Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics
Black hole ringdown and the no-hair test

Damped tones and the Kerr spectrum

Sandbox Physics ·

A ringdown is a sum of damped sinusoids, and for a Kerr black hole every frequency and damping time is a fixed number divided by the hole's mass, with the number set by the spin. This chapter sets up the units, writes the signal down, reads frequencies from a table of Kerr modes, and shows why the first overtone fades about three times faster than the fundamental.

Open the black hole ringdown Lab

Read why a newly merged black hole rings like a bell first if the idea is new. Exponentials, sines and complex numbers in the form a+iba+ib are enough for this chapter.

Measure time in units of the hole's mass

Set Newton's constant and the speed of light to one, G=c=1G=c=1. A black hole of mass MM then sets its own time unit, GM/c3GM/c^3. For one solar mass this is 4.925 μs4.925\,\mu\mathrm s, so for any mass

GMc3=4.925 μs×MM⊙.\frac{GM}{c^3}=4.925\,\mu\mathrm s\times\frac{M}{\mathrm{M}_\odot}.

A time written as "10M10M" means ten of these units. A dimensionless product such as MωM\omega holds for every mass at once; only the conversion to seconds changes.

Table 2.1 Time units of two remnants.
MassGM/c3GM/c^310 GM/c310\,GM/c^3
68.5 M⊙68.5\,\mathrm{M}_\odot0.3374 ms0.3374\,\mathrm{ms}3.374 ms3.374\,\mathrm{ms}
40 M⊙40\,\mathrm{M}_\odot0.1970 ms0.1970\,\mathrm{ms}1.970 ms1.970\,\mathrm{ms}

The masses here are measured at the detector. Light from a distant source is stretched by the expansion of the universe, so a mass inferred from frequencies is the source-frame mass times 1+z1+z. For GW150914 the event catalogue lists a source-frame remnant of 63.1 M⊙63.1\,\mathrm{M}_\odot at redshift 0.090.09, which gives 68.8 M⊙68.8\,\mathrm{M}_\odot at the detector. GWOSC, GW150914 event record, GWTC-1 v3

A ringdown is a sum of damped sinusoids

After the merger, the dominant part of the signal is the l=m=2l=m=2 angular pattern. Each of its modes, labelled by an overtone number nn, oscillates at a frequency fnf_n and decays with a damping time τn\tau_n:

h(t)=∑nAn e−t/τncos⁡ ⁣(2πfnt−ϕn),t≥t0.h(t)=\sum_{n}A_n\,e^{-t/\tau_n}\cos\!\left(2\pi f_n t-\phi_n\right),\qquad t\ge t_0 .

The amplitude AnA_n and phase ϕn\phi_n depend on how the merger happened. The frequency and damping time do not. It is convenient to package them in one complex frequency. With time dependence e−iωte^{-i\omega t}, a decaying mode has a negative imaginary part:

ωn=2πfn−iτn.\omega_n=2\pi f_n-\frac{i}{\tau_n}.

Multiplying by the mass gives a pure number, so

fn=Re(Mωn)2π GM/c3,τn=GM/c3∣Im(Mωn)∣.f_n=\frac{\mathrm{Re}(M\omega_n)}{2\pi\,GM/c^3},\qquad \tau_n=\frac{GM/c^3}{\lvert\mathrm{Im}(M\omega_n)\rvert}.

The quality factor Qn=πfnτn=Re(Mωn)/(2∣Im(Mωn)∣)Q_n=\pi f_n\tau_n=\mathrm{Re}(M\omega_n)/(2\lvert\mathrm{Im}(M\omega_n)\rvert) measures how long a mode rings: in one damping time it completes Qn/πQ_n/\pi cycles. It depends on the spin alone. Berti, Cardoso and Starinets, Quasinormal modes of black holes and black branes, arXiv:0905.2975v2

Reading a table of Kerr modes

General relativity fixes MωnM\omega_n as a function of the spin χ=a/M\chi=a/M alone. The numbers come from solving the Teukolsky wave equation with waves that only fall into the horizon and only leave towards infinity. We solved it with Leaver's continued-fraction method and stored the results on a spin grid of step 0.010.01. Berti, Cardoso and Starinets, §4.6 Our values agree with the published tables from the CENTRA ringdown data page to better than one part in 10910^9; the method tutorial shows how.

Table 2.2 Kerr gravitational modes from our frozen table, Mω=Re+i ImM\omega=\mathrm{Re}+i\,\mathrm{Im}.
Spin χ\chi220220221221330330
000.37367−0.08896i0.37367-0.08896i0.34671−0.27391i0.34671-0.27391i0.59944−0.09270i0.59944-0.09270i
0.50.50.46412−0.08564i0.46412-0.08564i0.44741−0.26022i0.44741-0.26022i0.74092−0.08868i0.74092-0.08868i
0.690.690.52822−0.08116i0.52822-0.08116i0.51648−0.24541i0.51648-0.24541i0.83721−0.08329i0.83721-0.08329i
0.90.90.67161−0.06487i0.67161-0.06487i0.66766−0.19525i0.66766-0.19525i1.04464−0.06546i1.04464-0.06546i

The label lmnlmn names the angular pattern and the overtone: 220220 is the fundamental, 221221 its first overtone, and 330330 the fundamental of the next angular pattern.

Worked example 1. Take M=68.5 M⊙M=68.5\,\mathrm{M}_\odot and χ=0.69\chi=0.69. The time unit is 0.3374 ms0.3374\,\mathrm{ms}. For the fundamental,

f220=0.528222π×0.3374 ms=249 Hz,τ220=0.3374 ms0.08116=4.16 ms.f_{220}=\frac{0.52822}{2\pi\times0.3374\,\mathrm{ms}}=249\,\mathrm{Hz},\qquad \tau_{220}=\frac{0.3374\,\mathrm{ms}}{0.08116}=4.16\,\mathrm{ms}.

LIGO and Virgo predicted f220=251±8 Hzf_{220}=251\pm8\,\mathrm{Hz} and τ220=4.0±0.3 ms\tau_{220}=4.0\pm0.3\,\mathrm{ms} (90 percent) from the full GW150914 signal. Abbott et al., Tests of general relativity with GW150914, arXiv:1602.03841v3 Our numbers use one fixed mass and spin, theirs a whole posterior, and the two agree within the quoted range.

Why the overtone fades first

Look down the 221221 column. Its real part is close to the fundamental's, so its pitch is similar, but its imaginary part is three times larger. In the same worked example f221=244 Hzf_{221}=244\,\mathrm{Hz} and τ221=1.37 ms\tau_{221}=1.37\,\mathrm{ms}.

The ratio of the two amplitudes changes by a constant factor per unit of time:

A1(t)A0(t)=A1A0 exp⁡ ⁣[−(∣Im Mω221∣−∣Im Mω220∣)tM].\frac{A_1(t)}{A_0(t)}=\frac{A_1}{A_0}\,\exp\!\left[-\left(\lvert\mathrm{Im}\,M\omega_{221}\rvert-\lvert\mathrm{Im}\,M\omega_{220}\rvert\right)\frac{t}{M}\right].

Worked example 2. At χ=0.69\chi=0.69 the bracket is 0.24541−0.08116=0.164250.24541-0.08116=0.16425, so the overtone loses e−0.16425=0.849e^{-0.16425}=0.849 of its relative size every 1M1M. Fits to a GW150914-like simulation give A1/A0A_1/A_0 close to 44 at the peak. Giesler, Isi, Scheel and Teukolsky, Black hole ringdown: the importance of overtones, Table I After 10M10M, about 3.4 ms3.4\,\mathrm{ms} here, the ratio has dropped to 4×e−1.6425=0.774\times e^{-1.6425}=0.77: the overtone is now weaker than the fundamental but still far from negligible.

Turning one tone back into mass and spin

Because QQ depends only on the spin, one measured tone can be inverted in two steps: its QQ gives χ\chi, then its frequency gives MM. Berti, Cardoso and Will fitted simple formulas for this, valid for 0≤χ≤0.990\le\chi\le0.99:

Mωlmn=f1+f2(1−χ)f3,Qlmn=q1+q2(1−χ)q3.M\omega_{lmn}=f_1+f_2(1-\chi)^{f_3},\qquad Q_{lmn}=q_1+q_2(1-\chi)^{q_3}.

For 220220 their coefficients are f1=1.5251f_1=1.5251, f2=−1.1568f_2=-1.1568, f3=0.1292f_3=0.1292, q1=0.7q_1=0.7, q2=1.4187q_2=1.4187, q3=−0.499q_3=-0.499, with a stated largest error of 1.851.85 percent in frequency and 0.880.88 percent in QQ. Berti, Cardoso and Will, On gravitational-wave spectroscopy of massive black holes with the space interferometer LISA, Table VIII

Worked example 3. Our table gives Q220=0.52822/(2×0.08116)=3.254Q_{220}=0.52822/(2\times0.08116)=3.254 at χ=0.69\chi=0.69. Inverting the fit, (1−χ)−0.499=(3.254−0.7)/1.4187=1.800(1-\chi)^{-0.499}=(3.254-0.7)/1.4187=1.800, so 1−χ=0.3081-\chi=0.308 and χ=0.692\chi=0.692. Putting that spin back into the frequency fit and using f220=249 Hzf_{220}=249\,\mathrm{Hz} gives M=68.9 M⊙M=68.9\,\mathrm{M}_\odot. The fit returns the input spin to within 0.30.3 percent and the mass to within 0.70.7 percent.

Lab tasks

  1. Predict f220f_{220} and τ220\tau_{220} for the default remnant from Table 2.2. Open the extra readouts in the Lab and compare.
  2. Drag the mass grip from 68.5 to about 40 solar masses. Check that the rings on the canvas get closer together and the horizon shrinks, both by the ratio of the masses.
  3. Raise the spin to 0.9 at fixed mass. Predict from Table 2.2 how much longer the fundamental rings, then watch the wave pattern reach farther out before it fades.

Exercises with explained answers

  1. Find f220f_{220} and τ220\tau_{220} for M=40 M⊙M=40\,\mathrm{M}_\odot and χ=0.9\chi=0.9.
  2. A Schwarzschild hole has χ=0\chi=0. How many full cycles does its fundamental complete in one damping time?
  3. By what factor does the overtone-to-fundamental ratio shrink over 5M5M at χ=0.69\chi=0.69?
  4. Why can a single measured frequency, without its damping time, not fix both mass and spin?
Answers
  1. The time unit is 0.1970 ms0.1970\,\mathrm{ms}. Then f220=0.67161/(2π×0.1970 ms)=543 Hzf_{220}=0.67161/(2\pi\times0.1970\,\mathrm{ms})=543\,\mathrm{Hz} and τ220=0.1970/0.06487 ms=3.04 ms\tau_{220}=0.1970/0.06487\,\mathrm{ms}=3.04\,\mathrm{ms}.
  2. The number of cycles is fτ=Q/πf\tau=Q/\pi. With Q220=0.37367/(2×0.08896)=2.10Q_{220}=0.37367/(2\times0.08896)=2.10, that is 0.670.67 of a cycle. A Schwarzschild ringdown is barely more than a single swing.
  3. The factor is e−5×0.16425=e−0.821=0.44e^{-5\times0.16425}=e^{-0.821}=0.44. Starting from 44, the ratio falls to about 1.81.8 at 5M5M.
  4. The frequency is Re(Mω)(χ)/M\mathrm{Re}(M\omega)(\chi)/M. A heavier hole with a higher spin can give the same frequency as a lighter, slower one, so one number leaves a whole curve of (M,χ)(M,\chi) pairs. The damping time, through QQ, picks the point on that curve.

Next, fit these damped sinusoids to a noisy record and see what goes wrong without the overtone in why a ringdown fit needs the overtone near the peak.

Try it in the Lab

Predict the fundamental frequency for 68.5 solar masses and spin 0.69, then open the extra readouts and compare. Open the black hole ringdown Lab

Sources

  1. GWOSC, GW150914 event record, GWTC-1 v3
  2. Berti, Cardoso and Starinets, Quasinormal modes of black holes and black branes, arXiv:0905.2975v2
  3. Abbott et al., Tests of general relativity with GW150914, arXiv:1602.03841v3
  4. Giesler, Isi, Scheel and Teukolsky, Black hole ringdown: the importance of overtones, Table I
  5. Berti, Cardoso and Will, On gravitational-wave spectroscopy of massive black holes with the space interferometer LISA, Table VIII

Keep reading

What this page links to directly

See this series on the content map →

Black hole ringdown and the no-hair test · Reading path

From a ringing black hole to a no-hair test

  1. ArticleWhy does a newly merged black hole ring like a bell?
  2. You are hereDamped tones and the Kerr spectrum
  3. ArticleWhy a ringdown fit needs the overtone near the peak
  4. ArticleFrom two tones to a no-hair test
  5. ArticleRecomputing ringdown tones, a synthetic signal and a slice of GW150914
  6. ArticleHow to read the 2019 GW150914 overtone paper and the debate that followed
Something broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy