Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics
Ram pressure and returning gas

Ram pressure and returning gas · L2

From a wind pulse to a restoring force

Sandbox Physics ·

A wind must act long enough to move gas. A slowly varying pressure can be compared with the strongest restoring force above a disk; a brief gust is better described by the momentum it transfers. Their time scales decide which comparison helps.

Choose a gas sheet and its coordinates

Take one small patch of a gas disk. Its area is AA and its mass is mm. Define its gas column as mass divided by area, so column has units of kilograms per square metre. A large column gives the wind more mass to accelerate behind the same exposed area.

Use the galaxy rest frame. The zz axis points along the disk normal and the incoming wind; RR is cylindrical distance from the centre in the disk plane. The incoming speed VV is positive, while the patch has its own normal velocity. With a fixed area, the force from relative normal motion follows the signed momentum flux.

Writing the relative-speed factor with an absolute value matters. When a patch moves faster than the incident flow, the direction of the drag reverses. Replacing it everywhere with the incident pressure is a useful scale estimate only when the patch speed is small compared with the wind.

The path offset is q=b/rcq=b/r_c: closest-approach distance bb divided by the atmosphere core scale rcr_c. The five computed values are 0, 0.37, 1.5, 2.72 and 4. The galaxy speed stays fixed; changing the offset selects a different complete pressure history.

Σg=mA,aram=ρ∣V−vz∣(V−vz)Σg\Sigma_g=\frac mA,\qquad a_{\rm ram}=\frac{\rho\lvert V-v_z\rvert(V-v_z)}{\Sigma_g}
Here ρ\rho is the prescribed incident density, vzv_z is the gas normal velocity, and acceleration has units of length divided by time squared. The full calculation keeps the gas mass changing through star formation. This teaching sheet law sets the normal momentum-coupling coefficient to one.

Reading: Original fixed-slice and static-restoring-force materials

Why vertical gravity has a maximum

The force toward a smooth midplane is zero exactly at the plane, rises above it and eventually weakens far from the galaxy. A gentle steady push can shift a gas sheet to a new height where upward pressure balances downward gravity. A stronger push can exceed the largest available restoring acceleration at that fixed radius.

The local static reference multiplies that maximum acceleration by the gas column. It is closely related to the Gunn–Gott pressure comparison. Its meaning is a force balance for a slowly changing configuration. It does not by itself describe how far a patch moves during a short pulse.

Our independent reference uses the declared three-component potential and searches positive heights at each initial radius. It shows one curve with the initial column and another after the specified consumption up to nominal closest approach. Those columns differ because gas mass is gradually converted into stars while the sheet area stays fixed.

Prestore(R)=Σg(R)max⁡z>0∣∂Φ(R,z)∂z∣P_{\rm restore}(R)=\Sigma_g(R)\max_{z>0}\left|\frac{\partial\Phi(R,z)}{\partial z}\right|
Φ\Phi is potential energy per unit mass, chosen to approach zero at infinity. The radius is held fixed in this reference; actual moving sheets can change radius.
Static fixed-radius restoring pressure for initial and nominal closest-approach gas columns
Independent numerical maxima of the original declared potential at 6464 initial radii. Blue uses initial columns; gold multiplies them by exp⁡(−500/2000)\exp(-500/2000). The horizontal line is the central incident peak. These are local quasi-static references, not a finite-pulse escape prediction. Open the full figure

Reading: Köppen, Jáchym, Taylor & Palouš, Ram Pressure Stripping Made Easy, arXiv:1806.05887v1 (2018) · Original fixed-slice and static-restoring-force materials

A short gust delivers an impulse

If the pulse is much shorter than the time the gas needs to move up and down in the potential, the gas barely changes position while the strongest push occurs. Add up pressure multiplied by each tiny time interval. The result is impulse per unit area: pressure integrated over time.

Divide that impulse by the column and you obtain a velocity change in the simplest short-pulse approximation. A pulse of twice the height and half the duration has the same impulse. That statement assumes the column stays nearly constant and ignores gravity and the changing relative speed during the short push.

For a numerical scale, take a pressure of one ten-trillionth pascal acting for 100 million years on a column of 0.002 kilograms per square metre. With the declared time-unit convention, the simple impulse estimate gives about 158 kilometres per second. Stretching the same pressure across a much longer interval eventually invalidates the short-pulse approximation because gravity and motion have time to respond. Use this estimate only when the vertical response time is much longer than the stated pulse duration.

Δvz≃1Σg∫Pinc(t) dt\Delta v_z\simeq\frac{1}{\Sigma_g}\int P_{\rm inc}(t)\,dt
The area under the pressure–time graph is the impulse per unit area. This estimate describes the brief impulse; the complete trajectory follows the changing force throughout.
Δt=100 Myr=3.156×1015 sΔvz≃10−13 Pa (3.156×1015 s)2×10−3 kg m−2=1.578×105 m s−1≃158 km s−1\begin{aligned}\Delta t&=100\,\mathrm{Myr}\\&=3.156\times10^{15}\,\mathrm s\\\Delta v_z&\simeq\frac{10^{-13}\,\mathrm{Pa}\,(3.156\times10^{15}\,\mathrm s)}{2\times10^{-3}\,\mathrm{kg}\,\mathrm m^{-2}}\\&=1.578\times10^5\,\mathrm m\,\mathrm s^{-1}\\&\simeq158\,\mathrm{km}\,\mathrm s^{-1}\end{aligned}
The declared numerical time unit is 1 Myr=3.156×1013 s1\,\mathrm{Myr}=3.156\times10^{13}\,\mathrm s. Pressure is force per area, so pressure times time divided by mass per area has velocity units.

Reading: Köppen, Jáchym, Taylor & Palouš, Ram Pressure Stripping Made Easy, arXiv:1806.05887v1 (2018) · Original fixed-slice and static-restoring-force materials

Let the vertical motion set the comparison

Near the midplane, a smooth potential often looks approximately like a spring: restoring acceleration grows roughly in proportion to height. The gas then has a natural vertical oscillation period. A pulse lasting much longer can be followed almost statically; a much shorter pulse resembles a kick.

Between these limits the gas moves while the pressure changes. Its velocity changes the drag, its column evolves, and gravitational work matters throughout the encounter. Integrating the actual equation of motion is how to follow that middle region.

The pressure curves in the reference figure therefore help form a prediction, then the saved trajectory tests its consequence. A local static threshold, a maximum tail height and the eventual bound mass describe related parts of the same event. They are useful together when their definitions remain explicit.

Reading: Köppen, Jáchym, Taylor & Palouš, Ram Pressure Stripping Made Easy, arXiv:1806.05887v1 (2018) · Original fixed-slice and static-restoring-force materials

Exercises and explained answers

  1. Two pulses have equal peak pressure, but one lasts ten times longer. Must they remove the same gas?

    Read the explanation

    No. A short pulse may deliver much less impulse. If both are slow compared with the vertical response, a static comparison can be useful; otherwise duration changes the motion.

  2. If the gas column halves while area and gravity stay fixed, what happens to the static restoring pressure?

    Read the explanation

    It halves because pressure is column times maximum restoring acceleration. At the same incident pressure the gas also accelerates more readily.

Try the prediction

Follow gas lifted by a cluster wind

  1. Compare two supported paths at the same native time. Use the pressure history to explain why the gas has reached its present height.
  2. Predict whether a high displaced fraction must equal the positive-energy fraction, then inspect both readouts.

Sources and calculation scope

  1. Köppen, Jáchym, Taylor & Palouš, Ram Pressure Stripping Made Easy, arXiv:1806.05887v1 (2018)

    Sections2.1–2.2 and5.4 explain the slow-pressure/impulse limits and re-accretable gas. Our fixed three-component potential, equal-mass sheets and consuming gas are specified independently; the own static comparison does not reproduce every published simulation or observational sample.

  2. Original fixed-slice and static-restoring-force materials

    Our five exact synthetic slices with sixty-four sheets and thirteen fields, initial common arrays, two global-light histories/three screens/four-age band subset, independent Python static maxima and mask/energy/colour diagnostics. Original trajectory and native SSP production are distinct earlier calculations; this offline package repeats diagnostics and band ratios. No browser Engine, original FITS/SED, paper, author code or observed-galaxy data is included.

FeedbackSomething broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy