---
title: "How to read the 2019 GW150914 overtone paper and the debate that followed"
description: "Read Isi et al. 2019 figure by figure, then see which overtone and nonlinear-mode claims are published, which are preprints and what is still open."
canonical_url: "https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/black-hole-ringdown/reading-the-gw150914-overtone-paper/"
language: "en"
page_type: "story"
alternate_languages:
  zh-CN: "https://sandboxphysics.com/zh/stories/black-hole-ringdown/reading-the-gw150914-overtone-paper/"
last_modified: "2026-11-14"
---

[Black hole ringdown and the no-hair test](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/black-hole-ringdown/)

# How to read the 2019 GW150914 overtone paper and the debate that followed

Sandbox Physics · 2026-11-14

Isi and colleagues fitted the GW150914 ringdown from its peak with the fundamental mode and one overtone. The mass and spin they found agree with the full-signal estimate, and the overtone's frequency agrees with the Kerr prediction to about 20 percent. That result is published. Whether the overtone is really detected in that event is still disputed in two later preprints, and the nonlinear modes found in simulations have not yet been measured in data.

[Open the black hole ringdown Lab](https://sandboxphysics.com/labs/black-hole-ringdown-spectroscopy/)

This guide reads arXiv version 2 of the paper, dated 8 August 2019, published as Phys. Rev. Lett. 123, 111102 (2019). [Isi, Giesler, Farr, Scheel and Teukolsky, Testing the no-hair theorem with GW150914, arXiv:1905.00869v2](https://arxiv.org/abs/1905.00869v2) We read the full text of the main paper, its four figures and the supplementary section on the likelihood. We did not compare it with the journal's typeset version. Our own fits, described in [the method tutorial](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/black-hole-ringdown/recomputing-ringdown-tones-and-a-public-event/), use one detector and do not reproduce the paper.

## Where each claim stands

**Table 6.1** Status of the claims discussed below, as of November 2026.

| Claim | Status | Source |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Kerr frequencies depend only on mass and spin | prediction of general relativity | Dreyer et al. 2004 |
| Overtones let a fit start at the peak, in simulations | published | Giesler et al., Phys. Rev. X 2019 |
| GW150914 overtone at $3.6\sigma$; $\delta f_1=-0.05\pm0.2$ | published | Isi et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 2019 |
| No overtone evidence after the peak | preprint, no journal entry on arXiv | Cotesta et al. 2022 |
| Overtone evidence is robust | preprint, no journal entry on arXiv | Isi and Farr 2022 |
| Quadratic modes in simulated ringdowns | published, simulations only | Mitman et al.; Cheung et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 2023 |
| Quadratic modes measurable in a real event | open question | none |

The journal references come from the arXiv record of each paper. [Giesler, Isi, Scheel and Teukolsky, Black hole ringdown: the importance of overtones, arXiv:1903.08284v2](https://arxiv.org/abs/1903.08284v2)

## Eq. (1): the model and its conventions

The paper writes the $l=m=2$ ringdown as

$$
h_{22}^N(t)=\sum_{n=0}^{N}A_n\exp\left[-i(\omega_nt+\phi_n)-t/\tau_n\right],
$$

for times after a start time $t_0$. Here $\omega_n$ is a real angular frequency and $\tau_n$ a damping time, both set by the remnant's mass and spin; $A_n$ and $\phi_n$ are free. Two details matter when you compare with other work.

- Printed vs used: the text defines $\Delta t=t-t_0$ right after Eq. (1), but the equation is written in $t$. Fig. 2 says the amplitudes are defined at $t=t_{\mathrm{peak}}$. Our code measures time from the fit start, which changes the amplitudes but not the mass and spin, because amplitudes are fitted away.
- Printed vs used: the paper keeps $\omega_n$ real and writes the decay separately. We use one complex frequency, $\omega=2\pi f-i/\tau$ with time dependence $e^{-i\omega t}$, as in the course chapters. The two forms describe the same mode.

The start time is measured from $t_{\mathrm{peak}}=1126259462.423$ GPS at Hanford.

## Fig. 1: three models from the peak

Fig. 1 shows 90 percent regions in mass and spin for $N=0$, $1$ and $2$, all from $\Delta t_0=0$, against the full-signal estimate, whose peak is at $M_f=68.5\,\mathrm{M}_\odot$, $\chi_f=0.69$. With $N=0$ the region misses the full-signal one; the text calls it biased and does not give a direction. With $N=1$ the two agree, and the text quotes $M_f=68\pm7\,\mathrm{M}_\odot$ and $\chi_f=0.63\pm0.16$ at 68 percent. With $N=2$ the region is slightly broader than with $N=1$, because two more free parameters do not buy a clearly detected second overtone.

Read this figure as a statement about model adequacy at the peak. In the Lab and in our Hanford-only slice, the $N=0$ fit from the peak also misses, once low and once high, so the direction depends on the record.

## Fig. 2: how strong is the overtone?

Fig. 2 shows the amplitude posteriors. With $N=1$, the mean of $A_1$ lies $3.6$ standard deviations from zero. That number describes the width of a posterior; it is not a false-alarm probability from noise-only data. With $N=2$, the case $A_1=A_2=0$ is excluded at 90 percent credibility. The paper also states that the post-peak network signal-to-noise ratio is about 14 above $154.7\,\mathrm{Hz}$.

## Fig. 3: waiting for the fundamental

Fig. 3 repeats the $N=0$ fit from $1$, $3$ and $5\,\mathrm{ms}$ after the peak. Around $3\,\mathrm{ms}$ it agrees with the full-signal estimate, with a larger region than the $N=1$ fit from the peak. This matches the earlier LIGO and Virgo analysis, where a single damped sinusoid started to overlap the prediction at $t_0=t_M+3\,\mathrm{ms}$, about $10M$. [Abbott et al., Tests of general relativity with GW150914, arXiv:1602.03841v3](https://arxiv.org/abs/1602.03841v3) The Lab's "wait for the fundamental" preset makes the same trade-off on a synthetic record.

## Fig. 4: the no-hair test itself

Here the overtone's frequency and damping time are freed, $f_1=f_1^{\mathrm{Kerr}}(1+\delta f_1)$ and $\tau_1=\tau_1^{\mathrm{Kerr}}(1+\delta\tau_1)$, with flat priors $\delta f_1\in[-0.5,0.5]$ and $\delta\tau_1\in[-1,1]$. The result is $\delta f_1=-0.05\pm0.2$ at 68 percent; $\delta\tau_1$ is largely unconstrained between about $-0.06$ and $1$. The Bayes factor for the Kerr model over the free one is $1.75$.

What this shows: a test with real data, passed at about the 20 percent level. What it does not show: a measurement precise enough to constrain specific alternative theories, or a test independent of the overtone's detection. If the overtone were absent, $\delta f_1$ would be poorly constrained, and the test would mean little.

## The supplementary likelihood

The supplement explains the data handling, and it is the part to read before trying to reproduce anything. The authors apply a fourth-order Butterworth high-pass at $20\,\mathrm{Hz}$, then work at $2048\,\mathrm{Hz}$ with $0.5\,\mathrm s$ of data from the peak. They estimate the noise autocovariance from $64\,\mathrm s$ of off-source data and use the full Toeplitz covariance in the time domain, because a taper would require data before the peak. They project the complex strain onto both detectors with antenna patterns.

Our Hanford-only slice copies the filter, sample rate, segment and Toeplitz likelihood. It differs in detector count, off-source length, amplitude treatment and sampling, and the method tutorial lists each difference.

## What came after

Cotesta, Carullo, Berti and Cardoso reanalysed the event and found no evidence for an overtone after the peak; support for a nonzero amplitude changed when the start time moved by much less than the overtone's damping time, and injections into nearby real noise produced false evidence. [Cotesta, Carullo, Berti and Cardoso, Analysis of ringdown overtones in GW150914, arXiv:2201.00822v2](https://arxiv.org/abs/2201.00822v2) Isi and Farr answered that they could not reproduce those results and that the overtone amplitude stayed nonzero over reasonable start times. [Isi and Farr, Revisiting the ringdown of GW150914, arXiv:2202.02941v2](https://arxiv.org/abs/2202.02941v2) The two groups disagree about the data analysis, and neither paper has a journal entry on arXiv.

Separately, two simulation studies found quadratic modes, sourced by the square of the $220$ mode, in the $(4,4)$ harmonic. [Mitman et al., Nonlinearities in black hole ringdowns, arXiv:2208.07380v2](https://arxiv.org/abs/2208.07380v2) [Cheung et al., Nonlinear effects in black hole ringdown, arXiv:2208.07374v3](https://arxiv.org/abs/2208.07374v3) They concern the $(4,4)$ harmonic, not the $(2,2)$ fit in Isi et al., but they show that a purely linear sum of modes is incomplete for higher harmonics in simulations.

Three questions remain open as of November 2026: whether nonlinear modes can be measured in any event, whether the GW150914 overtone is detected, and how early the linear description holds in the $(2,2)$ harmonic of real signals.

## Lab tasks

1. Use the default preset as a stand-in for Fig. 1: compare the amber $N=0$ region and the mint $N=1$ region with the white truth cross.
2. Use the "wait for the fundamental" preset for Fig. 3, and drag the start between $5M$ and $15M$.
3. Read the overtone frequency-shift curve as a synthetic Fig. 4 slice with $\delta\tau_1=0$. Remember that the Lab record is synthetic white-noise data, not LIGO data.

## Exercises with explained answers

1. The paper says $A_1=0$ is disfavoured at $3.6\sigma$. Why is this not the same as saying noise alone would produce such a value only once in several thousand trials?
2. Why does the $N=2$ region come out slightly broader than the $N=1$ region?
3. Which single figure would you check first to judge the no-hair claim, and what number on it?

Answers

1. The $3.6\sigma$ is the posterior mean of $A_1$ divided by its posterior standard deviation under the $N=1$ model. A false-alarm rate needs the distribution of that statistic in data without an overtone, which is a separate calculation. Cotesta and colleagues studied it with injections into nearby real noise.
2. Adding $A_2$ and $\phi_2$ adds freedom that the data cannot pin down, since the second overtone is not clearly detected. The extra freedom spreads the mass and spin posterior.
3. Fig. 4, and the $\delta f_1$ interval: $-0.05\pm0.2$ at 68 percent, consistent with zero. Then Fig. 2, because the test only means something if the overtone is present.

## Try it in the Lab

Use the default preset as a stand-in for Fig. 1 and the wait-for-the-fundamental preset for Fig. 3; remember the Lab record is synthetic, not LIGO data. [Open the black hole ringdown Lab](https://sandboxphysics.com/labs/black-hole-ringdown-spectroscopy/)

## Sources

1. [Isi, Giesler, Farr, Scheel and Teukolsky, Testing the no-hair theorem with GW150914, arXiv:1905.00869v2](https://arxiv.org/abs/1905.00869v2)
2. [Giesler, Isi, Scheel and Teukolsky, Black hole ringdown: the importance of overtones, arXiv:1903.08284v2](https://arxiv.org/abs/1903.08284v2)
3. [Abbott et al., Tests of general relativity with GW150914, arXiv:1602.03841v3](https://arxiv.org/abs/1602.03841v3)
4. [Cotesta, Carullo, Berti and Cardoso, Analysis of ringdown overtones in GW150914, arXiv:2201.00822v2](https://arxiv.org/abs/2201.00822v2)
5. [Isi and Farr, Revisiting the ringdown of GW150914, arXiv:2202.02941v2](https://arxiv.org/abs/2202.02941v2)
6. [Mitman et al., Nonlinearities in black hole ringdowns, arXiv:2208.07380v2](https://arxiv.org/abs/2208.07380v2)
7. [Cheung et al., Nonlinear effects in black hole ringdown, arXiv:2208.07374v3](https://arxiv.org/abs/2208.07374v3)

## Keep reading

Black hole ringdown and the no-hair test · Reading path

### From a ringing black hole to a no-hair test

1. [Article **Why does a newly merged black hole ring like a bell?**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/black-hole-ringdown/why-a-black-hole-rings/)
2. [Article **Damped tones and the Kerr spectrum**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/black-hole-ringdown/damped-tones-and-the-kerr-spectrum/)
3. [Article **Why a ringdown fit needs the overtone near the peak**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/black-hole-ringdown/fitting-a-ringdown-from-the-peak/)
4. [Article **From two tones to a no-hair test**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/black-hole-ringdown/from-two-tones-to-a-no-hair-test/)
5. [Article **Recomputing ringdown tones, a synthetic signal and a slice of GW150914**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/black-hole-ringdown/recomputing-ringdown-tones-and-a-public-event/)
6. [You are here **How to read the 2019 GW150914 overtone paper and the debate that followed**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/black-hole-ringdown/reading-the-gw150914-overtone-paper/)
