---
title: "Freeze-in, hot relics and faster expansion"
description: "Follow the same equation below the hot-relic plateau, where feeble particles freeze in from nothing, then add a faster early expansion."
canonical_url: "https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/dark-matter-relics/freeze-in-hot-relics-and-faster-expansion/"
language: "en"
page_type: "story"
alternate_languages:
  zh-CN: "https://sandboxphysics.com/zh/stories/dark-matter-relics/freeze-in-hot-relics-and-faster-expansion/"
last_modified: "2026-11-14"
---

[How dark matter was left over](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/dark-matter-relics/)

# Freeze-in, hot relics and faster expansion

Sandbox Physics · 2026-11-14

Turn the cross-section down far enough and the same Boltzmann equation stops describing freeze-out. If the particles start in equilibrium they keep the hot plateau, $Y\simeq5.3\times10^{-3}$. If they start with none, they are made from the bath with a yield that rises in proportion to the cross-section, $Y_{\mathrm{FI}}=(3\pi^2/32)a^2\lambda$ for the Lab's contact interaction. A faster early expansion changes the freeze-out branch: with a kination phase that ends at 20 MeV, annihilation keeps thinning the particles for a factor of a few hundred in temperature after they leave equilibrium.

This chapter follows [The Boltzmann equation and freeze-out](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/dark-matter-relics/the-boltzmann-equation-and-freeze-out/). It uses $\lambda$, $F(x)$ and $Y_{\mathrm{eq}}=a\,x^2K_2(x)$ with $a=45g/(4\pi^4g_{*s})=2.68\times10^{-3}$. You need integrals of Bessel functions, or a table of them. The aims are to compute the hot-relic and freeze-in yields, map all three regimes on one curve and derive the relentless law.

## The hot-relic plateau

If $\Gamma/H$ never exceeds one but the particles start in equilibrium, nothing changes $Y$ and it stays at its value while relativistic:

$$
Y_{\mathrm{hot}}=2a=\frac{90\,g}{4\pi^4g_{*s}}=5.36\times10^{-3}.
$$

The Lab's hot-relic preset uses $\langle\sigma v\rangle_0=10^{-38}\,\mathrm{cm^3\,s^{-1}}$, whose peak $\Gamma/H$ is $1.5\times10^{-3}$; that much annihilation removes 0.5 per cent, so it reports $5.33\times10^{-3}$. For $m=100\,\mathrm{GeV}$ this is $\Omega h^2=1.46\times10^{8}$, a billion times too much. Only a particle lighter than about 82 eV in this model ends with $\Omega h^2=0.120$, and a relic that light is hot dark matter, which is excluded. [Hall, Jedamzik, March-Russell and West, 2010, section 5.1](https://arxiv.org/abs/0911.1120v2) The same reasoning for Standard Model neutrinos, which decouple near 1 MeV, gives the familiar result $\Omega h^2=m/93\,\mathrm{eV}$. [Particle Data Group, 2025, eq. 27.4](https://pdg.lbl.gov/2025/reviews/rpp2025-rev-dark-matter.pdf)

## Freeze-in from an empty start

Start with $Y=0$ and a tiny $\lambda$. As long as $Y\ll Y_{\mathrm{eq}}$, drop $Y^2$:

$$
\frac{\mathrm dY}{\mathrm dx}=\frac{\lambda F(x)}{x^2}\,Y_{\mathrm{eq}}^2,\qquad Y_{\mathrm{FI}}=\lambda a^2\int_0^\infty x^2K_2(x)^2F(x)\,\mathrm dx.
$$

The integral can be done exactly for the contact interaction. Its thermal average obeys

$$
F(x)\,K_2(x)^2=\frac{1}{4m^2T}\int_{4m^2}^{\infty}\beta\sqrt{s}\,K_1\!\left(\frac{\sqrt s}{T}\right)\mathrm ds,\qquad \beta=\sqrt{1-\frac{4m^2}{s}},
$$

where $s$ is the pair energy squared. Put $T=m/x$ and swap the order of integration. The $x$ integral is $\int_0^\infty x^3K_1(bx)\,\mathrm dx=3\pi/(2b^4)$ with $b=\sqrt s/m$. What remains is

$$
Y_{\mathrm{FI}}=\frac{3\pi a^2\lambda m}{8}\int_{4m^2}^\infty\beta\,s^{-3/2}\,\mathrm ds=\frac{3\pi a^2\lambda m}{8}\cdot\frac{\pi}{4m}=\frac{3\pi^2}{32}\,a^2\lambda,
$$

where the last integral becomes the beta function $B(\tfrac12,\tfrac32)=\pi/2$ after substituting $s=4m^2/w$.

## Worked example: freezing in the observed amount

The observed density needs $Y=0.120/(2.74\times10^{8}\times100)=4.37\times10^{-12}$. With $3\pi^2a^2/32=6.64\times10^{-6}$, that requires $\lambda=6.59\times10^{-7}$, or

$$
\langle\sigma v\rangle_0=\frac{\lambda}{(2\pi\sqrt{10}/15)\sqrt{g_*}\,mM_{\mathrm{Pl}}}=2.57\times10^{-45}\,\mathrm{cm^3\,s^{-1}}.
$$

That is eight billion billion times below the freeze-out value. The full solution gives $Y_\infty=4.373\times10^{-12}$, 0.1 per cent below the closed form, the small difference coming from the start at $x=10^{-3}$ and the dropped $Y^2$. Dropping $Y^2$ is safe: by $x=3$, when 99 per cent of the yield is made, $Y$ is still below $3\times10^{-9}$ of $Y_{\mathrm{eq}}$, and later the produced particles are far too dilute to find each other.

Production is concentrated near $x\simeq1$. In the saved run $Y$ reaches 47 per cent of its final value by $x=0.5$, 75 per cent by $x=1$ and 99 per cent by $x=3$. Hall and colleagues call this IR domination: the yield is set by temperatures near the mass and does not care what happened earlier. [Hall, Jedamzik, March-Russell and West, 2010, section 1](https://arxiv.org/abs/0911.1120v2) It works here because $F\propto x^2$ at small $x$. If the cross-section were constant, $\mathrm dY/\mathrm dx\propto x^{-2}$ at small $x$ and the yield would grow as $1/x_{\mathrm{start}}$: the saved scripts find a factor of 10.1 between starts at $x=10^{-3}$ and $10^{-2}$.

## One curve, three regimes

**Table 4.1** Density today for $m=100\,\mathrm{GeV}$ and standard expansion, from the saved scan.

| $\langle\sigma v\rangle_0$ in $\mathrm{cm^3\,s^{-1}}$ | Start in equilibrium | Start empty |
| --- | --- | --- |
| $10^{-45}$ | $1.47\times10^{8}$ | $0.0467$ |
| $10^{-40}$ | $1.47\times10^{8}$ | $4.67\times10^{3}$ |
| $10^{-37}$ | $1.40\times10^{8}$ | $4.66\times10^{6}$ |
| $10^{-36}$ | $1.01\times10^{8}$ | $3.99\times10^{7}$ |
| $10^{-35}$ | $3.05\times10^{7}$ | $3.05\times10^{7}$ |
| $10^{-30}$ | $1.48\times10^{3}$ | $1.48\times10^{3}$ |
| $10^{-26}$ | $0.248$ | $0.248$ |

Reading down, the empty start rises tenfold per decade (freeze-in), meets the plateau near $10^{-35}$, and from there both starts fall together (freeze-out). The meeting point is where the peak of $\Gamma/H$ reaches about one. Above it, particles made from nothing reach equilibrium before freeze-out and the starting state is forgotten. This is the slice through the phase diagram drawn in Figure 4b of Hall and colleagues. [Hall, Jedamzik, March-Russell and West, 2010, section 5.1](https://arxiv.org/abs/0911.1120v2)

## A faster early expansion

D'Eramo, Fernandez and Profumo add a fluid whose energy density falls as $a^{-(4+n)}$ and equals radiation at $T_r$. [D'Eramo, Fernandez and Profumo, 2017, section II](https://arxiv.org/abs/1703.04793v1) With $g_*$ fixed,

$$
H=H_{\mathrm{rad}}\sqrt{1+\left(\frac{T}{T_r}\right)^{n}},\qquad \frac{\mathrm dY}{\mathrm d\ln x}=-\frac{\lambda F}{x\,E(x)}\left(Y^2-Y_{\mathrm{eq}}^2\right),\quad E=\sqrt{1+\left(\frac{x_r}{x}\right)^{n}},
$$

with $x_r=m/T_r$. Kination, a scalar field dominated by its kinetic energy, has $n=2$. Light-element abundances require $T_r\gtrsim(15.4)^{1/n}\,\mathrm{MeV}$, their eq. (14), so the Lab keeps $T_r\ge20\,\mathrm{MeV}$, which satisfies the bound for every $n$ it offers.

The larger $H$ makes freeze-out earlier: with the standard cross-section and $T_r=20\,\mathrm{MeV}$ the crossing moves from $x=25.2$ to 22.4, 19.5 and 12.9 for $n=1$, 2 and 4.

## The relentless law

For $x_f\ll x\ll x_r$, $E\simeq(x_r/x)^{n/2}$ and $Y_{\mathrm{eq}}$ is negligible, so

$$
\frac{\mathrm d}{\mathrm d\ln x}\frac1Y=\frac{\lambda F}{x_r^{n/2}}\,x^{n/2-1}.
$$

For $n<2$ the right side shrinks with $x$ and $1/Y$ converges soon after freeze-out, as in the standard case. For $n=2$ it is constant, so $1/Y$ grows by $(\lambda/x_r)\ln(x/x_f)$ all the way to $x\simeq x_r$. For $n>2$ it grows as a power. This is the relentless annihilation of eqs. (C16) and (C18). [D'Eramo, Fernandez and Profumo, 2017, appendix C](https://arxiv.org/abs/1703.04793v1)

Check it on the kination run, $x_r=5000$. The time-domain solution gives $1/Y=2.57\times10^{9}$ at $x=200$ and $3.56\times10^{9}$ at $x=500$. The law predicts an increase of $(\lambda/x_r)\int F\,\mathrm d\ln x=1.10\times10^{9}\times0.90=9.9\times10^{8}$, matching to 0.1 per cent. The final densities with the standard cross-section are $\Omega h^2=0.871$, 4.02 and 13.7 for $n=1$, 2 and 4, against 0.120 with standard expansion. The settling point moves from $x=208$ to 1140, 8080 and 26,900. These densities are 2 to 3 times below the paper's Figure 1, because the paper keeps the full $g_*(T)$ and the fall from 86.25 to 10.75 by $T_r$ raises the extra fluid's share of $H^2$. The [guide to the paper](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/dark-matter-relics/reading-relentless-dark-matter/) works through the difference.

## Lab tasks

Open the [dark matter relic Lab](https://sandboxphysics.com/labs/dark-matter-freeze-out-freeze-in/).

1. Choose Freeze-in from nothing. On the abundance chart, find the $x$ where the violet curve reaches its plateau and compare with the 99 per cent point above.
2. On the scan chart, follow the dashed empty-start curve up to where it joins the solid curve. Read off the cross-section and compare with Table 4.1.
3. Choose Faster expansion. Watch the dashed curve for the particles present on the rate chart: it stays near one for a long time instead of dropping away. Explain this with the relentless law.

## Exercises

1. Check the closed form numerically: with $a=2.678\times10^{-3}$ and $\lambda=6.597\times10^{-7}$, compute $Y_{\mathrm{FI}}$.
2. In freeze-in, $Y_{\mathrm{FI}}\propto\lambda\propto m\langle\sigma v\rangle_0$, while the observed yield is proportional to $1/m$. What cross-section does a 1 TeV particle need?
3. For a constant cross-section, show that $\int_{x_{\mathrm{start}}}Y_{\mathrm{eq}}^2x^{-2}\,\mathrm dx\simeq4a^2/x_{\mathrm{start}}$ when $x_{\mathrm{start}}\ll1$.
4. For $n=1$, integrate the relentless equation from $x_f$ to infinity, ignoring the eventual return to $E\simeq1$, and show that $1/Y$ stays finite.

Answers

1. $3\pi^2/32=0.9253$ and $a^2=7.172\times10^{-6}$, so $Y_{\mathrm{FI}}=0.9253\times7.172\times10^{-6}\times6.597\times10^{-7}=4.378\times10^{-12}$.
2. Fixing $\Omega h^2$ means $Y\propto1/m$, so $m\langle\sigma v\rangle_0\propto1/m$ and $\langle\sigma v\rangle_0\propto m^{-2}$. Ten times the mass needs a hundred times less: $2.57\times10^{-47}\,\mathrm{cm^3\,s^{-1}}$.
3. For $x\ll1$, $Y_{\mathrm{eq}}\simeq2a$, so the integrand is $4a^2/x^2$ and $\int_{x_{\mathrm{start}}}^{\sim1}4a^2x^{-2}\,\mathrm dx\simeq4a^2/x_{\mathrm{start}}$. The yield depends on where one starts, which no measurement fixes.
4. $\mathrm d(1/Y)/\mathrm dx=\lambda x^{-3/2}x_r^{-1/2}$, so $\Delta(1/Y)=2\lambda x_r^{-1/2}x_f^{-1/2}$, which is finite. The extra annihilation after freeze-out adds only a fixed correction.

## Sources

1. [Hall, Jedamzik, March-Russell and West, 2010, section 5.1](https://arxiv.org/abs/0911.1120v2)
2. [Particle Data Group, 2025, eq. 27.4](https://pdg.lbl.gov/2025/reviews/rpp2025-rev-dark-matter.pdf)
3. [D'Eramo, Fernandez and Profumo, 2017, section II](https://arxiv.org/abs/1703.04793v1)

## Keep reading

How dark matter was left over · Reading path

### From thermal equilibrium to relentless dark matter

1. [Article **Why did any dark matter survive the hot early universe?**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/dark-matter-relics/why-some-dark-matter-survived-the-cooling/)
2. [Article **Equilibrium, expansion and the reaction race**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/dark-matter-relics/equilibrium-expansion-and-the-reaction-race/)
3. [Article **The Boltzmann equation and freeze-out**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/dark-matter-relics/the-boltzmann-equation-and-freeze-out/)
4. [You are here **Freeze-in, hot relics and faster expansion**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/dark-matter-relics/freeze-in-hot-relics-and-faster-expansion/)
5. [Article **Recompute a relic abundance with the saved scripts**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/dark-matter-relics/recompute-a-relic-abundance/)
6. [Article **How to read the relentless dark matter paper of D'Eramo and colleagues**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/dark-matter-relics/reading-relentless-dark-matter/)
