Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics
How dark matter was left over

Equilibrium, expansion and the reaction race

Sandbox Physics ·

A particle of mass 100 GeV that annihilates with a low-temperature cross-section of 2.14×10−26 cm3 s−12.14\times10^{-26}\,\mathrm{cm^3\,s^{-1}} loses the race against expansion when the temperature falls to about 4 GeV. There its equilibrium annihilation rate equals the expansion rate, and there are only about six such particles per million million units of entropy. This chapter builds each of those numbers from the equilibrium density, the Friedmann equation and the definition of a reaction rate.

The chapter follows Why did any dark matter survive the hot early universe?. You need exponentials, a little integration and the idea of a number density. The aims are to write down the equilibrium number of a heavy particle in both limits, compute the expansion rate in the radiation era, and find where their ratio crosses one.

Units, symbols and what is held fixed

Use natural units, ℏ=c=kB=1\hbar=c=k_{\mathrm B}=1. Energies, masses and temperatures are then all in GeV, a number density is in GeV3\mathrm{GeV^3} and a rate is in GeV. To convert back, 1 GeV−1=6.58×10−25 s1\,\mathrm{GeV^{-1}}=6.58\times10^{-25}\,\mathrm s, and a cross-section times speed converts as 1 GeV−2=1.167×10−17 cm3 s−11\,\mathrm{GeV^{-2}}=1.167\times10^{-17}\,\mathrm{cm^3\,s^{-1}}.

The dark particle has mass mm and g=2g=2 internal states. The bath temperature is TT, and the clock used throughout is x=m/Tx=m/T, which grows as the universe cools. The bath counts as g∗=86.25g_*=86.25 relativistic species, the Standard Model value with every particle lighter than the bottom quark treated as massless. The Lab holds this number fixed. In reality it falls as the universe cools, steeply near the quark–hadron transition. Steigman, Dasgupta and Beacom, 2012, Fig. 2 Their fit to the full calculation needs a cross-section 8 per cent smaller than the Lab's for the observed density, so the simplification costs less than ten per cent above 10 GeV. The reduced Planck mass is MPl=2.435×1018 GeVM_{\mathrm{Pl}}=2.435\times10^{18}\,\mathrm{GeV}.

The equilibrium number

In equilibrium at temperature TT, the occupation of a state with energy E=p2+m2E=\sqrt{p^2+m^2} is e−E/T\mathrm e^{-E/T} when the particles are dilute. This Maxwell–Boltzmann form drops the ±1\pm1 of quantum statistics, which is accurate whenever E≫TE\gg T. Counting states in momentum space gives

neq=g∫d3p(2π)3 e−E/T=g2π2 m2T K2 ⁣(mT),n_{\mathrm{eq}}=g\int\frac{\mathrm d^3p}{(2\pi)^3}\,\mathrm e^{-E/T}=\frac{g}{2\pi^2}\,m^2T\,K_2\!\left(\frac{m}{T}\right),

where K2K_2 is a modified Bessel function. Two limits explain everything that follows. When x≪1x\ll1, K2(x)→2/x2K_2(x)\to2/x^2 and

neq→g T3π2,n_{\mathrm{eq}}\to\frac{g\,T^3}{\pi^2},

about the same as the photon density 2ζ(3)T3/π22\zeta(3)T^3/\pi^2. When x≫1x\gg1, K2(x)→π/2x e−xK_2(x)\to\sqrt{\pi/2x}\,\mathrm e^{-x} and

neq→g(mT2π)3/2e−m/T.n_{\mathrm{eq}}\to g\left(\frac{mT}{2\pi}\right)^{3/2}\mathrm e^{-m/T}.

The exponential is the cost of finding enough energy in a collision to make a particle of mass mm. It dominates as soon as TT is a few per cent of mm.

Counting per unit entropy

Expansion dilutes every density as a−3a^{-3}, where aa is the scale factor. To see only the effect of reactions, divide by something that dilutes the same way. The entropy density

s=2π245 g∗s T3s=\frac{2\pi^2}{45}\,g_{*s}\,T^3

does, because the total entropy in a comoving volume, sa3sa^3, is conserved while the bath stays in equilibrium. The number per unit entropy, Y=n/sY=n/s, therefore changes only when particles are made or destroyed. With g∗s=g∗g_{*s}=g_*,

Yeq=45 g4π4g∗s x2K2(x).Y_{\mathrm{eq}}=\frac{45\,g}{4\pi^4g_{*s}}\,x^2K_2(x).

At high temperature this reaches a plateau 90g/(4π4g∗s)=5.36×10−390g/(4\pi^4g_{*s})=5.36\times10^{-3}. The Particle Data Group quotes 0.278 g/g∗s0.278\,g/g_{*s}, which is the Bose–Einstein value; Maxwell–Boltzmann counting gives 0.231 g/g∗s0.231\,g/g_{*s}, 17 per cent lower. Particle Data Group, 2025, eq. 27.3 Both are right for their own statistics. The Lab uses Maxwell–Boltzmann throughout.

The expansion rate

In the radiation era the energy density is ρ=(π2/30) g∗T4\rho=(\pi^2/30)\,g_*T^4. The Friedmann equation for a flat universe, H2=ρ/(3MPl2)H^2=\rho/(3M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^2), then gives

H=π2g∗90 T2MPl=3.08 T2MPl.H=\sqrt{\frac{\pi^2g_*}{90}}\,\frac{T^2}{M_{\mathrm{Pl}}}=3.08\,\frac{T^2}{M_{\mathrm{Pl}}}.

At T=4 GeVT=4\,\mathrm{GeV} this is H=2.02×10−17 GeVH=2.02\times10^{-17}\,\mathrm{GeV}. The age of a radiation-dominated universe is t=1/(2H)t=1/(2H), so that temperature is reached about 1.6×10−8 s1.6\times10^{-8}\,\mathrm s after the start.

The reaction rate

A dark particle meets annihilation partners at the rate

Γ=neq ⟨σv⟩,\Gamma=n_{\mathrm{eq}}\,\langle\sigma v\rangle,

where ⟨σv⟩\langle\sigma v\rangle is the cross-section times relative speed, averaged over the thermal distribution. The Lab uses a contact interaction whose average tends to a constant ⟨σv⟩0\langle\sigma v\rangle_0 when the particles are slow and falls as T−2T^{-2} when they are fast. At x=25x=25 the average is 0.889 ⟨σv⟩00.889\,\langle\sigma v\rangle_0. The race is the ratio Γ/H\Gamma/H. While it is large, every particle annihilates many times per expansion time and the number follows equilibrium. When it falls below one, a typical particle no longer meets a partner in the time it takes the universe to double in size.

Worked example: the crossing near 4 GeV

Take m=100 GeVm=100\,\mathrm{GeV} and ⟨σv⟩0=2.136×10−26 cm3 s−1=1.830×10−9 GeV−2\langle\sigma v\rangle_0=2.136\times10^{-26}\,\mathrm{cm^3\,s^{-1}}=1.830\times10^{-9}\,\mathrm{GeV^{-2}}. Try x=25x=25, so T=4 GeVT=4\,\mathrm{GeV}.

The slow-particle density needs one correction, K2(x)≃π/2x e−x(1+15/8x)K_2(x)\simeq\sqrt{\pi/2x}\,\mathrm e^{-x}\left(1+15/8x\right), which adds 7.5 per cent at x=25x=25:

neq=2(100×42π)3/2e−25×1.076=1.52×10−8 GeV3.n_{\mathrm{eq}}=2\left(\frac{100\times4}{2\pi}\right)^{3/2}\mathrm e^{-25}\times1.076=1.52\times10^{-8}\,\mathrm{GeV^3}.

With ⟨σv⟩=0.889×1.830×10−9=1.63×10−9 GeV−2\langle\sigma v\rangle=0.889\times1.830\times10^{-9}=1.63\times10^{-9}\,\mathrm{GeV^{-2}}, the rate is Γ=2.47×10−17 GeV\Gamma=2.47\times10^{-17}\,\mathrm{GeV}. Dividing by H=2.02×10−17 GeVH=2.02\times10^{-17}\,\mathrm{GeV},

ΓH∣x=25=1.22.\frac{\Gamma}{H}\bigg|_{x=25}=1.22.

The ratio crosses one at xf=25.2x_f=25.2, a temperature of 3.97 GeV. At that point s=2.42×103 GeV3s=2.42\times10^{3}\,\mathrm{GeV^3} and Yeq=6.27×10−12Y_{\mathrm{eq}}=6.27\times10^{-12} at x=25x=25.

Table 2.1 The race for m=100 GeVm=100\,\mathrm{GeV} and ⟨σv⟩0=2.136×10−26 cm3 s−1\langle\sigma v\rangle_0=2.136\times10^{-26}\,\mathrm{cm^3\,s^{-1}}, from the saved model.
xxTTYeqY_{\mathrm{eq}}Γ/H\Gamma/H
11100 GeV100\,\mathrm{GeV}4.35×10−34.35\times10^{-3}3.27×1093.27\times10^{9}
3333.3 GeV33.3\,\mathrm{GeV}1.48×10−31.48\times10^{-3}1.15×1091.15\times10^{9}
101010 GeV10\,\mathrm{GeV}5.76×10−65.76\times10^{-6}2.37×1062.37\times10^{6}
20205 GeV5\,\mathrm{GeV}6.78×10−106.78\times10^{-10}161161
25254 GeV4\,\mathrm{GeV}6.27×10−126.27\times10^{-12}1.221.22
30303.33 GeV3.33\,\mathrm{GeV}5.49×10−145.49\times10^{-14}9.09×10−39.09\times10^{-3}

Between x=20x=20 and x=30x=30 the ratio falls by a factor of almost twenty thousand. That steepness is why the crossing is sharp and why xfx_f depends only logarithmically on the cross-section.

The crossing is a marker, not the end

Γ/H=1\Gamma/H=1 marks where equilibrium can no longer be maintained, not where the number stops changing. The full solution in the next chapter shows that the actual number per entropy is already 6 per cent above equilibrium at x=20x=20, is 6.8 times the equilibrium value at x=25.2x=25.2, and keeps falling until about x=200x=200. After the crossing the relevant rate is n⟨σv⟩n\langle\sigma v\rangle with the actual density nn, not neqn_{\mathrm{eq}}, and that rate falls only as a power of TT.

Lab tasks

Open the dark matter relic Lab. The "Reaction against expansion" chart shows Γ/H\Gamma/H for the equilibrium density as a solid cyan line and for the particles actually present as a dashed cyan line, with an orange line at one.

  1. Find where the solid line crosses one and compare with xf=25.2x_f=25.2 from the worked example. The "More numbers" group lists the same value.
  2. Drag the cyan handle on the stage up by about 0.3 in the logarithm, a factor of two. Predict how far the crossing moves before you look.
  3. Explain why the dashed line leaves the solid line and stays well above the equilibrium one for the rest of the run.

Exercises

  1. Show that for x≪1x\ll1 the equilibrium density with g=2g=2 is 1/ζ(3)=0.8321/\zeta(3)=0.832 times the photon density.
  2. By what factor does YeqY_{\mathrm{eq}} fall between x=25x=25 and x=26x=26? Estimate it from the slow-particle limit, then compare with the saved model value 0.3890.389.
  3. Double ⟨σv⟩0\langle\sigma v\rangle_0. Use the steepness of Γ/H\Gamma/H near xfx_f to estimate the new crossing.
  4. Show that YY is unchanged by expansion alone when g∗sg_{*s} is constant.
Answers
  1. Photons have nγ=2ζ(3)T3/π2n_\gamma=2\zeta(3)T^3/\pi^2. With g=2g=2, neq/nγ=1/ζ(3)=1/1.202=0.832n_{\mathrm{eq}}/n_\gamma=1/\zeta(3)=1/1.202=0.832.
  2. Yeq∝x3/2e−x(1+15/8x)Y_{\mathrm{eq}}\propto x^{3/2}\mathrm e^{-x}(1+15/8x) for x≫1x\gg1, so the ratio is (26/25)3/2 e−1×(1.0721/1.0750)=1.0606×0.3679×0.9973=0.389(26/25)^{3/2}\,\mathrm e^{-1}\times(1.0721/1.0750)=1.0606\times0.3679\times0.9973=0.389. A one-unit step in xx costs a factor of about e\mathrm e.
  3. Γ/H∝⟨σv⟩0 F(x) x1/2e−x\Gamma/H\propto\langle\sigma v\rangle_0\,F(x)\,x^{1/2}\mathrm e^{-x} near xfx_f, so dln⁡(Γ/H)/dx≃−1+1/2x≃−0.98\mathrm d\ln(\Gamma/H)/\mathrm dx\simeq-1+1/2x\simeq-0.98. Doubling the cross-section raises ln⁡(Γ/H)\ln(\Gamma/H) by ln⁡2=0.69\ln2=0.69, which is cancelled by Δx≃0.71\Delta x\simeq0.71. The new crossing is near x=25.9x=25.9; the saved model gives 25.9125.91.
  4. Y=n/s=na3/(sa3)Y=n/s=na^3/(sa^3). Without reactions na3na^3 is constant, and sa3sa^3 is constant when entropy is conserved. With s∝g∗sT3s\propto g_{*s}T^3 and g∗sg_{*s} fixed this means T∝1/aT\propto1/a.

Sources

  1. Steigman, Dasgupta and Beacom, 2012, Fig. 2
  2. Particle Data Group, 2025, eq. 27.3

Keep reading

What this page links to directly

See this series on the content map →

How dark matter was left over · Reading path

From thermal equilibrium to relentless dark matter

  1. ArticleWhy did any dark matter survive the hot early universe?
  2. You are hereEquilibrium, expansion and the reaction race
  3. ArticleThe Boltzmann equation and freeze-out
  4. ArticleFreeze-in, hot relics and faster expansion
  5. ArticleRecompute a relic abundance with the saved scripts
  6. ArticleHow to read the relentless dark matter paper of D'Eramo and colleagues
Something broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy