Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics
Weak gravitational lensing and mass maps

Convergence, shear and what a galaxy shape measures

Sandbox Physics ·

A lens maps every small patch of the source plane onto the sky through a two-by-two matrix. Two numbers describe it: the convergence κ\kappa, which enlarges an image equally in all directions, and the shear γ\gamma, which stretches it along one axis. A galaxy shape is sensitive only to their ratio, the reduced shear g=γ/(1−κ)g=\gamma/(1-\kappa), and the average shape of many galaxies estimates gg. For an isothermal halo the shear falls as one over radius, which gives a first way to weigh a cluster from shapes.

Before this chapter, read how barely stretched galaxies map dark matter. You need small angles, partial derivatives, two-by-two matrices and complex numbers in polar form.

The lens equation and its Jacobian

Let θ\boldsymbol\theta be the position of an image on the sky and β\boldsymbol\beta the true position of the source. Light is deflected by the reduced angle α(θ)\boldsymbol\alpha(\boldsymbol\theta), so

β=θ−α(θ),α=∇ψ.\boldsymbol\beta=\boldsymbol\theta-\boldsymbol\alpha(\boldsymbol\theta),\qquad \boldsymbol\alpha=\nabla\psi .

The lensing potential ψ\psi is a weighted projection of the gravitational potential along the line of sight. A galaxy is much smaller than the scale over which α\boldsymbol\alpha changes, so we expand to first order around its centre. The Jacobian matrix A=∂β/∂θ\mathcal A=\partial\boldsymbol\beta/\partial\boldsymbol\theta is symmetric, and we name its parts:

A=(1−κ−γ1−γ2−γ21−κ+γ1),κ=12(ψ,11+ψ,22),γ1=12(ψ,11−ψ,22),γ2=ψ,12.\mathcal A=\begin{pmatrix}1-\kappa-\gamma_1 & -\gamma_2\\ -\gamma_2 & 1-\kappa+\gamma_1\end{pmatrix},\qquad \kappa=\tfrac12(\psi_{,11}+\psi_{,22}),\quad \gamma_1=\tfrac12(\psi_{,11}-\psi_{,22}),\quad \gamma_2=\psi_{,12}.

Weak Gravitational Lensing, Eqs. 3.11-3.12

The convergence is the projected surface density in units of a critical density, κ=Σ/Σcr\kappa=\Sigma/\Sigma_{\rm cr} with Σcr=c2Ds/(4πGDlDls)\Sigma_{\rm cr}=c^2D_{\rm s}/(4\pi G D_{\rm l}D_{\rm ls}), where DlD_{\rm l}, DsD_{\rm s} and DlsD_{\rm ls} are angular-diameter distances to the lens, to the source, and from lens to source. The shear has no such direct meaning: it is set by mass anywhere around the line of sight, not only on it. We write it as one complex number, γ=γ1+iγ2=∣γ∣e2iφ\gamma=\gamma_1+i\gamma_2=|\gamma|e^{2i\varphi}.

What a circle becomes

The eigenvalues of A\mathcal A are 1−κ∓∣γ∣1-\kappa\mp|\gamma|. A circular source of radius rr therefore appears as an ellipse with semi-axes

a=r1−κ−∣γ∣,b=r1−κ+∣γ∣,a=\frac{r}{1-\kappa-|\gamma|},\qquad b=\frac{r}{1-\kappa+|\gamma|},

with the long axis at angle φ\varphi. Its area grows by the magnification μ=1/det⁡A=1/[(1−κ)2−∣γ∣2]\mu=1/\det\mathcal A=1/[(1-\kappa)^2-|\gamma|^2]. Its elongation is

a−ba+b=∣γ∣1−κ=∣g∣,g≡γ1−κ.\frac{a-b}{a+b}=\frac{|\gamma|}{1-\kappa}=|g|,\qquad g\equiv\frac{\gamma}{1-\kappa}.

The elongation depends on κ\kappa and γ\gamma only through gg. Multiply 1−κ1-\kappa and γ\gamma by the same factor and the shape is unchanged; only the size changes. This is the root of the mass-sheet degeneracy in the next chapter.

Shapes of real galaxies

Real galaxies are not circles. Describe any elliptical image, with axis ratio b/ab/a and long axis at angle φ\varphi, by the complex ellipticity

ϵ=a−ba+b e2iφ.\epsilon=\frac{a-b}{a+b}\,e^{2i\varphi}.

The factor 2 is there because an ellipse turned by 180∘180^\circ is the same ellipse; quantities with this symmetry are called spin 2. The observed ellipticity follows from the intrinsic one, ϵs\epsilon^{\rm s}, by

ϵ=ϵs+g1+g∗ϵs(∣g∣≤1),ϵ≈ϵs+g(∣g∣≪1).\epsilon=\frac{\epsilon^{\rm s}+g}{1+g^{*}\epsilon^{\rm s}}\quad(|g|\le1),\qquad \epsilon\approx\epsilon^{\rm s}+g\quad(|g|\ll1).

If intrinsic orientations are random, ⟨ϵs⟩=0\langle\epsilon^{\rm s}\rangle=0, and the average observed ellipticity is exactly the reduced shear, ⟨ϵ⟩=g\langle\epsilon\rangle=g. Cosmology with cosmic shear observations: a review, Eqs. 25-27

Each galaxy is a noisy estimate of gg with a scatter per component of about σϵ=0.26\sigma_\epsilon=0.26. The average of NN independent galaxies has error σϵ/N\sigma_\epsilon/\sqrt N.

Tangential and cross shear

Around a lens the natural components are measured relative to the direction to the lens centre. For a galaxy at polar angle ϕ\phi about that centre,

γt=−Re(γ e−2iϕ),γ×=−Im(γ e−2iϕ).\gamma_{\rm t}=-\mathrm{Re}\left(\gamma\,e^{-2i\phi}\right),\qquad \gamma_\times=-\mathrm{Im}\left(\gamma\,e^{-2i\phi}\right).

The minus sign makes γt\gamma_{\rm t} positive when images line up along circles around a mass. Images along spokes give a negative γt\gamma_{\rm t}, and a circularly symmetric lens produces no γ×\gamma_\times at all. Cosmology with cosmic shear observations: a review, Eq. 31

For a circularly symmetric lens Gauss's theorem in two dimensions gives a clean result: the tangential shear at radius θ\theta is the mean convergence inside θ\theta minus the convergence at θ\theta, γt(θ)=κˉ(<θ)−κ(θ)\gamma_{\rm t}(\theta)=\bar\kappa(<\theta)-\kappa(\theta). Mass outside the circle contributes nothing.

The isothermal halo

A singular isothermal sphere, a ball of matter whose particles all move with one-dimensional velocity dispersion σv\sigma_v, is the simplest model of a cluster. Its convergence and tangential shear are equal:

κ(θ)=γt(θ)=θE2θ,θE=4π σv2c2 DlsDs.\kappa(\theta)=\gamma_{\rm t}(\theta)=\frac{\theta_{\rm E}}{2\theta},\qquad \theta_{\rm E}=4\pi\,\frac{\sigma_v^2}{c^2}\,\frac{D_{\rm ls}}{D_{\rm s}} .

Weak Gravitational Lensing, Eqs. 3.17-3.18

The Einstein radius θE\theta_{\rm E} is the radius where κ=1/2\kappa=1/2 and ∣g∣=1|g|=1. In a flat universe angular-diameter distances are D=χ/(1+z)D=\chi/(1+z) with χ\chi the comoving distance, so Dls/Ds=(χs−χl)/χsD_{\rm ls}/D_{\rm s}=(\chi_{\rm s}-\chi_{\rm l})/\chi_{\rm s}. This ratio, the lensing efficiency, is zero when the source is at the lens and grows toward one for sources far behind it.

Worked example. Take σv=1000 km s−1\sigma_v=1000\ \mathrm{km\,s^{-1}}, a lens at zl=0.3z_{\rm l}=0.3 and sources at zs=1.0z_{\rm s}=1.0 in a flat universe with matter density Ωm=0.3\Omega_{\rm m}=0.3. Numerical integration of χ(z)\chi(z) gives Dls/Ds=0.638D_{\rm ls}/D_{\rm s}=0.638. Then 4π(σv/c)2=1.40×10−44\pi(\sigma_v/c)^2=1.40\times10^{-4} rad, so θE=0.638×1.40×10−4 rad=18.4′′\theta_{\rm E}=0.638\times1.40\times10^{-4}\ \mathrm{rad}=18.4''. The shear is γt=0.153\gamma_{\rm t}=0.153 at 1′1', 0.0770.077 at 2′2' and 0.0310.031 at 5′5'. At 1′1' the convergence is also 0.1530.153, so the reduced shear is 0.153/0.847=0.1810.153/0.847=0.181, 18 percent above γt\gamma_{\rm t}. By 5′5' the difference has fallen to 3 percent.

Worked example. How many galaxies does it take to measure γt=0.05\gamma_{\rm t}=0.05 at three standard deviations? We need σϵ/N=0.05/3\sigma_\epsilon/\sqrt N=0.05/3, so N=(3×0.26/0.05)2≈243N=(3\times0.26/0.05)^2\approx243. At 20 galaxies per square arcminute that is an area of 12 square arcminutes, for example an annulus between 2′2' and 2.8′2.8'.

Lab tasks

  1. In the weak-lensing mass map Lab, load Shapes without scatter. Find the galaxies just outside a halo ring and check that their long axes lie along the circle.
  2. Select a halo and raise its velocity dispersion from 700 to 1300 km/s. Predict by what factor the true Einstein radius should grow, then read it.
  3. Lower the source redshift slowly toward the redshift of the selected halo. Watch the lensing efficiency readout and explain why it heads to zero.

Exercises

  1. Show that A\mathcal A has eigenvalues 1−κ∓∣γ∣1-\kappa\mp|\gamma| and that a circle maps to an ellipse with (a−b)/(a+b)=∣g∣(a-b)/(a+b)=|g|.
  2. A point mass has κˉ(<θ)=θE2/θ2\bar\kappa(<\theta)=\theta_{\rm E}^2/\theta^2 and κ=0\kappa=0 away from the centre. Find γt(θ)\gamma_{\rm t}(\theta) and compare its fall-off with the isothermal halo.
  3. A galaxy has intrinsic ellipticity ϵs=0.2\epsilon^{\rm s}=0.2 and is lensed by g=0.05g=0.05. Compute ϵ\epsilon exactly and in the weak limit. Repeat for ϵs=0.2i\epsilon^{\rm s}=0.2i.
  4. Take σv=1050 km s−1\sigma_v=1050\ \mathrm{km\,s^{-1}}, the first halo in the Lab, and sources at zs=1.2z_{\rm s}=1.2, and move the lens from zl=0.3z_{\rm l}=0.3 to 0.60.6. The efficiencies are 0.6830.683 and 0.4140.414. By what factor does θE\theta_{\rm E} change?
  5. To detect γt=0.02\gamma_{\rm t}=0.02 at five standard deviations with σϵ=0.26\sigma_\epsilon=0.26 and 20 galaxies per square arcminute, how much sky do you need?
Answers
  1. det⁡(A−λI)=(1−κ−λ)2−γ12−γ22=0\det(\mathcal A-\lambda I)=(1-\kappa-\lambda)^2-\gamma_1^2-\gamma_2^2=0 gives λ=1−κ∓∣γ∣\lambda=1-\kappa\mp|\gamma|. The image of a circle of radius rr has semi-axes r/λr/\lambda, so (a−b)/(a+b)=(λ+−λ−)/(λ++λ−)=2∣γ∣/[2(1−κ)]=∣g∣(a-b)/(a+b)=(\lambda_+-\lambda_-)/(\lambda_++\lambda_-)=2|\gamma|/[2(1-\kappa)]=|g|.
  2. γt=θE2/θ2−0=θE2/θ2\gamma_{\rm t}=\theta_{\rm E}^2/\theta^2-0=\theta_{\rm E}^2/\theta^2. It falls as 1/θ21/\theta^2, faster than the 1/θ1/\theta of the isothermal halo, because all the mass sits inside every circle.
  3. ϵ=0.25/1.01=0.2475\epsilon=0.25/1.01=0.2475; the weak limit gives 0.250.25, 1 percent higher. For ϵs=0.2i\epsilon^{\rm s}=0.2i: ϵ=(0.05+0.2i)/(1+0.01i)=(0.05+0.2i)(1−0.01i)/1.0001=0.0520+0.1995i\epsilon=(0.05+0.2i)/(1+0.01i)=(0.05+0.2i)(1-0.01i)/1.0001=0.0520+0.1995i. The weak limit gives 0.05+0.2i0.05+0.2i.
  4. θE∝Dls/Ds\theta_{\rm E}\propto D_{\rm ls}/D_{\rm s}, so it shrinks by 0.414/0.683=0.6060.414/0.683=0.606, from 21.7′′21.7'' to 13.2′′13.2'' (with 4π(σv/c)2=31.8′′4\pi(\sigma_v/c)^2=31.8'').
  5. N=(5×0.26/0.02)2=4225N=(5\times0.26/0.02)^2=4225 galaxies, which at 20 per square arcminute is 211 square arcminutes, a square about 14.5′14.5' on a side.

The isothermal model has two flaws that the Lab removes: its density diverges at the centre and its total mass is infinite. The Lab softens the centre with a small core and truncates the halo far out, so its shear profile bends away from 1/θ1/\theta near both ends.

Next: turning a shear field into a mass map.

Sources

  1. Weak Gravitational Lensing, Eqs. 3.11-3.12
  2. Cosmology with cosmic shear observations: a review, Eqs. 25-27

Keep reading

What this page links to directly

See this series on the content map →

Weak gravitational lensing and mass maps · Reading path

From galaxy shapes to a map of mass

  1. ArticleHow can galaxies that are barely stretched map dark matter?
  2. You are hereConvergence, shear and what a galaxy shape measures
  3. ArticleTurning a shear field into a mass map
  4. ArticleShear correlation functions and redshift tomography
  5. ArticleRecompute shear correlations and tomography from a simulation
  6. ArticleHow to read the DES Year 3 lensing and clustering analysis
Something broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy