Compare ideal flow with particles that never collide
Collisions redistribute momentum among directions. With instantaneous isotropisation, longitudinal pressure keeps doing substantial work. With no collisions, longitudinal momenta redshift and the pressure weakens. Starting the two models from the same isotropic state lets us see that difference without changing the initial energy.
Before you beginUse the conservation law from chapter 2 and the conformal pressure relation from chapter 1. An integral here is a weighted sum over the initial particle directions.
The ideal conformal curve is an analytic reference
An ideal conformal fluid keeps PL=PT=e/3. Substitute that pressure into the conservation law, divide by energy density, then integrate the logarithmic derivative. The temperature follows by taking a fourth root.
e(τ)=e0(ττ0)4/3,T(τ)=T0(ττ0)1/3
These powers are exact within boost-invariant, transversely homogeneous ideal conformal flow. They provide an independent check of numerical time evolution.
At zero chemical potential the equilibrium entropy density is seq=(e+p)/T=4e/(3T). Its ideal evolution satisfies seqτ=constant. Far from equilibrium this expression remains an equilibrium reference; the physical kinetic entropy must be computed separately from the full distribution.
Free streaming retains its initial angular distribution
Now take massless particles with an initially isotropic momentum distribution. Write q=τ0/τ and let μ be the cosine of the initial momentum angle to the beam. The longitudinal momentum at the later time is pz=qpz,0, whereas transverse momenta are unchanged. The momentum-space volume element supplies a further factor of q.
e0e(τ)=2q∫−111−(1−q2)μ2dμ
This angular integral is obtained by adding each particle’s redshifted energy. The radial momentum integral cancels in the density ratio for an initially isotropic massless distribution.
e0PL(τ)=2q3∫−111−(1−q2)μ2μ2dμ,PT=2e−PL
Pressure weights each momentum by its directional momentum flux. At the starting time the integrals recover equal pressures.
The limiting inverse-time density law appears only after the longitudinal pressure has become small. Applying it from a finite initial isotropic state would silently replace that state with zero longitudinal pressure. The Lab’s free-streaming curve keeps the declared initial pressure distribution.
What the comparison leaves for dynamics
The ideal solution assumes directional momentum has equilibrated instantly. The collisionless solution never redistributes it. Neither contains a finite relaxation time. A causal relaxation model introduces that extra timescale and lets directional stress carry memory of how the system began.
Matching the same initial energy is always possible. Matching all initial pressures as well is possible for the isotropic preset; an ideal fluid cannot share an arbitrary anisotropic initial stress. When using another preset, compare each model’s stated initial pressure before attributing every difference to its later dynamics.
Double the age from an isotropic initial state
Set τ/τ0=2. The ideal solution gives e/e0=2−4/3≃0.39685. In the free-streaming integral q=1/2; its analytic value is below.
e0e=2q[q+1−q2arcsin1−q2]≃0.42730
The collisionless density is larger because it has done less longitudinal work after the pressures begin to separate. The asymptotic expression would give 0.5 and is already inaccurate at this finite time.
Predict, then try the model
Predict whether a collisionless cloud can approach equal pressures simply by expanding for longer.
Choose the isotropic-start comparison. Advance proper time and watch both the energy curves and the pressure ratio.
The longitudinal momenta keep redshifting. Collisionless expansion makes the pressure distribution more anisotropic even as the energy density falls.
Exercises with explanations
1. How much of the ideal initial temperature remains after proper time increases eightfold?
Read the reasoning
The temperature power is one third, so T/T0=8−1/3=1/2. Energy density falls by 8−4/3=1/16.
2. Why can a falling energy density by itself not show that particles have thermalised?
Read the reasoning
Both free streaming and ideal hydrodynamics dilute the system. Their difference lies in momentum redistribution and pressure evolution. An energy density is only one moment of the full distribution.
Version 3 (19 October 2017), §§5.1, 5.3, 6 and 7.4; notation and limits of kinetic and hydrodynamic descriptions. This is a review, not an independent experimental dataset.