Grain boundaries move by curvature, so a round grain shrinks at a steady rate
Sandbox Physics ·
Heat a metal made of many small crystals and the crystals grow: small ones disappear and boundaries straighten. Nothing pushes the boundaries from outside. They move because boundary length costs energy, and a curved boundary lowers it by moving toward its centre of curvature. For a round grain the result is striking: its area falls at a constant rate, 2πMγ, whatever its size. This chapter derives that law from the phase-field model the Lab runs and measures how closely the Lab’s grid follows it.
Where two crystals of different orientation meet, atoms cannot sit in either lattice, so the boundary carries an energy γ per unit length in two dimensions. Shortening the boundary lowers the energy. A straight boundary cannot get shorter by moving, but a curved one can: moving toward its centre of curvature shortens it.
The simplest kinetic law makes the speed proportional to the driving force, which for a boundary of energy γ and curvature κ is γκ per unit area. With a mobility M, the speed is Mγκ. For a round grain of radius R the curvature is 1/R, and the radius shrinks ever faster as it gets smaller. Its area, though, falls at a constant rate, because the faster motion acts on a shorter perimeter.
v=Mγκ⟹dtdR=−RMγ,dtdA=2πRdtdR=−2πMγ
Motion by curvature, and its consequence for a round grain of area A=πR2.
Kazaryan, Wang, Dregia and Patton describe a polycrystal with one field ηi per orientation. Inside grain i, ηi=1 and the others vanish; across a boundary one field falls as the next rises. Each field relaxes down the gradient of a free energy, Eq. (1). The free energy, Eq. (2), adds a gradient term with coefficient k to a bulk density f that has a minimum for each pure grain.
The bulk density of their Eq. (5) with a1=a2=1 and a3=2 is written out below. The cross term penalises two fields that are both large at one point, so grains do not overlap. The Lab gives every grain its own field, so two grains can never merge by sharing an index, and stores at each cell only the four largest fields.
Near a gently curved boundary, write the Laplacian in a coordinate n along the normal. It splits into the second derivative across the boundary plus a curvature term. The flat equilibrium profile already balances the bulk force against the second-derivative term, so only the curvature term is left over.
That leftover is Lkκ times the slope of the profile. A profile that slides along its normal at speed v changes at exactly that rate times its slope, so the boundary moves with v=Lkκ. The bulk density drops out. Comparing with the sharp law gives Mγ=Lk, and an island grain shrinks as dA/dt=−2πLk, which is Eq. (6) of Kazaryan et al. for an isotropic boundary.
∇2η=∂n2η+κ∂nη⟹∂tη=Lkκ∂nη⟹v=Lkκ,Mγ=Lk
The curvature term left over near a curved boundary, read as a moving profile.
The route benchmark shrinks round grains on a 128 by 128 grid with L=k=1 and fits a straight line to the area while it falls from 0.9 to 0.25 of its start. Divided by 2πLk, the rate is 0.956, 0.953 and 0.952 for starting radii 20, 30 and 40. The rate does not depend on size, as the law says, but is about 5% slow.
Raising k widens the boundary, which then spans more grid cells. With the radius scaled up by the same factor, the runs are the same problem on a finer grid. The ratio rises to 0.978 at k=2 and 0.990 at k=4. The shortfall halves each time k doubles, which is what a second-order discretisation gives when the boundary width grows as k. The gap is a grid error that closes as the boundary is resolved more finely.
Choose A round grain shrinks at a steady rate. Predict whether the island’s area falls along a straight line or a curve, and how long it lasts.
Reset and double the boundary mobility to 2. Predict the new lifetime, then watch.
Choose A large grain eats its neighbours. Explain why a round grain on its own always shrinks, while a large grain surrounded by small ones can grow.
Exercises with explained answers
With L=1 and k=2, how long does a round grain of starting radius 30 last, by the law and on the grid?
Show the answer
By the law, R02/(2Lk)=900/4=225 time units. The benchmark ratio at k=2 is 0.978, so about 230 on the grid.
The Lab advances the field with forward Euler steps. Its nine-point Laplacian has its most negative eigenvalue at −16/3, and the bulk term adds a curvature of up to 2, so a step is stable only if LΔt(16k/3+2)<2. Is the default Δt=0.1 stable for L=k=2?
Show the answer
The bound is Δt<2/[2×(32/3+2)]=0.079, so 0.1 is unstable. The Lab takes 0.8 of the bound, Δt=0.063, whenever the default step would exceed it.
Why does a straight boundary between two large grains not move at all in this model, however different their orientations?
Show the answer
Its curvature is zero, so v=Lkκ=0. In the isotropic model the driving force comes only from curvature. A flat boundary would need a second driving force, such as a difference in stored energy between the grains, which this model leaves out.
Version 1, full text. Eq. (1): one Allen–Cahn equation per order parameter. Eq. (2): the free energy with gradient terms. Eq. (5): the bulk free-energy density, used with a1=a2=1 and a3=2. Eq. (6) and Fig. 3: an isolated grain shrinks at a constant area rate. The closing paragraphs and Fig. 5: the mean grain area grows linearly in time. This course uses only the isotropic case.
Version 1. Section II, Eq. (1): the von Neumann–Mullins relation dA/dt=−2πMγ(1−n/6), exact for isotropic two-dimensional grain growth. Section III A 1 and Fig. 4(a): the distribution of edges per grain, and Euler’s theorem fixing the mean number of edges at six.
Keep reading
What this page links to directly
You are hereGrain boundaries move by curvature, so a round grain shrinks at a steady rate