Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics

Black Hole Ringdown and the No-Hair Test

Why does a ringdown fit near the peak need the overtone? A black hole left by a merger rings at a few set tones, and in general relativity their pitch and fade time depend only on its mass and spin. Two measured tones therefore test that rule, but close to the loudest moment a fast-fading overtone must be included, or the inferred mass and spin come out wrong. A single fit that drifts away from the prediction is not, by itself, new physics.

Drag the remnant mass, spin and fit start. Two damped tones with f(M,χ)f(M,\chi) and τ(M,χ)\tau(M,\chi) pin down the black hole; dropping the overtone biases the result.

Interactive modelBlack Hole Ringdown and the No-Hair Test
Mass, fundamental + overtone MM68.9−19.4+20.2 M⊙68.9^{+20.2}_{-19.4}\,\mathrm{M}_\odot
Spin, fundamental + overtone χ\chi0.34−0.31+0.460.34^{+0.46}_{-0.31}
Mass, fundamental only MM48.1−5.9+6.8 M⊙48.1^{+6.8}_{-5.9}\,\mathrm{M}_\odot
Overtone frequency shift δf221\delta f_{221}0.06−0.50+0.400.06^{+0.40}_{-0.50}

Record, fits and what they infer

Synthetic record computed in this browser; no detector data.

From this start time the fundamental-only fit misses the injected remnant; adding the overtone recovers it.

Synthetic strain and the two fits
  • Noisy samples
  • Injected fundamental
  • Injected overtone
  • Fit, fundamental + overtone
  • Fit, fundamental only
Axes and priors

Horizontal: time after the peak in ms. Vertical: whitened strain in units of the injected fundamental amplitude A0A_0. Grey samples before t0t_0 are left out of both fits.

Remnant mass and spin, 90 % regions (M,χ)(M,\chi)
  • Fundamental + overtone
  • Fundamental only
  • Injected remnant
Axes and priors

Horizontal: M/M⊙M/\mathrm{M}_\odot over the whole prior. Vertical: χ\chi. Flat priors; amplitudes and phases fitted.

Overtone frequency test δf221\delta f_{221}
  • Posterior, shaded 90 %
  • General relativity
Axes and priors

Horizontal: δf221\delta f_{221} with f221=f221Kerr(M,χ) (1+δf221)f_{221}=f_{221}^{\mathrm{Kerr}}(M,\chi)\,(1+\delta f_{221}), flat prior on [−0.5, 0.5][-0.5,\,0.5]. Mass and spin are marginalised.

More readouts
Credible level of the injected point, fundamental + overtone
49.7 %49.7\,\%
Credible level of the injected point, fundamental only
100 %100\,\%
Injected fundamental frequency
f220=249 Hzf_{220}=249\,\mathrm{Hz}
Injected fundamental damping time
τ220=4.16 ms\tau_{220}=4.16\,\mathrm{ms}
Injected overtone frequency
f221=244 Hzf_{221}=244\,\mathrm{Hz}
Injected overtone damping time
τ221=1.37 ms\tau_{221}=1.37\,\mathrm{ms}
Overtone share of the amplitude at the fit start
80 %80\,\%
Samples in the fit window
8383

A credible level near 100 % means the injected values sit outside the inferred region. Over many noise draws the 90 % region should miss about one time in ten.

Hearing a black hole’s mass and spin

BackgroundAfter two black holes merge, the remnant settles down by radiating damped gravitational waves. In general relativity each tone, labelled by (ℓ,m,n)(\ell,m,n), has a frequency and a damping time fixed by the remnant mass MM and spin χ\chi alone. The overtone n=1n=1 has almost the same pitch as the fundamental n=0n=0 but dies about three times faster.

Why it mattersMove the fit start and watch whether a model with one tone, or with two, can find the remnant that was put into the record.

One-sentence intuition
Near the peak the overtone is louder than the fundamental. A one-tone model then has to bend MM and χ\chi to imitate it; with both tones tied to the same (M,χ)(M,\chi) the fit lands on the injected remnant.

Core mathematical model

A sum of damped tones

h(t)=∑nAn e−(t−t0)/τncos⁡ ⁣[2πfn (t−t0)−ϕn],t≥t0h(t)=\sum_{n}A_n\,e^{-(t-t_0)/\tau_n}\cos\!\left[2\pi f_n\,(t-t_0)-\phi_n\right],\qquad t\ge t_0

The Lab fits this model from the start time t0t_0 with one tone (n=0n=0) or two (n=0,1n=0,1). Amplitudes and phases are free; frequencies and damping times are not.

Mass and spin set every tone

2πfℓmn−iτℓmn=c3GM ω^ℓmn(χ)2\pi f_{\ell mn}-\frac{\mathrm{i}}{\tau_{\ell mn}}=\frac{c^3}{GM}\,\hat\omega_{\ell mn}(\chi)

The dimensionless number ω^ℓmn(χ)\hat\omega_{\ell mn}(\chi) comes from black-hole perturbation theory. The Lab reads it from a table computed with Leaver’s continued-fraction method and checked against the published Berti tables. Doubling MM halves every frequency.

Fitting with the amplitudes solved for

ln⁡L(M,χ)=12σ2 dTX(XTX)−1XTd\ln\mathcal{L}(M,\chi)=\frac{1}{2\sigma^2}\,\mathbf{d}^{\mathsf T}X\left(X^{\mathsf T}X\right)^{-1}X^{\mathsf T}\mathbf{d}

For each trial (M,χ)(M,\chi) the columns of XX are the damped cosines and sines of the tones. Least squares fixes the amplitudes; σ\sigma is the white-noise level. The outlines enclose 90 % of the resulting weight on a flat grid.

Letting the overtone drift

f221=f221Kerr(M,χ) (1+δf221)f_{221}=f_{221}^{\mathrm{Kerr}}(M,\chi)\,\left(1+\delta f_{221}\right)

Isi et al. (2019) used this form on GW150914. A value of δf221\delta f_{221} far from zero, repeated across events and robust to the start time and noise model, would be a problem for general relativity; one wide or offset curve is not.

Common difficulties

Waiting longer is not free

Typical misconceptionStarting the fit later always gives a cleaner answer, because the overtone has gone.

Better mental modelLater start times avoid the overtone but throw away the loudest part of the signal, so the regions grow. With the default record the fundamental-only region already contains the injected values a couple of M after the peak, mostly because it has grown, not because the bias has gone. By 10 M it is wider than the two-tone region from the peak.

An offset is not a discovery

Typical misconceptionIf the fitted overtone frequency is not exactly the Kerr value, general relativity has failed.

Better mental modelNoise alone moves the curve: try other noise draws. A real test also has to rule out a wrong start time, missing modes, nonlinear effects and detector noise that is not white. Published GW150914 analyses disagree on how strongly the overtone is detected at all.

Run the experiment

  1. 01

    See the bias

    Start from the default and compare the amber dashed outline with the white cross in the mass-spin chart.

    What to observe: The fundamental-only fit from the peak points to a lighter, slower-spinning remnant; the two-tone fit around it contains the injected (M,χ)(M,\chi).
  2. 02

    Move the fit start

    Drag along the strain chart, or choose “Wait for the fundamental”.

    What to observe: By t0≈10 Mt_0\approx 10\,M the overtone is already weaker than the fundamental and the amber outline contains the cross, but both regions are much larger than the two-tone region from the peak.
  3. 03

    Turn up the signal

    Choose “A loud event” and look at the overtone frequency test.

    What to observe: At ρ=80\rho=80 the curve for δf221\delta f_{221} narrows and still contains zero, while the fundamental-only outline shrinks to a small region well away from the cross.
  4. 04

    Change the remnant

    Drag the ergoregion edge and the spin dial in the scene.

    What to observe: A heavier remnant rings at a lower pitch with longer waves; a faster spin raises the pitch and makes the fundamental ring longer.

Related experiments and articles

What this page links to directly

See every article series on the content map →

Black hole ringdown and the no-hair test · Reading path

From a ringing black hole to a no-hair test

Articles on this path that use this experiment, followed by the other experiments they suggest.

  1. ArticleWhy does a newly merged black hole ring like a bell?
  2. ArticleDamped tones and the Kerr spectrum
  3. ArticleWhy a ringdown fit needs the overtone near the peak
  4. ArticleFrom two tones to a no-hair test
  5. ArticleRecomputing ringdown tones, a synthetic signal and a slice of GW150914
  6. ArticleHow to read the 2019 GW150914 overtone paper and the debate that followed
Something broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy