Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics
Active matter · A course with experiments

L2 · Chapter 5

Why a liquid-crystal defect can turn only halfway

A liquid-crystal orientation is an axis, so reversing it gives the same local arrangement. After a walk around a defect, the axis can return to itself even though its angle has turned only halfway. That is the origin of a half-integer topological charge.

Matchsticks have an axis before they have an arrow

Scatter short matchsticks on a table and comb them into parallel rows. Ignore which end has the match head. A stick facing left now has the same orientation as one facing right. This is nematic order: nearby long objects share an axis without agreeing on a head-to-tail direction.

An ordinary average of arrows would fail here. Half the arrows could point left and half right, giving zero even in a perfectly aligned patch. A nematic order tensor solves this problem by recording the axis and how strongly the rods share it. In two dimensions, it can be stored as two numbers at every point.

The local preferred axis is called the director. In a real image, estimate it over a small patch containing several rods. Tiny patches are noisy; very large patches smear out sharp turns. Choosing a measurement scale is part of defining the field.

Carry a pencil around the centre

Look at the comet-shaped texture of a positive half defect. Place a pencil along the local axis, then carry it slowly around the centre, keeping it aligned with the rods. Keep track of the rotation continuously; never reset the pencil merely because an angle crosses the edge of a plotting scale.

After one circuit, the pencil has turned half a revolution. It points the other way, but it lies along the same axis. Around a negative half defect, the continuous rotation is a half revolution in the opposite sense. The surrounding pattern has three arms instead of a comet’s head and tail.

Charge counts this net rotation in units of a full revolution. The sign depends on traversing the loop counterclockwise in a fixed right-handed plane. A screen often measures height downward, while a physical angle is measured upward. Mixing those two coordinate conventions reverses a computed sign; reflecting both coordinates and rods consistently preserves the charge.

s=Δθcontinuous2π=+12 or −12s=\frac{\Delta\theta_{\rm continuous}}{2\pi}=+\frac12\ \text{or}\ -\frac12

Worked example

Count an example without trusting the picture

Walk counterclockwise around four corners of a small square. Suppose the director rotates smoothly by 45 degrees along each edge. Four changes add to 180 degrees: the enclosed charge is positive one half. The final axis matches the initial one.

At each edge, choose the equivalent director rotation whose magnitude is less than 90 degrees. If the field turns farther between samples, the sign becomes ambiguous. Add more samples or use a larger, well-resolved loop around the core. Inside the core, local alignment weakens and a director may be poorly defined.

A detector finds winding, then a tracker connects it

A sampled-field detector adds these small angle changes around every grid cell. Cells with half-turn winding mark candidate defects. Its input is the recorded orientation field, not the locations used to prepare a synthetic texture. An analytic test texture is useful precisely because its known charge lets us check the detector.

Tracking is another operation. A positive defect in one frame is connected to a nearby positive defect in the next, within a stated maximum displacement. If two defects pass too closely, merge or disappear, a trajectory can become ambiguous. Mark a track as uncertain whenever the association is ambiguous.

On a flat periodic plane with no holes, all charges sum to zero. Defects can appear or disappear in opposite-charge pairs. A nonzero measured total is a warning to inspect the resolution, seam treatment and order threshold. A bounded region has a different relation: the orientation around its boundary supplies the total winding.

An experiment to think through

Predict, change, explain

  1. Before revealing detections, identify which texture has a comet shape and which has three arms.
  2. Move a defect and vary the sampling grid or noise. Compare detections with the saved director field.
  3. Explain why the detector can miss a close pair and why the periodic total charge should remain zero.

The LCD link shows passive orientation through optics. The defect microscope samples a synthetic director field.

Try explaining it yourself

1. Does reversing every rod change the nematic texture?

Read an explained answer

No. Reversal preserves each local axis. A polar flock would change because its direction distinguishes head from tail.

2. Can a positive half defect appear alone inside a periodic, initially uniform field?

Read an explained answer

An isolated uncompensated charge is inconsistent with that flat periodic geometry. Creation must preserve total charge, usually by producing an opposite-charge partner.

Sources to read alongside

  1. Giomi, Geometry and topology of turbulence in active nematics, arXiv:1409.1555v2 (2015), Physical Review X 5, 031003

    Equation (1), Section I.2 and Figure 2 provide the continuum context and active-length scaling. Our screened-flow benchmark is a manufactured solution, separate from the paper’s turbulent simulations.

  2. Serra, Lemma, Giomi, Dogic & Mahadevan, Defect-mediated dynamics of coherent structures in active nematics, Nature Physics 19, 1355–1361 (2023)

    Figure 1 and equations (1)–(3) introduce the flow map and finite-time stretching; Figure 2 uses experimental microtubule–kinesin velocities. This is a guided reading, with no copied images or imported experimental dataset.

FeedbackSomething broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy