\propto1/m and ⟨σv⟩0∝m−2\langle\sigma v\rangle_0\propto m^{-2}. Ten times the mass needs a hundred times less: 2.57×10−47 cm3 s−12.57\times10^{-47}\,\mathrm{cm^3\,s^{-1}}.
  3. For x≪1x\ll1, Yeq≃2aY_{\mathrm{eq}}\simeq2a, so the integrand is 4a2/x24a^2/x^2 and ∫xstart∼14a2x−2 dx≃4a2/xstart\int_{x_{\mathrm{start}}}^{\sim1}4a^2x^{-2}\,\mathrm dx\simeq4a^2/x_{\mathrm{start}}. The yield depends on where one starts, which no measurement fixes.
  4. d(1/Y)/dx=λx−3/2xr−1/2\mathrm d(1/Y)/\mathrm dx=\lambda x^{-3/2}x_r^{-1/2}, so Δ(1/Y)=2λxr−1/2xf−1/2\Delta(1/Y)=2\lambda x_r^{-1/2}x_f^{-1/2}, which is finite. The extra annihilation after freeze-out adds only a fixed correction.

Sources

  1. Hall, Jedamzik, March-Russell and West, 2010, section 5.1
  2. Particle Data Group, 2025, eq. 27.4
  3. D'Eramo, Fernandez and Profumo, 2017, section II

Keep reading

What this page links to directly

See this series on the content map →

How dark matter was left over · Reading path

From thermal equilibrium to relentless dark matter

  1. ArticleWhy did any dark matter survive the hot early universe?
  2. ArticleEquilibrium, expansion and the reaction race
  3. ArticleThe Boltzmann equation and freeze-out
  4. You are hereFreeze-in, hot relics and faster expansion
  5. ArticleRecompute a relic abundance with the saved scripts
  6. ArticleHow to read the relentless dark matter paper of D'Eramo and colleagues
Something broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy