Page 219: the argument in one paragraph
The right column of the first page gives the whole mechanism before any equation. The first pulse leaves a term f1(v)exp(−ik1x+ik1vt); the second, at time τ, leaves a second-order term whose velocity coefficient vanishes at t=τk2/(k2−k1). Note the sign convention: the paper writes the first pulse as e−ik1x and the second as eik2x, so its echo has wave number k3=k2−k1 with both k positive. Chapter 6 used the same convention.
The paper then fixes its model: one dimension, a uniform ion background, an initially uniform electron distribution f0(v), and two impulsive external potentials. Footnote 4 says Φk1 and Φk2 carry units of potential because the delta functions take ωpt as their argument. In plasma units, with ωp=1, the impulse is the same as the potential kick used in the echo Lab.
Equations (1) to (4): from the transformed equations to the echo integral
Equations (1) and (2) are the Vlasov and Poisson equations after a Fourier transform in space and a Laplace transform in time; the external pulses appear as sources in Eq. (2). Expanding in powers of the two potentials, the first order is ordinary Landau damping after each pulse. Equation (3) is the second-order potential at k3, a double contour integral with three dielectric functions in the denominator.
Equation (4) follows by picking up two poles, under stated assumptions: τ long compared with a damping period, ∣γ(k1)τ∣ and the other damping exponents large, and k1/k3≈1. The integral stops phase mixing when k3(t−τ)≈k1τ, the echo time again. The paper adds that setting the dielectric functions to one gives the free-streaming result, “an easy limit in which to check Eq. (4)”. The project benchmark does that check: with the self-consistent field switched off, the simulated echo-mode density matches an independent quadrature of the free-streaming solution.
Equation (5) and Fig. 1: an echo that rises and falls at different rates
Equation (5) evaluates Eq. (4) for a Maxwellian. Before the echo the envelope grows as exp[γ(k1)(k3/k1)(τ′−t)]; after it, it decays as exp[γ(k3)(t−τ′)], where γ(k) is the negative Landau damping rate. Fig. 1 sketches three panels: the response to the first pulse, the response to the second, and the echo between them, drawn for k3≈k1≈k2/2.
Read the figure as a schematic. Its caption says “approximate variation”, and the text says the curves are drawn for k1≃k3. Its time axis has no scale and the vertical axes have no units, so there is nothing to digitise. What can be checked are the two envelope rates.
Worked example
What this site reproduced, and how far it goes
The Fig. 1 case is modes 1 then 2 in the echo Lab: k1=k3=0.5, k2=1.0. Equation (5) then predicts equal rise and fall rates of 0.153. With the first pulse’s own response subtracted, the simulated echo falls at 0.150, fitted 6 to 20 time units after the peak. The rise is steeper: 0.243 at τ=20, 0.204 at τ=30 and 0.188 at τ=40. It moves toward Eq. (5) as the delay grows, as an asymptotic formula should, but it has not reached it, and we have not isolated why. For modes 2 then 3, k1=1.0 and k3=0.5, outside the paper’s assumption k1≈k3; Eq. (5) gives a rise of 0.851×0.5=0.426 and a fall of 0.153, and the simulation gives 0.483 and 0.153. The fitted rates for both pairs, with their windows, are listed in the benchmark file.
The reproduction is limited. It covers the echo time, the echo wave number, the absence of an echo when k2<k1, the product scaling with the two pulse strengths and the fall rate of the envelope, all in a one-dimensional periodic simulation. The rise rate agrees only roughly at these delays. It does not reproduce the absolute amplitude prefactor of Eq. (5), the third-order echo at τ2k2/(2k2−k1), the spatial echo, ion-wave echoes, or the experiment of Malmberg and colleagues in 1968, of which only the abstract was checked.
Collisions and the suggestion at the end
The last column says the calculation fails if collisions destroy the phase information before the echo. Small-angle Coulomb collisions act through a Fokker–Planck operator, which multiplies the collision rate by about (kvτ)2≈(ωpτ)2 for a perturbation like eikvτ. The authors suggest using this sensitivity to measure the collision rate. Chapter 7 turns the remark into an estimate and compares it with the simulation; the estimate overstates the suppression, and the cause of that gap remains an open check.
A checklist for the next primary source
Write down the version and date, the sign convention for every wave, and the units of every applied quantity, including footnotes such as Footnote 4. List the stated assumptions of each derived equation before comparing it with a simulation, and note whether your test case satisfies them. For a schematic figure, compare rates or ratios, not drawn amplitudes. Finally, give each claim one of four labels: published theory, published experiment, our numerical result, or still to be reproduced.