How a small tilt travels through a magnet as a spin wave
Tilt a few moments in a magnetized film and the tilt does not stay put. Each tilted moment precesses, and exchange passes the tilt to its neighbours, so it travels as a spin wave. In the Pt/Co film of this course no wave below 26.4 GHz can travel at zero field. Above that gap the frequency grows with the square of the wavenumber. Damping makes every wave fade: at 60 GHz with a damping of 0.1 the wavelength is 30.7 nm and the amplitude falls by a factor of e in 55 nm.
Sandbox Physics ·
Small tilts around the up domain
Take the up domain, m≈(mx,my,1) with small mx and my. Keep each field in the effective field (Abert 2019, Sec. 2) to first order in the tilt. The applied field and the effective anisotropy point along z: H+HK0, with μ0HK0=2K0/Ms=927mT. The chain of the Lab also keeps the small hard-axis term of Chapter 4 in the domains, so mx feels an extra −HKmx. Exchange adds (2A/μ0Ms)∇2m.
For a plane wave m∝ei(kx−ωt) the Laplacian becomes −k2, so exchange acts like an extra field Hex=2Ak2/(μ0Ms) pulling the tilt back. A shorter wave bends the magnetization more sharply and feels a stronger restoring field.
Interfacial DMI drops out at this order. Its energy density is D(mx∂xmz−mz∂xmx). The first term is second order in the tilt, because mz≈1−(mx2+my2)/2. The second is −D∂xmx to first order, a total derivative that integrates to zero. We derived this; it holds for waves along x in a perpendicular domain and says nothing about other geometries.
Worked example
The dispersion relation and its gap
Without damping the LLG equation reduces to m˙x=−γ0H2my and m˙y=γ0H1mx, with the two stiffness fields below. Differentiate the first once more and substitute the second: m¨x=−γ02H1H2mx. The tilt precesses at ω=γ0H1H2.
At k=0 and zero field, μ0H1=958mT and μ0H2=927mT, so the lowest frequency is f0=ω/2π=26.4GHz. A 40 mT field along the domain raises it to 27.5 GHz. Below the gap an antenna can only make a tilt that dies away next to it.
Now go the other way, from frequency to wavelength. At 60 GHz and zero field, solve (γ0H1)(γ0H2)=ω2 for Hex: it needs μ0Hex=1.20T, so k=0.203nm−1 and the wavelength is 30.9 nm. A 10 nm wave needs an exchange field of 11.5 T and runs at 348 GHz.
On a chain of cells of size a the second difference replaces k2 by (2−2coska)/a2, which is smaller for short waves. With 1 nm cells the 60 GHz wave comes out at 30.86 nm instead of 30.92 nm, a 0.2 per cent change. At 150 GHz the gap between chain and continuum grows to 0.6 per cent. This is the same second-order mesh error as in Chapter 3, now seen as a shift of the wavelength.
The Lab checks the chain against its own discrete dispersion. A periodic chain of 512 cells, seeded with a small disturbance and run without damping, is Fourier transformed in space and time. Every peak lands within half a 1.95 GHz frequency bin of the formula.
k2⟶a22−2coska=k2(1−12k2a2+…)
Worked example
Damping turns the wavenumber complex
An antenna drives the film at one real frequency. With Gilbert damping each γ0H in the precession equations becomes γ0H−iαω, so the condition reads (γ0H1−iαω)(γ0H2−iαω)=ω2. Write X=γ0Hex−iαω. The condition is a real quadratic in X, so X is real, and k2 picks up an imaginary part ∝αω.
The real part of k sets the wavelength, λ=2π/Rek. The imaginary part sets how far the amplitude travels before falling by e: ℓ=1/Imk.
On the 1 nm chain at zero field and 60 GHz: with α=0.1 the wave has λ=30.7nm and ℓ=55.1nm; with the film’s α=0.5, λ=28.6nm and ℓ=11.9nm, less than half a wavelength. That is why the spin-wave preset lowers the damping to 0.1, an assumed value chosen so the wave stays visible.
In the Lab the antenna at 60 GHz launches a wave the chain measures at 30.75 nm, against 30.74 nm from the damped formula. The benchmark solves the same condition by Newton iteration instead of the closed form and matches the chain to 0.07 per cent in wavelength and 0.6 per cent in decay length at 40, 60, 100 and 150 GHz.
X=2−(p+q)+(p−q)2+4ω2,μ0Ms2Aγ0k2=X+iαω
What this picture leaves out
The chain keeps the stray field only as local terms, the same approximation Thiaville et al. use for ultrathin films. The long-range part of a wave’s stray field is left out, and this course does not estimate how much it would change the dispersion. The antenna is a uniform field over a 5 nm strip, and the temperature is zero.
An experiment to think through
Predict, change, explain
At 60 GHz with damping 0.1 the wave is 30.7 nm long and decays over 55 nm. Predict both numbers at 100 GHz.
In the domain-wall Lab choose “An antenna launches spin waves”, then raise the antenna frequency from 60 to 100 GHz.
Explain why the wavelength shrinks by about a third while the decay length shrinks by only about an eighth.
The macrospin Lab treats the strip of muMAG Standard Problem 4 as one moment. The wall and skyrmion Labs use the Pt/Co film of Thiaville et al. with local stray-field terms. All three run at zero temperature.
Try explaining it yourself
1. What is the lowest frequency a spin wave can have in the up domain at 40 mT?
Read an explained answer
At k=0, f0=γ0(H+HK0+HK)(H+HK0)/2π=27.5GHz.
2. Without damping, what is the continuum wavelength at 100 GHz and zero field?
Read an explained answer
Solve γ02H1H2=ω2 for Hex, then k=μ0MsHex/2A. The result is λ=20.9nm; on the 1 nm chain it is 20.8 nm.
3. With damping 0.1 the 100 GHz wave decays over 48.5 nm. Why does a higher frequency decay over a shorter distance even though the imaginary part of k2 grows only in proportion to ω?
Read an explained answer
The decay length is 1/Imk. For small damping Imk≈Im(k2)/(2Rek). Going from 60 to 100 GHz raises Im(k2) by 5/3 and Rek by about 1.48, so Imk grows by about 1.13 and the decay length drops from 55.1 to 48.5 nm.
Read: the exchange energy (Eq. 10), the demagnetizing field (Sec. 2.3), uniaxial anisotropy (Sec. 2.4), interfacial DMI (Eq. 33) and its boundary term (Sec. 3.5), the Landau-Lifshitz-Gilbert equation in Gilbert and explicit form (Eqs. 117 and 118), the conservation of the magnetization length and the energy dissipation (Eqs. 120 to 125), the Zhang-Li torque (Eq. 134) and the finite-difference method (Sec. 6.1). Other sections were not read.
Read in full: the Pt/Co/AlOx parameters, the effective anisotropy, the critical DMI for a Néel wall, the collective-coordinate wall equations with DMI and the steady speed below the Walker field.