Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics
Galaxies in close encounters

Read how black-hole binaries shrink in a galaxy merger

In the RABBITS simulations, gas can shorten the life of a massive black-hole binary by forming new stars nearby. It does this even in some runs where the direct torque from a gas disk contributes little to the shrinkage.

Start counting once the binary is hard

Open Section 3.3 and Table 2 of the 2024 published study, using the frozen arXiv version linked below. The authors start their zoomed-in reruns from snapshots where the two black holes are already closely bound. They reset the eccentricity to 0.6 to make different reruns easier to compare.

The clock in Figure 4 starts at that snapshot. For the disc-disc set, the table gives a mean of about 929 Myr for NoGas and about 454 Myr for CoolStarKinAGN. The bars show scatter across ten realizations. These are predictions for the chosen setups and starting eccentricity.

Liao et al., RABBITS I, arXiv:2311.01499v2 (2024)

Read the slope of each curve

The rows of Figure 5 show how inverse semimajor axis grows with time. A faster increase means a faster decline in binary size. Study the nearly linear stretches before gravitational waves dominate and compare them with the steeper late phase.

Now move to Figure 6. Its points compare the measured hardening rate with stellar density and dispersion near the binary. The line is a scattering reference. Stars that pass close can carry off orbital energy, and Figure 7 follows the changing population of orbits that reach the binary.

s=ddt(1a)s=\frac{\mathrm{d}}{\mathrm{d}t}\left(\frac{1}{a}\right)
The semimajor axis a is the size of the black-hole orbit. A positive s means the orbit is shrinking.

Liao et al., RABBITS I, arXiv:2311.01499v2 (2024)

Separate the two ways gas can matter

The simulations compare cooling, new stars and black-hole feedback. More cooling can produce a denser central population of stars. A binary then has more chances to give energy to stars on close passages. Direct gas torque is a different channel, discussed in Section 4.3.

These calculations concern a binary in the center of an already merged galactic system. The Lab’s markers probe a much larger galactic encounter. A quiet center-separation curve in the Lab leaves the binary’s later evolution open.

Liao et al., RABBITS I, arXiv:2311.01499v2 (2024) · Galaxy encounter direct-sum runs and archived numerical checks

Exercise

Why do two runs with gas need not have the same merger time?

Read the explanation

Cooling and feedback can leave different numbers of stars close to the binary. Those stars change the scattering rate even if the binary receives little direct torque from a disk.

Try it in the Lab

Compare the kiloparsec units of the Lab with the binary scales in Figure 5. Name one physical process the Lab would need to add before it could predict a binary lifetime.

Sources

Keep reading

What this page links to directly

See this series on the content map →

Galaxies in close encounters · Reading path

Galaxies in close encounters

  1. ArticleWhy galaxies merge even though their stars rarely meet
  2. ArticleTidal acceleration across a galaxy disk
  3. ArticleHow a galaxy orbit loses energy
  4. ArticleCompare a drag orbit with a direct galaxy simulation
  5. You are hereRead how black-hole binaries shrink in a galaxy merger
Something broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy