Pulled and pushed waves differ in who leads an expanding population
Sandbox Physics ·
A species spreading into empty land advances like a wave. If lone pioneers at the tip grow fastest, the tip pulls the wave along and the future population descends from a handful of pioneers. If individuals need company to grow well, the tip lags and the crowd behind pushes the wave. The difference decides how fast the wave moves and how much genetic diversity it keeps.
Let n(x,t) be the population density along a line. Individuals disperse with diffusion constant D and grow at the per-capita rate r(n). The growth law on the right has carrying capacity N, growth rate g0 at low density, and a cooperativity B. For B=0 growth is logistic and fastest when the population is sparse. For large B individuals grow faster in company, which ecologists call an Allee effect.
The Lab runs the discrete version of this model used by Birzu, Hallatschek and Korolev: a row of demes, each holding up to about N individuals. Every generation a quarter of each deme migrates to its two neighbours, the local density grows by the rule above, and the next generation is resampled at random. The random sampling is the drift of chapters 1 to 3, now acting deme by deme.
∂t∂n=D∂x2∂2n+r(n)n,r(n)=g0(1−Nn)(1+BNn)
The reaction-diffusion equation and the cooperative growth law.
Far ahead of the front the density is tiny, so r(n)≈g0 and the equation becomes linear. In the frame ζ=x−vt moving with the front, try ρ∼e−kζ. Substituting gives Dk2−vk+g0=0, which has a real decay rate only if v≥2Dg0. This minimum is the Fisher speed vF.
For B≤2 the front moves at exactly vF: it is pulled by its tip, and the bulk does not matter. For B>2 growth at intermediate density is strong enough to push the front faster than the tip alone could. The exact speed for this growth law is given by the second formula.
vF=2Dg0(B≤2),v=2g0DB(1+B2)(B>2)
Front speed for the cooperative growth law: pulled for B≤2, pushed for larger B.
Birzu and co-workers found that pushed waves come in two kinds. Their perturbative formulas for drift and front wandering contain integrals over the front that converge only if the density at the tip falls fast enough. Using the decay rate k of the tip, the integrals converge when v/vF exceeds 3/(22). That point separates fully pushed waves, whose fluctuations scale as 1/N, from semi-pushed waves, where they fall more slowly. For this growth law the boundary is B=4.
The figure checks the speeds. The noise-free lattice model follows the continuum curve to within 0.6 per cent at every B, and a finite-difference solution of the continuum equation, extrapolated to zero grid spacing, matches the exact pushed speeds to 2×10−5 relative error.
Decay of the front tip and the condition for a fully pushed wave.Front speed divided by the Fisher speed as cooperation grows. Line: the continuum formula. Dots: noise-free lattice fronts from the Lab model, each divided by the lattice v∗. The front is pulled up to B=2, semi-pushed up to B=4, where the ratio reaches 3/(22), and fully pushed beyond.
Problem. The Lab uses D=0.125 demes squared per generation and g0=0.01 per generation. Find the speed for B=3, its class, and compare with the simulations.
Speeds. vF=20.125×0.01=0.0707. For B=3, v=0.01×0.125×1.5×(1+2/3)=0.0722. The ratio is 1.021, above 1 and below 1.061, so the wave is semi-pushed.
Tip. vF2/v2=0.96, so k=0.289×1.2=0.346 per deme. The integrand in the drift formula grows towards the tip as e(2v/D−3k)ζ, and 2v/D−3k=1.155−1.039>0, so the integral diverges. For B=4 the same exponent is exactly zero.
Check. The noise-free lattice front moves at 0.07242 demes per generation, 0.34 per cent faster than the continuum value; the lattice is not exactly the continuum equation. The continuum solver gives 0.0721684 against the exact 0.0721688.
Answer. v=0.0722, two per cent above the Fisher speed, and semi-pushed.
In a pulled wave, the individuals at the far tip grow fastest and run into empty space first, so almost all future individuals descend from them. In a pushed wave, the tip grows slowly and ancestry spreads over the bulk of the front. The mean-field theory weighs each position by ρ2evζ/D.
The Lab tests this by tagging every individual from a chosen position to the tip and counting how often the tag takes over, in 80 seeded rounds for each case with N=1000. In the fully pushed wave at B=10, a tag starting at the front position won 69±5 per cent of rounds against 71 per cent expected. In the other three cases the tag won less often than the weight predicts: 29±5 against 40 per cent from two demes further forward, 49±6 against 69 in the semi-pushed wave at B=3 from four demes ahead, and 91±3 against 99.8 in the pulled wave from six demes ahead. The weight ignores fluctuations at the tip, which matter most in exactly these cases.
A pulled front depends on a few individuals at its tip, so it feels the discreteness of individuals strongly. Two results from van Saarloos’s review apply. A deterministic pulled front approaches its asymptotic speed v∗ slowly, as the first formula shows. A noisy front with N individuals per deme is slower by an amount that shrinks only as one over the square of lnN, the Brunet–Derrida correction.
For the Lab lattice v∗=0.07095. The noise-free front fitted over its second half gives 0.07061; adding back the slow approach gives 0.07097. With noise, N=1000 gives 0.0614±0.0012 against 0.0636 from Brunet–Derrida, and N=104 gives 0.0655±0.0005 against 0.0668. The formula is the leading term of an expansion in 1/lnN, and the simulations sit a few per cent below it. A fully pushed front at B=10 with N=1000 runs at 0.09532±0.00019, about a tenth of a per cent below its noise-free speed.
v(t)≈v∗−2λ∗t3,vN≈v∗−ln2Nπ2λ∗D∗
Slow approach of a deterministic pulled front, and the speed of a noisy pulled front with N individuals per deme.
Choose Pulled: the tip wins. Predict whether a tagged region that starts behind the front position can take over, then move the tagged region back and watch several rounds.
Raise the cooperativity from zero to ten in steps. Predict where the speed ratio first rises above one and where the wave becomes fully pushed, then read the wave class.
Choose Few individuals slow the front and lower the carrying capacity. Predict whether a pulled or a fully pushed front slows more, then compare the measured speed for both.
Exercises with explained answers
Show that Dk2−vk+g0=0 has a real root only for v≥2Dg0, and find k at that speed.
Show the answer
The discriminant v2−4Dg0 must be non-negative, so v≥2Dg0. At the minimum the double root is k=v/(2D)=g0/D, which is 0.283 per deme for the Lab parameters.
Compute the speed ratio v/vF=B/8(1+2/B) for B=4 and B=10, and classify each wave.
Show the answer
For B=4, 0.5×1.5=1.061=3/(22), exactly the boundary, so fully pushed. For B=10, 1.25×1.2=1.342, fully pushed.
By how much does the Brunet–Derrida correction π2λ∗D∗/ln2N shrink when N goes from 103 to 106? Compare with a correction proportional to 1/N.
Show the answer
ln2N grows from 47.7 to 190.9, so the correction falls by a factor of four. A 1/N correction would fall by a factor of a thousand. That slow decay is why pulled fronts stay sensitive to noise even in huge populations.
Version 2, full text. Eq. (2): the Fisher speed. Eq. (3): the cooperative growth law. Eq. (5): perturbative rate of diversity loss. Eqs. (6)-(7): the leading-edge decay and the speed ratio 3/(22) that separates semi-pushed from fully pushed waves. Fig. 5: diversity loss in the three classes. Methods, Eq. (11): the simulation model. SI Eq. (S28): ancestry weight; Eq. (S122): closed form of the loss rate; section Duration of simulations and data collection, Eqs. (S149)-(S150).
Version 2, full text. Section 2.2, Eqs. (24)-(27): the linear spreading speed v∗ and steepness λ∗ from the dispersion relation. Section 2.9.1, Eq. (78): the universal slow approach v(t)=v∗−3/(2λ∗t) of a pulled front. Section 7.1, Eqs. (241)-(246): the cutoff correction to the pulled speed in particle models, proportional to 1/ln2N; Eq. (248): the front diffusion constant falling as 1/ln3N.
Keep reading
What this page links to directly
You are herePulled and pushed waves differ in who leads an expanding population