Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics
Fracture mechanics · A course with experiments

Find the energy release rate from a compliance curve

Measure the compliance, the displacement per unit load, at several crack lengths. The energy release rate equals half the load squared times the slope of compliance with crack length, divided by the thickness. The same formula holds whether the load or the grip displacement is held fixed while the crack advances.

A longer crack makes a softer spring

Take one advancing crack front. Let aa increase along the crack in metres and let BB be the out-of-plane specimen thickness in metres, so new crack-plane area is B daB\,da. The opening force PP is in newtons and the separation Δ\Delta of the two loading points is in metres; positive PP increases positive Δ\Delta. Compliance C=Δ/PC=\Delta/P has units m N−1\mathrm{m\,N^{-1}}, and the stored elastic energy UU is in joules.

Pull a cracked specimen through its grips and record the load and the grip displacement. In the linear range their ratio is the compliance. A longer crack lets the specimen open more for the same load, so compliance rises with crack length. The stored elastic energy is half the load times the displacement, which is half the load squared times the compliance.

C(a)=ΔP,U=12PΔ=12P2C(a)\begin{aligned}C(a)&=\frac{\Delta}{P},\\U&=\frac12P\Delta=\frac12P^2C(a)\end{aligned}

Two loading routes, one energy release rate

Hold the load fixed and let the crack grow a little. The grips move apart because compliance rose, and the load does work equal to the load times that extra displacement. The stored energy rises by only half of that work. The other half goes to the crack tip.

Now hold the grips fixed instead. No external work is done. The load drops because the specimen became softer, and the stored energy falls. To first order in the small crack advance, the drop equals the amount released under fixed load. Either way, divide by the new crack area to get the energy release rate.

The result needs only the compliance curve. That is why compliance methods are common in fracture tests: they replace the stress field near the tip by a global stiffness measurement.

At fixed force, subtract the external work and obtain ΠP=−P2C/2\Pi_P=-P^2C/2. At fixed separation, there is no incremental external work, and ΠΔ=Δ2/(2C)\Pi_\Delta=\Delta^2/(2C). Differentiate each with respect to crack length while holding its own control fixed. Both yield the displayed GG at a state with the same PP and Δ\Delta. Their later loading paths differ as the crack grows.

GP=P22BdCda,GΔ=Δ22BC2dCda=GP\begin{aligned}G_P&=\frac{P^2}{2B}\frac{dC}{da},\\G_\Delta&=\frac{\Delta^2}{2BC^2}\frac{dC}{da}=G_P\end{aligned}

Worked example

Work out a double cantilever beam

In this double-cantilever example, BB is the width into the page and each arm has height hh, both in metres. The equal and opposite forces on the arms each have magnitude PP; PP is not the sum of their magnitudes. Each arm has second moment Ib=Bh3/12I_b=Bh^3/12 and end deflection Pa3/(3EIb)Pa^3/(3EI_b). Adding the two deflections gives the total opening and its compliance.

Split a beam of thickness B and arm height h along its mid-plane to a depth equal to the crack length. Each arm is a cantilever of that length. Simple beam theory, which neglects shear and the rotation at the arm root, gives the total opening per unit load. The compliance grows as the cube of the crack length.

Differentiate and insert into the compliance formula. At fixed load the energy release rate grows as the square of the crack length. Doubling the arm height at the same load cuts it by a factor of eight. Chapter three uses the fixed-grip form of the same result to show why this specimen tears stably.

C=8a3EBh3,dCda=24a2EBh3,G=12P2a2EB2h3\begin{aligned}C&=\frac{8a^3}{EBh^3},\\\frac{dC}{da}&=\frac{24a^2}{EBh^3},\\G&=\frac{12P^2a^2}{EB^2h^3}\end{aligned}

Worked example

Worked example with two slender arms

Choose an illustrative elastic beam with E=70 GPaE=70\,\mathrm{GPa}, B=20 mmB=20\,\mathrm{mm}, each arm height h=2.00 mmh=2.00\,\mathrm{mm} and crack length a=30.0 mma=30.0\,\mathrm{mm}. Pull each arm with P=10.0 NP=10.0\,\mathrm N. Convert all lengths to metres first. The compliance is 1.93×10−5 m N−11.93\times10^{-5}\,\mathrm{m\,N^{-1}}, giving a total opening of 0.193 mm0.193\,\mathrm{mm} and G=4.82 J m−2G=4.82\,\mathrm{J\,m^{-2}}.

The arm length is fifteen times its height and the opening is small compared with that length. Those checks support this slender-beam, small-deflection estimate. This slender-beam estimate neglects shear deformation and root rotation.

How the Lab takes the slope and checks it

The Griffith crack growth Lab solves each specimen once on a finite-element mesh, with the crack plane as a row of nodes that can open. It computes the compliance for every tip position and takes a central difference in crack length. Plates with a central crack are loaded by a uniform stress on the far edge; strips and edge notches are held by rigid grips.

Two checks bound the error. A local estimate uses only the force needed to hold the tip node shut and the opening one element behind it. It agrees with the compliance slope to within 0.32 percent. For a central crack in a plate of finite width, the slope approaches the secant formula from the stress-analysis handbook as the mesh is refined. When the crack spans half the half-width, the ratio goes from 0.976 to 0.987 to 0.994 with 32, 64 and 128 elements across the half-width. The handbook formula is taken as quoted in a 2022 paper by Sargado, Welch and Lüthje.

The local closure expression uses the solver’s symmetry-reduced, unit-thickness convention: RtipR_{\rm tip} holds the tip node shut and vbehindv_{\rm behind} is the displacement of one face, not the full crack opening. Those factors already account for the reflected part of the specimen. Restoring a full specimen requires restoring the work, both faces and the crack-area increment together.

Glocal≈RtipvbehindΔa,Gref=πσ2aEF2(λ),F(λ)=(1−0.025λ2+0.06λ4)⋅sec⁡(πλ/2),λ=a/W\begin{aligned}G_{\rm local}&\approx\frac{R_{\rm tip}v_{\rm behind}}{\Delta a},\\G_{\rm ref}&=\frac{\pi\sigma^2a}{E}F^2(\lambda),\\F(\lambda)&=(1-0.025\lambda^2+0.06\lambda^4)\\&\quad\cdot\sqrt{\sec(\pi\lambda/2)},\\\lambda&=a/W\end{aligned}

An experiment to think through

Predict, change, explain

  1. Open the gripped-strip preset in the Griffith crack growth Lab. Predict the shape of the energy release rate curve as the crack runs along the strip.
  2. Switch to the plate preset and compare the shape of the same curve.
  3. Explain the flat curve of the strip and the rising curve of the plate with the slope of compliance and the loading route.

The fracture Labs run simplified two-dimensional models in scaled units. Each Lab states its model, units and limits in its notes and can export the record behind its readouts.

Try explaining it yourself

1. Under fixed grips, does the stored elastic energy rise or fall as the crack grows?

Read an explained answer

It falls. The grips do no work, so all of the energy that reaches the tip comes out of the stored elastic energy.

2. In a double cantilever beam at fixed load, the crack length doubles. How does the energy release rate change?

Read an explained answer

It grows as the square of the crack length, so it becomes four times larger.

3. A compliance curve is measured with an error that is the same constant offset at every crack length. Does that offset change the energy release rate?

Read an explained answer

No. A constant offset drops out of the slope. Errors that change with crack length, such as grip slip that grows with load, do enter.

Sources to read alongside

  1. Bouchbinder, Fineberg & Marder, Dynamics of Simple Cracks, arXiv:0911.0173; Annual Review of Condensed Matter Physics 1, 371–395 (2010)

    Section 1, equations (1) to (3), defines the Griffith point of a rigidly gripped strip and the surface energy per unit area. Section 2 states the energy balance, the inverse-square-root stress near the tip, the relation between energy release rate and stress intensity, the principle of local symmetry and the assumptions of linear elastic fracture mechanics. It also reports the micro-branching onset near 0.4 of the Rayleigh speed in PMMA and glass. Section 3 discusses small scales at the tip, including cohesive zones and phase-field models. The course quotes these statements; it does not use the review’s data.

  2. Sargado, Welch & Lüthje, Approximate formulas for the energy release rate of a crack perpendicular to a material interface, arXiv:2210.06315v1 (2022)

    Equations (1) to (3) restate the energy released by a centre crack in a large plate and its energy release rate, with the effective modulus for plane stress and plane strain. Equation (29) quotes the Tada, Paris and Irwin secant correction for a centre-cracked strip. The course uses it as the finite-width reference for the centre-crack benchmark. The 1973 handbook itself was not consulted.

  3. Handbook for Damage Tolerant Design, section 2.2.6.1.2, Compliance and elastic energy

    Equations 2.2.25–2.2.32 and Figure 2.2.12 compare crack extension under fixed load and fixed displacement. Equality concerns the same initial elastic state; subsequent loading paths differ.

Keep reading

What this page links to directly

See this series on the content map →

Fracture mechanics · Reading path

Fracture mechanics from Griffith’s energy balance to branching cracks

  1. ArticleWhy a crack needs energy to grow
  2. You are hereFind the energy release rate from a compliance curve
  3. ArticleWhen a growing crack stays under control
  4. ArticleStress near a crack tip and the stress intensity factor
  5. ArticleModel a crack as a narrow band of damage
  6. ArticlePredict when a notch starts to crack, then test the prediction
  7. ArticleFast cracks and branching in a dynamic phase-field model
  8. ArticleHow frozen disorder roughens a fast crack path
1 more group

Other articles that use the same experiments

Each experiment from this article that another series also uses, followed by the articles there.

  1. LabStress–Strain Material Tester
  2. ArticleStress relaxation and creep in a Maxwell liquid
Something broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy