Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics
Fast radio bursts: repeats, echoes and plasma lenses

How a clump of plasma delays and bends a radio burst

Sandbox Physics ·

Free electrons make radio waves travel slower than light by an amount that grows as the square of the wavelength. A column of electrons therefore delays a burst, and a column that changes across the sky also bends it. For a Gaussian clump, one dimensionless number, the lens strength α\alpha, collects the electron column, the clump size, the distance and the frequency. When α\alpha is larger than about 2.24, one burst can reach us along three paths.

Before this chapter, read is a repeating radio flash the source repeating, or its path? You need the small-angle approximation, the derivative of e−x2e^{-x^2} and the idea that a wave's phase advances by 2πνt2\pi\nu t in a time tt.

The refractive index of a plasma

In a cold, unmagnetized plasma of electron density nen_e, waves below the plasma frequency νp\nu_p cannot propagate. Above it the refractive index is

n=1−νp2ν2≈1−νp22ν2,νp2=nerec2π,n=\sqrt{1-\frac{\nu_p^2}{\nu^2}}\approx1-\frac{\nu_p^2}{2\nu^2},\qquad \nu_p^2=\frac{n_e r_e c^2}{\pi},

where re=2.818×10−15 mr_e=2.818\times10^{-15}\,\mathrm{m} is the classical electron radius. For interstellar gas νp\nu_p is of order a kilohertz, so at radio frequencies νp≪ν\nu_p\ll\nu and the first-order form is enough.

A burst travels at the group velocity vg=cnv_g=cn. Integrating 1/vg−1/c≈νp2/(2cν2)1/v_g-1/c\approx\nu_p^2/(2c\nu^2) along the path gives the extra arrival time

tDM=c re2πν2∫ne dl=c re DM2πν2=4.149 ms  DMνGHz2,t_{\rm DM}=\frac{c\,r_e}{2\pi\nu^2}\int n_e\,\mathrm dl=\frac{c\,r_e\,\mathrm{DM}}{2\pi\nu^2}=4.149\,\mathrm{ms}\;\frac{\mathrm{DM}}{\nu_{\rm GHz}^2},

with the dispersion measure DM=∫ne dl\mathrm{DM}=\int n_e\,\mathrm dl in pc cm−3\mathrm{pc\,cm^{-3}}. The coefficient follows from SI constants: our independent check gives 4.1488 ms. Cordes and Chatterjee's review quotes 4.15 ms as the leading term of the arrival time, with smaller terms in ν−3\nu^{-3} and ν−4\nu^{-4} that we neglect. Fast Radio Bursts: An Extragalactic Enigma, Eq. 1

Phase runs ahead, so rays bend away

The phase velocity c/nc/n is larger than cc. Over the same path the phase therefore runs ahead of vacuum by

Δϕ=2πνc∫(n−1) dl=−λ re Ne,\Delta\phi=\frac{2\pi\nu}{c}\int(n-1)\,\mathrm dl=-\lambda\,r_e\,N_e,

where NeN_e is the electron column in m−2\mathrm{m^{-2}}. A wavefront is a surface of constant phase. Where the column is larger the phase is further ahead, so the wavefront tilts and the ray turns toward smaller columns. The deflection angle is

θ(x)=λ2πdΔϕdx=−λ2re2πdNedx.\theta(x)=\frac{\lambda}{2\pi}\frac{\mathrm d\Delta\phi}{\mathrm dx}=-\frac{\lambda^2 r_e}{2\pi}\frac{\mathrm dN_e}{\mathrm dx}.

A clump denser than its surroundings has dNe/dx<0\mathrm dN_e/\mathrm dx<0 on its far side, so rays are pushed outward: an overdense plasma clump is a diverging lens. Because θ∝λ2\theta\propto\lambda^2, low frequencies bend more.

A Gaussian clump and its lens equation

Follow Clegg, Fey and Lazio and take a one-dimensional clump with a Gaussian column, Ne(x)=Nℓ e−x2/a2N_e(x)=N_\ell\,e^{-x^2/a^2}, of peak dispersion measure DMℓ\mathrm{DM}_\ell and width aa. The Gaussian plasma lens in astrophysics Its deflection is

θ(x)=λ2reNℓπa2 x e−x2/a2.\theta(x)=\frac{\lambda^2 r_e N_\ell}{\pi a^2}\,x\,e^{-x^2/a^2}.

Put the lens a distance DD in front of the source, with the observer much farther away. A ray that leaves the source at transverse position xsx_s, crosses the lens plane at xx and then heads for the observer must have been deflected by θ(x)=(xs−x)/D\theta(x)=(x_s-x)/D. Measure lengths in units of aa: u=x/au=x/a for the crossing point and u′=xs/au'=x_s/a for the source offset from the lens centre. Then

u(1+α e−u2)=u′,α=λ2re DMℓ Dπa2=3430 DMℓ Dkpc(νGHz aAU)2.u\left(1+\alpha\,e^{-u^2}\right)=u',\qquad \alpha=\frac{\lambda^2 r_e\,\mathrm{DM}_\ell\,D}{\pi a^2}=3430\,\frac{\mathrm{DM}_\ell\,D_{\rm kpc}}{(\nu_{\rm GHz}\,a_{\rm AU})^2}.

This is Eq. 2 of Cordes and colleagues, with their Eq. 3 for α\alpha; for a lens far from both ends, DD becomes dsldlo/dsod_{\rm sl}d_{\rm lo}/d_{\rm so}. Lensing of fast radio bursts by plasma structures in host galaxies, Eqs. 1 to 3 Our independent calculation of the coefficient from SI constants gives 3429.8.

Each solution uu is a separate path, an image of the source. The left side is a straight line bent by a bump. When the bump is weak, every u′u' has one solution. When it is strong, the curve turns back on itself and some offsets have three. The next chapter shows the turn-back needs α>e3/2/2≈2.24\alpha>e^{3/2}/2\approx2.24.

Two delays for each path

Each path is late for two reasons. It is longer than the straight line, by (x−xs)2/2D(x-x_s)^2/2D in the small-angle limit, and it crosses part of the electron column. In units of aa,

t(u)=tg0 (u−u′)2+tDM0 e−u2,tg0=a22cD,tDM0=4.149 ms  DMℓνGHz2.t(u)=t_{g0}\,(u-u')^2+t_{\rm DM0}\,e^{-u^2},\qquad t_{g0}=\frac{a^2}{2cD},\qquad t_{\rm DM0}=4.149\,\mathrm{ms}\;\frac{\mathrm{DM}_\ell}{\nu_{\rm GHz}^2}.

These are Eqs. 12 to 14 of the 2017 paper. A useful identity ties the scales together: tg0 α=tDM0t_{g0}\,\alpha=t_{\rm DM0}. For a=1 AUa=1\,\mathrm{AU} and D=1 kpcD=1\,\mathrm{kpc}, tg0=1.21 μst_{g0}=1.21\,\mu\mathrm s.

Worked example. Take the Lab default, DMℓ=0.6 pc cm−3\mathrm{DM}_\ell=0.6\,\mathrm{pc\,cm^{-3}}, a=30 AUa=30\,\mathrm{AU}, D=1 kpcD=1\,\mathrm{kpc}, at 600 MHz600\,\mathrm{MHz}. Then α=3430×0.6/(0.6×30)2=6.35\alpha=3430\times0.6/(0.6\times30)^2=6.35, tDM0=4.149×0.6/0.36=6.91 mst_{\rm DM0}=4.149\times0.6/0.36=6.91\,\mathrm{ms} and tg0=1.21 μs×900=1.09 mst_{g0}=1.21\,\mu\mathrm s\times900=1.09\,\mathrm{ms}. Their ratio is 6.35, as the identity says. A source exactly behind the core, u′=0u'=0, has one image at u=0u=0: it pays the full dispersive delay of 6.91 ms and no geometric delay.

Lab tasks

  1. In the plasma-lens echo Lab, choose the preset that puts the source behind the lens. Predict the delay of the single copy from tDM0t_{\rm DM0}, then read it from the data row.
  2. Halve the lens column with the first slider. Predict how α\alpha and tDM0t_{\rm DM0} change, then check the secondary readouts.
  3. Move the observing frequency from 600 to 400 MHz. Explain from the formula for α\alpha why the scene changes.

Exercises

  1. Compute tDM0t_{\rm DM0} for DMℓ=0.6 pc cm−3\mathrm{DM}_\ell=0.6\,\mathrm{pc\,cm^{-3}} at 400 MHz and at 800 MHz.
  2. Show that tg0 α=tDM0t_{g0}\,\alpha=t_{\rm DM0} from the definitions.
  3. A clump has DMℓ=2 pc cm−3\mathrm{DM}_\ell=2\,\mathrm{pc\,cm^{-3}}, a=10 AUa=10\,\mathrm{AU} and sits 0.1 kpc0.1\,\mathrm{kpc} from the source. Find α\alpha, tDM0t_{\rm DM0} and tg0t_{g0} at 1 GHz.
  4. Where across the Gaussian clump is the deflection largest, and how large is it for the Lab default?
Answers
  1. tDM0=4.149×0.6/νGHz2t_{\rm DM0}=4.149\times0.6/\nu_{\rm GHz}^2 gives 15.6 ms15.6\,\mathrm{ms} at 400 MHz and 3.89 ms3.89\,\mathrm{ms} at 800 MHz. Halving the frequency multiplies the delay by four.
  2. tg0 α=a22cD⋅c2re DMℓ Dπν2a2=c re DMℓ2πν2=tDM0t_{g0}\,\alpha=\dfrac{a^2}{2cD}\cdot\dfrac{c^2 r_e\,\mathrm{DM}_\ell\,D}{\pi\nu^2a^2}=\dfrac{c\,r_e\,\mathrm{DM}_\ell}{2\pi\nu^2}=t_{\rm DM0}, using λ=c/ν\lambda=c/\nu.
  3. α=3430×2×0.1/(1×10)2=6.86\alpha=3430\times2\times0.1/(1\times10)^2=6.86, tDM0=4.149×2=8.30 mst_{\rm DM0}=4.149\times2=8.30\,\mathrm{ms} and tg0=1.21 μs×100/0.1=1.21 mst_{g0}=1.21\,\mu\mathrm s\times100/0.1=1.21\,\mathrm{ms}. The lens is strong enough to make three images.
  4. θ∝u e−u2\theta\propto u\,e^{-u^2} peaks where its derivative (1−2u2)e−u2(1-2u^2)e^{-u^2} vanishes, at u=1/2u=1/\sqrt2. There θmax⁡=α (a/D) e−1/2/2=0.429 α a/D\theta_{\max}=\alpha\,(a/D)\,e^{-1/2}/\sqrt2=0.429\,\alpha\,a/D. With α=6.35\alpha=6.35, a=30 AUa=30\,\mathrm{AU} and 1 kpc=2.06×108 AU1\,\mathrm{kpc}=2.06\times10^8\,\mathrm{AU}, θmax⁡=4.0×10−7 rad\theta_{\max}=4.0\times10^{-7}\,\mathrm{rad}, about 0.08 arcseconds.

Next: images, gains and delays of a Gaussian plasma lens.

Sources

  1. Fast Radio Bursts: An Extragalactic Enigma, Eq. 1
  2. The Gaussian plasma lens in astrophysics
  3. Lensing of fast radio bursts by plasma structures in host galaxies, Eqs. 1 to 3

Keep reading

What this page links to directly

See this series on the content map →

Fast radio bursts: repeats, echoes and plasma lenses · Reading path

From one burst to source-or-path tests

  1. ArticleIs a repeating radio flash the source repeating, or its path?
  2. You are hereHow a clump of plasma delays and bends a radio burst
  3. ArticleImages, gains and delays of a Gaussian plasma lens
  4. ArticleTelling source repetition from path effects with timing statistics
  5. ArticleSearch one CHIME burst for a lens echo and test R3's repeats
  6. ArticleHow to read the CHIME paper on the 16-day FRB cycle
Something broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy