Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics

Travel-Time Tomography: Ray Coverage, Resolution and Damping

How do many travel times become a map of fast and slow rock, and how far can you trust that map? Each travel time is a sum of slowness along its ray, so many crossing rays give a linear system for the slowness of every block. Rock that many rays cross from many directions is resolved; elsewhere the image is smeared along the rays. Damping keeps noise from turning into false structure, at the cost of weaker anomalies.

Rays cross a 40 km block that hides a slow and a fast anomaly. The delays are inverted on a 16 by 16 grid. Change the station layout and the damping and see what the image can and cannot resolve.

Interactive modelTravel-Time Tomography: Ray Coverage, Resolution and Damping
Pattern match with the truth0.7240.724
Anomaly amplitude recovered96.5 %96.5\,\%
Misfit per ray (chi-square)0.1710.171
Mean resolution-matrix diagonal0.4220.422
Data: measured delays and the reconstruction’s prediction
  • measured, slower ray
  • measured, faster ray
  • predicted
Where the rays can resolve: resolution-matrix diagonal
  • near 1: resolved
  • near 0: not resolved
Point-spread function of the probe cell
  • probe cell
More readouts and the model record
Rays
Cells
Cells no ray crosses
Pick noise
Conjugate-gradient iterations shown
Resolution-matrix diagonal at the probe cell

The record saves the rays, the measured and noise-free delays, the true model, the reconstruction and the diagonal of the resolution matrix.

Continue the course: seismic imaging from waves to inversion

Travel-Time Tomography: Ray Coverage, Resolution and Damping

BackgroundSlowness is the inverse of wave speed. A wave that crosses slow rock arrives late; one that crosses fast rock arrives early. The delay of each ray is the sum of the extra slowness along its path.

Why it mattersDivide the region into cells. Then each delay is a weighted sum di=∑jGijmjd_i=\sum_j G_{ij}m_j, with the weights equal to the ray length in each cell. Inverting many such sums is travel-time tomography.

One-sentence intuition
The data fix only combinations of cells that rays sample differently. Regularization picks one model among many that fit, and the resolution matrix shows exactly how each true cell is blurred into the image.

Core mathematical model

Regularized least squares

Φ(m)=(Gm−d)TCd−1(Gm−d)+ε2τ mTm+η2τ mTDTDm\Phi(\mathbf m)=(\mathbf G\mathbf m-\mathbf d)^{\mathsf T}\mathbf C_d^{-1}(\mathbf G\mathbf m-\mathbf d)+\varepsilon^2\tau\,\mathbf m^{\mathsf T}\mathbf m+\eta^2\tau\,\mathbf m^{\mathsf T}\mathbf D^{\mathsf T}\mathbf D\mathbf m

Damping ε\varepsilon pulls the model towards the background; smoothing η\eta penalizes differences between neighbouring cells. The mean diagonal of the data term, τ\tau, makes both weights dimensionless.

Resolution matrix

m^=R mtrue+G−gϵ,R=G−gG\hat{\mathbf m}=\mathbf R\,\mathbf m_{\rm true}+\mathbf G^{-g}\boldsymbol\epsilon,\qquad \mathbf R=\mathbf G^{-g}\mathbf G

With the generalized inverse G−g\mathbf G^{-g}, the estimate is the truth filtered by R\mathbf R plus mapped noise. A column of R\mathbf R is the image of a single spike.

Common difficulties

A good checkerboard is not a guarantee

Typical misconceptionIf the checkerboard is recovered, every feature of the real image is reliable.

Better mental modelA checkerboard tests one pattern at one amplitude. Rawlinson and Spakman (2016) show that it can look good while other structures are smeared; look at point-spread functions as well.

Run the experiment

  1. 01

    Compare station layouts

    Start from Stations all around, then choose Two wells: sideways smear.

    What to observe: With only near-horizontal rays, both anomalies are smeared sideways and the probe cell’s point-spread function stretches into a horizontal streak.
  2. 02

    Run the checkerboard test

    Choose Checkerboard test, then switch the stations to Quakes below.

    What to observe: The checkerboard comes back well inside the ring and loses its pattern in the corners that rays do not cross.
  3. 03

    Take away the damping

    Choose No damping: noise takes over and watch the misfit per ray.

    What to observe: The misfit falls far below one while the image fills with stripes: the inversion is fitting the noise.

Related experiments and articles

What this page links to directly

See every article series on the content map →

Continue exploring

Sound and elastic waves in matter

How do sound and elastic waves push particles, form images, locate earthquakes and carry heat?

  1. LabResonance Tube & Sound SpeedDrag the silver end plate and find resonant lengths half a wavelength apart.
  2. LabAcoustic Radiation Force: Trapping Particles in a Standing WaveDrag the orange probe toward a side wall, let go and watch it return to the node.
  3. LabUltrasound Pulse-Echo Imaging: Building a Picture from Echo TimesChoose A long pulse smears depth, then slide the bandwidth up and watch the wires sharpen.
  4. LabSeismic Wave Reflection and P-to-S Conversion at an InterfaceChoose P turns into S and switch the wavefield to S only to see the converted wave.
  5. LabInertial SeismometerCompare Mass follows the case with Mass stays behind and watch the gap between them.
  6. LabEarthquake Location from Arrival Times and Its Error EllipseChoose Stations on one side, or drag stations to one edge, and watch the error ellipse stretch.
  7. You are hereTravel-Time Tomography: Ray Coverage, Resolution and DampingStart from Stations all around, then choose Two wells: sideways smear and compare the images.
  8. LabBallistic and Diffusive Heat in a Thin FilmCompare Very thin: phonons fly across with Thick film: Fourier returns in the heat-flux chart.
  9. LabTransient Thermal Grating: When Heat Rings Like SoundChoose Second sound: stripes swap and watch hot and cold stripes trade places like a wave.

Seismic imaging · Reading path

Seismic waves and imaging, from rock boundaries to tomography

Articles on this path that use this experiment, followed by the other experiments they suggest.

  1. ArticleTravel-time tomography and what the resolution matrix shows
  2. ArticleReading Rawlinson and Spakman (2016) on resolution tests in seismic tomography
Something broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy