Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics

Neural Avalanches and Criticality: When a Power Law Misleads

Does a power-law distribution of avalanche sizes show that a network is critical? No. A near-critical network does give avalanche sizes close to a power law with exponent three halves, but uncoupled units that share a slow input also pass a power-law test and give a branching estimate near one. Only a causal test, such as kicking one unit and counting what follows, separates real cascades from the mimic.

Record cascades in a simulated network. Uncoupled units that only share a slow input also give a plausible power law and a branching estimate near one.

Interactive modelNeural Avalanches and Criticality: When a Power Law Misleads
Power-law fit to recorded avalanche sizesα^=1.462±0.010, p=0.21\hat\alpha=1.462\pm0.010,\ p=0.21
Branching estimate from the recordingm^MR=0.98479±0.00074\hat m_{\mathrm{MR}}=0.98479\pm0.00074
Recorded spikes after kicking one unitnˉkick=97.4\bar n_{\mathrm{kick}}=97.4
Model truth: coupling and kick cascade ratioσ=1.05, mkick=0.994\sigma=1.05,\ m_{\mathrm{kick}}=0.994
Recorded avalanche sizes and the power-law fit
Regression slopes across lags and the multistep fit
Causal test: recorded spikes after kicking one unit of a silent network
More numbers and how they are computed
Lower cutoff and range of the fit
00
Naive test: plausible power law near three halves
00
Conventional one-step slope
00
Multistep estimate on every unit (model truth)
00
Network spikes per kick (model truth)
00
Units under the array
00
Analysed record
00
Time bin
00

The size chart, the fit and the slopes use only the recorded, binned spikes. The kick test and the whole-network estimate need the model itself and are marked as model truth. The exported file holds the binned recording, the avalanche sizes, the fit and the kick response.

A power law is not proof of criticality

BackgroundRecordings of brain tissue show bursts of activity, called avalanches, whose sizes spread over orders of magnitude. A branching process poised at its critical point predicts a power law with exponent three halves, so a fitted power law is often read as a sign of criticality.

Why it mattersThe inference runs backwards: from statistics of a partial recording to the dynamics that made them. A simulation where the truth is known is the cleanest place to test which analyses can be fooled, and by what.

One-sentence intuition
A coupled network near its critical point gives sizes close to s−3/2s^{-3/2}. Units with no coupling at all, sharing only a slow input, also give a plausible power law and a branching estimate near one. Kicking a single unit separates them: the coupled network answers with about a hundred recorded spikes, the mimic with just the kicked one.

Core mathematical model

Critical branching process

P(s)≃2π  s−3/2(m=1, binary branching, odd s)P(s)\simeq\sqrt{\tfrac{2}{\pi}}\;s^{-3/2}\quad(m=1,\ \text{binary branching, odd }s)

For binary branching at the critical point, Zapperi, Lauritsen and Stanley (1995) derive this large-size tail. Below the critical point an exponential cutoff appears.

Discrete maximum-likelihood exponent

α^≃1+n[∑i=1nln⁡sismin⁡−12]−1\hat\alpha\simeq1+n\Big[\sum_{i=1}^{n}\ln\frac{s_i}{s_{\min}-\tfrac12}\Big]^{-1}

Only avalanches with si≥smin⁡s_i\ge s_{\min} enter. A goodness-of-fit pp above 0.1 means the power law is not rejected; it does not mean it is proved.

Multistep regression

rk=Cov⁡(at+k,at)Var⁡at=b mkr_k=\frac{\operatorname{Cov}(a_{t+k},a_t)}{\operatorname{Var}a_t}=b\,m^k

Subsampling scales every slope by the same factor bb, so fitting the decay with kk recovers mm. Any slow input that correlates activity across time also gives m≈1m\approx1.

Common difficulties

A good fit is not a mechanism

Typical misconceptionIf the power-law test passes, the network must be critical.

Better mental modelThe shared slow input preset has no coupling, yet its fit gives p≈0.9p\approx0.9 over more than two decades.

The exponent depends on how you look

Typical misconceptionThe avalanche exponent is a property of the network alone.

Better mental modelRecording 20 of 1000 units from the same near-critical network moves the fitted exponent from about 1.46 to about 3.1, and the one-step slope falls to about 0.49.

Run the experiment

  1. 01

    Record near-critical cascades

    Leave the first preset running and watch the size chart fill.

    What to observe: The fitted exponent is about 1.46 and the multistep estimate about 0.985. One kicked unit leads to about 97 recorded spikes, itself included.
  2. 02

    Switch the coupling off

    Choose Shared slow input, no coupling.

    What to observe: The fit is still plausible, now with α^≈2.1\hat\alpha\approx2.1, and the multistep estimate rises to about 0.997. The kick now produces one spike: the kicked unit itself.
  3. 03

    Record from a corner

    Choose A few electrodes see little, then drag the array or its corner.

    What to observe: The network is the same near-critical one, yet the exponent moves to about 3.1. Enlarging the array brings it back toward 1.5.

Related experiments and articles

What this page links to directly

See every article series on the content map →

Continue exploring

Chance and thresholds in living systems

How do random events, thresholds and neighbour coupling shape populations, neurons and tissue patterns?

  1. LabGenetic Drift and Fixation: Who Takes Over a Small Population?Leave Half and half: a coin flip running and watch chance alone let one type take over.
  2. LabRange Expansion Sectors: Why a Mixed Colony Grows in StripesChoose A straight front loses colours and watch the number of sectors fall as it grows.
  3. LabPulled and Pushed Waves: Where an Invading Population Comes FromCompare the Pulled and Fully pushed presets and see where the ancestors of the front sit.
  4. LabHodgkin–Huxley Model: How a Squid Axon Fires an Action PotentialCompare One all-or-none spike with Just below threshold and watch the membrane voltage.
  5. LabStochastic Ion Channels: Why Small Neurons Fire UnreliablyLeave Threshold becomes a coin flip running and count how often the same shock fires.
  6. LabExcitable waves and spiralsChoose A half-recovered sheet and drag a short stroke on each side to see where a wave starts.
  7. You are hereNeural Avalanches and Criticality: When a Power Law MisleadsCompare Cascades near the critical point with Shared slow input, no coupling on the size chart.
  8. LabIsing Critical FluctuationsCompare Order survives with Heat breaks the patches and watch how far aligned patches reach.
  9. LabHopfield Associative MemoryChoose Recall lightning, drag over part of the picture and watch the network restore it.
  10. LabTuring patternsChoose Spots emerge, then Diffusion smooths, and compare whether a pattern grows.
  11. LabActive Nematic FlowCompare Defects drive the flow with Reverse the stress and watch the flow turn around.

Statistical physics of neurons · Reading path

From a charged membrane to avalanches in a network of neurons

Articles on this path that use this experiment, followed by the other experiments they suggest.

  1. ArticleNeural avalanches from branching spikes, seen through a partial recording
  2. ArticleWhy a power law cannot prove the brain is critical
Something broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy