How finite chain length caps stretch and extensional viscosity in the FENE-P model
Sandbox Physics ·
A linear spring can stretch forever, which is why the Oldroyd-B extensional stress grows without bound above the threshold. A real chain has a contour length, and its spring becomes very stiff close to full extension. The FENE-P model writes this into the conformation equation: the closer the stretch is to the limit, the faster the recovery. The extensional viscosity then stops at a finite plateau, the shear viscosity falls with shear rate, and an exact balance still links elastic energy, work and dissipation.
The end-to-end distance of a real chain cannot exceed its contour length, and the tension of a FENE spring diverges near that length. The Peterlin approximation replaces the length-dependent factor in the tension by its value at the mean conformation, giving a factor f that depends only on trA. L2 is the upper limit of trA, the squared maximum extension.
At equilibrium trA=3 and f=1, so the model coincides with Oldroyd-B. As trA approaches L2, f diverges and the recovery rate f/λ can match any stretch rate. For L2→∞ the model returns to Oldroyd-B.
A∇=−λ1(fA−I),τp=G(fA−I),f=L2−trAL2−3
Eqs. (1.86)–(1.87) of Morozov and Spagnolie write the same model in terms of stress, with the factor 1+λtrτp/(ηpL2); inserting the stress–conformation relation gives this form. Table II of Datta and co-authors uses the form shown here.
In steady planar extension the components separate as in Chapter 3, except that the relaxation rate is multiplied by f. Each diagonal component is written in terms of f, but f depends on their sum, so one self-consistent equation remains; bisection over f>2Wi finds the root.
Under strong stretching Axx is large, so the denominator f−2Wi must be small and f sits just above 2Wi: the spring stiffens until its recovery rate exactly cancels the stretch rate. With the identity f(Axx−Ayy)=2Wi(Axx+Ayy) the extensional viscosity takes the form below. At large Wi, Axx approaches L2 and the extensional viscosity approaches its ceiling.
Eq. (7) of McKinley gives the ceiling on the tensile stress in uniaxial extension, 2ηpε˙L2, and Section 5.4 the matching ceiling on the extensional viscosity, 3ηs+2ηpL2. In planar extension the 3 becomes 4.
In steady shear Ayy=1/f and the polymer shear stress is GWi/f, so the shear viscosity is ηs+ηp/f. Faster shear means longer coils, a larger f and a lower viscosity. The Oldroyd-B shear viscosity is constant; the FENE-P shear viscosity falls with shear rate.
Inserting the steady shear components into the self-consistency condition gives a cubic for f. The larger L2, the closer f stays to one at a given Wi, and the weaker the thinning.
η=ηs+fηp,f2(f−1)=L22Wi2
Obtained by inserting the steady shear values Ayy=1/f, Axy=Wi/f2 and Axx=1/f+2Wi2/f3 into the self-consistency condition.
FENE-P has an elastic free energy ψ that is zero at equilibrium and positive for every other conformation. Following the fluid, its rate of change equals the power the flow delivers to the polymers, τp:L, minus a dissipation D that is a sum of squares over the eigenvalues ai and never negative.
This balance gives an independent check on a numerical solution: accumulate the work, the stored energy and the dissipation over a run, and their mismatch should be close to zero. Eqs. (4)–(5) of Thomases, Shelley and Thiffeault write the same kind of balance for Oldroyd-B, using the integral of 21tr(S−I) as the energy.
The conformation tensor must stay positive definite, and FENE-P also requires trA<L2. Discretization error can push the smallest eigenvalue below zero or the trace past the limit, and from then on the stress has no physical meaning. Section 6 of Morozov and Spagnolie warns that Oldroyd-B simulations often fail at high Weissenberg number, known in the literature as the high-Weissenberg-number problem.
Three remedies are common. Solve for the matrix logarithm of the conformation tensor, the log-conformation scheme, which keeps it positive definite automatically. Add a little diffusion to the stress equation to smooth gradients that are too steep. Or switch to a bounded model such as FENE-P. The review by Datta and co-authors discusses the first and states that Oldroyd-B is almost never quantitative at high Weissenberg number. Chapter 7 shows what the second remedy can cost.
Worked example: two chain lengths in planar extension
Take β=0.5 and Wi=3. Oldroyd-B has no steady state here; the stretch grows exponentially. FENE-P with L2=400 gives, by bisection, f=6.003, only 0.003 above 2Wi=6. Then Axx=333.6, Ayy=0.0833, Azz=0.167, and the trace is 333.9, 83.5% of the limit. The stretch is 333.9/3=10.5, against a largest possible value of 400/3=11.5.
The extensional viscosity is ηP=4×0.5+2×0.5×(333.6+0.083)=335.7η0, with a ceiling of 4×0.5+400=402η0.
With L2=100 instead: f=6.012, Axx=83.6, a trace of 83.9 or 83.9% of the limit, a stretch of 5.29, and an extensional viscosity of 85.7η0 against a ceiling of 102η0. A quarter of the squared length gives roughly a quarter of the extensional viscosity, while the fraction of the limit in use barely changes.
Energy check: with λ=1s and G=0.5Pa, at L2=400 the flow delivers (τxx−τyy)ε˙=3.00×103W/m3 to the polymers, and the dissipation computed from the eigenvalues is the same. In the steady state the elastic energy no longer changes and all of the work is dissipated.
Choose the Chains hit full length preset (FENE-P, Weissenberg number 3, L2=100). At the end of the run the coil stretch in extension should be close to the 5.29 of the worked example, and the largest share of the finite-extension bound used close to 0.84.
Change the maximum extension squared to 400 and predict the new stretch and extensional viscosity before comparing with the worked example. In the detailed readouts, check that the largest mismatch of work minus stored minus dissipated is far smaller than the work itself.
Choose the Stress puts on the brakes preset. Under an imposed stress, once the extensional viscosity grows, the same stress can only sustain a smaller stretch rate. Watch the extension-side Weissenberg number fall with time.
Exercises with explained answers
A FENE-P solution has β=0.1 and L2=1000. What is the ceiling on the planar extensional viscosity in units of the zero-shear viscosity, and how many times the Newtonian value is that?
Show the answer
The ceiling is 4×0.1+2×0.9×1000=1800.4 times the zero-shear viscosity. The Newtonian value is 4η0, so the ceiling is about 450 times larger.
Take the elastic energy in the Oldroyd-B limit and let A=diag(a,1/a,1). Write ψ and show that it is never negative.
Show the answer
trA−3=a+1/a−2 and detA=1, so ψ=2G(a+1/a−2). By the inequality of arithmetic and geometric means, a+1/a≥2, with equality only at a=1.
FENE-P with β=0.5 and L2=100 in steady shear at Wi=3. Estimate the shear viscosity.
Show the answer
Solve f2(f−1)=2×9/100=0.18 to get f≈1.14. The shear viscosity is 0.5+0.5/1.14=0.94η0, only about 6% lower, while at the same Weissenberg number the extensional viscosity is 86 times the zero-shear viscosity.
Why is f always just above 2Wi under strong stretching?
Show the answer
In the steady state Axx=1/(f−2Wi). Under strong stretching Axx is close to L2, a large number, so the denominator must be small. Physically, the spring keeps stiffening until its recovery rate f/λ cancels the amplification 2ε˙ by the flow.
Section 3: the Weissenberg number defined as the relaxation time times the shear rate, and Eq. (1.27), the generalized Newtonian liquid. Section 4.1: Eqs. (1.47)–(1.51), the spring, the dashpot, the Maxwell liquid and its memory integral, with a relaxation time equal to viscosity over modulus. Eq. (1.72): the upper-convected derivative; Eq. (1.80): Oldroyd-B; Eqs. (1.86)–(1.87): FENE-P. Section 4.4: the Hookean dumbbell, Eqs. (1.98)–(1.110). Eq. (1.116): the steady-shear normal stress of Oldroyd-B. Eqs. (1.117)–(1.125): hoop stress and the cone-and-plate normal force. Eqs. (1.128)–(1.131): uniaxial extension and the Oldroyd-B divergence at half the inverse relaxation time. The chapter has no startup solution and no planar extension; the course derives both.
Eqs. (1)–(2): strain rate and Hencky strain of a thinning thread. Eqs. (4)–(7): Oldroyd-B stress growth in uniaxial extension and the finite-extensibility cap. Eq. (8): elasto-capillary thinning, in which the radius falls exponentially with a time constant of three relaxation times, so the thread runs at a Weissenberg number of 2/3. Eq. (11): linear thinning once the extensional viscosity is constant. Eq. (15): the zero-dimensional force balance on the neck. Eq. (16): the Newtonian similarity solution with prefactor 0.0709; the text after it says the simple zero-dimensional estimate is off by more than 100 %. Section 5.4: the terminal extensional viscosity of a finitely extensible dumbbell. The front factor of Eq. (8) and the one listed in Table 2 differ by the cube root of two; Section 5.4 attributes this to the one-dimensional similarity solution. The course uses only the exponent.
arXiv version 1, 22 August 2021; the journal version was not checked. Section II, Eq. (1): the Pakdel–McKinley criterion, which combines streamline curvature with the ratio of normal stress to shear stress. No critical value is given for Taylor–Couette or cone-and-plate flow. Section III: simulations of cross-slot flows lose symmetry or become time dependent when the largest local value of that criterion exceeds about 4 to 5; Eq. (2) and Table II write Oldroyd-B, FENE-P and other models with a conformation tensor, which allows a positive-definiteness check and log-conformation schemes; a two-dimensional Taylor–Couette simulation became chaotic near a Weissenberg number of 10. The workshop summary states that Oldroyd-B is almost never quantitative at high Weissenberg number.
Eqs. (1)–(2) and (6): the same model with stress diffusion 1e-3 for Weissenberg numbers up to 10. Eqs. (4)–(5): the polymer strain energy balance. Section 3.1, Fig. 2: a small perturbation of the symmetric steady state decays at 4.8 and grows at 4.9; 256 by 256 grid, and doubling the resolution does not change the dynamics. Fig. 6(d): at 10 the velocity spectrum has periods of about 330 and 55. Section 5: between about 4.9 and 9 the asymmetric flow settles down again; above about 9 a vortex unpins and persistent oscillations mix the fluid; periodic at 12 and 15, aperiodic above about 20. Appendix B: stress diffusion is calibrated against FENE-P; its effect on the threshold is not reported.
Keep reading
What this page links to directly
You are hereHow finite chain length caps stretch and extensional viscosity in the FENE-P model