Calculate migration times and reconstruct Kepler-223 angles
Sandbox Physics ·
Start with a local disk prediction, then turn to a measured resonant chain. The calculations ask how an adopted torque would move a planet and what phase information real transit times contain. Their inputs and inference boundaries remain distinct.
Fix a four-Earth-mass circular planet at one AU, height ratio 0.055 and density scale 0.0001. The public script evaluates 25 temperature slopes from 0.3 to 1.5 and 31 logarithmic viscosities from one billionth to one ten-thousandth in model units. Each of the 775 cells stores both torque contributions, signed drift and local migration time.
The frozen grid has 678 inward and 97 outward cells. Dots flag 222 cells whose net sign can reverse under a chosen twenty-percent perturbation envelope on the individual torque contributions. This is a deterministic sensitivity test, not a confidence interval or a calibrated error distribution. The physical law and units are the same as the preceding chapters.
Near cancellation the local time grows very large and diverges at an exact torque zero. It is radius divided by the current drift rate, not an integrated arrival time. Changing radius, disk evolution or a dynamical torque can change the subsequent route. The static zero is a useful place to test additional physics.
τlocal=∣a˙∣a,ν=10xAU2/t0
The map horizontal coordinate is the viscosity exponent; color shows direction and the logarithm of local time. Exact zero drift is stored as an infinite-time null with an explicit meaning.
The input contains all forty-four quarterly transit-time shifts in Mills et al., arXiv:1612.07376v1, Extended Data Table 1: eleven bins for each of planets b, c, d and e. These are fitted timing measurements from real Kepler photometry, not synthetic transit times, individual transits or posterior draws.
The frozen author manuscript is 4,229,509 bytes with SHA-256 ee22071732db64c776a333b99e3e487c7e4ec3ca246cb52c1a1ed5c00f2b8115. The table is PDF page thirty. We redistribute factual numerical measurements with citation and our own scripts, not the paper’s text, figures or code. The table says BJD minus 2454900 without explicitly naming a dynamical time scale; no UTC or TDB conversion is invented.
Each measured shift is relative to a particular reference ephemeris. Using the fitted dynamical periods from another table would change the diagnostic. The input metadata therefore stores the exact four reference periods and zero-transit epochs from Extended Data Table 1.
Quarter bins are matched by chronological index, but each planet’s mean observing time differs. Choose the arithmetic mean of those four actual times for a common diagnostic time. Within each bin hold the measured timing shift constant; then repeat the calculation at the earliest and latest planet mean time to measure alignment sensitivity.
For an edge-on nearly circular orbit, a transit is assigned a quarter turn of mean longitude under the paper’s convention. If a transit occurs late, its phase at the reference time is behind the unshifted prediction. That fixes the minus sign of the timing shift.
Use the near-circular mean-longitude approximation to form two adjacent-triplet Laplace angles and their four-body combination. The third is algebraically dependent on the first two; it is not a third independent detection.
λi(t)≃2π+Pi2π(t−T0,i−δTi)
This approximation is not the full eccentric photodynamical transformation.
ϕ1=−λb+2λc−λd,ϕ2=λc−3λd+2λe
Integer coefficients cancel a common longitude zero point.
ϕ3=−3ϕ1+2ϕ2=3λb−4λc−3λd+4λe
Compute this combination directly from the original timing coefficients, preserving the reuse of the same measurements.
Download the listed scripts, CSV, source metadata and two synthetic reference records. The basic calculation uses Python’s standard library only and does not import this website, a private repository or a Lab Engine. It prints the torque grid, measured-angle ranges and an independent short RK4 check of a synthetic replay.
The checksum manifest verifies the frozen scientific inputs and scripts. Hashes certify exact bytes; numerical outputs are compared with tolerances because Python versions can differ in their last floating-point digits. The script does not claim to regenerate the entire long IAS15 history.
The reconstructed angles stay within the ranges below over the observed eleven bins. Changing the common time from the earliest to latest planet mean time changes the diagnostic by less than one degree in these data. This small alignment sensitivity does not remove the near-circular approximation or the finite observing window.
Each published timing interval is asymmetric and given as a signed offset from its best value at stated changes in chi-square. The script propagates a rectangle made from the four individual intervals by taking extrema of the linear combination. That envelope is neither a joint confidence interval nor a credible interval. It assumes no fabricated independence and supplies no posterior probability.
The timing calculation reproduces a limited diagnostic from real measured data. Separately, the synthetic torque grid verifies the Lab’s local prescription, and an independently authored fourth-order Runge–Kutta integration checks an eight-orbit clip against IAS15. With maximum code-time steps 0.04, 0.02 and 0.01, the largest Cartesian differences shrink from 0.00001096 to 0.0000000208 in the adopted length or velocity units.
For a full synthetic rerun, download the optional generator, orbit and disk modules, packer and C force source. Install pinned REBOUND 5.2.2 in a separate environment; the generator also works with a Python force callback. Compiling the optional force source speeds a long rerun. The website distributes no compiled executable. Record actual integrator, parameters, duration, phase cadence and stop reason when making a new comparison.
A short bounded angle arc does not by itself prove long-term resonant stability. The original paper’s interpretation also uses interacting-orbit fits and stability calculations. Eccentricity, projection, priors and the covariance of the fitted parameters matter; the quarterly table cannot recreate all of them.
Likewise, a synthetic two-planet disk model does not infer the birth locations or disk parameters of this real four-planet chain. Testing that history requires a forward model tied to the observations and an explicit comparison of competing histories.
Fixed four-Earth-mass, one-AU circular model. Dots mark sensitivity to a stated component perturbation, without a confidence interpretation.Each point uses four measured quarterly timing shifts. The bars are rectangle envelopes of individual profile intervals, with no joint confidence interpretation.
Put the basic files below in one empty directory. The first command uses Python standard library only. The manifest checks exact input bytes; output comparisons use numerical tolerances across Python versions.
Optional: regenerate the complete synthetic history
These extra scientific sources are independent of the browser Engine. Install pinned REBOUND 5.2.2 in a separate environment. Without the optional native library, the generator uses the Python force callback; it is slower but runs the same equations.
The optional packer needs a native force library only to regenerate the dense final clip. Compile the supplied C source against the installed REBOUND header; the generator accepts the same library through --native-library. Numerical attribution and complete source hashes are included above.
Run the public timing calculation before opening the synthetic Lab.
Compare the four-planet Laplace combinations with the Lab’s two-planet critical angles.
State each calculation’s supported inference and its observational or model boundary.
Exercises and explained answers
Why not combine the uncertainty envelopes of the first two angles as independent errors to get the third?
Both angles reuse the same planetary timing shifts. The four-body combination must be propagated from the original four measurements and their coefficients. The table does not supply a joint covariance or posterior, so the result remains a rectangle envelope.
A new archive table gives more precise periods. Should you insert them into this reproduction?
Not while retaining the old timing shifts unchanged. Those shifts are defined relative to the frozen reference ephemerides. A changed reference must transform the shifts consistently and be labeled as a separate analysis.
The eccentricity-damping and migration-time prescriptions, including the small-eccentricity wave time. We use the coplanar limit and restrict eccentricity below 0.7 aspect ratios.
Methods on timing and Laplace-angle reconstruction, Extended Data Table 1 (PDF page 30) and Figure 3 (page 35). The tutorial freezes all 44 quarterly timing measurements and their original linear ephemerides.
Sections 2.2–2.3, 5.2, 6.1 and 8; figures 7 and 14. This population study links migration, chains and later instability. Our two-planet illustration is not its population reproduction.
IAS15 reference integration with accuracy parameter one times ten to minus ten. The optional generator pins REBOUND 5.2.2; no package code is copied into the public tutorial.
Keep reading
What this page links to directly
You are hereCalculate migration times and reconstruct Kepler-223 angles