---
title: "Search one CHIME burst for a lens echo and test R3's repeats"
description: "Fit a frozen CHIME dynamic spectrum with and without a lensed copy, then compare the repeat statistics of FRB 20180916B with what a lens allows."
canonical_url: "https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/fast-radio-burst-echoes/fit-a-chime-burst-and-r3-repeats/"
language: "en"
page_type: "story"
alternate_languages:
  zh-CN: "https://sandboxphysics.com/zh/stories/fast-radio-burst-echoes/fit-a-chime-burst-and-r3-repeats/"
last_modified: "2026-11-14"
---

[Fast radio bursts: repeats, echoes and plasma lenses](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/fast-radio-burst-echoes/)

# Search one CHIME burst for a lens echo and test R3's repeats

Sandbox Physics · 2026-11-14

This guide fits a frozen CHIME dynamic spectrum of FRB 20180725A with one burst and with one burst plus a lensed copy. It finds no copy: the best copy improves $\chi^2$ by only 0.63, and pure noise does at least that well 67 percent of the time. Injections show what the fit can and cannot see. It then measures the repeat statistics of FRB 20180916B from the second CHIME catalogue and works out what lens would be needed to fake them. Every number on this page comes from one script that runs in under a minute.

Read [the Gaussian lens chapter](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/fast-radio-burst-echoes/gaussian-plasma-lens-images/) and [the timing-statistics chapter](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/fast-radio-burst-echoes/repetition-statistics-source-or-path/) first. Both inputs are observed CHIME data; the noise trials and injections are synthetic.

## Get the files

Put these eight files in one empty folder:

- [README.md](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/fast-radio-burst-echoes/materials/README.md), run instructions, results and failure cases
- [propagation\_fit.py](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/fast-radio-burst-echoes/materials/propagation_fit.py), the one-burst and burst-plus-copy fits
- [repeat\_statistics.py](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/fast-radio-burst-echoes/materials/repeat_statistics.py), gaps, windows, folding and lens requirements
- [reproduce.py](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/fast-radio-burst-echoes/materials/reproduce.py), runs both and compares every number
- [chime-frb20180725a-intensity.json](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/fast-radio-burst-echoes/materials/chime-frb20180725a-intensity.json), the frozen intensity cutout
- [r3-catalog2-rows.csv](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/fast-radio-burst-echoes/materials/r3-catalog2-rows.csv), the 142 catalogue rows of FRB 20180916B
- [expected-outputs.json](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/fast-radio-burst-echoes/materials/expected-outputs.json), the numbers quoted here
- [provenance.json](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/fast-radio-burst-echoes/materials/provenance.json), sources, data kinds and SHA-256 checksums

Then run:

```
python3 -m pip install numpy scipy
python3 reproduce.py
```

It exits with status 0 when every value matches the saved outputs to a relative $5\times10^{-3}$ or an absolute 0.05. The burst fit uses Nelder-Mead, which stops at a tolerance, so the last digits can differ between platforms. We ran it with Python 3.9.6, numpy 2.0.2 and scipy 1.13.1. The data come from the CHIME/FRB Collaboration: the First CHIME/FRB Catalog (DOI 10.11570/21.0007) for the cutout and the Second CHIME/FRB Catalog (DOI 10.11570/25.0066) for the rows. Cite them with any copy; no broader licence is asserted.

## Units and conventions

**Table 5.1** Units and conventions.

| Quantity | Convention |
| --- | --- |
| Time in the fit | ms; delays quoted at 600 MHz |
| Dispersion | $t=4.148808\,\mathrm{ms}\,\mathrm{DM}/\nu_{\rm GHz}^2$, DM in $\mathrm{pc\,cm^{-3}}$ |
| Scattering | one-sided exponential, $\tau(\nu)=\tau_{600}\,(\nu/600\,\mathrm{MHz})^{-4}$ |
| Catalogue time | mjd\_400, topocentric UTC referenced to 400.1953125 MHz |
| Selection | excluded\_flag = 0, one event per catalogue name |
| Lens model | Cordes et al. 2017 Eqs. 3, 14, 25, 26; $T_4=1$; lens width $a=3r_{\rm F}$ |

## Step 1: fit one burst

The cutout has 64 channels from 400 to 800 MHz and 38 time bins of 0.983 ms. Ten channels are fully masked, leaving 54. The burst model is a Gaussian of width $\sigma$ convolved with a one-sided exponential tail, shifted in each channel by a residual dispersion $\delta\mathrm{DM}$. Each channel gets its own amplitude and baseline, solved linearly; noise per channel comes from the off-pulse bins 0 to 7 and 22 to 37.

**Table 5.2** One-burst fit (model H0).

| Parameter | Value |
| --- | --- |
| Arrival at 600 MHz | 12.61 ms after window start |
| Width $\sigma$ | 0.601 ms |
| Scattering $\tau_{600}$ | 1.147 ms |
| Residual DM | 0.101 $\mathrm{pc\,cm^{-3}}$ |
| $\chi^2$ / degrees of freedom | 2478.8 / 1940 (reduced 1.28) |

A reduced $\chi^2$ of 1.28 means the model misses some structure. Keep that in mind when reading the significance below.

## Step 2: add a lensed copy

A plasma-lens echo is the same burst, weaker, later and, when the dispersive term dominates, with a delay that grows as $\nu^{-2}$. The constrained model adds one copy with a single amplitude ratio $r$ and delay shared by every channel:

$$
I_c(t)=A_c\left[s_c(t)+r\,s_c\left(t-\Delta t\,(\nu_c/600\,\mathrm{MHz})^{-2}\right)\right]+B_c .
$$

A second version, achromatic, uses the same delay in every channel. The scan covers delays from 0.5 to 9.5 ms (chromatic; longer copies leave the window at 400 MHz) or 0.5 to 20 ms (achromatic), and ratios from 0.05 to 1.5. The statistic is the largest drop $\Delta\chi^2$ over the grid. Its null distribution comes from 300 synthetic data sets: the best H0 model plus white noise with each channel's off-pulse scatter, seed 20261114.

**Table 5.3** Echo search on FRB 20180725A.

| Copy | max $\Delta\chi^2$ | null 95th / 99th percentile | false alarm probability |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| chromatic | 0.63 | 5.55 / 7.74 | 0.67 |
| achromatic | 1.33 | 7.51 / 11.45 | 0.81 |

No copy is detected. The best grid point sits at the smallest ratio, 0.05, which is what an absent signal looks like. Rescaling the noise so the H0 fit has reduced $\chi^2=1$ gives false alarm probabilities of 0.68 and 0.86.

An earlier version gave each channel its own copy amplitude. It returned $\Delta\chi^2=104$ for an achromatic copy, an apparent detection. The 54 extra free amplitudes, fitted to a model that already misses structure, made that number meaningless. Sharing one ratio across the band is the physical constraint that turns the fit into a test.

## Step 3: what the fit can see

Inject a chromatic copy into the best H0 model, add noise, refit H0 and rescan.

**Table 5.4** Injection tests.

| Injected delay, ratio | $\Delta\chi^2$ | Recovered delay, ratio | Refit $\tau_{600}$ |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 4.0 ms, 0.50 | 23.8 | 4.3 ms, 0.15 | 3.36 ms |
| 4.0 ms, 0.15 | 5.97 | 4.8 ms, 0.05 | 2.01 ms |
| 0.5 ms, 0.50 | 6.32 | 8.3 ms, 0.05 | 1.32 ms |

The first row is the main failure case. The copy is clearly detected at nearly the right delay, but the refit scattering tail triples and swallows most of it, so the ratio comes back three times too small. A scattering tail and a delayed copy are partly degenerate at 1 ms resolution. The second row is marginal, near the 95th percentile of the null. The third shows that a copy closer than one time bin is lost: the scan finds noise at a wrong delay.

## Step 4: repeat statistics of FRB 20180916B

repeat\_statistics.py reads the 142 catalogue rows, keeps 131 taken during nominal operation and merges sub-bursts into 104 events.

**Table 5.5** Repeat statistics, Catalogue 2.

| Quantity | Value |
| --- | --- |
| Events, span | 104, MJD 58410.34 to 60125.65 |
| Gaps | 36.3 s to 112.7 d, median 14.9 d |
| Gaps under 1 h / 1 h to 1 d / over 1 d | 22 / 21 / 60 |
| Sub-burst offsets in one event | 0.10 to 68 ms (27 offsets) |
| Distance from transit, 95th percentile | 0.42 h; none beyond 3 h |
| Weibull shape, all gaps | $k=0.42$ |
| Window-only Poisson trials | $k$ from 0.60 to 0.84 (central 90 percent of 200) |
| Fraction in the published window at 16.35 d | 0.91 |
| Phase uncertainty at the last event | 0.99 cycles |
| Rayleigh peak, 15.5 to 17.5 d | 16.33 d |

The fold is a consistency check with topocentric 400 MHz times, not a new period measurement. The published period used barycentric times at infinite frequency. [Periodic activity from a fast radio burst source](https://arxiv.org/abs/2001.10275v5)

## Step 5: what a lens would need

For each delay, the script finds the gain-one image at $u^2=1/2$, where the delay is close to $t_{\rm DM0}\,\alpha/2e$. It fixes the lens width at $a=3r_{\rm F}$, solves for the column and computes free-free absorption with Eq. 26 of Cordes and colleagues. [Lensing of fast radio bursts by plasma structures in host galaxies](https://arxiv.org/abs/1703.06580v1)

**Table 5.6** Optical depth at 600 MHz of a lens that makes a gain-one echo.

| Echo delay | $\tau_{\rm ff}$, lens 1 pc from source | $\tau_{\rm ff}$, lens 1 kpc from source | $\alpha$ |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 36.3 s (shortest gap) | 0.37 | 0.012 | $4.1\times10^5$ |
| 1 day | 871 | 27.5 | $2.0\times10^7$ |
| 14.9 d (median gap) | 13000 | 412 | $7.7\times10^7$ |
| 16.35 d (period) | 14200 | 450 | $8.0\times10^7$ |

Only the shortest gap could escape absorption, and it would need an extreme lens with the source $1.7\times10^5$ lens radii off axis. None of this changes the basic count: one lens gives at most three copies with fixed delays.

## Failure cases and limits

- The null uses white noise. The reduced $\chi^2$ of 1.28 shows correlated residuals, so the false alarm probabilities are approximate.
- One copy, one ratio for all channels. A real lens gain changes with frequency; a copy that is bright in only part of the band would be missed.
- Delays below one 0.98 ms bin are not resolved, and a scattering tail can hide a copy a few ms late.
- The Weibull fit treats all gaps as one sample. The window-only trials are an idealized exposure; CHIME's real exposure varies from day to day.
- The lens requirement assumes a single Gaussian lens at $10^4$ K and $a=3r_{\rm F}$. A hotter lens absorbs less: $\tau_{\rm ff}\propto T_4^{-1.32}$.

## Lab tasks

Set the burst width in [the plasma-lens echo Lab](https://sandboxphysics.com/labs/frb-plasma-lens-echoes/) to about 0.6 ms, the width fitted here. Find a lens setting whose second copy is 4 ms late, and compare the time profile with the injection in Table 5.4.

The CHIME paper on the 16-day cycle is read figure by figure in the next guide: [how to read the CHIME paper on the 16-day FRB cycle](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/fast-radio-burst-echoes/reading-the-chime-r3-periodicity-paper/).

## Try it in the Lab

[FRB echoes through a plasma lens](https://sandboxphysics.com/labs/frb-plasma-lens-echoes/): Set the burst width to 0.6 ms and see how far apart copies must be to resolve.

## Sources

1. [Periodic activity from a fast radio burst source](https://arxiv.org/abs/2001.10275v5)
2. [Lensing of fast radio bursts by plasma structures in host galaxies](https://arxiv.org/abs/1703.06580v1)

## Keep reading

Fast radio bursts: repeats, echoes and plasma lenses · Reading path

### From one burst to source-or-path tests

1. [Article **Is a repeating radio flash the source repeating, or its path?**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/fast-radio-burst-echoes/repeat-or-echo/)
2. [Article **How a clump of plasma delays and bends a radio burst**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/fast-radio-burst-echoes/plasma-delay-and-bending/)
3. [Article **Images, gains and delays of a Gaussian plasma lens**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/fast-radio-burst-echoes/gaussian-plasma-lens-images/)
4. [Article **Telling source repetition from path effects with timing statistics**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/fast-radio-burst-echoes/repetition-statistics-source-or-path/)
5. [You are here **Search one CHIME burst for a lens echo and test R3's repeats**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/fast-radio-burst-echoes/fit-a-chime-burst-and-r3-repeats/)
6. [Article **How to read the CHIME paper on the 16-day FRB cycle**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/fast-radio-burst-echoes/reading-the-chime-r3-periodicity-paper/)
