Skip to main content
Sandbox Physics

L2 · Derivation and worked examples

Turn an orbiting ring into a velocity–delay map

Sandbox Physics ·

A rotating ring maps to an ellipse because the delay follows the cloud’s position along the sightline and the Doppler velocity follows its motion along that same sightline. Keeping both quantities attached to each cloud makes the map a testable geometric prediction.

Give each point a position and a velocity

Prerequisite: the previous chapter’s extra-path derivation, trigonometry and circular motion. The observer remains on the positive zz axis. Define inclination ii as zero for a face-on ring. Let the angle ϕ\phi increase around the ring, starting at its nearest point. One convenient coordinate choice is

(x,y,z)=r(sin⁡ϕ,cos⁡icos⁡ϕ,sin⁡icos⁡ϕ).(x,y,z)=r(\sin\phi,\cos i\cos\phi,\sin i\cos\phi).

This angle origin is chosen for the derivation; a numerical implementation may start its azimuth elsewhere without changing the ring. In a circular orbit around a point mass MM, gravitational acceleration balances the acceleration needed to bend the path:

GMr2=vK2r,vK=GMr.\frac{GM}{r^2}=\frac{v_{\rm K}^2}{r},\qquad v_{\rm K}=\sqrt{\frac{GM}{r}}.

Here GG is the gravitational constant. Differentiate the position with respect to time, using angular speed vK/rv_{\rm K}/r. The sightline component is vz=−vKsin⁡isin⁡ϕv_z=-v_{\rm K}\sin i\sin\phi. We call recession positive, so v=−vzv=-v_z. Combining velocity and delay gives

v=vKsin⁡isin⁡ϕ,τ=rc(1−sin⁡icos⁡ϕ).v=v_{\rm K}\sin i\sin\phi,\qquad \tau=\frac{r}{c}(1-\sin i\cos\phi).

A cloud on the near or far edge has zero recession velocity. A cloud on either side reaches the largest projected speed and has delay r/cr/c. The two measurements come from different projections of the same orbit.

Eliminate the hidden angle

Square the normalized velocity and normalized displacement from the mean delay. Their sum is one:

(vvKsin⁡i)2+(τ−r/c(r/c)sin⁡i)2=1.\left(\frac{v}{v_{\rm K}\sin i}\right)^2+ \left(\frac{\tau-r/c}{(r/c)\sin i}\right)^2=1.

This is an ellipse in the velocity–delay plane. The expression applies when sin⁡i\sin i is nonzero; the face-on ring collapses to zero projected speed and one delay.

Worked example. Set r=20r=20 light-days, M=5.0×107M⊙M=5.0\times10^7M_\odot and i=30∘i=30^\circ. Converting the radius to metres and using Newtonian gravity gives vK≈3.58×103 km s−1v_{\rm K}\approx3.58\times10^3\,\mathrm{km\,s^{-1}}. The projected extrema are about 1.79×103 km s−11.79\times10^3\,\mathrm{km\,s^{-1}}, at a delay of twenty days. The near and far edges give ten and thirty days at zero projected velocity.

An ideal rotating ring traces an ellipse, with near-side response at ten days and far-side response at thirty days.

Original analytic ring map for the worked example. Positions on the line are possible responses to a short central flash. It is a model response, not a recovered map of NGC 5548. The line thickness is a drawing choice.

Turn the ring into an annulus

A finite annulus contains rings with different radii. Each contributes its own ellipse. Outer rings have longer characteristic delays and smaller circular speeds; inner rings respond sooner and span larger speeds.

The chosen weights matter. Equal numbers of equal-response clouds per unit radius are different from a uniform response per unit area: area grows with radius. In the Lab, the model uses the documented cloud weights to build both the delay map and the emission-line response. Changing the radial width spreads the response over more delays. It also combines different circular speeds.

The map is a response distribution. Brightness at a particular observing time requires one further operation: send the earlier continuum light through this distribution. A cloud answering at delay fifteen days samples the driver fifteen days before the observing time. Adding the weighted cloud contributions makes the light curve.

Add a prescribed radial motion

To diagnose signs, first imagine only radial inflow. Near-side gas moves away from us toward the centre, so it is redshifted and responds early. Far-side gas moves toward us, so it is blueshifted and responds late. Outflow reverses that ordering.

Adding a radial velocity to circular motion tilts the association between velocity and delay. In this teaching model it is a prescribed instantaneous velocity field. A cloud with a radial component is not being evolved on a permanently circular orbit. An observed red-blue asymmetry also depends on response weights, obscuration and line blending; a dynamical interpretation should test those alternatives.

Predict, calculate, explain

  1. Keep radius and inclination fixed, and multiply the central mass by four. How does the map change?
  2. Double every ring radius at fixed mass. What happens to delays and circular speeds?
  3. Turn the ring face-on. Does a narrow line imply a small mass?
  4. Suppose the blue side responds later than the red side. What sign of radial motion would the simple symmetric model suggest?
Answers
  1. Circular speed doubles. The ellipse widens horizontally; its delay range stays fixed.
  2. Delays double. Speeds decrease by a factor of 2\sqrt{2}. This follows from inverse-square gravity and the extra photon path.
  3. No. A face-on disk hides its orbital velocities across the sky. Geometry has removed the projected width.
  4. Inflow. Near-side inflow is redshifted and has the shorter path. The interpretation is conditional on the symmetric illumination and response assumptions.

Sources

Pancoast, Brewer and Treu, arXiv:1407.2941v2, Sections 2.4–2.5, for distinguishing position, response weighting and kinematics in a phenomenological cloud model.

Horne and collaborators, arXiv:2003.01448v2, Sections IV–V. The paper’s recovered maps are an observational inference; the ellipse above is an independently derived ideal ring.

Try the prediction

Watch one geometry feed two plots

  1. Predict the effect of multiplying mass by four at fixed radius and inclination.
  2. Keep radial spread at zero and compare the velocity–delay ellipse before and after changing only mass.
  3. Check its velocity extent and delay endpoints. Then use a finite radial spread to superpose rings.

Keep reading

What this page links to directly

See this series on the content map →

Measure a black hole with light echoes · Reading path

Measure a black hole with light echoes

  1. ArticleHow a black hole can be measured with an echo
  2. ArticleFind the extra distance travelled by an echo
  3. You are hereTurn an orbiting ring into a velocity–delay map
  4. ArticleMeasure a lag before turning it into a mass
  5. ArticleRecompute an observed echo in NGC 5548
  6. ArticleRead a velocity–delay map as an inference from changing spectra
Something broken, confusing, or missing on this page?Tell us
What kind of feedback?

Sent with this page’s address, its Lab ID, the site language and your device type. Please leave out personal details. Feedback is kept for up to 12 months.Privacy policy