---
title: "Let returning gas become escaping light"
description: "Solve a causal energy-reservoir model, compare rapid and slow escape, and separate a bolometric toy from band-limited observations."
canonical_url: "https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/tidal-disruption-fallback/diffusion-and-observed-light/"
language: "en"
page_type: "story"
alternate_languages:
  zh-CN: "https://sandboxphysics.com/zh/stories/tidal-disruption-fallback/diffusion-and-observed-light/"
last_modified: "2026-11-16"
---

L3 · Derivation and worked examples

# Let returning gas become escaping light

Sandbox Physics · 2026-11-16

An energy reservoir lets light emerge later than the returning mass that supplies it. The simplest useful calculation keeps the orbit model fixed, prescribes a heating rate, and lets stored energy escape over a chosen time. It makes the delay understandable without treating one telescope band as a direct mass-flow meter.

## Separate mass, power and an observed flux

Prerequisites are the fallback calculation from the previous chapter and energy conservation. A mass rate $\dot M$ has units of kilograms per second. A heating power $H$ and an escaping luminosity $L$ have units of watts. Stored energy $E$ has units of joules. For comparison with astronomical tables, one watt is $10^7\,\mathrm{erg\,s^{-1}}$.

The Lab assigns a deliberately restricted heating law. First convert a fraction $\eta$ of the returning rest-mass energy into a candidate power, then cap the power admitted to the reservoir:

$$
\begin{gathered}
H(t)=\min\!\left[\eta\dot M(t)c^2,L_{\rm Edd}\right],\\
L_{\rm Edd}=1.26\times10^{38}
\frac{M_\bullet}{M_\odot}\,\mathrm{erg\,s^{-1}}.
\end{gathered}
$$

The second relation is the usual ionized-hydrogen electron-scattering scale. In a spherical static argument, outward radiation force on electrons balances inward gravity on the electron–proton pair. Real moving gas can differ substantially. Here the scale defines an imposed cap on heating; it is not a universal law that all tidal-disruption luminosities must obey.

The candidate power above the cap never enters this reservoir. Its physical destination lies outside the model. The efficiency is prescribed; calculating it would require a description of the shock or accretion flow that supplies the heat.

## Solve the reservoir before drawing its light

Take an escape time $\tau>0$. If a fraction $dt/\tau$ of stored energy escapes during a short interval $dt$, then $L=E/\tau$. Conservation inside this defined reservoir gives

$$
\frac{dE}{dt}=H-L,\qquad L=\frac{E}{\tau}.
$$

Start with zero stored energy before heating begins. Multiplying the differential equation by the integrating factor $e^{t/\tau}$ and integrating gives

$$
L(t)=\int_0^t\frac{H(t')}{\tau}
e^{-(t-t')/\tau}\,dt'.
$$

Every contribution comes from an earlier time. Heat deposited long ago has mostly escaped; recent heat is still partly stored. The exponential kernel integrates to one over all later times, so an isolated pulse ultimately releases all the energy admitted to the reservoir.

When heating is constant within a numerical bin of width $\Delta t$, the exact update between its endpoints is

$$
L_{\rm end}=H+(L_{\rm start}-H)e^{-\Delta t/\tau}.
$$

A plotted value inside the bin must use the elapsed time from the bin’s start in that same update. For the geometric centre $t_{\rm c}=\sqrt{t_{\rm left}t_{\rm right}}$ used here, that elapsed time is $t_{\rm c}-t_{\rm left}$. It equals half the width only for an arithmetic centre. Assigning an endpoint value to an interior time would create a timing error. The limit $\tau\to0$ gives instantaneous escape, $L=H$, and is handled separately.

## A pulse gives an independent check

**Worked example.** Feed the reservoir a constant $H_0=10^{44}\,\mathrm{erg\,s^{-1}}$ for twenty days, then switch it off. Use $\tau=10$ days and a million-solar-mass black hole, whose imposed cap lies above this input. During heating, $L/H_0=1-e^{-t/\tau}$. At day twenty the luminosity is $0.864665H_0$.

After switch-off, the stored energy decays exponentially. Twenty more days later, the luminosity is $0.864665e^{-2}H_0=0.117020H_0$. Integrating the full luminosity curve, including its tail, yields $H_0$ times twenty days. A test that checks both these values and the total energy probes the implementation more strongly than copying its numerical update.

![A twenty-day heating pulse drives three-day and fifteen-day escape reservoirs; the longer escape time produces a broader light curve and longer tail.](https://sandboxphysics.com/astronomy/ac53/figures/stored-light.en.svg)

An analytic twenty-day heating pulse drives two reservoirs. A long escape time makes the rise slower and leaves a longer tail after heating stops. The input and output are powers; this is a teaching reservoir, not observed photometry or a radiation-transfer simulation.

Increasing the escape time while keeping the fallback record fixed changes the escaping light but leaves the debris orbits and mass-return curve unchanged. A change in the light curve can originate after orbital return. Identifying the actual storage process requires additional information about the gas.

## A detector sees only part of the escaping spectrum

Bolometric luminosity means power added over all wavelengths. A telescope’s band flux is power per collecting area within its selected energy or wavelength range, after the relevant spectral modelling and absorption treatment. Even if total power followed fallback exactly, the fraction in one band could evolve.

The simple limit $F=L/(4\pi D^2)$ assumes isotropic emission, a suitable luminosity distance $D$ and a bolometric flux. It does not convert an X-ray table into a bolometric luminosity without a spectral correction. [Lodato and Rossi’s multiband calculation](https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/410/1/359/1034124), Sections 3–4, illustrates how different bands can acquire different decline shapes from the same underlying accretion model.

The companion tutorial preserves ASASSN-14li’s published X-ray fluxes and errors. It normalizes the observed and model curves separately to ask a narrower question: how similar are their declining shapes under an explicit choice of time origin? This loses the absolute amplitude deliberately. A good shape match would still leave distance, spectrum, absorption and the mass-to-light process to be determined.

## Exercises in causality and units

1. Heating switches off. Can the model luminosity remain positive? Where does the energy come from?
2. At fixed fallback, increase the efficiency until heating is capped throughout the peak. Does a further increase necessarily raise the peak light?
3. A programme feeds uncapped heating into a reservoir, then caps only the escaping light. Is it the same model as the one above?
4. An X-ray flux falls twice as fast as a normalized fallback curve. Give two physical quantities that could vary without changing the debris return times.

Answers with the reasoning

1. Yes. Stored energy continues to escape. The tail must be included when checking the total admitted and emitted energy.
2. No. While the cap is active, the admitted heating stays fixed. The reservoir responds to that admitted power, not to the rejected candidate power.
3. No. It stores the excess energy and changes the later output. Its energy equation and treatment of capped emission would have to be defined separately.
4. The spectrum’s temperature can change the fraction inside the X-ray band; the intervening absorbing column can also change. Spectral observations can test these possibilities in an individual event.

## Sources

[Lodato and Rossi, Multiband light curves of tidal disruption events](https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/410/1/359/1034124), Sections 3–4. We use their distinction between multiband and bolometric evolution; the single-reservoir calculation here is an explicitly defined teaching model.

[Holoien and colleagues, CDS J/MNRAS/455/2918](https://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/VizieR?-source=J/MNRAS/455/2918), the observed ASASSN-14li measurements compared in the method tutorial.

[Law-Smith and colleagues, arXiv:2007.10996v3](https://arxiv.org/pdf/2007.10996v3), Section 1 and Equations 3–4, for fallback as a separate mass-return quantity.

## Try the prediction

### [Delay the light without changing the orbit](https://sandboxphysics.com/labs/tidal-disruption-fallback/)

1. Predict which curve changes when the diffusion time increases.
2. Keep mass and penetration fixed; compare a short and a long diffusion time.
3. Check that fallback stays fixed while the luminosity broadens, then explain the stored energy.

### [Follow light from a supplied disk](https://sandboxphysics.com/labs/black-hole-light/)

1. Compare the saved disk spectra at different supply rates and inclinations.
2. Keep this separate steady-disk radiation calculation distinct from the debris return and illustrative transient reservoir.

## Keep reading

Follow stellar debris back to a black hole · Reading path

### Follow stellar debris back to a black hole

1. [Article **Why a shredded star can take weeks to brighten**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/tidal-disruption-fallback/why-a-shredded-star-brightens-late/)
2. [Article **Give the debris its orbital energies**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/tidal-disruption-fallback/tides-and-frozen-orbital-energy/)
3. [Article **Turn orbital energies into a return-rate curve**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/tidal-disruption-fallback/orbital-periods-and-fallback/)
4. [You are here **Let returning gas become escaping light**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/tidal-disruption-fallback/diffusion-and-observed-light/)
5. [Article **Replay debris orbits beside a real X-ray light curve**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/tidal-disruption-fallback/replaying-debris-and-a-light-curve/)
6. [Article **Read the evidence for colliding tidal streams**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/tidal-disruption-fallback/reading-stream-collisions-and-polarization/)

1 more group

### Other articles that use the same experiments

Each experiment from this article that another series also uses, followed by the articles there.

1. [Lab **Black Hole Light Lab**](https://sandboxphysics.com/labs/black-hole-light/)
2. [Article **Why gas around a black hole shines**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/accretion-disks/why-accretion-disks-shine/)
3. [Article **Where a thin disk heats**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/accretion-disks/thin-disk-torque-temperature/)
4. [Article **Adding the spectra of differently heated rings**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/accretion-disks/adding-disk-blackbody-spectra/)
5. [Article **How frequency and brightness change on the way out**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/accretion-disks/photon-frequency-and-brightness/)
6. [Article **Which disk surface a light path meets first**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/accretion-disks/first-opaque-disk-crossing/)
7. [Article **Recompute a disk image and spectrum from saved intersections**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/accretion-disks/recompute-frozen-disk-light/)
8. [Article **How to read a thin-disk spectrum paper**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/accretion-disks/reading-thin-disk-spectrum-paper/)
9. [Article **Why collapse does not need a perfectly spherical star**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/astronomy-gravity/penrose-trapped-surfaces/)
