The von Neumann–Mullins law says grains with fewer than six sides shrink
Sandbox Physics ·
In a flat polycrystal, whether a grain grows or shrinks does not depend on its size or shape, only on how many neighbours it has. Grains with fewer than six sides shrink, grains with more grow, and six-sided grains hold their area. This is the von Neumann–Mullins law. Together with Euler’s count, which fixes the average number of sides at six, it explains why a polycrystal coarsens. This chapter derives both and measures them in seeded simulations, where one of the two numbers comes out 2% off.
A grain’s area changes at the rate its boundary sweeps inward, the integral of the normal speed around it. With motion by curvature that integral becomes −Mγ times the total curvature of the boundary.
Walk once around the grain. Your direction turns by 2π in total. Part of the turning happens smoothly along the sides; the rest happens at the corners, the triple junctions. Where three boundaries of equal energy meet, their tensions balance only at 120∘ angles, so at each corner your direction jumps by π/3. An n-sided grain turns by nπ/3 at its corners, leaving 2π−nπ/3 for the smooth parts.
The result, Eq. (1) of Mason, Lazar, MacPherson and Srolovitz, holds for every grain whatever its size or shape. Six-sided grains have straight sides on average and keep their area. With Mγ=Lk from chapter 4, the slope of the area rate against n−6 is π/3=1.0472 in units of Lk.
dtdA=∮vnds=−Mγ∮κds,∮κds+n3π=2π
The area rate as total curvature, and the turning of the boundary split between the smooth sides and the n corners.
dtdAn=−2πMγ(1−6n)=3πMγ(n−6)
The von Neumann–Mullins law for an n-sided grain in an isotropic two-dimensional polycrystal.
A two-dimensional grain network in a periodic box is a map on a torus with V corners, E sides and F grains, and Euler’s formula gives V−E+F=0. Three sides meet at every corner and every side has two ends, so 3V=2E. Each side borders two grains, so the side counts add to 2E. Together these fix the mean number of sides at exactly six, as Section III A 1 of Mason et al. notes.
The two facts fit together. Adding the law over all grains gives a total rate proportional to the sum of n−6, which vanishes, so the total area is conserved. Grains with few sides shrink and vanish; their area goes to grains with many sides. Each disappearance removes a grain, so the mean grain area grows. Kazaryan et al. report that the mean area grows linearly in time once the structure looks the same at every scale.
V−E+F=0,3V=2E⟹F=3E,⟨n⟩=F2E=6
Euler’s formula on a torus for a network with three sides at every corner.
The route benchmark grows three seeded polycrystals of 80 grains on a 160 by 160 grid with L=k=1 up to time 1000. It counts each grain’s neighbours, records the area change of every grain over windows in which its side count stays fixed, and fits a line through the origin of rate against n−6. That gives 3620, 3710 and 4000 samples per seed.
The fitted slope is 1.0704±0.0007 in units of Lk over the three seeds, against π/3=1.0472. The figure shows where the excess comes from. Five-sided grains shrink at −1.045, on the law. Grains with seven or more sides grow 3% to 6% faster than the law, and six-sided grains grow at +0.035 on average instead of holding still. The mean number of sides is 5.979±0.004, not exactly six.
Those last two numbers point to one likely cause, which we have not tested. Two grains count as neighbours only if they share at least two cell faces, so a very short side can be missed. A seven-sided grain counted as six then raises the six-sided average, and since grains with more sides have more chances to hide a short one, the bias grows with n and steepens the slope. Counting triple junctions directly would test this. Until then the 2% excess is an unexplained systematic error of the measurement.
Mean area rate of grains with n sides, in units of Lk, pooled over three seeded 160 by 160 polycrystals (dots, sample counts from 17 to 3731). The dashed line is the von Neumann–Mullins law (π/3)(n−6). Five-sided grains sit on it; six-sided grains grow slightly, and grains with more sides grow 3% to 6% faster than the law.
Worked example: which grains of a small cluster survive?
Problem. In a polycrystal with L=k=1, a four-sided grain of area 60 cells sits next to an eight-sided grain of area 400 cells. Assuming both keep their side counts, how fast does each change, and when does the small one vanish?
Rates. For n=4, dA/dt=(π/3)(4−6)=−2.09 cells per unit time. For n=8, +2.09. Neither depends on the area.
Lifetime. 60/2.09=29 time units. As it shrinks it is likely to lose sides, which would make it shrink faster, so this is an upper estimate.
Check. The pooled benchmark rates are −2.12 for four-sided and +2.16 for eight-sided grains, 1% and 3% faster than the law.
Answer. The four-sided grain loses about 2.1 cells per unit time and is gone within about 29 time units; the eight-sided one gains at the same rate as long as it keeps eight sides.
Fitting the mean area against time from t=333 to 1000 gives an exponent of 0.81±0.05, not the 1 of linear growth. By the end of that window only 18 to 25 grains are left in each box, down from 43 to 55 at its start. That is too few for the self-similar state that the linear law assumes, and the run is short. The benchmark therefore does not test linear coarsening; a larger box and a longer run would be needed. The free energy fell or stayed level in all 150 checks.
Choose One defect in a honeycomb with grains coloured by their number of sides. Predict which grains will change area first and which will stay as they are.
Choose A polycrystal coarsens and let it run. Predict the value the measured slope readout should approach.
Watch the grain count and the mean number of sides together. Explain why the number of grains falls while the mean number of sides stays close to six.
Exercises with explained answers
Use the law to show that the total area of a periodic polycrystal does not change.
Show the answer
Adding over all F grains, the total rate is (π/3)Mγ∑i(ni−6)=(π/3)MγF(⟨n⟩−6), which is zero because ⟨n⟩=6.
If triple junctions met at an angle θ instead of 120∘, which number of sides would hold its area?
Show the answer
Each corner turns the boundary by π−θ, so the smooth parts turn by 2π−n(π−θ). The rate vanishes at n=2π/(π−θ), which is six for θ=2π/3. Junction angles are fixed by the balance of three equal tensions, which is why the law needs equal boundary energies.
A three-sided grain of area 30 cells shrinks with L=k=1. Estimate its lifetime and compare with the pooled benchmark rate for three-sided grains.
Show the answer
The law gives dA/dt=−π=−3.14, so about 9.5 time units. The benchmark pools 30 samples with a mean rate of −3.18, 1.3% faster.
Why would a fit of the mean area against time over a short run with about twenty grains left give an exponent below one, even if the law of linear growth were correct?
Show the answer
Linear growth of the mean area holds once the grain structure is statistically the same at every scale. Starting from a random arrangement of seeds, the side and size distributions take time to reach that state, and with only about twenty grains each disappearance changes the mean area in a large step. A short window over few grains measures the approach to the scaling state.
Version 1, full text. Eq. (1): one Allen–Cahn equation per order parameter. Eq. (2): the free energy with gradient terms. Eq. (5): the bulk free-energy density, used with a1=a2=1 and a3=2. Eq. (6) and Fig. 3: an isolated grain shrinks at a constant area rate. The closing paragraphs and Fig. 5: the mean grain area grows linearly in time. This course uses only the isotropic case.
Version 1. Section II, Eq. (1): the von Neumann–Mullins relation dA/dt=−2πMγ(1−n/6), exact for isotropic two-dimensional grain growth. Section III A 1 and Fig. 4(a): the distribution of edges per grain, and Euler’s theorem fixing the mean number of edges at six.
Keep reading
What this page links to directly
You are hereThe von Neumann–Mullins law says grains with fewer than six sides shrink