Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics
Complex fluids

Stress relaxation and creep in a Maxwell liquid

Deform a liquid quickly, then hold its shape. Elastic memory lets stress persist and gradually relax. Hold a stress instead, and the same material can keep flowing. A spring and dashpot in series explain both responses in the Maxwell model. Two liquids with the same steady viscosity can have very different relaxation times.

Choose a shear direction and connect two elements

Take a homogeneous sample between parallel plates. The lower plate is fixed; positive horizontal displacement of the upper plate divided by the gap defines positive shear strain γ\gamma. Tangential force in that direction divided by plate area is shear stress τ\tau. Strain is dimensionless, stress has units of pascals, and shear rate γ˙\dot\gamma has units of inverse seconds. This is a scalar, small-deformation, homogeneous-shear model; finite rotations require a tensor description.

The spring has shear modulus GG in pascals; the dashpot has viscosity η\eta in pascal seconds. In series they carry the same stress. Total strain adds spring strain γs\gamma_s and dashpot strain γd\gamma_d. Differentiate that sum, then replace each contribution using the two element laws. A dot denotes a time derivative.

Multiplication by viscosity gives a time in seconds, λ=η/G\lambda=\eta/G, called the relaxation time. It sets how quickly excess stress decays after deformation stops. Only two of modulus, viscosity and relaxation time can be chosen independently.

γ=γs+γdτ=Gγs=ηγ˙dγ˙=τ˙G+τητ+λτ˙=ηγ˙λ=ηG\begin{gathered}\gamma=\gamma_s+\gamma_d\\\tau=G\gamma_s=\eta\dot\gamma_d\\\dot\gamma=\frac{\dot\tau}{G}+\frac{\tau}{\eta}\\\tau+\lambda\dot\tau=\eta\dot\gamma\\\lambda=\frac{\eta}{G}\end{gathered}
Morozov and Spagnolie, Section 4.1, Eqs. (1.47)–(1.49). These rheological elements are parameterized by shear modulus and viscosity.

Source: A. Morozov and S. E. Spagnolie

Hold strain and let stress relax

Start with an unstressed sample. At t=0t=0 impose an ideal strain step γ0\gamma_0 and hold it. The dashpot cannot accumulate a finite strain in that instant, so the spring takes the whole step and stress jumps to Gγ0G\gamma_0. A real instrument loads over a finite time. Its peak approaches this step result only when loading is much faster than relaxation.

During the hold, shear rate is zero. Stress therefore changes at a rate equal to minus stress divided by relaxation time. Divide by stress and integrate: the logarithm of the stress ratio equals minus time over relaxation time. Exponentiation gives the decaying stress. One relaxation time leaves a fraction 1/e≈0.3681/e\approx0.368 of the initial stress. The pure Maxwell liquid eventually relaxes to zero.

A Newtonian dashpot has no such residual stress once motion stops. An additional equilibrium spring in parallel changes the long-time result to a nonzero plateau. Then it is the excess above the plateau that follows the relaxing branch.

γ˙=0(t>0)τ˙=−τλln⁡τ(t)τ(0+)=−tλτ(0+)=Gγ0τ(t)=Gγ0e−t/λ\begin{gathered}\dot\gamma=0\quad(t>0)\\\dot\tau=-\frac{\tau}{\lambda}\\\ln\frac{\tau(t)}{\tau(0^+)}=-\frac t\lambda\\\tau(0^+)=G\gamma_0\\\tau(t)=G\gamma_0e^{-t/\lambda}\end{gathered}
Pure Maxwell response to an ideal strain step. Time starts at loading; substitution checks both the first-order equation and the initial value.

Source: A. Morozov and S. E. Spagnolie

Hold stress and then unload

Now change the experiment. Apply and hold a stress τ0\tau_0. The spring immediately contributes strain τ0/G\tau_0/G, and the dashpot continues deforming at rate τ0/η\tau_0/\eta. Total strain starts with a jump and then grows linearly. This continuing deformation is creep.

Remove the stress after a hold time tht_h. The spring strain recovers immediately and the accumulated viscous strain τ0th/η\tau_0t_h/\eta remains. Superscripts minus and plus mean just before and just after unloading. The residual comes from viscous flow; a plastic yield law is not needed.

For G=10 PaG=10\,\mathrm{Pa} and λ=2 s\lambda=2\,\mathrm{s}, viscosity is 20 Pa s20\,\mathrm{Pa\,s}. A stress τ0=0.02 Pa\tau_0=0.02\,\mathrm{Pa} held for six seconds gives strain 0.002+0.006=0.0080.002+0.006=0.008. Unloading recovers 0.002 and leaves 0.006. These strains are relative deformations, with no length unit.

γ(t)=τ0G+τ0ηtγ(th−)=τ0G+τ0thηγ(th+)=τ0thη\begin{gathered}\gamma(t)=\frac{\tau_0}{G}+\frac{\tau_0}{\eta}t\\\gamma(t_h^-)=\frac{\tau_0}{G}+\frac{\tau_0t_h}{\eta}\\\gamma(t_h^+)=\frac{\tau_0t_h}{\eta}\end{gathered}
Integrate the constant strain rate during the hold and include the spring jumps at loading and unloading. This remains an ideal step-input, small-deformation constitutive example.

Source: A. Morozov and S. E. Spagnolie

At startup the solvent responds first

A polymer solution also contains solvent. Put a Newtonian solvent element in parallel with a polymer Maxwell element: their rates are equal and their stresses add. Let solvent viscosity be ηs\eta_s, polymer viscosity parameter ηp\eta_p and polymer stress τp\tau_p. Total model viscosity η0\eta_0 is the sum, and β\beta denotes the solvent fraction.

Starting from rest, step the shear rate to a constant value. Solvent stress reaches ηsγ˙\eta_s\dot\gamma immediately; polymer stress grows exponentially from zero to ηpγ˙\eta_p\dot\gamma. This shear-stress solution also occurs in homogeneous Oldroyd-B startup shear. The next chapter introduces its normal stresses.

At steady shear the ratio of stress to rate is always η0\eta_0, independent of relaxation time. Changing the relaxation time changes the approach to steady state without changing this viscosity. A steady sweep alone therefore cannot rule out material memory. This linear shear relation also does not generate shear thinning.

τ=ηsγ˙+τpτp+λτ˙p=ηpγ˙τp(0)=0τ(t)=ηsγ˙+ηpγ˙(1−e−t/λ)η0=ηs+ηp,β=ηsη0\begin{gathered}\tau=\eta_s\dot\gamma+\tau_p\\\tau_p+\lambda\dot\tau_p=\eta_p\dot\gamma\\\tau_p(0)=0\\\tau(t)=\eta_s\dot\gamma\\+\eta_p\dot\gamma(1-e^{-t/\lambda})\\\eta_0=\eta_s+\eta_p,\quad\beta=\frac{\eta_s}{\eta_0}\end{gathered}
Solve the polymer first-order equation with zero initial stress, then add the instantaneous solvent contribution. Morozov and Spagnolie Eqs. (1.80) and (1.116) give the corresponding Oldroyd-B constitutive and steady-shear relations.

Hold strain

Vertical: τ/(Gγ0)\tau/(G\gamma_0)

Normalized stress decays from one toward zero

Horizontal: t/λt/\lambda

Hold stress

Vertical: γ/(τ0/G)\gamma/(\tau_0/G)

Normalized strain starts at one and grows linearly

Horizontal: t/λt/\lambda

Start a constant shear rate

Vertical: τp/(ηpγ˙)\tau_p/(\eta_p\dot\gamma)

Normalized polymer stress grows from zero toward one

Horizontal: t/λt/\lambda

Original analytic curves for the stated ideal protocols, not measured data. Dashed lines mark one relaxation time. Relaxation and creep start just after the ideal step. Startup shows the polymer stress alone; solvent stress is added separately.

Source: A. Morozov and S. E. Spagnolie

Worked example: distinguish reported inputs from predictions

The Methods of Groisman and Steinberg’s 2000 paper report, at 12 degrees Celsius, solvent viscosity ηs=0.324 Pa s\eta_s=0.324\,\mathrm{Pa\,s}, solution viscosity 0.424 Pa s0.424\,\mathrm{Pa\,s} at γ˙=1 s−1\dot\gamma=1\,\mathrm{s}^{-1}, and relaxation time λ=3.4 s\lambda=3.4\,\mathrm{s} estimated from the phase shift between stress and shear rate in oscillatory tests. One viscosity point is neither a whole flow curve nor an independent zero-shear viscosity measurement.

For a single-mode teaching calculation, choose ηp=0.100 Pa s\eta_p=0.100\,\mathrm{Pa\,s} so the model steady viscosity matches 0.424 pascal seconds at that point. Then G=ηp/λ=0.0294 PaG=\eta_p/\lambda=0.0294\,\mathrm{Pa}. Starting from rest at a shear rate of one per second, total stress begins at 0.324 pascals, reaches 0.387 Pa0.387\,\mathrm{Pa} after one relaxation time, and tends to 0.424 pascals.

To reach 99% of the polymer stress alone, solve for the exponential remainder: λln⁡100≈15.7 s\lambda\ln100\approx15.7\,\mathrm{s}. To reach 99% of the final total stress, the solvent has already supplied much of the answer. The wait is instead 10.7 s10.7\,\mathrm{s}. A settling tolerance needs its reference quantity.

First wait for model steady shear, then stop. Solvent stress vanishes immediately; polymer stress continues to relax. Ten seconds later it is 0.100e−10/3.4≈5.28×10−3 Pa0.100e^{-10/3.4}\approx5.28\times10^{-3}\,\mathrm{Pa}. These startup and cessation values are model predictions. Real samples can have several relaxation times, shear thinning and instrument transients; 15.7 seconds is not a universal waiting rule.

τ(λ)=[0.324+0.100(1−e−1)] Pa≃0.387 Pat99,p=λln⁡100≃15.7 st99,total=λln⁡0.1000.00424≃10.7 s\begin{aligned}\tau(\lambda)={}&[0.324\\&+0.100(1-e^{-1})]\,\mathrm{Pa}\\\simeq{}&0.387\,\mathrm{Pa}\\t_{99,p}={}&\lambda\ln100\\\simeq{}&15.7\,\mathrm{s}\\t_{99,\rm total}={}&\lambda\ln\frac{0.100}{0.00424}\\\simeq{}&10.7\,\mathrm{s}\end{aligned}
The allowed remainder is 0.00424 pascals for 99% of total stress and 0.001 pascals for 99% of polymer stress.

Source: A. Groisman and V. Steinberg · A. Morozov and S. E. Spagnolie

Keep deformation, observation and inertia separate

The Weissenberg number Wi\mathrm{Wi} multiplies relaxation time by a characteristic shear rate. It compares memory with deformation. The Deborah number De\mathrm{De} instead compares relaxation time with a chosen observation duration TobsT_{\rm obs}. A long observation can still contain rapid sustained shear. The two comparisons answer different questions.

Check inertia using the Reynolds number, with speed UU, length LL, density ρ\rho and a stated viscosity, here the total model value η0\eta_0. Only after choosing shear rate as speed over size does their ratio take the form below. A larger ratio makes elasticity more important relative to inertia; it does not by itself make elastic stress large.

Our example has Wi=3.4\mathrm{Wi}=3.4. That does not specify every elastic-to-viscous stress ratio or establish an instability threshold: polymer share, flow and geometry matter. Groisman and Steinberg report the same normalized resistance relation after reducing every apparatus dimension fourfold at equal shear rate. Speed fell fourfold and Reynolds number sixteenfold. This supports their low-inertia elastic-instability interpretation; the paper says the rescaled data are not separately plotted. The scalar Maxwell equation does not itself predict that instability.

Wi=λγ˙De=λTobsRe=ρULη0WiRe=λη0ρL2when γ˙=U/L\begin{gathered}\mathrm{Wi}=\lambda\dot\gamma\\\mathrm{De}=\frac{\lambda}{T_{\rm obs}}\\\mathrm{Re}=\frac{\rho UL}{\eta_0}\\\frac{\mathrm{Wi}}{\mathrm{Re}}=\frac{\lambda\eta_0}{\rho L^2}\\\text{when }\dot\gamma=U/L\end{gathered}
The first definitions compare deformation, observation and inertia. The last relation additionally assumes the shear-rate scale is speed divided by length.

Source: A. Morozov and S. E. Spagnolie · A. Groisman and V. Steinberg

Try it in the Lab

Predict the nonzero hold plateau

  1. Choose Viscoelastic hold and predict whether stress will reach zero. This is a tensile specimen with an equilibrium spring parallel to one Maxwell branch, so a nonzero plateau remains.
  2. Set each hold to ten seconds and Maxwell relaxation time to one second. Find the excess stress above the plateau at hold onset, then the point at 1/e1/e of that excess. They should be about one second apart. Compare excess stress, not total stress.
  3. Change relaxation time to five seconds. Predict how much excess disappears during a ten-second hold, then inspect the curve. Loading is a finite ramp, so its rate also changes the starting peak.

What a steady sweep can answer

  1. Use Newtonian standard and record torque and apparent viscosity at two speeds. Then choose Shear thinning. Predict which quantity can rise and which can fall.
  2. This rheometer gives isothermal, no-slip, memoryless steady readings from the current shear rate. It has no relaxation time; matching viscosity values do not replace a relaxation measurement.
  3. For the example’s Maxwell-plus-solvent model, calculate separate waits for 99% of polymer stress and 99% of total stress. Explain the difference between about 15.7 and 10.7 seconds.

Exercises with explained answers

  1. A pure Maxwell liquid with G=10 PaG=10\,\mathrm{Pa} and λ=2 s\lambda=2\,\mathrm{s} receives an ideal strain step of 0.005. Find stress immediately and after four seconds.

    Show the answer

    Initially Gγ0=0.05 PaG\gamma_0=0.05\,\mathrm{Pa}; after four seconds 0.05e−2≈0.00677 Pa0.05e^{-2}\approx0.00677\,\mathrm{Pa}. Two relaxation times leave about 13.5%. These values assume the ideal step.

  2. Hold the same liquid at a shear stress of 0.02 pascals for six seconds, then unload. Which strain recovers and which remains?

    Show the answer

    Viscosity is twenty pascal seconds. Spring strain is 0.002 and accumulated dashpot strain is 0.006, for a total of 0.008. The spring recovers 0.002 on unloading; the viscous strain of 0.006 remains.

  3. Two Maxwell liquids have the same viscosity but relaxation times of one and ten seconds. Can steady shear alone distinguish them?

    Show the answer

    No. Their steady stresses equal the same viscosity times the shear rate. Startup, cessation or oscillation can distinguish the time response. The longer-relaxing liquid loses an initial stress more slowly.

  4. Reduce every apparatus dimension tenfold at fixed fluid and shear rate. What happens to Reynolds and Weissenberg numbers? Does that alone establish instability?

    Show the answer

    Weissenberg number is unchanged. Speed and length each fall tenfold, so Reynolds number falls a hundredfold. Inertia is smaller, but material, flow and boundary conditions still determine instability; the ratio alone is insufficient.

Sources and what we recomputed

  1. A. Morozov and S. E. Spagnolie, Introduction to complex fluids, in Complex Fluids in Biological Systems (Springer, 2015), chapter 1

    Section 3: the Weissenberg number defined as the relaxation time times the shear rate, and Eq. (1.27), the generalized Newtonian liquid. Section 4.1: Eqs. (1.47)–(1.51), the spring, the dashpot, the Maxwell liquid and its memory integral, with a relaxation time equal to viscosity over modulus. Eq. (1.72): the upper-convected derivative; Eq. (1.80): Oldroyd-B; Eqs. (1.86)–(1.87): FENE-P. Section 4.4: the Hookean dumbbell, Eqs. (1.98)–(1.110). Eq. (1.116): the steady-shear normal stress of Oldroyd-B. Eqs. (1.117)–(1.125): hoop stress and the cone-and-plate normal force. Eqs. (1.128)–(1.131): uniaxial extension and the Oldroyd-B divergence at half the inverse relaxation time. The chapter has no startup solution and no planar extension; the course derives both.

  2. A. Groisman and V. Steinberg, Elastic turbulence in a polymer solution flow, Nature 405, 53–55 (2000); arXiv:nlin/0104052v1

    arXiv version 1, read in full. Fig. 1: swirling flow between a rotating plate of radius 38 mm and a cup of radius 43.6 mm, liquid depth 10 mm, 12 °C. Methods: 65 % saccharose and 1 % NaCl solvent of viscosity 0.324 Pa s with 80 ppm polyacrylamide of molecular weight 1.8e7; solution viscosity 0.424 Pa s at a shear rate of 1 per second; relaxation time 3.4 s. Fig. 2: transition near a shear rate of 1 per second (Weissenberg number 3.5, Reynolds number about 0.3), with hysteresis; resistance up to about 12 times laminar for a 10 mm gap and 19 for 20 mm. Fig. 3: snapshots at Weissenberg number 13. Fig. 4: brightness spectra. Fig. 5: velocity spectra, a power law with exponent −3.5 at 4 per second over about one decade. Text: Reynolds stress below 0.5 % of the resistance.

Keep reading

What this page links to directly

See this series on the content map →

Complex fluids · Reading path

Relaxation, stretching, extension and elastic instability

  1. You are hereStress relaxation and creep in a Maxwell liquid
  2. ArticleFrom a bead-spring dumbbell to the conformation tensor and the Oldroyd-B equation
  3. ArticleWhy extensional flow unravels polymer coils while shear only tumbles them
  4. ArticleHow finite chain length caps stretch and extensional viscosity in the FENE-P model
  5. ArticleReading a relaxation time from the exponential thinning of a polymer filament
  6. ArticleHow normal stress along curved streamlines drives elastic instability
  7. ArticleHow a four-roll flow loses symmetry at its stagnation point, and how much the numerics change it
  8. ArticleReading elastic turbulence: the evidence for chaotic flow without inertia, and what is still open
1 more group

Other articles that use the same experiments

Each experiment from this article that another series also uses, followed by the articles there.

  1. LabStress–Strain Material Tester
  2. ArticleWhy a crack needs energy to grow
  3. ArticleFind the energy release rate from a compliance curve
  4. ArticleStress near a crack tip and the stress intensity factor
  5. LabRotational Rheometer & Couette–Poiseuille Flow
  6. ArticleRotational rheometers need both torque and speed
  7. ArticleStokes flow and the two tests for negligible inertia
Something broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy