Derivation
A collision model that keeps the conservation laws
The simulation uses a model collision operator of drag plus diffusion in velocity, introduced by Dougherty in 1964. At each position it pulls electrons toward the local mean velocity u and spreads them with the local temperature T, both computed from the same column of the distribution. That choice conserves the number of electrons, their momentum and their kinetic energy.
The operator also never lowers the entropy −∫flnfdv, and the only distribution it leaves unchanged is a Maxwellian with the local u and T. In a test with collisions only, the entropy rises at every step and ends within 6×10−10 of the Maxwellian value with the same energy.
Fine stripes go first
A stripe pattern eiκv under diffusion with coefficient νT decays at the rate νTκ2. A smooth Maxwellian has κ of order one; the stripes from chapter 3 have κ=kt, which reaches 20 at t=40 for k=0.5. The stripes are erased 400 times faster than the smooth part.
Integrating that rate along the stripe’s history gives the total loss. For a stripe whose wave number grows as kt from zero, the accumulated exponent after time t is νk2t3/3: it grows with the cube of time.
Worked example
Worked example: estimate the echo loss
The echo-producing stripes tighten as k1t until the second pulse, then loosen at the rate k2−k1 until they vanish at τ′. Adding the two pieces, with T=1, gives the estimate below. For modes 1 then 2, k1=0.5, k2=1, τ=20, the bracket is 1333. With ν=0.002 the estimate predicts that the echo shrinks by e−2.67≈0.07.
The simulation gives a ratio of 0.18, an exponent of 1.69. The free-streaming estimate leaves out the drag half of the collision operator and the self-consistent field, and in our runs it overestimates the exponent by roughly 20% to 60%, more for stronger suppression; at τ=30 the measured exponents are 0.38, 0.74 and 1.40 for ν=10−4, 2×10−4 and 4×10−4, against estimates 0.45, 0.90 and 1.80. The cubic growth with delay is the robust part: a collision rate that barely touches a single wave removes most of a long-delay echo.
Where irreversibility enters
Without collisions, the Vlasov equation is reversible and the echo proves it: information hidden in the stripes comes back. With collisions, the finest stripes are converted into a smooth change of the distribution, and the entropy rises. No later pulse can recover them.
The 1967 paper noted that this sensitivity could be used to measure weak collision rates, because Coulomb collisions act through exactly this velocity-space diffusion, enhanced for a stripe of wave number kvτ by a factor of order (kvτ)2. Su and Oberman published a theory of collisional echo damping in 1968; comparing the simulation with their result is left as a further check.