Load, shear and moment
Downward loading is positive; upward displacement and sagging moment are positive. Shear jumps at a point load; moment remains continuous.
Can measured bending reveal material stiffness? Yes. With the supports and section known, the load–deflection slope gives the elastic modulus through a beam model. A short, deep beam also shears; ignoring that extra deflection makes the inferred modulus too low.
Load solid or hollow beams and measure their stiffness. Compare bending and shear deflection, then fit the same gauge readings with either theory.
BackgroundThe supports hold the beam while the copper shoe loads it slowly. The colored section shows axial tension and compression; the gold gauge follows the magnified neutral axis.
Why it mattersA deep beam can deflect more than bending theory predicts. Ignoring the extra shear motion can make a stiff material look softer in a measurement.
Downward loading is positive; upward displacement and sagging moment are positive. Shear jumps at a point load; moment remains continuous.
The solid section has no inner rectangle. A positive moment compresses the top fibers; the hollow-section plot leaves the void empty.
Bending-only kinematics equates slope and section rotation. Adding shear separates them; centerline slope can jump at a point load, while section rotation stays continuous.
The first area moment and local material width give the Jourawski shear field. Its energy gives five-sixths of the area for a solid rectangle; the tube uses a width-averaged one-dimensional approximation.
The simply supported end moments are zero. At a clamp, section rotation is fixed; centerline slope can include shear. The plotted model difference estimates omitted shear, not the full three-dimensional error.
A free-intercept fit uses simulated gauge readings. Known geometry and the chosen inference theory supply unit-modulus compliance; the fixed distributed load enters the intercept.
Typical misconceptionA low stress guarantees that a short beam follows bending-only theory.
Better mental modelShear can matter in a deep section even at low stress. The reference adds shear flexibility, but still omits local load effects and three-dimensional warping.
Typical misconceptionA lower fitted modulus proves the material became softer.
Better mental modelKeep the same short-beam observations and change only the inference model. Including the missing shear contribution can recover the original modulus.
Typical misconceptionEvery cross-section is perpendicular to the bent centerline.
Better mental modelThat is the bending-only assumption. The shear-flexible scene rotates sections by the bending rotation and shifts their centers by the total displacement.
Watch Simply supported, then drag the copper shoe.
What to observe: Loading pauses and both reactions change with the lever arms. Drag the gold gauge to sample a new section.Choose Cantilever tip load.
What to observe: The clamp supplies a vertical force and a holding couple. The free end moves most; the couple appears in the model checks.Choose Rectangular tube and inspect the separate data row.
What to observe: The section has a real hollow interior. Its stress map colors only the walls, and the moment and curvature plots show the selected model.Compare Shear omitted and Shear adds deflection.
What to observe: Both use the same short geometry. The bending-only case warns about slenderness; the shear case adds deflection and allows valid load observations.On Shear adds deflection, open Measure the stiffness and switch Inference model to Shear flexible.
What to observe: The raw points stay fixed. The bending-only estimate is low; adding shear recovers the material modulus for these synthetic data.Open Geometry, material and display to add noise, then acquire nine load steps and export the observations.
What to observe: Only points inside the selected model screens are retained. Yield checks cover axial bending stress; plasticity, shear yield and instability require further models.