How much work can be extracted by measuring a trapped bead and moving the trap
Sandbox Physics ·
In the earlier chapters the trap followed a fixed plan, and the mean work never fell below the free-energy change. Now we play differently: first look at where the bead has wandered, then decide where to move the trap. If the reading is useful, the bead drops into the new trap and the heat of the water does work for us. This chapter computes that work and its limit, the thermal energy times the information the measurement carries.
Let z be the bead offset from the trap centre, in units of the thermal width kBT/k, with energies in units of kBT. At the start of a cycle z is Gaussian with variance S. A camera reads y=z+ε, where the error ε has variance R. The trap then jumps by gy; g is called the gain.
The bead has no time to move during the jump, so the work is just the change in potential energy, given below. Then the trap stays put while the bead relaxes for a time tw. No work is done during the wait, and every drop in potential energy leaves as heat into the water. With a=e−2tw/τr, the offset variance must return to S after the wait, which fixes the steady variance.
Averaging uses ⟨zy⟩=S and ⟨y2⟩=S+R. A positive extracted work means the reading really did let the bead fall lower; the second term is the cost of the error, and it grows with the gain.
βW=21[(z−gy)2−z2],S=1−a(1−g)2ag2R+1−a
The first expression is the work done on the bead by one jump; the second is the condition that the variance is unchanged after one round of jump and relaxation.
−β⟨W⟩=21[(2g−g2)S−g2R]
Mean work extracted per cycle. It vanishes at zero gain: no measurement, no work.
How much information one reading carries
How much the reading y tells us about the bead is measured by the stochastic information I=ln[p(y∣z)/p(y)], Eq. (151) of the Seifert review. It is large when the reading lands unexpectedly close to the true position, and it can be negative when the reading lands far off.
Its average is the mutual information. For a Gaussian reading p(y) has variance S+R and p(y∣z) has variance R. Averaging the difference of their logarithms gives the formula below. It depends only on the signal-to-noise ratio S/R and is measured in nats.
⟨I⟩=21ln(1+RS)
An error-free reading carries unlimited information; a reading whose error far exceeds the bead jitter carries almost none.
Sagawa and Ueda proved that with feedback ⟨W⟩≥ΔF−kBT⟨I⟩. After a full cycle the trap has the same shape, so ΔF=0 and the mean extracted work cannot exceed kBT⟨I⟩. Our cycle starts from the steady state of the loop, and the matching exact equality is Eq. (156) of the Seifert review, where the total entropy production Δstot is the system entropy change plus βQ.
Averaging Eq. (156), and using the fact that in the steady state the mean system entropy change equals −Ileft, gives a tighter bound. Ileft is the information about the bead that the reading still holds at the end of the cycle. Nobody used it, and the next measurement makes it obsolete. After a long wait it is almost zero.
The bound limits only the average. A single cycle can extract more than kBTI, just as a single pull in Chapter 4 could cost less than the free-energy change. The sample average of the equality behaves like the Jarzynski average too: a few cycles whose reading points badly the wrong way dominate it, so small samples fall short of one.
⟨e−(Δstot+I)⟩=1⇒−β⟨W⟩≤⟨I⟩−Ileft≤⟨I⟩
The left side averages over the random quantities of each cycle; Jensen’s inequality turns it into the bound on the right.
After a long wait a→0 and S→1. Setting the derivative with respect to the gain to zero gives the best gain g∗=1/(1+R), which extracts 21SNR/(1+SNR) thermal energies per cycle, with SNR=1/R. The sharper the reading, the closer the best gain gets to one, which means moving the trap all the way to the reading.
The extracted work never exceeds half a thermal energy, while the information grows with the logarithm of the signal-to-noise ratio. Their ratio is the efficiency below. It approaches one as the signal-to-noise ratio goes to zero and is only about 0.21 at a ratio of 100. Section 7.3.5 of the Seifert review states that this bound cannot be reached by controlling the trap centre alone; using all the information also requires changing the trap stiffness.
η∗=kBT⟨I⟩−⟨W⟩=(1+SNR)ln(1+SNR)SNR
Efficiency at the best gain after a long wait. It is always below one and approaches one only for blurry readings.
The engine seems to draw work steadily from water at a single temperature. The missing piece is the controller’s memory: each reading must be recorded and then erased before the next one. Sagawa and Ueda showed in 2009 that measuring and erasing together cost at least kBTI of work. Include that cost, and the whole machine gains no net work per cycle; the second law holds.
Information therefore acts like a fuel. It can be turned into work, at most one thermal energy per nat, and making and clearing it costs at least as much.
Take a trap stiffness of 10pN/μm, so the thermal width is 20.4nm and the relaxation time τr=0.942ms. A measurement error of 10nm gives R=(10/20.35)2=0.241, a signal-to-noise ratio of 4.14 and a best gain of 0.806. Use g=0.8 and wait 3ms, so a=0.0017 and S=0.999.
The mean work formula gives −β⟨W⟩=21[(1.6−0.64)(0.999)−0.64(0.241)]=0.402. The information is 21ln(1+0.999/0.241)=0.818nat, so the efficiency is 0.49. In physical units each cycle extracts 1.67pNnm, an average power of about 0.56aW.
Now cycle fast: error 2nm, g=1, and a wait of only 0.25ms. Then a=0.588, R=0.0097 and S=0.417: the bead has no time to spread back to its thermal width, so the feedback has cooled it. Each cycle extracts only 0.204kBT, less than the 0.494 of a full 3ms wait, but cycles are twelve times shorter and the power rises from 0.165 to 0.815kBT/ms.
Predict first: raise the gain from 0.8 to 1.8. How do the information and the extracted work change? Then select Overshoot costs work to check.
Select Sharp eye, wasted bits and then Blurry eye, frugal use. Compare the information and the efficiency, and test both efficiencies against the η∗ formula.
Look at the middle scatter plot: cycles above the line beat the bound. Note what share they make up, and which side of the line the mean point sits on.
Drag the handle of the large trap and move the trap under the bead when it wanders. Compare your extracted work with the automatic feedback, and think about how accurate and how fast your own reading is.
Exercises with explained answers
After a long wait, with zero measurement error and a gain of one, what mean work is extracted per cycle, and what is the efficiency?
Show the answer
Here S=1 and R=0, so each cycle extracts 21kBT, the whole mean potential energy of the bead. The information 21ln(1+1/R) diverges, so the efficiency goes to zero: almost all the information in a perfect reading goes unused.
With a signal-to-noise ratio of one and a long wait, find the best gain, the work extracted per cycle and the efficiency.
Show the answer
The best gain is g∗=1/2, the work is 21⋅21=0.25kBT, the information is 21ln2=0.347nat and the efficiency is 1/(2ln2)=0.72.
Why does the engine pay work at gains above two after a long wait, however sharp the reading?
Show the answer
After a long wait −β⟨W⟩=21[(2g−g2)−g2R]. For g>2 the term 2g−g2 is negative, so both terms are negative. The trap overshoots so far that the bead sits higher in the new trap than in the old one, and every jump adds energy to it.
Version 1, 18 May 2012. Section 2: overdamped Langevin dynamics, Eq. (14) for the heat released into the medium and Eqs. (15)–(19) for the first law along one trajectory. Section 4: Eqs. (58) and (61), the Jarzynski and Crooks relations. Section 6.2: entropy production for master equations, Eqs. (120)–(129). Section 7.2: relative-entropy bounds on dissipation, Eqs. (146)–(150). Section 7.3: measurement and feedback, Eqs. (151)–(163).
Version 3, 20 January 2010. Eq. (3): with feedback, the mean work can fall below the free-energy change by at most the thermal energy times the mutual information. Eq. (4): the corresponding equality for a process that starts in equilibrium. The trapped-bead engine of this course and its numbers are our own.
Version 3, 30 May 2009. Eq. (4): the work to measure and then erase the record together is at least the thermal energy times the mutual information obtained.
Keep reading
What this page links to directly
You are hereHow much work can be extracted by measuring a trapped bead and moving the trap