Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics
Stellar Activity and Radial Velocity

A star can fake a wobble

A dark patch on a spinning star can imitate part of a planet’s pull. It hides light from one side of the star, changing the average velocity carried by the light that reaches us.

One star contributes many shifted lines

Imagine an unresolved star turning in front of you. One edge approaches, the other recedes. Light from the approaching edge has shorter wavelengths, toward the blue; light from the receding edge has longer wavelengths, toward the red. This is the Doppler effect. Each patch contributes its own slightly shifted absorption notch. Their sum is one broadened line.

Now put a dark patch on the receding half. It contributes less light, so less of the combined line comes from positive, receding velocities. The line’s centre moves toward the blue. Nothing has pushed the whole star toward us: the weights in an average have changed. When the patch reaches the approaching half, the shift reverses.

A companion produces a different physical change. It pulls the star around their shared centre of mass, shifting all the local contributions together. Both mechanisms can move the line’s centre, the wavelength that averages the absorption across it. A velocity inferred from that centre can contain both contributions.

Reading: Dumusque, Boisse & Santos — SOAP 2.0, arXiv:1409.3594v1 · Haywood et al. — CoRoT-7, arXiv:1407.1044v1

The darkest moment need not give the largest shift

A small equatorial spot near the middle of the visible disk can hide plenty of light while its local rotational velocity toward or away from us is almost zero. Near an edge, its projected velocity is larger, but we see less of the patch. The brightness dip and the apparent velocity therefore need not reach their extremes together. Their timing carries information about how the signal was made.

The same missing light moves the photocentre, the star’s brightness-weighted apparent position. Hide light on the right and that position shifts left. For a rigidly rotating star with identical local line shapes, the rotational velocity and this position shift are directly proportional. That simple case gives a way to connect two measurements of the same uneven surface.

Reading: Dumusque, Boisse & Santos — SOAP 2.0, arXiv:1409.3594v1 · Rajpaul et al. — joint activity processes, arXiv:1506.07304v1

Magnetic regions can change the line without much dimming

Bright gas rising through a stellar surface usually outweighs the light from darker sinking gas. The summed absorption line acquires a small net blueshift. Magnetic activity can weaken that convective motion, reducing the blueshift and making the local line relatively redder. A bright magnetic region can change a measured velocity even when its brightness contrast is small.

Dumusque, Boisse and Santos included this effect in SOAP 2.0 in 2014, alongside spots, bright regions and the dimmer appearance of the stellar limb. Their calculations showed why magnetic bright regions can dominate the activity velocity of a slowly rotating star. Brightness and apparent position remain useful clues, but neither supplies a universal subtraction for every velocity signal.

Reading: Dumusque, Boisse & Santos — SOAP 2.0, arXiv:1409.3594v1 · Haywood et al. — CoRoT-7, arXiv:1407.1044v1

A repeating signal needs more than a period

A long-lived region returns as the star rotates. Two similar regions can produce two prominent changes per turn, leaving a signal at half the rotation period. Irregular observation times can also mix a real variation with the observing schedule, creating an alternative apparent period called an alias. A smooth repeating curve is the beginning of an orbital investigation.

Independent channels help distinguish the possibilities. Brightness tracks missing or added light; activity-sensitive spectral lines respond to magnetic regions; changes in an absorption line’s shape reveal uneven contributions. A planet interpretation becomes stronger when one orbital model explains the observations while those stellar effects and their uncertainties are included.

The 2012 observations of CoRoT-7 offer a concrete example. Haywood and colleagues combined velocities with simultaneous brightness measurements to study a star whose activity obscures its planets. The companion data guide follows its published velocity table. It separates what was observed from the particular models used to explain it.

Reading: Haywood et al. — CoRoT-7, arXiv:1407.1044v1 · Rajpaul, Aigrain & Roberts — Ghost in the time series, arXiv:1510.05598v1

Exercises and explanations

  1. A dark region moves onto the receding half of the star. With convection switched off and no companion, which way should the measured centroid move?

    Read the explanation

    Toward the blue, or negative velocity in our away-positive convention. Removing positive-velocity absorption leaves a negative weighted average. At the disk centre the rotational contribution is close to zero, so the darkest moment need not be the largest velocity shift.

  2. A velocity varies while the brightness is almost steady. Has activity been ruled out?

    Read the explanation

    No. A region may alter convective line shifts much more than its continuum brightness. Several regions can also cancel some brightness variation. Activity indicators and their uncertainties help test that possibility.

Try the prediction

Make a false wobble

  1. Open the binary-star mass Lab and choose “A spot without a planet.” Pause and drag the visible region across the disk.
  2. Compare the synthetic line centroid, the gray companion-only reference and the apparent-position track. The reference stays at zero while the surface signal changes.
  3. Choose “Bright magnetic region” to add convective-shift effects. The surface, activity-area indicator and enlarged orbit are illustrative; the real CoRoT-7 records are shown separately.

Sources and calculation scope

  1. Dumusque, Boisse & Santos — SOAP 2.0, arXiv:1409.3594v1

    11 September 2014 version. Sections 2.1–2.3, Equations 1–7 and Figure 1: surface-profile integration, flux contrast and convective blueshift. Our identical Gaussian local profiles are a simpler independent mechanism model.

  2. Haywood et al. — CoRoT-7, arXiv:1407.1044v1

    3 July 2014 version. Sections 2–3 and 4.2, Equations 1–12 and Table A1. All 71 HARPS2012 numerical rows are retained; the tutorial does not reproduce the full contemporaneous-photometry analysis.

  3. Rajpaul et al. — joint activity processes, arXiv:1506.07304v1

    24 June 2015 version. Sections 3.1–3.4 and 4.1–4.2, Figures 3–4, Appendix A.2. Derivative covariance signs follow a lag equal to first time minus second time; kernel-width normalizations must be kept with their equations.

  4. Rajpaul, Aigrain & Roberts — Ghost in the time series, arXiv:1510.05598v1

    20 October 2015 version. Sections 2–3 and Figures 1–3: sampling-window and synthetic-content tests. The Alpha Centauri B analysis is a source guide, not our reproduced dataset.

Keep reading

What this page links to directly

See this series on the content map →

A star can fake a wobble · Reading path

A star can fake a wobble

  1. You are hereA star can fake a wobble
  2. ArticleThe speed hidden in a line
  3. ArticleFollow a spot’s missing light
  4. ArticleA posterior for two explanations
  5. ArticleReplay the HARPS campaign
  6. ArticleEarth-mass signals and active stars
  1. ArticleReplay the HARPS campaign
  2. ArticleThe speed hidden in a line
  3. ArticleEarth-mass signals and active stars
1 more group

Other articles that use the same experiments

Each experiment from this article that another series also uses, followed by the articles there.

  1. LabRadial Velocities, Active Stars and Binary Masses
  2. ArticleA starspot tells the time at its own latitude
  3. ArticleTurn changing starlight into competing periods
  4. ArticleHow a stellar wind slows rotation
  5. ArticleA rotation age is a distribution on a chosen scale
  6. ArticleHold out a whole cluster and test a rotation clock
  7. ArticleRead the evidence for changing magnetic braking
  8. ArticleThe stars that weighed the Milky Way’s dark centre
  9. ArticleA pulsar clock revealed an orbit losing energy
  10. ArticleThe four-day year of 51 Pegasi b
Something broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy