Why paths around a conical intersection can cancel
Sandbox Physics ·
An electronic state carried around a conical intersection can return with a minus sign. Its own density stays unchanged. Recombining it with another amplitude can turn a bright fringe dark, making the path-dependent phase observable in the model.
Use the dimensionless Hamiltonian He=(xyy−x) with energies E±=±x2+y2. Parameterize a centered circle by x=Rcosθ and y=Rsinθ, with R>0 and increasing counterclockwise angle.
A continuous real lower-state eigenvector uses the half-angle below. Advancing the angle through a full turn reverses both components. Energy returns to its original value, but the state acquires phase π and factor −1.
Let ∣uj⟩ be lower states sampled along the path. Normalize each neighboring overlap to unit magnitude and multiply around the full circuit, including the closing link.
A local eigenvector phase appears in two adjacent overlaps with opposite signs, so it cancels. This gauge-invariant product is negative for a loop enclosing this real degeneracy and positive for a nonenclosing loop. A path through the origin has an undefined adiabatic eigenstate and requires another dynamical treatment.
W=j=0∏N−1∣⟨uj∣uj+1⟩∣⟨uj∣uj+1⟩,uN=u0
The result is positive or negative one for this real model. General complex eigenstates can give any unit-modulus phase.
Control dynamical phase with symmetric arms
Prescribe paths (x,y)=(c+Rcosθ,Rsinθ). Upper and lower arms travel from left to right along mirror semicircles. Their energy histories and travel times match, so their dynamical phases agree. Offset c and radius R determine whether the combined loop surrounds the origin.
This is a guided adiabatic two-arm amplitude reduction with prescribed nuclear paths. It does not propagate the full two-dimensional nuclear wavefunction. The dimensionless output coordinate q has normalized Gaussian envelope G(q), fringe wave number k, external relative phase φ and upper-arm weight w.
The recombiner adds or subtracts the arm amplitudes and divides each by the square root of two. The upper amplitude is proportional to weikq and the lower to 1−we−i(kq+φ+γ). Their cross term supplies the cosine.
An ideal balanced recombiner yields the two output densities below. Their sum is the original envelope. Geometric phase γ redistributes this probability between the ports.
pA,B(q)=2G(q)[1±2w(1−w)cos(2kq+φ+γ)]
The phase-omitted control retains the same paths, weights, envelope and external phase.Two paths meet with a relative phase. Conceptual diagram; positions and heights are schematic.
Worked example of a bright-to-dark central fringe
Set w=1/2, φ=0 and q=0. A nonenclosing loop has γ=0, giving central density G(0) at port A and zero at B. An enclosing loop gives γ=π and swaps them.
An additional external phase π restores the bright center at A. Unequal weights w=0.92 give visibility 20.92×0.08≃0.543. Destructive interference then leaves a background because the two amplitudes have different magnitudes.
Check the conditions for interpreting the phase
Moving the loop from enclosing to nonenclosing requires passing through a path that touches the degeneracy. Its minimum gap vanishes and adiabatic following can fail. The experiment marks the small-gap region instead of assigning it a valid adiabatic cycle.
Different enclosing shapes can share the same loop sign. Travel time changes dynamical phase, controlled here by mirrored arms. A freely evolving molecular packet can also change arm weights, widths and arrival times, which must enter a molecular prediction.
Published original connecting conical intersections with nuclear-motion phase. Bibliography and the 1983 erratum are recorded by the authors’ group. This is further reading; the guided Lab derives its phase from Berry’s fixed two-state example.
Published primary derivation: equations (5)–(6) separate dynamical and geometrical phase; section 3 treats a degeneracy. The path experiment is a controlled two-state model, with the reduction and phase comparison specified on its page.
Keep reading
What this page links to directly
You are hereWhy paths around a conical intersection can cancel