Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics

L1 · Derivation and worked examples

Give the debris its orbital energies

Sandbox Physics ·

An orbital-energy difference appears because the near and far sides of a star start at different depths in the black hole’s potential. Assigning the same velocity to those positions gives a calculable first model of the debris. Its central approximation is to release all the material at one instant and then follow independent particles.

Compare accelerations across the star

Prerequisites are Newtonian gravity, kinetic energy and a first derivative. A derivative tells us how rapidly one quantity changes when another changes by a small amount. Here it compares gravity at neighbouring positions.

Let the black hole have mass M∙M_\bullet, the star mass M∗M_* and radius R∗R_*. Distances and speeds are in metres and metres per second; masses are in kilograms. Put the black hole at the origin. At the release instant the stellar centre is at distance rtr_{\rm t} on the positive xx axis. A small displacement x∗x_* is positive away from the black hole.

The gravitational acceleration has magnitude GM∙/r2GM_\bullet/r^2. Its radial gradient has magnitude 2GM∙/r32GM_\bullet/r^3. Across one stellar radius, the tidal acceleration is therefore of order GM∙R∗/r3GM_\bullet R_*/r^3, with a coefficient that depends on the direction and disruption criterion. Compare it with the star’s surface gravity, of order GM∗/R∗2GM_*/R_*^2. We define the conventional scale

rt=R∗(M∙M∗)1/3.r_{\rm t}=R_*\left(\frac{M_\bullet}{M_*}\right)^{1/3}.

Both sides of the acceleration comparison have units of metres per second squared. This radius is a scale, not a universal surface where every star suddenly disintegrates. A dense surviving core changes the distinction between partial and full disruption. The STARS hydrodynamic study calculates that distinction for specified stellar structures.

Define the penetration factor β=rt/rp\beta=r_{\rm t}/r_{\rm p}, where rpr_{\rm p} is the centre orbit’s pericentre. A larger value means a closer encounter. The teaching model assumes release of all material and uses penetration to change the supplied orbit. Calculating survival would additionally require the star’s internal structure and gas response.

Freeze positions and velocities at the tidal radius

Take the incoming centre orbit to be parabolic, meaning its specific orbital energy is zero. “Specific” means per unit mass. At the release radius its speed vcv_{\rm c} satisfies

vc22=GM∙rt.\frac{v_{\rm c}^2}{2}=\frac{GM_\bullet}{r_{\rm t}}.

Temporarily ignore rotation and internal velocities. Give each stellar element the same vector velocity as the centre. Its position differs by a vector δr\boldsymbol{\delta r}. Its exact Newtonian specific energy is

ε=vc22−GM∙∣rc+δr∣.\varepsilon=\frac{v_{\rm c}^2}{2} -\frac{GM_\bullet}{|\boldsymbol r_{\rm c}+\boldsymbol{\delta r}|}.

Negative energy means a bound ellipse, positive energy an escaping hyperbola. For displacements small compared with the tidal radius, expand the potential to first order along the radial direction:

ε≃GM∙rt2x∗,Δε=GM∙R∗rt2.\begin{gathered} \varepsilon\simeq\frac{GM_\bullet}{r_{\rm t}^2}x_*,\\ \Delta\varepsilon=\frac{GM_\bullet R_*}{r_{\rm t}^2}. \end{gathered}

The near side has negative x∗x_* and negative energy, as expected. The spread has units of joules per kilogram. In this convention, Δε\Delta\varepsilon is the half-width: the leading approximation runs from its negative to its positive value.

Notice where the release was made. Replacing the tidal radius by the pericentre would multiply this estimate by β2\beta^2 and would describe a different prescription. We keep the tidal-radius choice throughout. Stone, Sari and Loeb, Sections 2–3, explain why the release location matters.

The star supplies the weights

For a uniform-density sphere, a slice at x∗x_* has area π(R∗2−x∗2)\pi(R_*^2-x_*^2). Its mass per unit distance is this area times density. With ρ=3M∗/(4πR∗3)\rho=3M_*/(4\pi R_*^3) and the linear energy assignment, a change of variable gives

dMdε=3M∗4Δε[1−(εΔε)2].\frac{dM}{d\varepsilon} =\frac{3M_*}{4\Delta\varepsilon} \left[1-\left(\frac{\varepsilon}{\Delta\varepsilon}\right)^2\right].

This expression applies inside the energy interval; outside, it is zero. It peaks at zero energy because the widest stellar slices sit near the centre. Integrating the whole interval gives the stellar mass. Symmetry puts half on each side of zero in this linear idealization.

Thin slices through a uniform star have different cross sections; the resulting analytic energy distribution peaks at zero energy and vanishes at both edges.

The mass in stellar slices determines the energy distribution in the uniform-density, linear impulse model. The curve vanishes at the two stellar edges. A flat energy distribution is a separate ideal reference, useful for deriving a simple late-time law.

Worked example. For M∙=106M⊙M_\bullet=10^6M_\odot, M∗=M⊙M_*=M_\odot and R∗=R⊙R_*=R_\odot, the mass ratio’s cube root is one hundred. With R⊙=6.957×108 mR_\odot=6.957\times10^8\,\mathrm m, the tidal radius is 6.957×1010 m6.957\times10^{10}\,\mathrm m, about 0.4650.465 astronomical units. Using G=6.67430×10−11 m3 kg−1 s−2G=6.67430\times10^{-11}\,\mathrm{m^3\,kg^{-1}\,s^{-2}} and M⊙=1.98847×1030 kgM_\odot=1.98847\times10^{30}\,\mathrm{kg} gives Δε≃1.91×1013 J kg−1\Delta\varepsilon\simeq1.91\times10^{13}\,\mathrm{J\,kg^{-1}}.

These are scales, not relativistic capture calculations. The Lab restricts the black-hole mass and penetration to keep the prescribed orbit away from the immediate strong-field region. Pressure, self-gravity after release, shocks, stellar spin and surviving cores are omitted from its ballistic debris. Published hydrodynamic references are labelled separately.

Check the approximation by changing the encounter

  1. At fixed star, multiply the black-hole mass by eight. How do the tidal radius and the energy half-width change?
  2. A fragment is slightly nearer the black hole than the centre but shares its velocity. Explain the sign of its energy.
  3. Someone increases penetration and multiplies the energy width by its square while still claiming a fixed tidal-radius release. Diagnose the inconsistency.
  4. Why might an exact finite-size particle calculation produce a bound fraction slightly different from one half?
Answers with the reasoning
  1. The radius doubles because it scales as M∙1/3M_\bullet^{1/3}. The width also doubles: inserting that radius gives Δε∝M∙1/3\Delta\varepsilon\propto M_\bullet^{1/3} for the same star.
  2. The kinetic term stays fixed and the potential becomes more negative. Its total energy is negative, so it is bound.
  3. The extra factor corresponds to evaluating the potential gradient at a different radius. Either release prescription must be stated and used consistently; the specified model uses the tidal radius.
  4. The exact potential depends on the full three-dimensional distance. Terms beyond the linear radial expansion break the simple energy symmetry. Sampling, edge positions and finite stellar size can then shift the numerical split. The saved states let us calculate that split directly.

Sources

Stone, Sari and Loeb, arXiv:1210.3374v1, Sections 2–3. We use the tidal-radius energy-scale discussion; the chapter’s uniform-sphere slice calculation is an explicit teaching derivation.

Law-Smith and colleagues, arXiv:2007.10996v3, Equations 1–4 and Table 1. Their one-solar-mass zero-age star has its own density profile and radius, distinct from the uniform one-solar-radius example.

Try the prediction

Inspect a deeper encounter

  1. Predict how a deeper pericentre changes the track at fixed black-hole mass.
  2. Drag the incoming-orbit handle and keep the freeze radius at the tidal radius.
  3. Export both states and compare energy widths. Explain the small finite-size corrections.

First watch a deformable moon

  1. Compare strong and weak material during the same close passage.
  2. Use the gravity difference as a starting picture; the elastic moon is a separate model from stellar gas.

Keep reading

What this page links to directly

See this series on the content map →

Follow stellar debris back to a black hole · Reading path

Follow stellar debris back to a black hole

  1. ArticleWhy a shredded star can take weeks to brighten
  2. You are hereGive the debris its orbital energies
  3. ArticleTurn orbital energies into a return-rate curve
  4. ArticleLet returning gas become escaping light
  5. ArticleReplay debris orbits beside a real X-ray light curve
  6. ArticleRead the evidence for colliding tidal streams
Something broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy