Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics
Fields, scales and critical phenomena

FR01 · L2 · Chapter 4

What a correlation function predicts

Work from a Gaussian generating function through Wick contractions to a scalar scattering amplitude.

Before you start: Chapter 3. Gaussian averages and the generating function are developed before Wick’s theorem.

You will be able to: Evaluate a Gaussian four-point function and explain the additional steps needed for scattering.

Calculated ideal referenceAnalytic reference curves, with axes and parameter definitions in the caption.Two-point correlation (reference normalization)0.00.00.141.30.282.50.413.80.555.0Inverse length 1Inverse length 2Separation (reference length)
Ideal analytic reference; dimensionless reference units. G(s)=e−m∣s∣/(2m),m=1,2G(s)=e^{-m\lvert s\rvert}/(2m),\quad m=1,2These are infinite-line Euclidean functions. Finite-volume samples in the Lab have their own reference.

A correlation function records how outcomes at different positions or times vary together. For a free Gaussian field, knowing every two-point function determines all higher moments. With interactions, new connected correlations appear. In a relativistic theory with well-defined incoming and outgoing particles, those connected functions also lead to scattering amplitudes after several additional steps.

Start with the smallest calculation that shows the structure: an average of four field values.

Two points establish a length scale

For a zero-mean Euclidean field, define G(x,y)=⟨ϕ(x)ϕ(y)⟩G(x,y)=\langle\phi(x)\phi(y)\rangle. The brackets mean an ensemble average, or the quantum expectation appropriate to the specified correlator. A positive value means that displacements of the same sign tend to occur together. Zero mean at each point does not force their product to average to zero.

On an infinite one-dimensional Euclidean line, the Gaussian action is

SE=12∫dx [(∂xϕ)2+m2ϕ2],G(s)=e−m∣s∣2m,s=x−y.S_E=\frac12\int dx\,[(\partial_x\phi)^2+m^2\phi^2],\qquad G(s)=\frac{e^{-m|s|}}{2m},\quad s=x-y.

Coordinates use a chosen reference length, and the action is dimensionless. The mass parameter has inverse-length units. The covariance is the Green function of −∂x2+m2-\partial_x^2+m^2: away from the origin it solves the homogeneous equation, while integrating across the origin fixes the jump in its derivative and the factor 1/(2m)1/(2m).

The decay length is ξ=1/m\xi=1/m. For m=1m=1, the correlation falls from 0.5000.500 at zero separation to about 0.1840.184 at separation one and 0.06770.0677 at separation two. The figure shows how both the width and the height change when the mass doubles. These are ideal infinite-line values; finite-domain references in the experiment include their boundary conditions.

A generating function saves repeated integrals

For a finite set of field values, put their covariance in a matrix CC. Let JJ be a list of source strengths, one coupled to each field value. Define a normalized generating function Z(J)=⟨exp⁡(JTϕ)⟩Z(J)=\langle\exp(J^{\mathsf T}\phi)\rangle. A derivative with respect to one source brings down the corresponding field. Setting the sources back to zero therefore produces moments.

A Gaussian with positive quadratic kernel KK has C=K−1C=K^{-1}. Complete the square in the exponent,

−12ϕTKϕ+JTϕ=−12(ϕ−CJ)TK(ϕ−CJ)+12JTCJ.-\frac12\phi^{\mathsf T}K\phi+J^{\mathsf T}\phi=-\frac12(\phi-CJ)^{\mathsf T}K(\phi-CJ)+\frac12J^{\mathsf T}CJ.

Shifting the integration variable leaves the normalization unchanged, so

Z(J)=exp⁡ ⁣(12JTCJ).Z(J)=\exp\!\left(\frac12J^{\mathsf T}CJ\right).

This step explains the pattern behind Wick’s theorem. Differentiating the quadratic exponential four times can only group the four external fields into pairs. There are three possible pairings:

⟨ϕ1ϕ2ϕ3ϕ4⟩=C12C34+C13C24+C14C23.\langle\phi_1\phi_2\phi_3\phi_4\rangle=C_{12}C_{34}+C_{13}C_{24}+C_{14}C_{23}.

For one Gaussian variable with variance 0.250.25, the fourth moment is 3(0.25)2=0.18753(0.25)^2=0.1875. The connected fourth moment subtracts these three pair products and is zero. In this Gaussian model, the covariance determines the fourth moment completely. The variance itself remains nonzero.

Interactions add connected information

Consider a relativistic real scalar field in three spatial dimensions, in natural units. Add an interaction density LI=−gϕ4/4!\mathcal L_I=-g\phi^4/4! to its free Lagrangian. Here gg is dimensionless in four spacetime dimensions. The interaction weights configurations according to more than their quadratic amplitude.

Time evolution in the interaction picture is organized by the Dyson series. Its time-ordering operation puts the later-time operators first. Expand the exponential to first order in the coupling and evaluate averages in the free vacuum. For the connected four-point function, each external field can contract with one of the four fields at the interaction point. The 4!4! assignments cancel the factorial in the interaction:

G4,c(1)(x1,x2,x3,x4)=−ig∫d4z ∏j=14ΔF(xj−z).G^{(1)}_{4,c}(x_1,x_2,x_3,x_4)=-ig\int d^4z\,\prod_{j=1}^4\Delta_F(x_j-z).

Here ΔF(x−y)=⟨0∣Tϕ(x)ϕ(y)∣0⟩\Delta_F(x-y)=\langle0|T\phi(x)\phi(y)|0\rangle is the free time-ordered Minkowski propagator. It differs from the one-dimensional Euclidean function above in dimension, time convention and boundary prescription. The formula illustrates one connected interaction joining all four points.

What remains before we call it scattering

A four-point function includes propagation from the external positions to the collision region. To obtain an incoming-to-outgoing amplitude, Fourier transform the external coordinates, isolate stable single-particle poles, remove the external propagator factors and put the external momenta on their physical mass shells. The LSZ reduction formula formalizes this procedure and supplies the field-normalization factors.

At tree level in this scalar example, removing the four external propagators leaves iM=−igi\mathcal M=-ig, or M=−g\mathcal M=-g in that convention. A measured cross section also needs incident flux, final-state phase space and the correct counting of identical particles. A spatial covariance plot supplies none of those experimental ingredients by itself.

The point of the example is the connection: free two-point functions build the contractions, interactions produce connected terms, and their on-shell residues encode scattering. Loop corrections require regularization and parameter matching, which motivate the later chapters.

Correlation and influence answer different questions

Two locations can share a nonzero correlation without allowing a signal between them. In a relativistic local theory, spacelike local observables commute. A controllable response is governed by commutators and retarded propagation, not by the magnitude of a symmetric two-point function alone.

In the correlation Lab, first compare a sample estimate with its finite-lattice reference. Move the probes farther apart and predict the trend. The spin-chain quench Lab provides a separate real-time many-body setting: its Hamiltonian, observables and time evolution define a different experiment. Use it to ask how a change spreads through that specified chain, keeping its correlators separate from the Euclidean path samples.

Exercises

Calculate a mixed fourth moment

Two zero-mean Gaussian variables have C11=C22=1C_{11}=C_{22}=1 and C12=1/2C_{12}=1/2. Find ⟨ϕ12ϕ22⟩\langle\phi_1^2\phi_2^2\rangle.

Answer and reasoning

One pairing joins the two copies at each position and contributes 11. The other two pair across the positions and each contribute 1/41/4. The total is 3/23/2. This calculation uses the joint Gaussian assumption. For a non-Gaussian distribution, the fourth moment requires more information.

Which result would reveal non-Gaussian behavior?

You measure a fourth moment that differs from the three Wick pair products. What should be checked before attributing it to an interaction?

Answer and reasoning

Estimate the uncertainty of the difference using the same retained records, including their correlations. Check finite-sample bias and the definition of the ensemble. A statistically resolved connected fourth moment demonstrates non-Gaussian behavior of that distribution. Identifying its physical cause then requires the specified dynamics and preparation.

Why keep external propagators at all?

If tree-level scalar scattering leaves a constant amplitude, why does its connected position-space four-point function depend on four positions?

Answer and reasoning

The four propagators describe how each external field connects to the interaction region. Their position dependence remains before reduction. The constant describes the local tree vertex after external propagation and the overall momentum-conservation factor have been treated separately.

Try the physics

Euclidean Field Correlations →Move two probes apart on a sampled scalar field. Compare the correlation estimated from many field configurations with the lattice prediction and its continuum limit.Quantum Spin Chain Quench →Choose a site to flip and compare its chain with an unflipped control. Watch the mean spins evolve, then save joint snapshots at one observation time.

Sources and reading scope

  1. David Tong, Quantum Field Theory, Chapter 2

    Sections 2.1–2.7: oscillator quantization, free scalar modes, vacuum two-point functions and spacelike commutators.

  2. David Tong, Quantum Field Theory, Chapter 3

    Sections 3.1.1, 3.3, 3.5.3–3.5.4 and 3.7.2: Dyson expansion, Wick contractions, the scalar tree vertex and on-shell reduction. Only the scalar tree example is calculated here.

  3. David Tong, Statistical Field Theory, Chapter 2

    Gaussian integrals, inverse-kernel covariance, correlation length and the Euclidean quantum-mechanical interpretation. Finite-chain normalizations are derived for this course.

FeedbackSomething broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy