Waveform amplitude, orbit tilt and luminosity distance
Sandbox Physics ·
The strain of an inspiralling binary is fixed by its chirp mass, its frequency, the tilt of its orbit and its luminosity distance. The chirp mass is read from how fast the frequency rises, so the amplitude leaves the tilt and the distance as the unknowns. A face-on source and a slightly tilted, nearer source arrive almost equally strong, and that trade sets most of a single event's distance error. Expansion adds one more limit: the waveform reveals the redshifted chirp mass and the luminosity distance, never the redshift itself.
Two masses m1 and m2 on a circular orbit of separation a have total mass M=m1+m2, reduced mass μ=m1m2/M and, from Kepler's law, orbital angular frequency ω with ω2a3=GM. Far away, the quadrupole formula gives the strain
hij=c4D2GQ¨ijTT,
where Qij is the mass quadrupole and TT keeps only the part transverse to the line of sight. For a face-on orbit the second derivative of Qij oscillates at twice the orbital frequency with amplitude 2μa2ω2. Using Kepler's law to remove a, μa2ω2=G2/3μM2/3ω2/3. The masses appear only in the combination called the chirp mass,
M=(m1+m2)1/5(m1m2)3/5,M5/3=μM2/3.
The wave frequency is f=ω/π, so the face-on amplitude is
Worked example 1. Take M=1.2M⊙, typical of two neutron stars, at f=100Hz and D=40Mpc. With GM⊙/c2=1.477km, GM/c2=1.772km and πf/c=1.048×10−6m−1. Then h0=8.68×10−23. For an optimally placed detector with four-kilometre arms, the difference between the two arm lengths changes by hL≈3.5×10−19m.
The chirp fixes the chirp mass
Radiation drains orbital energy, the orbit shrinks and the frequency rises at the rate
Worked example 2. For M=1.2M⊙, GM/c3=5.91μs. At 30Hz the frequency rises by 0.20Hz each second and the merger is 55s away; at 100Hz it rises by 17Hzs−1 with 2.2s left. Once M is known from the sweep, the amplitude formula has only D and the orientation left.
How the tilt divides the signal
Let ι be the angle between the orbital angular momentum and the line of sight, and v=cosι. The two polarisations of the wave carry the factors
Table 2.1 Polarisation factors and their root mean square, which sets the signal-to-noise ratio for a network that responds equally to both polarisations.
Tilt ι
χ+
χ×
(χ+2+χ×2)/2
0∘, face-on
1
1
1
30∘
0.875
0.866
0.871
60∘
0.625
0.5
0.566
90∘, edge-on
0.5
0
0.354
In the Lab the network is idealised in this way: the optimal signal-to-noise ratio is ρ=ρ100(100Mpc/D)(χ+2+χ×2)/2, where ρ100 is the face-on value at 100Mpc. The default event has ρ100=25, D=75Mpc and ι=30∘, so ρ=33.3×0.871=29.0. The observed value differs from that by the noise draw.
Why distance and tilt trade off
Near face-on both factors fall together. At v=0.9, a tilt of 25.8∘, χ+=0.905 and χ×=0.9, and the root mean square is 0.903.
Worked example 3. A face-on binary at 90Mpc and the same binary tilted to 25.8∘ at 90×0.903=81.2Mpc give the same signal-to-noise ratio. The only difference is the ratio of the two polarisations, χ+/χ×=1.006, a 0.6 percent effect. At ρ≈25 each amplitude is uncertain by roughly 1/ρ=4 percent, so the two cases cannot be told apart. The distance is uncertain by about 10 percent toward the near side.
Near edge-on the cross polarisation disappears and the ratio χ×/χ+ changes quickly with tilt. Measuring that ratio pins the tilt and therefore the distance. This is why the distance likelihood in the Lab is a long banana for a face-on source and a compact spot for an edge-on one. The same correlation appears in real data: for GW170817, fixing the distance with the host galaxy's velocity also narrowed the inclination, to 157∘ to 177∘ when the Planck value of the Hubble constant was assumed. Angles near 180∘ describe an orbit seen nearly face-on from the other side, and Table 2.1 depends only on v2 and ∣v∣ in the same way. Abbott et al., A gravitational-wave standard siren measurement of the Hubble constant Cutler and Flanagan note that the usual linear error estimate breaks down as v→1 because two signal parameters become degenerate there. Cutler and Flanagan, Gravitational waves from merging compact binaries, §IV A
The redshift hides inside the masses
A binary at cosmological distance is seen with its clocks slowed by 1+z. Every frequency is divided by 1+z and every time is stretched by it. The waveform is unchanged if frequencies are divided by a factor and masses, times and distances are all multiplied by it, because general relativity has no preferred mass scale. The detector therefore measures the redshifted chirp mass and the luminosity distance,
The amplitude formula holds with these two replacements. A neutron-star binary with Msource=1.2M⊙ at z=0.1 looks like a binary with M=1.32M⊙ at rest. Without outside information about z, or about the true mass, the redshift cannot be extracted. Supplying it is the subject of the next chapter.
Lab tasks
Choose the face-on blur preset. Read the distance band in the likelihood map, then drag the tilt handle to near edge-on and read it again. Explain the change with Table 2.1.
Drag the binary from 40 to 160Mpc at fixed tilt. Check that the signal-to-noise readout falls as 1/D.
In the advanced group, halve the detector sensitivity ρ100. Predict where the event drops below the threshold of 12 and test it.
Exercises with explained answers
The binary of Worked example 1 is moved to 80Mpc. What is h0?
A binary has twice the chirp mass at the same frequency and distance. By what factor does h0 change?
In the Lab network a face-on source at 60Mpc has ρ=30. What is ρ for the same source at ι=60∘?
An analysis finds Mdet=1.32M⊙ for a source with DL=460Mpc. Someone ignores the redshift. Which quantity do they get wrong, and by how much if z=0.1?
AnswersShow the answer
h0∝1/D, so it halves to 4.34×10−23.
h0∝M5/3, so it grows by 25/3=3.17.
The factor at 60∘ is 0.566, so ρ=30×0.566=17.0, still above the threshold of 12.
The distance is correct: the amplitude measures DL directly. The source-frame chirp mass is wrong. It should be 1.32/1.1=1.20M⊙; ignoring the redshift overstates it by 10 percent.
Try it in the Lab
Choose the face-on blur preset, then drag the tilt handle to edge-on and compare the width of the distance band in the likelihood map. Open the standard sirens Lab