Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics

FRB Echoes Through a Plasma Lens

Is a repeating radio flash the source repeating, or the path playing tricks? For the best-studied repeater, FRB 20180916B, the source. A plasma lens can split one burst into two or three copies that arrive microseconds to milliseconds apart in a fixed, frequency-dependent pattern. Repeats spread from seconds to months need the source to flash again. The path still matters: a drifting lens can brighten a source for a day and dim it for months.

Drag a plasma cloud and a burst source. One lens model splits a single fast radio burst into delayed copies, sweeps them across frequency and adds fringes, then compares the delays with real repeat intervals.

Interactive modelFRB Echoes Through a Plasma Lens
Copies reaching the telescope33
First to last copy10.2 ms10.2\,\mathrm{ms}
Total brightness / no lens3.513.51
Dispersion difference between copies0.527 pc cm−30.527\,\mathrm{pc\,cm^{-3}}
One burst across the bandSynthetic record · same lens in every channel
Arrivals at the readout frequencySynthetic record · noise-free
Fringes when copies overlapCalculated · coherent sum over a narrow band
Lens echoes against real repeatsObserved · CHIME/FRB Catalog 2, FRB 20180916B

Dashed gold line in the spectrum: readout frequency. Colored marks: copies 1, 2 and 3 in arrival order, as in the scene.

More readouts and what the charts assume
Fringe spacing of the two brightest copies
1.43 kHz1.43\,\mathrm{kHz}
Lens strength at the readout frequency
6.356.35
Longest echo this lens allows in the Lab's range
12.5 ms12.5\,\mathrm{ms}

The spectrum and profile add the copies by intensity, as a channel much wider than the fringe spacing would. The fringe chart adds them as waves, which only a channel much narrower than the fringe spacing resolves. Neither includes noise, scattering screens or motion.

Repeat intervals are the gaps between successive bursts of FRB 20180916B in the CHIME/FRB Catalog 2 (one entry per event), and sub-bursts are the offsets of components within one event. Gaps longer than one daily transit are shaped by when the telescope can see the source.

One burst, several paths: what a plasma lens can and cannot repeat

BackgroundFree electrons slow radio waves, and slow low frequencies more. A cloud with extra electrons therefore acts as a diverging lens. Near its edge it can bend several paths from one source into the telescope, so one fast radio burst arrives as two or three copies.

Why it mattersSome fast radio bursts repeat. Before calling that a property of the source, we need to know what a lens on the way could fake: how many copies, how far apart, and with what pattern in frequency.

Focus question
Can a plasma lens make copies of one burst arrive days apart, as the repeats of FRB 20180916B do?
One-sentence intuition
The delays a single plasma lens produces are set by its own dispersion delay, a few milliseconds per unit of electron column at these frequencies, times a factor that grows only with the lens strength; the copies keep a fixed order and frequency dependence.

Core mathematical model

Lens equation

u(1+α e−u2)=u′,α=λ2re DMℓπa2 dsldlodsou\left(1+\alpha\,e^{-u^{2}}\right)=u',\qquad \alpha=\frac{\lambda^{2}r_{e}\,\mathrm{DM}_{\ell}}{\pi a^{2}}\,\frac{d_{sl}d_{lo}}{d_{so}}

u is where a ray crosses the lens plane and u' is where the straight line would cross, both in lens radii. Above a threshold strength the equation has three solutions near the lens edge.

Gain of each copy

Gj=∣1+α(1−2uj2)e−uj2∣−1G_j=\left|1+\alpha\left(1-2u_j^{2}\right)e^{-u_j^{2}}\right|^{-1}

Behind the lens core the gain drops to one over one plus alpha. Where two solutions merge the gain diverges in geometric optics and is capped by diffraction.

Arrival time of each copy

tj=tg0 (uj−u′)2+tDM0 e−uj2,tDM0≈4.15 ms DMℓνGHz2t_j=t_{g0}\,(u_j-u')^{2}+t_{\mathrm{DM}0}\,e^{-u_j^{2}},\qquad t_{\mathrm{DM}0}\approx 4.15\,\mathrm{ms}\,\frac{\mathrm{DM}_{\ell}}{\nu_{\mathrm{GHz}}^{2}}

A longer bent path and the extra electrons both delay a copy. The electron term scales as one over frequency squared, so the copies sweep across the band.

Fringe spacing

Δνfringe=1∣ta−tb∣\Delta\nu_{\mathrm{fringe}}=\frac{1}{|t_a-t_b|}

If two copies overlap coherently inside one channel, their sum oscillates across frequency with this period.

Common difficulties

A plasma lens is a diverging lens

Typical misconceptionA dense cloud between us and the source should focus the burst and make it brighter.

Better mental modelExtra electrons raise the phase velocity, so rays bend away from the dense core. Directly behind the core the burst gets dimmer. Bright spikes appear only at caustics near the lens edge.

Echoes are not repeats

Typical misconceptionAny second burst from the same direction could be a lensed copy of the first.

Better mental modelA single lens gives at most three copies, with delays no longer than the lens maximum in the comparison chart. Their order, spacing and frequency drift are fixed by the lens. Hundreds of bursts at irregular gaps of minutes to months cannot come from one lens.

Run the experiment

  1. 01

    Drag the lens across the line of sight

    Start from One burst, three copies. Drag the plasma cloud slowly upward until it sits right on the straight dashed line, then keep going.

    What to observe: Three copies merge into two and then into one. Behind the core the single copy dims to about one seventh. Past the other edge three copies appear again.
  2. 02

    Watch the copies sweep in frequency

    Look at the dynamic spectrum and move the readout frequency from 800 to 400 MHz.

    What to observe: The late copy arrives later at low frequency, and at some frequencies the extra copies vanish. A lens leaves a chromatic fingerprint that a source flashing again does not need.
  3. 03

    Compare with the repeats

    Raise the electron column to its maximum, set the readout frequency to 400 MHz and read the dashed lens maximum in the delay chart.

    What to observe: Anywhere in the Lab's range, no echo comes more than about a second after the first copy, while the observed repeats of FRB 20180916B are minutes to months apart.

Related experiments and articles

What this page links to directly

See every article series on the content map →

Fast radio bursts: repeats, echoes and plasma lenses · Reading path

From one burst to source-or-path tests

Articles on this path that use this experiment, followed by the other experiments they suggest.

  1. ArticleIs a repeating radio flash the source repeating, or its path?
  2. ArticleHow a clump of plasma delays and bends a radio burst
  3. ArticleImages, gains and delays of a Gaussian plasma lens
  4. ArticleTelling source repetition from path effects with timing statistics
  5. ArticleSearch one CHIME burst for a lens echo and test R3's repeats
  6. ArticleHow to read the CHIME paper on the 16-day FRB cycle
Something broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy