---
title: "From two tones to a no-hair test"
description: "Turn two measured tones into a consistency test, parameterize a deviation, read its credible interval, and learn what such a test cannot prove."
canonical_url: "https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/black-hole-ringdown/from-two-tones-to-a-no-hair-test/"
language: "en"
page_type: "story"
alternate_languages:
  zh-CN: "https://sandboxphysics.com/zh/stories/black-hole-ringdown/from-two-tones-to-a-no-hair-test/"
last_modified: "2026-11-14"
---

[Black hole ringdown and the no-hair test](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/black-hole-ringdown/)

# From two tones to a no-hair test

Sandbox Physics · 2026-11-14

Two measured tones give four numbers, two frequencies and two damping times, but a Kerr black hole has only two, its mass and spin. The no-hair test asks whether one mass and one spin predict all four. In practice one lets the second tone's frequency drift by a fraction $\delta f$ and checks whether the data still favour $\delta f=0$. A passed test bounds how large a departure from Kerr can be; a single failed fit is first a question about noise, start time and missing modes.

[Open the black hole ringdown Lab](https://sandboxphysics.com/labs/black-hole-ringdown-spectroscopy/)

This chapter builds on [fitting a ringdown](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/black-hole-ringdown/fitting-a-ringdown-from-the-peak/). It uses the grid posterior and profile likelihood from there.

## What the no-hair statement claims

In general relativity a black hole that has settled down is a Kerr black hole, fixed by its mass $M$ and angular momentum $J=\chi M^2$, with electric charge negligible for astrophysical holes. Every quasinormal frequency is then a function of those two numbers alone, $\omega_{lmn}=\omega_{lmn}(M,\chi)$. Dreyer and colleagues turned this into a test: measure several tones and check that one $(M,\chi)$ fits them all. Another theory of gravity, or a different kind of compact object, would in general break that agreement. [Dreyer et al., Black hole spectroscopy: testing general relativity through gravitational wave observations, arXiv:gr-qc/0309007v1](https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0309007v1)

## Two tones over-determine the hole

One mode gives two measured numbers, $f$ and $\tau$, and two unknowns. It can always be fitted by some $(M,\chi)$ and so tests nothing. A second mode adds two more numbers with no new unknowns:

$$
\begin{aligned}
2\pi f_{220}\,\frac{GM}{c^3}&=\mathrm{Re}\,M\omega_{220}(\chi), & \frac{GM/c^3}{\tau_{220}}&=\lvert\mathrm{Im}\,M\omega_{220}(\chi)\rvert,\\
2\pi f_{221}\,\frac{GM}{c^3}&=\mathrm{Re}\,M\omega_{221}(\chi), & \frac{GM/c^3}{\tau_{221}}&=\lvert\mathrm{Im}\,M\omega_{221}(\chi)\rvert .
\end{aligned}
$$

Each mode on its own defines a point in the $(M,\chi)$ plane. The test is whether the two points coincide within their uncertainties.

**Worked example 1.** Take the tones of a Kerr hole with $M=68.5\,\mathrm{M}_\odot$ and $\chi=0.69$: $Q_{220}=3.254$, $f_{220}=249\,\mathrm{Hz}$ and $Q_{221}=1.052$, $f_{221}=244\,\mathrm{Hz}$. Invert each with the Berti, Cardoso and Will fits. For $221$ the coefficients are $q_1=0.1$, $q_2=0.5436$, $q_3=-0.4731$ and $f_1=1.3673$, $f_2=-1.026$, $f_3=0.1628$. [Berti, Cardoso and Will, On gravitational-wave spectroscopy of massive black holes with the space interferometer LISA, Table VIII](https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0512160v2) Then $(1-\chi)^{-0.4731}=(1.052-0.1)/0.5436=1.752$, so $\chi=0.694$ and $M=69.1\,\mathrm{M}_\odot$. The fundamental gave $\chi=0.692$ and $M=68.9\,\mathrm{M}_\odot$. The two points agree to within the fits' stated errors of one to two percent, as they must for a Kerr input.

## Parameterising a departure

Real data do not give four sharp numbers. The standard approach keeps the Kerr model but frees the overtone:

$$
f_{221}=f_{221}^{\mathrm{Kerr}}(M,\chi)\,(1+\delta f_1),\qquad \tau_{221}=\tau_{221}^{\mathrm{Kerr}}(M,\chi)\,(1+\delta\tau_1).
$$

The fundamental pins down $(M,\chi)$, and the overtone then tests the prediction. Isi and colleagues used exactly this form for GW150914, with flat priors $\delta f_1\in[-0.5,0.5]$ and $\delta\tau_1\in[-1,1]$. [Isi, Giesler, Farr, Scheel and Teukolsky, Testing the no-hair theorem with GW150914, arXiv:1905.00869v2](https://arxiv.org/abs/1905.00869v2) They found the damping time poorly constrained, and that fixing $\delta\tau_1=0$ left the frequency result unchanged. The Lab therefore frees only $\delta f_1$ and computes

$$
p(\delta f_1\mid d)\propto\sum_{M,\chi}L_{\mathrm{prof}}(M,\chi,\delta f_1),
$$

on a grid of $41$ values of $\delta f_1$ from $-0.5$ to $0.5$, $41$ masses and $34$ spins.

## Reading the interval

**Table 4.1** Overtone frequency shift in the Lab presets, synthetic Kerr records, median and 5 to 95 percent range.

| Preset | $\rho$ | $\delta f_1$ |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Overtone needed at the peak | $14$ | $0.06\;[-0.44,\,0.46]$ |
| A loud event | $80$ | $0.09\;[-0.06,\,0.31]$ |
| A fast-spinning remnant | $30$ | $0.11\;[-0.38,\,0.48]$ |
| A faint overtone | $30$ | $-0.02\;[-0.45,\,0.41]$ |

Every record here is Kerr, so the true value is $0$, and every interval contains it. At $\rho=14$ the interval fills almost the whole prior range: the data barely constrain the overtone's frequency. Only the loud event narrows it to a band of about $0.37$.

For GW150914 Isi and colleagues report $\delta f_1=-0.05\pm0.2$ at 68 percent credibility. They also give a Bayes factor of $1.75$ for the no-hair model over the free model. [Isi, Giesler, Farr, Scheel and Teukolsky](https://arxiv.org/abs/1905.00869v2) Our synthetic numbers are not a check on theirs. They use two detectors, coloured noise and sampled amplitudes; we use one white-noise record and a profile likelihood.

**Worked example 2.** A Bayes factor multiplies prior odds into posterior odds. With even prior odds, a factor of $1.75$ gives a no-hair probability of $1.75/(1+1.75)=0.64$. That is a mild preference: the data sit comfortably with Kerr and still leave room for a departure.

## Why one deviation is not new physics

Suppose a fit returns an interval that excludes $\delta f_1=0$. Check these causes before anything else:

- Noise. A 90 percent interval misses the truth one time in ten by design. In our coverage test the $N=1$ regions held the truth in 89 of 100 draws. Among the Lab's 20 noise draws, two or so should miss by chance.
- Start time. Cotesta and colleagues reported that support for the GW150914 overtone changed when the start moved by less than the overtone's damping time. [Cotesta, Carullo, Berti and Cardoso, Analysis of ringdown overtones in GW150914, arXiv:2201.00822v2](https://arxiv.org/abs/2201.00822v2) A real departure should not come and go with the start time.
- Missing modes. Simulations show quadratic modes, sourced by the product of two linear modes. In the $(4,4)$ harmonic the mode sourced by $220\times220$ is comparable to or larger than the linear $(4,4)$ mode. [Mitman et al., Nonlinearities in black hole ringdowns, arXiv:2208.07380v2](https://arxiv.org/abs/2208.07380v2) [Cheung et al., Nonlinear effects in black hole ringdown, arXiv:2208.07374v3](https://arxiv.org/abs/2208.07374v3) A fit with only $220$ and $221$ cannot absorb such terms.
- Noise model and priors. Coloured noise must be estimated from nearby data, and an interval that reaches the edge of its prior measures the prior.

A departure becomes interesting only when it survives changes of start time, noise estimate and mode content, and when other events show the same sign and size.

## The overtone debate as a case study

The GW150914 overtone shows how a single analysis turns into a long discussion. Isi and colleagues reported the overtone at $3.6\sigma$ in 2019, in a paper published in Physical Review Letters. Cotesta and colleagues found no evidence for it after the peak and argued the earlier claim was noise-dominated. Isi and Farr replied that they could not reproduce that result and that their measurement was robust to analysis choices. [Isi and Farr, Revisiting the ringdown of GW150914, arXiv:2202.02941v2](https://arxiv.org/abs/2202.02941v2) arXiv lists no journal publication for either of the 2022 papers. Both nonlinear-mode papers appeared in Physical Review Letters in 2023, but they analyse simulations, not detector data. Whether quadratic modes can be measured in a real event is an open question.

## Lab tasks

1. In the default preset, read $\delta f_1$ and compare its width with the prior range $[-0.5,0.5]$.
2. Switch to the loud event. Check that zero is still inside and measure how much the interval has narrowed.
3. Step through noise draws $1$ to $20$ in the advanced group at $\rho=80$, and count how many intervals exclude zero.

## Exercises with explained answers

1. Why does a single damped sinusoid test nothing about the no-hair theorem?
2. Suppose one record gives $\delta f_1=0.30\;[0.05,\,0.48]$ at $t_0=0$ and $0.02\;[-0.40,\,0.45]$ at $t_0=2M$. What do you conclude?
3. With prior odds of $1:10$ against the no-hair model, what posterior probability does a Bayes factor of $1.75$ give?
4. Isi and colleagues give $\delta f_1=-0.05\pm0.2$ at 68 percent. If the posterior were Gaussian, what would its 90 percent interval be, and how much of the prior range would it cover?

Answers

1. Two measured numbers, $f$ and $\tau$, can always be matched by some $(M,\chi)$ on the Kerr curves. A test needs more measured numbers than unknowns.
2. The departure does not survive a small change of start time, so it is more likely a fluctuation or an early-time effect than a property of the remnant. Repeat with other noise draws and start times before saying anything else.
3. Posterior odds are $1.75\times0.1=0.175$, so the no-hair probability is $0.175/1.175=0.15$. The Bayes factor alone cannot overturn strong prior odds.
4. A Gaussian's 90 percent half-width is $1.645$ times its 68 percent half-width, so $0.2\times1.645=0.33$ and the interval is about $[-0.38,\,0.28]$. That covers two thirds of the prior range $[-0.5,0.5]$. The real posterior need not be Gaussian, and the paper's Fig. 4 shows its 90 percent bounds directly.

To see these steps on public data, follow [recomputing ringdown tones, a synthetic signal and a slice of GW150914](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/black-hole-ringdown/recomputing-ringdown-tones-and-a-public-event/).

## Try it in the Lab

Compare the overtone frequency-shift curve in the default and loud-event presets; note how much narrower it gets and whether it still contains zero. [Open the black hole ringdown Lab](https://sandboxphysics.com/labs/black-hole-ringdown-spectroscopy/)

## Sources

1. [Dreyer et al., Black hole spectroscopy: testing general relativity through gravitational wave observations, arXiv:gr-qc/0309007v1](https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0309007v1)
2. [Berti, Cardoso and Will, On gravitational-wave spectroscopy of massive black holes with the space interferometer LISA, Table VIII](https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0512160v2)
3. [Isi, Giesler, Farr, Scheel and Teukolsky, Testing the no-hair theorem with GW150914, arXiv:1905.00869v2](https://arxiv.org/abs/1905.00869v2)
4. [Cotesta, Carullo, Berti and Cardoso, Analysis of ringdown overtones in GW150914, arXiv:2201.00822v2](https://arxiv.org/abs/2201.00822v2)
5. [Mitman et al., Nonlinearities in black hole ringdowns, arXiv:2208.07380v2](https://arxiv.org/abs/2208.07380v2)
6. [Cheung et al., Nonlinear effects in black hole ringdown, arXiv:2208.07374v3](https://arxiv.org/abs/2208.07374v3)
7. [Isi and Farr, Revisiting the ringdown of GW150914, arXiv:2202.02941v2](https://arxiv.org/abs/2202.02941v2)

## Keep reading

Black hole ringdown and the no-hair test · Reading path

### From a ringing black hole to a no-hair test

1. [Article **Why does a newly merged black hole ring like a bell?**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/black-hole-ringdown/why-a-black-hole-rings/)
2. [Article **Damped tones and the Kerr spectrum**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/black-hole-ringdown/damped-tones-and-the-kerr-spectrum/)
3. [Article **Why a ringdown fit needs the overtone near the peak**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/black-hole-ringdown/fitting-a-ringdown-from-the-peak/)
4. [You are here **From two tones to a no-hair test**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/black-hole-ringdown/from-two-tones-to-a-no-hair-test/)
5. [Article **Recomputing ringdown tones, a synthetic signal and a slice of GW150914**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/black-hole-ringdown/recomputing-ringdown-tones-and-a-public-event/)
6. [Article **How to read the 2019 GW150914 overtone paper and the debate that followed**](https://sandboxphysics.com/stories/black-hole-ringdown/reading-the-gw150914-overtone-paper/)
