Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics
Pulsar timing arrays and the Hellings–Downs curve

Deriving the Hellings–Downs curve

Sandbox Physics ·

The Hellings–Downs curve is the average correlation between the timing residuals of two pulsars separated by an angle ζ\zeta, when an isotropic, unpolarised gravitational-wave background passes the Earth. It comes from one geometric factor per pulsar, the antenna pattern, multiplied for the two pulsars and averaged over all wave directions and both polarisations. The result depends only on ζ\zeta, has no monopole and no dipole part, and so differs in shape from the correlation that a clock error or an ephemeris error produces. This chapter derives the antenna pattern, states the curve in its two common normalisations, checks its features and compares it with the other two patterns.

You need vectors, the dot product, and the idea of averaging over a sphere. The previous chapter, what a pulsar timing residual measures, defines the residual.

One wave and one pulsar

Let p^\hat p point from the Earth to a pulsar at distance LL, and let a plane gravitational wave travel in the direction Ω^\hat\Omega with metric perturbation hij(t,x⃗)h_{ij}(t,\vec x). Integrating the perturbation along the path of the radio pulse gives the fractional change of the pulse frequency,

z(t)=12 p^ip^j1+Ω^⋅p^[hij(t,0⃗)−hij(t−L(1+Ω^⋅p^)/c,  Lp^)].z(t)=\frac12\,\frac{\hat p^i\hat p^j}{1+\hat\Omega\cdot\hat p}\Big[h_{ij}(t,\vec 0)-h_{ij}\big(t-L(1+\hat\Omega\cdot\hat p)/c,\;L\hat p\big)\Big].

The first term is the Earth term, the second the pulsar term. The timing residual is the time integral of zz. The factor 1/(1+Ω^⋅p^)1/(1+\hat\Omega\cdot\hat p) comes from that integration along the photon path. Jenet and Romano, 2014, eqs. 54 to 56

Write the wave in its two polarisations, hij=h+eij++h×eij×h_{ij}=h_+e^+_{ij}+h_\times e^\times_{ij}, with e+=θ^θ^−ϕ^ϕ^e^+=\hat\theta\hat\theta-\hat\phi\hat\phi and e×=θ^ϕ^+ϕ^θ^e^\times=\hat\theta\hat\phi+\hat\phi\hat\theta built from two unit vectors perpendicular to Ω^\hat\Omega. The antenna pattern of the pulsar for polarisation AA is

FA(Ω^,p^)=12 p^ip^j eijA(Ω^)1+Ω^⋅p^.F^A(\hat\Omega,\hat p)=\frac12\,\frac{\hat p^i\hat p^j\,e^A_{ij}(\hat\Omega)}{1+\hat\Omega\cdot\hat p}.

Here Ω^\hat\Omega is the propagation direction. The NANOGrav anisotropy paper writes the denominator as 1−Ω^⋅p^1-\hat\Omega\cdot\hat p because its Ω^\hat\Omega points toward the source. The two forms are the same function. NANOGrav Collaboration, 2023b, eq. 2

Worked example: the antenna pattern in the wave's own frame

Put Ω^\hat\Omega along the zz axis and take θ^\hat\theta and ϕ^\hat\phi along xx and yy. A pulsar at polar angle θ\theta and azimuth ϕ\phi has p^⋅e+⋅p^=sin⁡2θcos⁡2ϕ\hat p\cdot e^+\cdot\hat p=\sin^2\theta\cos2\phi and p^⋅e×⋅p^=sin⁡2θsin⁡2ϕ\hat p\cdot e^\times\cdot\hat p=\sin^2\theta\sin2\phi. Because sin⁡2θ/(1+cos⁡θ)=1−cos⁡θ\sin^2\theta/(1+\cos\theta)=1-\cos\theta,

F+=12(1−cos⁡θ)cos⁡2ϕ,F×=12(1−cos⁡θ)sin⁡2ϕ.F^+=\tfrac12(1-\cos\theta)\cos2\phi,\qquad F^\times=\tfrac12(1-\cos\theta)\sin2\phi .

The response vanishes for a wave travelling toward the pulsar, θ=0\theta=0, and grows toward a wave arriving from behind the pulsar, θ→180∘\theta\to180^\circ. In that last direction the delay L(1+cos⁡θ)/cL(1+\cos\theta)/c between the Earth and pulsar terms goes to zero, the two terms cancel, and the full response still goes to zero.

From two antenna patterns to one curve

For an isotropic, unpolarised background every direction and both polarisations carry equal power, and different directions are independent. The Earth-term correlation of pulsars aa and bb is therefore proportional to

∫d2Ω^ [Fa+Fb++Fa×Fb×].\int \mathrm d^2\hat\Omega\,\Big[F^+_aF^+_b+F^\times_aF^\times_b\Big].

The pulsar terms are delayed by L(1+Ω^⋅p^)/cL(1+\hat\Omega\cdot\hat p)/c, thousands of years for a pulsar a kiloparsec away. For two different pulsars these delays differ by many wave periods, and the pulsar-term products average to zero. For one pulsar compared with itself, the pulsar term correlates with itself and doubles the result.

Doing the integral gives the Hellings–Downs function. In the normalisation of the NANOGrav 15-year paper,

Γ(ζ)=32 xln⁡x−x4+12+12 δab,x=1−cos⁡ζ2.\Gamma(\zeta)=\frac32\,x\ln x-\frac x4+\frac12+\frac12\,\delta_{ab},\qquad x=\frac{1-\cos\zeta}{2}.

NANOGrav Collaboration, 2023, eqs. 4 and 5 Allen averages the polarisation-summed product over the sky and writes the same shape as μu(γ)=14+cos⁡γ12+12(1−cos⁡γ)ln⁡1−cos⁡γ2\mu_u(\gamma)=\tfrac14+\tfrac{\cos\gamma}{12}+\tfrac12(1-\cos\gamma)\ln\tfrac{1-\cos\gamma}{2}, which equals 23Γ\tfrac23\Gamma for two different pulsars and starts at 13\tfrac13. Allen, 2022, eq. 2.4 When you read a paper, check which normalisation it uses before comparing numbers.

Worked example: two pulsars at a right angle

At ζ=90∘\zeta=90^\circ, x=12x=\tfrac12, so Γ=32⋅12ln⁡12−18+12=−0.520+0.375=−0.145\Gamma=\tfrac32\cdot\tfrac12\ln\tfrac12-\tfrac18+\tfrac12=-0.520+0.375=-0.145. In Allen's normalisation this is −0.0966-0.0966. Two pulsars a right angle apart are slightly anticorrelated.

Checking the shape

The curve starts at 12\tfrac12 for two different pulsars very close together, crosses zero twice, reaches its minimum near 82.5∘82.5^\circ and rises to 14\tfrac14 for pulsars on opposite sides of the sky. The NANOGrav paper quotes zero crossings at 49.2∘49.2^\circ and 121.8∘121.8^\circ. Solving the formula above numerically gives 49.32∘49.32^\circ and 121.79∘121.79^\circ; at 49.2∘49.2^\circ the formula is still +0.001+0.001. The printed 49.2∘49.2^\circ is a rounding or a typo, not a different curve.

We checked the formula independently: a direct quadrature of the polarisation-summed antenna patterns over 240×480240\times480 sky cells, with explicit tensors rather than the closed form. Its sky mean, multiplied by 32\tfrac32, agrees with the formula to within 3.5×10−43.5\times10^{-4} at every angle tested.

Table 3.1 Sky quadrature of the antenna patterns against the closed-form Hellings–Downs function, both in the NANOGrav normalisation.
SeparationQuadrature times three halvesClosed form
10∘10^\circ0.44260.4425
30∘30^\circ0.21160.2116
60∘60^\circ-0.0824-0.0824
82.5∘82.5^\circ-0.1519-0.1519
121.8∘121.8^\circ0.00010.0001
179∘179^\circ0.24990.2499

Why it is neither a monopole nor a dipole

Any function of cos⁡ζ\cos\zeta can be written as a sum of Legendre polynomials Pl(cos⁡ζ)P_l(\cos\zeta). A clock error is pure l=0l=0, because every pair correlates with the same value 11. An ephemeris error shifts each pulsar by e⃗(t)⋅p^/c\vec e(t)\cdot\hat p/c. For an error vector with no preferred direction, the correlation is proportional to p^a⋅p^b=cos⁡ζ=P1\hat p_a\cdot\hat p_b=\cos\zeta=P_1, pure l=1l=1. Tiburzi et al., 2015, Section 2

The Hellings–Downs function has none of these two terms:

Γ(ζ)=∑l=2∞gl Pl(cos⁡ζ),gl=32 (2l+1) (l−2)!(l+2)!.\Gamma(\zeta)=\sum_{l=2}^{\infty}g_l\,P_l(\cos\zeta),\qquad g_l=\frac32\,\frac{(2l+1)\,(l-2)!}{(l+2)!}.

NANOGrav Collaboration, 2023, eq. 12 The leading term is quadrupolar, g2=1548=0.3125g_2=\tfrac{15}{48}=0.3125, because a gravitational wave stretches along one axis and squeezes along the other. Projecting the closed form onto the Legendre polynomials by quadrature reproduces these coefficients to 3×10−93\times10^{-9} up to l=8l=8, and g0g_0 and g1g_1 come out zero.

Worked example: the first three Legendre coefficients

g2=32⋅5⋅0!4!=0.3125g_2=\tfrac32\cdot\tfrac{5\cdot0!}{4!}=0.3125, g3=32⋅7⋅1!5!=0.0875g_3=\tfrac32\cdot\tfrac{7\cdot1!}{5!}=0.0875 and g4=32⋅9⋅2!6!=0.0375g_4=\tfrac32\cdot\tfrac{9\cdot2!}{6!}=0.0375. They fall roughly as l−3l^{-3}, so a few terms already trace the curve; the sum of all glg_l is Γ(0+)=12\Gamma(0^+)=\tfrac12.

One sky is not the average sky

The curve is an average over an ensemble of skies. Allen computes how much one sky can differ. For a single point source and pulsar pairs swept around the sky at fixed γ\gamma, the correlation has mean μu\mu_u and variance

σu2=9780+c24−839720 c2+112 ψ (18−10c−3ψ),c=cos⁡γ,ψ=(1−c)ln⁡1−c2.\sigma_u^2=\frac{97}{80}+\frac{c}{24}-\frac{839}{720}\,c^2+\frac{1}{12}\,\psi\,(18-10c-3\psi),\qquad c=\cos\gamma,\quad \psi=(1-c)\ln\frac{1-c}{2}.

Allen, 2022, eq. 2.6 At small separation σu=0.30\sigma_u=0.30 while μu=0.33\mu_u=0.33: one source alone barely traces the curve. Many sources at different frequencies average this out; sources at the same frequency interfere and leave a cosmic variance that more pulsars cannot remove. Our sky quadrature reproduces eq. 2.6 to within 9×10−59\times10^{-5}.

Lab task

Open the pulsar-timing-array Lab with the default background. Drag one pulsar slowly across the sky map and watch its pair points slide along the angle axis of the correlation plot. Then load the clock-error and ephemeris-error presets and watch the dashed reference curve change shape.

Exercises

  1. Evaluate Γ(60∘)\Gamma(60^\circ) and Γ(180∘)\Gamma(180^\circ).
  2. What is Γ\Gamma for a pulsar compared with itself? Which term supplies the extra half?
  3. Show that the average of Γ\Gamma over pulsar pairs spread uniformly on the sky is zero. What does that imply for a clock error fitted with the Hellings–Downs shape alone, if pulsars were spread uniformly?
  4. Using the Legendre series and ∫−11Pl2 dμ=2/(2l+1)\int_{-1}^{1}P_l^2\,\mathrm d\mu=2/(2l+1), show that the uniform-sky average of Γ2\Gamma^2 is ∑lgl2/(2l+1)\sum_l g_l^2/(2l+1). Evaluate the first three terms.
  5. Convert Γ(82.5∘)=−0.152\Gamma(82.5^\circ)=-0.152 to Allen's normalisation.
Answers
  1. At 60∘60^\circ, x=14x=\tfrac14 and Γ=38ln⁡14−116+12=−0.0824\Gamma=\tfrac38\ln\tfrac14-\tfrac1{16}+\tfrac12=-0.0824. At 180∘180^\circ, x=1x=1, ln⁡x=0\ln x=0 and Γ=14\Gamma=\tfrac14.
  2. Γ=12+12=1\Gamma=\tfrac12+\tfrac12=1. The Earth term gives 12\tfrac12 and the pulsar term, which correlates only with itself, gives the other 12\tfrac12.
  3. A uniform average picks out the P0P_0 coefficient, which is g0=0g_0=0. For a uniform array, a monopole and the Hellings–Downs shape would be orthogonal and a clock error would not leak into the fit on average. Real arrays are not uniform, which the optimal-statistic chapter quantifies.
  4. Squaring the series and averaging over μ=cos⁡ζ\mu=\cos\zeta with weight 12\tfrac12 keeps only the diagonal terms, ∑lgl2/(2l+1)\sum_l g_l^2/(2l+1). The first three are 0.019530.01953, 0.001090.00109 and 0.000160.00016; the full sum is 1/48=0.020831/48=0.02083.
  5. Multiply by 23\tfrac23: −0.101-0.101.

Sources

  1. Jenet and Romano, 2014, eqs. 54 to 56
  2. NANOGrav Collaboration, 2023b, eq. 2
  3. NANOGrav Collaboration, 2023, eqs. 4 and 5
  4. Allen, 2022, eq. 2.4
  5. Tiburzi et al., 2015, Section 2

Keep reading

What this page links to directly

See this series on the content map →

Pulsar timing arrays and the Hellings–Downs curve · Reading path

From one ticking pulsar to a Galaxy-sized detector

  1. ArticleHow can a pulsar timing array tell gravitational waves from a bad clock?
  2. ArticleWhat a pulsar timing residual measures
  3. You are hereDeriving the Hellings–Downs curve
  4. ArticleThe optimal statistic and its null tests
  5. ArticleRecompute a Hellings–Downs statistic from NANOGrav 15-year data
  6. ArticleReading the NANOGrav 15-year evidence for a gravitational-wave background
Something broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy