{
  "dataLabel": "real observation: recomputed from public NANOGrav 15-year products with a simplified noise model",
  "publishedReference": {
    "source": "arXiv:2306.16213v1 section 3 (amplitude) and section 4 (optimal statistic)",
    "amplitudeAtOneOverYear": "2.4 (+0.7 / -0.6) e-15, median and 90 % interval, gamma = 13/3",
    "optimalStatisticSignalToNoise": "4 +- 1 for the gamma = 13/3 common process",
    "optimalStatisticPValue": "5e-5 from 400000 phase shifts, 1.8e-4 from simulations, 1.9e-4 analytic; sky scrambles p < 1e-4"
  },
  "publishedAmplitudeSquared": 5.76e-30,
  "models": [
    {
      "noiseModel": "published-spectrum",
      "description": "NG15 per-pulsar spectrum as published (it already contains white noise, so white noise is counted twice)",
      "timingModelMarginalised": true,
      "singleTemplate": {
        "hellingsDowns": {
          "amplitudeSquared": 3.4614442097001955e-31,
          "amplitudeSquaredUncertainty": 8.419387072894272e-31,
          "signalToNoise": 0.4111278148553253
        },
        "monopole": {
          "amplitudeSquared": 1.4514377714219427e-31,
          "amplitudeSquaredUncertainty": 1.5153781988941482e-31,
          "signalToNoise": 0.9578056306215397
        },
        "dipole": {
          "amplitudeSquared": 1.7139055775003448e-31,
          "amplitudeSquaredUncertainty": 2.417925797965457e-31,
          "signalToNoise": 0.7088329918736531
        }
      },
      "hellingsDownsAmplitude": 5.883403954939857e-16,
      "multipleTemplate": {
        "hellingsDowns": {
          "amplitudeSquared": 2.343103259531303e-31,
          "amplitudeSquaredUncertainty": 1.0408250207666434e-30,
          "signalToNoise": 0.22511980522964725
        },
        "monopole": {
          "amplitudeSquared": 1.4328484059203658e-31,
          "amplitudeSquaredUncertainty": 2.073247167773748e-31,
          "signalToNoise": 0.6911131620929489
        },
        "dipole": {
          "amplitudeSquared": -1.3235631246330945e-32,
          "amplitudeSquaredUncertainty": 3.8698626248867607e-31,
          "signalToNoise": -0.034201811612675125
        }
      },
      "bins": [
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 12.781625020547244,
          "pairCount": 147,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 3.143012857637835e-33,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 4.56179449415244e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": 0.41529921198843817
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 23.575585128021974,
          "pairCount": 147,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 4.897162639421277e-31,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 6.903788104761386e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": 0.29072041818925975
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 32.553533649705344,
          "pairCount": 148,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 2.528051033057828e-31,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 5.126985951810085e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": 0.18059931522395
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 40.84529566268244,
          "pairCount": 147,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 2.461464741788533e-31,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 5.181909937202273e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": 0.08497266568731948
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 48.85457175354877,
          "pairCount": 148,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 2.507690002462099e-31,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 4.585471658330337e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": 0.004228249004186835
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 57.374400249143584,
          "pairCount": 147,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 8.451466701785269e-32,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 4.287536931706712e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": -0.06494465098218039
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 65.82761081269331,
          "pairCount": 147,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 6.676314793585161e-32,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 5.727135912923715e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": -0.11409505195241276
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 76.51574070378582,
          "pairCount": 148,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 4.378082805678877e-32,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 6.29776558454197e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": -0.1471868728303678
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 86.7012037424536,
          "pairCount": 147,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 1.045986569345701e-31,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 4.928922091080721e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": -0.1496442117485196
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 97.43575600611875,
          "pairCount": 148,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 6.827729553805966e-32,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 4.790581734422148e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": -0.1252279190721335
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 107.67150020699658,
          "pairCount": 147,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 2.7127928397397725e-32,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 7.795847448159814e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": -0.08143513790913826
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 118.78093627653428,
          "pairCount": 147,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": -3.3618706250270733e-32,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 8.727256477483263e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": -0.01864249191688594
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 131.8484128460689,
          "pairCount": 148,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 2.454550796494104e-31,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 1.2043882296962313e-30,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": 0.06400669137101112
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 145.55987456713007,
          "pairCount": 147,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": -9.498937530311891e-33,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 1.2622195920712054e-30,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": 0.14638533518508035
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 162.32733468660965,
          "pairCount": 148,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 9.019499626367585e-31,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 1.2906443233312823e-30,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": 0.22092494352259945
        }
      ],
      "phaseShiftNull": {
        "trials": 1000,
        "mean": 0.0015185167016173351,
        "standardDeviation": 0.16756079868177826,
        "observedInNullStandardDeviations": 2.4445413329141155,
        "exceedances": 12,
        "empiricalPValue": 0.012987012987012988
      },
      "skyScrambleNull": {
        "trials": 1000,
        "mean": -0.004797630492465332,
        "standardDeviation": 0.19388903737867366,
        "observedInNullStandardDeviations": 2.1451725738132903,
        "exceedances": 27,
        "empiricalPValue": 0.027972027972027972
      }
    },
    {
      "noiseModel": "spectrum-minus-white-floor",
      "description": "NG15 per-pulsar spectrum minus its value at 2e-7 Hz (preferred)",
      "timingModelMarginalised": true,
      "singleTemplate": {
        "hellingsDowns": {
          "amplitudeSquared": 4.899022755374863e-31,
          "amplitudeSquaredUncertainty": 6.7818335257639105e-31,
          "signalToNoise": 0.722374375124909
        },
        "monopole": {
          "amplitudeSquared": 1.316026400626266e-31,
          "amplitudeSquaredUncertainty": 1.1913641872485926e-31,
          "signalToNoise": 1.104638207788985
        },
        "dipole": {
          "amplitudeSquared": 1.9604517968521135e-31,
          "amplitudeSquaredUncertainty": 1.9049620092663792e-31,
          "signalToNoise": 1.0291290783311233
        }
      },
      "hellingsDownsAmplitude": 6.999301933317967e-16,
      "multipleTemplate": {
        "hellingsDowns": {
          "amplitudeSquared": 3.2091006511869183e-31,
          "amplitudeSquaredUncertainty": 8.330526579532738e-31,
          "signalToNoise": 0.385221824880957
        },
        "monopole": {
          "amplitudeSquared": 1.0754114147655411e-31,
          "amplitudeSquaredUncertainty": 1.6338455556613835e-31,
          "signalToNoise": 0.6582087340135481
        },
        "dipole": {
          "amplitudeSquared": 3.647514092488905e-32,
          "amplitudeSquaredUncertainty": 3.0386132353545407e-31,
          "signalToNoise": 0.12003877459789049
        }
      },
      "bins": [
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 12.781625020547244,
          "pairCount": 147,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 6.731566024286775e-32,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 3.8944436514889638e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": 0.41529921198843817
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 23.575585128021974,
          "pairCount": 147,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 4.659833252897856e-31,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 5.02344786858381e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": 0.29072041818925975
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 32.553533649705344,
          "pairCount": 148,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 2.2472470777475515e-31,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 3.842151506737964e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": 0.18059931522395
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 40.84529566268244,
          "pairCount": 147,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 2.4376873874208793e-31,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 4.111011260778199e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": 0.08497266568731948
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 48.85457175354877,
          "pairCount": 148,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 2.3516396054148265e-31,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 3.8159828825420163e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": 0.004228249004186835
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 57.374400249143584,
          "pairCount": 147,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 7.810332456179855e-32,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 3.191694612310176e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": -0.06494465098218039
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 65.82761081269331,
          "pairCount": 147,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 8.118641089418949e-32,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 4.380348935192522e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": -0.11409505195241276
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 76.51574070378582,
          "pairCount": 148,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": -4.1008942370879513e-32,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 4.878773019345165e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": -0.1471868728303678
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 86.7012037424536,
          "pairCount": 147,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 8.213100426746486e-32,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 4.033670236775877e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": -0.1496442117485196
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 97.43575600611875,
          "pairCount": 148,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 4.6212630840724463e-32,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 3.8058939989509414e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": -0.1252279190721335
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 107.67150020699658,
          "pairCount": 147,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": -6.754499969719438e-32,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 6.16193153768747e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": -0.08143513790913826
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 118.78093627653428,
          "pairCount": 147,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": -4.3396387161312817e-32,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 6.63807998861968e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": -0.01864249191688594
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 131.8484128460689,
          "pairCount": 148,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 2.2467968958101083e-31,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 8.756973991613952e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": 0.06400669137101112
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 145.55987456713007,
          "pairCount": 147,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": -1.1762865586960703e-31,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 1.025013517881235e-30,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": 0.14638533518508035
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 162.32733468660965,
          "pairCount": 148,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 7.27281473826308e-31,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 1.0529462784539945e-30,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": 0.22092494352259945
        }
      ],
      "phaseShiftNull": {
        "trials": 1000,
        "mean": 0.0035464334000680155,
        "standardDeviation": 0.18864094652898744,
        "observedInNullStandardDeviations": 3.8105615718715797,
        "exceedances": 1,
        "empiricalPValue": 0.001998001998001998
      },
      "skyScrambleNull": {
        "trials": 1000,
        "mean": -0.00401479635362433,
        "standardDeviation": 0.21568248333570772,
        "observedInNullStandardDeviations": 3.3678635383102278,
        "exceedances": 3,
        "empiricalPValue": 0.003996003996003996
      }
    },
    {
      "noiseModel": "common-process-only",
      "description": "only the gamma = 13/3 common process at A = 2.4e-15; intrinsic red noise ignored",
      "timingModelMarginalised": true,
      "singleTemplate": {
        "hellingsDowns": {
          "amplitudeSquared": 5.490940793610116e-30,
          "amplitudeSquaredUncertainty": 6.60720727560929e-31,
          "signalToNoise": 8.310532066823592
        },
        "monopole": {
          "amplitudeSquared": -9.598024106355432e-33,
          "amplitudeSquaredUncertainty": 1.2191901053561437e-31,
          "signalToNoise": -0.07872458990759038
        },
        "dipole": {
          "amplitudeSquared": 7.2508364318130286e-31,
          "amplitudeSquaredUncertainty": 1.847445448962314e-31,
          "signalToNoise": 3.9247905457158314
        }
      },
      "hellingsDownsAmplitude": 2.343275654636073e-15,
      "multipleTemplate": {
        "hellingsDowns": {
          "amplitudeSquared": 5.727737398946328e-30,
          "amplitudeSquaredUncertainty": 7.4655821911860235e-31,
          "signalToNoise": 7.6721911999155
        },
        "monopole": {
          "amplitudeSquared": -3.8939635280530746e-31,
          "amplitudeSquaredUncertainty": 1.3446556717499562e-31,
          "signalToNoise": -2.8958815329915715
        },
        "dipole": {
          "amplitudeSquared": 2.453003052918755e-31,
          "amplitudeSquaredUncertainty": 2.1742990257362544e-31,
          "signalToNoise": 1.1281810937150776
        }
      },
      "bins": [
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 12.781625020547244,
          "pairCount": 147,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": -1.8835378403499617e-30,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 4.203159387138806e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": 0.41529921198843817
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 23.575585128021974,
          "pairCount": 147,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 3.68435305930748e-30,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 4.187901713963257e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": 0.29072041818925975
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 32.553533649705344,
          "pairCount": 148,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 7.204604205978738e-30,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 4.116495005321757e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": 0.18059931522395
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 40.84529566268244,
          "pairCount": 147,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": -5.436483637663699e-31,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 4.399804704444134e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": 0.08497266568731948
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 48.85457175354877,
          "pairCount": 148,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": -1.8439433148560278e-30,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 4.163783737598677e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": 0.004228249004186835
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 57.374400249143584,
          "pairCount": 147,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": -6.164010040158547e-30,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 4.921984601567321e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": -0.06494465098218039
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 65.82761081269331,
          "pairCount": 147,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 1.930832131298474e-30,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 5.018144892676109e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": -0.11409505195241276
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 76.51574070378582,
          "pairCount": 148,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": -7.720681108753518e-31,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 4.381943044614357e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": -0.1471868728303678
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 86.7012037424536,
          "pairCount": 147,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": -2.059953247894825e-30,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 4.8722622984448655e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": -0.1496442117485196
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 97.43575600611875,
          "pairCount": 148,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": -1.0007731288458012e-30,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 4.931026568667622e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": -0.1252279190721335
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 107.67150020699658,
          "pairCount": 147,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": -2.717625567371665e-30,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 4.619295260379394e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": -0.08143513790913826
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 118.78093627653428,
          "pairCount": 147,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 9.759193435240131e-31,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 4.984899476827583e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": -0.01864249191688594
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 131.8484128460689,
          "pairCount": 148,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 5.8379348081491256e-31,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 5.437164313483073e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": 0.06400669137101112
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 145.55987456713007,
          "pairCount": 147,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": -2.191789427757432e-30,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 6.237967476715121e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": 0.14638533518508035
        },
        {
          "meanAngleDegrees": 162.32733468660965,
          "pairCount": 148,
          "weightedMeanCorrelation": 2.513013350695395e-30,
          "uncertaintyIgnoringPairCovariance": 5.994312154242545e-31,
          "hellingsDownsAtMeanAngle": 0.22092494352259945
        }
      ],
      "phaseShiftNull": {
        "trials": 1000,
        "mean": -0.013954751244599958,
        "standardDeviation": 7.446047446843209,
        "observedInNullStandardDeviations": 1.1179739153552404,
        "exceedances": 137,
        "empiricalPValue": 0.13786213786213786
      },
      "skyScrambleNull": {
        "trials": 1000,
        "mean": -0.23625649189421713,
        "standardDeviation": 6.550290736512923,
        "observedInNullStandardDeviations": 1.3047952987912306,
        "exceedances": 99,
        "empiricalPValue": 0.0999000999000999
      }
    }
  ],
  "runSeconds": 13.1
}
