The lowest erbium-166 levels spread farther apart as their angular momentum grows. A shared deformed configuration explains this pattern through collective rotation. Meanwhile, nucleons can correlate in zero-angular-momentum pairs. Separating rotation from the cost of breaking a pair shows why both pictures belong in nuclear structure.
Classical rotational energy is L2/(2I). A larger moment of inertia I carries the same angular momentum at lower energy. For an axially deformed nucleus, take rotation perpendicular to the symmetry axis and replace squared angular momentum with its quantum eigenvalue.
The axially symmetric even-even ground band has intrinsic projection K=0 and allows J=0,2,4,…. Its members share an intrinsic configuration. The drawn shape belongs to a body-fixed frame; a zero-spin laboratory ground state has no fixed spatial orientation.
EJ=AJ(J+1),A=2Iℏ2
These are excitation energies relative to the ground state. Constant inertia is the approximation being tested.
Worked example: one calibration predicts three levels
The March 2008 ENSDF erbium-166 ground band starts at 0,80.5776,264.990,545.454,911.208keV, with spins increasing by two. The first excited level sets A=80.5776/6=13.4296keV.
For the three higher spins the rotor gives 268.592,564.0432,966.9312keV. Subtracting the original evaluated values gives residuals +3.602,+18.5892,+55.7232keV. Increasing overprediction at higher spin suggests that the effective inertia changes as the nucleus is excited.
A quick pattern check is E4/E2. The rigid rotor gives 10/3 and the evaluated ratio is about 3.29. Yet the quoted energy errors range from 0.0020 to 0.006keV, much smaller than the model discrepancy. The rotor explains the coarse pattern; precision spectroscopy needs finer dynamics.
Consider a different starting point: a small quadrupole distortion about a spherical equilibrium. One quantum of this vibration is a phonon and carries angular momentum two. In the harmonic limit each additional phonon costs the same energy.
One phonon gives 2+. Two identical quadrupole phonons combine into degenerate 0+,2+,4+ states. Following only the maximum-spin member at each phonon number gives E4/E2=2, well below the evaluated erbium ratio. The workbench lists the other two-phonon states alongside this stretched sequence.
Anharmonicity and configuration mixing split real multiplets. Quadrupole transition strengths and quadrupole moments provide further tests. Energy ratios identify a promising explanation. Reconstructing the shape then requires the spectrum together with these electromagnetic observables.
En=nℏω,E2E4stretched=2
The ground-state zero-point energy is subtracted. The energy subscripts label spin, whereas n counts phonons.
Within a fixed j shell, magnetic projections mj and −mj are time-reversed partners. An attractive zero-angular-momentum pairing interaction mixes configurations of these occupied pairs and lowers their energy. Pairing concerns nucleon correlations; rotation concerns collective orientation. Both can occur in a deformed nucleus.
A minimal exact example has 2Ω=2j+1 magnetic substates and Ω available pair positions. Put only one pair in the shell. Suppose every matrix element between pair positions is −G. An equal-amplitude superposition receives Ω equal contributions in each row, so its energy is −GΩ. Orthogonal combinations have zero energy.
Take j=5/2 and G=0.30MeV. Three pair positions give correlation energy −0.90MeV. In this restricted model a broken pair loses that attraction, at an energy cost of 0.90MeV. As G→0, the cost vanishes. These illustrative parameters are not fitted to erbium masses or spectra.
For more particles, seniority v counts particles outside these zero-angular-momentum pairs. The exact degenerate-shell result below extends the one-pair calculation. Real shells have level spacings and additional correlations that couple pairing to deformation and rotation.
E(n,v)=−4G(n−v)(2Ω−n−v+2)
Here n counts particles, Ω counts available pair positions and G is a positive attraction. Allowed seniority has the same parity as particle number and must fit within both particle and hole spaces.
Choose An erbium rotational band. Calculate the next three energies from the first excitation, then compare model values and residuals.
Predict the effect of doubling inertia, then set Moment of inertia relative to reference to two. Explain why all energies halve but the ratios stay fixed.
Choose Test a vibration ladder. Identify the shared calibration energy, explain the diverging higher levels and list the two-phonon spins omitted from the stretched sequence.
Exercises and explanations
With E2=120keV, predict E4 and E6 for the rotor and stretched harmonic sequence.
Read the explanation
The rotor multiplies by 20/6 and 42/6, giving 400 and 840keV. Two and three phonons give 240 and 360keV. An identical first excitation therefore leads to clearly different higher spacings.
Place two particles in a degenerate j=7/2 shell with G=0.20MeV. Find the paired ground energy and breaking cost. Does a filled shell have zero interaction energy?
Read the explanation
There are Ω=4 pair positions, giving −GΩ=−0.80MeV and breaking cost 0.80MeV. With n=8,v=0, the filled-shell result is still −0.80MeV. The Hamiltonian includes diagonal attraction on occupied pair positions; its energy convention must stay fixed.
Evaluated level energies and published reaction measurements retain their source versions and uncertainties. Model curves, schematic figures and synthetic scattering records are identified separately. The offline benchmark files state which calculations have been reproduced.
Selected ground-band levels in the frozen adopted evaluation; the dataset records the evaluation date and errors. Only selected numerical facts are redistributed; model curves and artwork are original.
Collective rotational sequences and intrinsic deformation. The rigid rotor and harmonic vibrator are limiting models; the evaluated band residuals test their range.